Incompetence Again

baghdad.jpg

Jonathan Chait makes the case against the "incompetence dodge" argument. I see three main strands of counterargument here:

  • "[T]he more we learn about the war's conduct, the more we learn that the administration didn't just make the normal sorts of mistakes that inevitably occur in wartime; it was almost criminally negligent." In other words, Bush was really inept.

  • "When the authority of government dissolves, people retreat to the safety of tribal solidarity, and under such conditions they can do savage things of which they never thought themselves capable. Once the expectation of chaos sets in, it can spiral out of control." In other words, the sectarian divisions now plaguing the country are the consequence of poor initial management, and not the cause of problems.

  • Last, the conclusion: "The funny thing is that, in other contexts, liberals don't dispute the notion that Bush administration incompetence caused otherwise preventable catastrophes. Almost no liberal believes otherwise when it comes to, say, the response to Hurricane Katrina. If Bush could have bungled Katrina this badly, isn't it just possible he could have done the same thing in Iraq?"

I think Katrina is a useful example to bring up in this regard. What I would say about it is that, clearly, the Bush administration badly mishandled that situation and, as a result, things became much worse than they might have been. On the other hand, though, it's not Bush's fault that a hurricane hit New Orleans. There was nothing FEMA possibly could have done that would have made a levy-breaching hurricane hit on New Orleans somehow non-catastrophic; Bush took a bad thing and made it worse, he didn't take a benign occurence and make it bad.

Specifically in the Iraqi context, it's worth taking full account of exactly how far short the United States has fallen from its ambitious nation-building goals. The idea was that we were going to reconstruct Iraq into a stable, unitary, liberal democracy in the heart of the Middle East. The odds of achieving this were always extremely low. It's worth reviewing the arguments, knowable ex ante that this was unlikely. One is simpl the so-called "resourse curse," in this case oil. As John Judis has written:

Today, all of the world's oil nations, except Norway, have either authoritarian governments, such as those in Saudi Arabia and Iraq, or what Carnegie Endowment for International Peace political scientist Marina Ottaway calls "semi-authoritarian" governments. Some of the latter, such as Algeria, Indonesia, and Nigeria, have embraced aspects of democracy only to fall back onto authoritarianism and one-party domination as oil revenues have provided the means for repression and corruption as well as co-optation.

Read his article for a full account of the underlying theoretical explanation, but suffice it to say that vast resource wealth both increases the incentives for authoritarian governance and also makes it easier to pull off. Norway is, in this context, a good example of the proverbial "exception that proves the rule" in that Norway already had well-entrenched structures of liberal democracy and civil society before its oil wealth started to pay off. It was also homogenous and deeply embedded in the democracy-friendly neighborhood of Western Europe.

Iraq combined the disadvantages of the oil curse with none of Norway's advantages. Only one of Iraq's neighbors, Turkey, is a democracy. What's more, Iraq doesn't share important cultural ties with Turkey. Rather, its ties are with the Arab world and with Iran, both authoritarian. It had no tradition of functioning democracy and while it used to have a functioning civil society, that was crushed by several decades of Saddam Hussein's rule. Under the circumstances, it's natural that the Baath Party and various religious (and therefore sectarian of necessity) groups began to fill the void. On top of that is the diversity. Chait makes the following argument about Bosnia:

Many doves on the left and right looked at the savagery in Sarajevo in the 1990s and saw a never-ending tribal war, but in fact Serbs, Bosnians and Croats had peacefully coexisted in a multiethnic city for decades.

This is true. What Serbs, Croats, and Bosnian Muslims never did was coexisted peacefully in a democracy. Indeed, it was the opening of the Yugoslavian political system that led to the degeneration into sectarian violence. One of the things your better-run autocracies, like Tito's Yugoslavia or contemporary Singapore, are good at is managing ethno-religious divisions in a peaceful manner. But very few functioning democracies have something like Iraq's tripartite balance. This is made especially bad by the fact that Kurds overwhelmingly -- and since long before the invasion -- fundamentally reject the idea of Iraq and that Iraq's Sunni Arab population firmly believes itself to be the rightful governing class and doesn't even believe that it's a minority.

Last, a word about the stakes. Chait writes that in this dispute "At stake is nothing less than who gets to direct the party's foreign policy." I'm not super-concerned about personnel as such. Indeed, I obviously have no standing to argue that nobody who supported the war should be listened to about anything in the future. My concern is about policies. The implication of the "dodger" argument is that, in the future, when we have a competent Democratic administration it makes sense to try and spread democracy by toppling hostile entrenched dictatorships, occupying their territory, and rebuilding them as liberal democracies. This, to my mind, would be a disaster. Insofar as people don't want to do that, then I don't especially care about their retrospective take on Iraq, though I do think there's an obvious logical linkage between the issues.

Comments

His use of "hawks" and "doves" is somewhat slippery, as well. Much of the anti-Iraq War crowd--including, I think, you--critiques the decision to go to war in the same way that Scowcroft does. Yet no one would call Scowcroft a "dove." To the extent that those Dems who supported the Iraq War are really neoconservative-lights--a fair charge--then "hawk" and "dove" doesn't get to the heart of the disagreement. More, it muddles the disagreement: the implication is that "doves" are dead-set against war in almost all cases, and that nothing is lost by grouping them with pacifists.

But as you note, the real disagreement regards the appropriate ends to which war should be used. That's not a "hawk" vs. "dove" split; that's closer to a "realist" vs. "neocon" split.

Posted by: SomeCallMeTim on September 17, 2006 02:54 PM

"The idea was that we were going to reconstruct Iraq into a stable, unitary, liberal democracy in the heart of the Middle East. The odds of achieving this were always extremely low."

We're in Iraq because many different folks with different agendas all wanted us in Iraq.

The idea you've settled upon as the reason we went to war - the Athenization of Iraq - is indeed near impossible with the resources we committed. But with 500,000 multinational troops for at least 5 years, even such an ambitious goal would have been possible.

Or with the forces we did commit, deposing Saddam and quickly installing a less hostile regime so we could finally settle the ongoing Gulf War I would also have been possible.

The incompetency argument against the Bush administration in Iraq is sound because they did not match their war aims with equal war resources, and thus guaranteed us failure.

Posted by: Petey on September 17, 2006 03:17 PM

First, note the Bush team's strength: getting elected.

Second, remember that Bush told a friend back in 1999 that were he elected he'd like there to be a war so that he could push his domestic agenda.

Everything flows from that. Personally, I don't think Iraq was bungled in the sense that they stupidly made assumptions that turned out false. I think that the Bushies mangled Iraq on purpose to prolong it. Iraq's don't just come along every day and the advantages that flow from being a "war time president" must not be squandered.

Posted by: Jeffrey Davis on September 17, 2006 03:34 PM

It's not a question only of whether or not it could have "succeeded," Chomsky is clear enough in his opinion that it could have, and more than a few experts- on Iraq not American politics- argued that Iraqu nationalism was the stroner than sectarianism, at least at the beginning. The invasion of Afghanistan should have worked: the people there still want our help. But it's failing thanks the Bush and co.

I'd still call both invasions mistakes and the invasion of Iraq a crime. Oversimplify for your own reasons if you want. Americans understand "Law and Order" but not law.

Posted by: Seth Edenbaum on September 17, 2006 03:42 PM

too many typos.

Posted by: s.e. on September 17, 2006 03:42 PM

>Today, all of the world's oil nations, except Norway, have either authoritarian governments, such as those in Saudi Arabia and Iraq, or what Carnegie Endowment for International Peace political scientist Marina Ottaway calls "semi-authoritarian" governments.

Canada, home of the largest oil fields outside of Saudi Arabia, has a semi-authoritarian government? This Judis fellow must be really smart, to know so much that the rest of us don't.

Posted by: Potato Head on September 17, 2006 03:53 PM

"There was nothing FEMA possibly could have done that would have made a levy-breaching hurricane hit on New Orleans somehow non-catastrophic; Bush took a bad thing and made it worse, he didn't take a benign occurence and make it bad."

The Army Core of Engineers could have done something about it. New Orleans did not receive a direct hit. Instead the effects of hurricane (at a level 1 or level 2 force) caused the break in the levees. Those levees should have been able to withstand that force. Congress is also responsible for not funding improvements. So the federal government, and by extension Bush, could have done something about the 'levy breaching hurricane'. Bush is not responsible for the hurricane, but insofar he is responsible for the federal government's actions, he is responsible for the hurricane being a 'levy breaching' hurricane.

Posted by: Tim on September 17, 2006 04:02 PM

just a little clarification. a LEVEE breaching hurricane did not hit new orleans. katrina caused cat 1 or 2 conditions in new orleans, and the federally designed and constructed levees failed under those conditions. there were supposed to protect against cat 3 conditions. the army corp of engineers has investigated and admitted this, but no one seems to notice.

new orleans was hit by incompetence.

Posted by: mark on September 17, 2006 04:06 PM

Potato Head,

Norway already had well-entrenched structures of liberal democracy and civil society before its oil wealth started to pay off. If you insert Canada (or Great Britain) into this sentence the same argument applies.

Besides, Candada is 2nd largest in terms of reserves, in the form of tar sands, but I would be surprised if production from tar sands exceeds 2 million barrels/day within the next 20 years, if ever.

Posted by: DMonteith on September 17, 2006 04:10 PM

Interesting how these countries' fall into "authoritarianism" only happens when it stops doing the US bidding re access to its resources. If it elects a ruler who has different ideas (Venezuela/Chavez, Iran/Mossadegh), it somehow becomes a 'moral' issue that we 'liberate' the country's poor inhabitatns, and if the replacement (the Shah) is rather worse, we still send him millions of dollars in aid, as long as he reverts to an obedient posture. And then we count on dutiful lickspittles like Chait and Judis to cluck their tongues about the mysterious "curse" of being an oil-rich nation.

Posted by: Potato Head on September 17, 2006 04:16 PM

If Bush could have bungled Katrina this badly, isn't it just possible he could have done the same thing in Iraq?

Just because it was possible for Katrina to be less of a fiasco doesn't mean SDI is possible. What a bizarre chain of reasoning (for Chait): pointing out the incompetence of the Bush admin in one area means you are granting that any of its other stated goals are achievable.

Posted by: kth on September 17, 2006 04:17 PM

Another factor here is the "Big Gamble" of the Iraq invasion -- no matter how you slice it, invading Iraq was a gamble, a gamble in which some degree of failure was (and is) a major potential outcome. While liberal hawks may plausibly argue that the outcome has been worse due to Bush Administration incompetance, they have not even begun to make a case that total, or even partial, success would have been likely under different, more competant leadership. They argue that the Bush Administration's mistakes were all avoidable, but if those mistakes were not made (say, if a super-competant Administration were in effect), would the outcome in Iraq be 180 degrees different? Or would it be just a little bit less of a quagmire?

Or, perish the thought, would a liberal hawk administration's handling of the war have been worse due to partisan squabbling or even just dumb bad luck?

Accidents happen, history takes odd turns, and risky endeavors can turn ugly at the slightest gust of wind no matter how skilled the leaders are. The risk of failure in Iraq was (and is) far bigger than anything but the most farfetched benefits of success.

The problem, ultimately, is just as you say: the whole idea was misbegotten to begin with. The "hubris", in the neocon camp and in the liberal hawk camp, is this idea: America can spontaneously and unilaterally invade and topple a major power halfway around the world and successfully make it into a friendly ally without aggravating countless other political, military, ethnic, and ideological conflicts around the world. While possible in theory, Murphy's Law alone should be enough to convince a rational person to back off.

I still think that the heart of the whole thing is simple: the Bush Administration was, even before 9/11, scammed in a Rasputin-like way by Chalabi into beleiving that the invasion was not going to be risky. They then sold that idea to the liberal hawks, who were all too happy to take an opportunity to expose the size of their balls. Now they're all just making shit up as they go along.

Posted by: Christopher Fahey on September 17, 2006 04:27 PM

What all the hawks have in common is that they seem to think the
only opinions and contexts that matter in Iraq are American ones. Many Iraqis were required to work in the disarmament program in 1991-1992, they were free to tell all their friends after the fall of Baghdad in 2003 that the WMD accusation was false. They also had experienced the rigorous embargo and the bombing in the 'no fly zones.' They also know now that Iran provided useful disinformation to help motivate the Americans, repeated faithfully by Paul Wolfowitz and Judith Miller.
The bungling and political patronage practiced by Rumsfeld and Bremer made things worse, but this is an occupation that was doomed to fail in winning majority Iraqi support. I'm sure that many other resource-rich nations in the world have taken note of the lie and violence campaign in Iraq and are not stinting in their preparations to resist the most predatory government that now exists.

Posted by: Multisect on September 17, 2006 04:31 PM

Jebus, I'm having trouble reading the original Chait article. It goes from inaccurate generalization to crappy stereotyping to mislabling to just plain b.s.

He starts with saying the all Dems love the circular firing squad and that Dems are next going to have an ideological "bloodbath" over doves and hawks, specifically, whether Iraq failed through incompetence or was doomed to failure no matter what.

First of all, if it's an ideological bloodbath, it's because idiot hawks like him make it so. Second of all, he creates a false dichotomy. He labels people who believe Iraq was doomed to failure as doves. Wrong. Believing going into Iraq, a country of a few tens of millions, of diverse and often warring backgrounds, in a volatile, oil-rich region, with a different culture, for NO GOOD REASON, to build a democracy?! It doesn't take a dove to think that's a bad idea and it was doomed to failure from the get-go. Add in Bush's incompetence, his policy against nation-building, the fact that he wanted to go in with a skeleton crew, and all the other facts that should've lit up the switch board like a nuclear reactor melting down, and yeah, this project was doomed from the start.

Also, it seems Chait's still living in the 60's and early 70's, as the first paragraph indicates. He needs to WAKE UP!! This ain't the 60's. Opposing this war does not a hippie make. Nor does it mean that person is opposed to all wars, or all uses of force, or all military deployments. It simply means that people thought this war was crap from the get-go. Obviously, blindingly, crap. Chait needs to stop with the crass, inaccurate, and misleading stereotypes.

"Democrats are never truly happy unless they're at each others' throats." It's past time we did away with this meme. It only helps the Republicans.

Posted by: Bribes on September 17, 2006 04:34 PM

You're missing the most obvious "oil wealth" democracy: The United States. We used to be the worlds largest supplier of oil, and today we're something like the third (after Saudi Arabia, and Russia, but ahead of Iran, Nigeria and Venezuela). We also used to be an Oil exporter, in fact the reason the Japanese attacked us was for Oil!

Of course, Oil has always played a much smaller roll in our economy then SA or other oil nations. Oh well.

Posted by: Chad Okere on September 17, 2006 04:47 PM

Mr. Potato,
The key figure is the ratio of oil gdp to total gdp.
In this respect Canada is more like the USA than any OPEC country or Norway. This is not some sort of metric that Judis pulled out of his back pocket, it is as fairly lonstanding political science hypothesis, almost as well established as the correlation between stable democratic regimes and the presense of protestantism. Also
Canada has a long extablished democratic constitutional order (responsible government since the 1840s), (but I bet you knew that)

Posted by: Captain Canuck on September 17, 2006 05:01 PM

The other problem Chait doesn't address is that the very nature of the build-up to war -- all the scare tactics, bully-boy rhetoric and blatant politicizing before the '02 midterms -- provided PLENTY of reasons to doubt both the motives and methods of the enterprise. (Not to mention the serious questions that were raised by serious people inside and outside the government, which -- while not accorded front-page status -- were certainly there to see for anyone paying attention, as I assume Chait was.) The nature of the Bush administration and how it was going to exploit Sept. 11 for its own political gains was already well established by that point, and everything about the beating of the war drums should have set off the bullshit detectors in the brains of anyone who knew just a little bit of history (remember the Maine? the Gulf of Tonkin? I learned this stuff in 10th grade). I remember reading Pollack's piece in Foreign Affairs and thinking, well, maybe there's a case for confrontation -- or there would be, if only we had a government that you could trust with carrying it out in good faith. But we CLEARLY did not have that government.

So whether you want to argue that it was a noble cause bungled by idiots or a fool's errand bungled by idiots, you're still left with the fact that anyone who supported it was supporting a bunch of idiots. And along the way, they either tolerated or actively participated in the sneering derogation of anyone who raised reasonable questions or voiced reasonable doubts as a bunch of America-hating, Saddam-appeasing girlie-men. So no, I don't think the "hawks" should be allowed anywhere near the policy apparatus until they show that they can tell the difference between shit and shoe polish. In the meantime, I would advise Mr. Chait to get a second opinion before he enters into any business with deposed Nigerian princes.

Posted by: not a dove, just a skeptic on September 17, 2006 05:09 PM

I think Jeffrey Davis and Christopher Fahey are circling around an important point, and that is the role of domestic politics. The primary concern of both the Bush administration and the liberal hawks was how they would appear at home. The liberal hawks were indeed "all too happy to take an opportunity to expose the size of their balls", and the Republicans wanted to ride the war president to reelection in 04. The facts on the ground were secondary. Given those priorities, incompetence in Iraq was hardly surprising. Each group has achieved their primary goal, however. Bushco was reelected and the liberal hawks are still taken seriously because they were "wrong for the right reasons".

I am growing very weary of the game of 'Quien es mas macho?' that constitutes American political discourse.

Posted by: DMonteith on September 17, 2006 05:15 PM

As I've said many times before, I don't ask of Iraq hawks that they publicly declare that they were in error, to put on a hair shirt, or to be banished from polite society. All I ask is that they stop saying that somehow, if you look at it sideways in the correct manner, really they were right!

Is that too much to ask?

Posted by: Redshift on September 17, 2006 05:54 PM

Competence wouldn't have made their immorality any more justifiable.

Thousands of people have been mercilessly slaughtered.

Posted by: David Ehrenstein on September 17, 2006 05:57 PM

The Iraq situation can best be described by this old guy I used to work with at a program that helped inner city kids get an education after dropping out of school, he would tell the wanna be gang types that ended up getting in trouble "boys you can't even do wrong right"

Posted by: jbou on September 17, 2006 06:23 PM

Apologies for posting this here instead of emailing you directly, but I couldn't find an email address on your site. I understand the appeal of trading blows with Mr. Chait, but it seems to me something might be getting lost in the mix.

I'd like to know if you agree or disagree.

http://thepremise.com/archives/09/17/2006/126

Mark

Posted by: Mark Barrett on September 17, 2006 06:35 PM

If we had had a good reason to invade Iraq (e.g., they were attacking one of their neighbors), and if we had had a leadership that was both willing and able - that is, not merely competent, but dedicated to making Iraq a genuinely better place than before we invaded it - we had possibly as much as a 20% chance of success, optimistically.

But anyone who had watched Bush in action at any time during the campaign, or during the Selection fiasco, or during his first months in residence in the White House, already knew better. They knew that Team Bush not only lacked the heart to build a free country, but was ideologically opposed to the existence of such a country even if they hadn't had the sociopolitical divisions, backed by religion, that already affected them.

In other words, it was obvious well before we invaded that doing so was, at the very best, a really risky idea under any circumstances, and utterly insane under Bush's leadership.

But it was even more insane to do so when we had just been attacked by Islamist religious extremists.

Many people compare invading Iraq after being attacked by Al Qaeda with invading Mexico after being hit by the Japanese at Pearl Harbor and having Hitler declare war on us. It is not. It is like attacking England or France.

Posted by: Avedon on September 17, 2006 07:14 PM

Chait's upholding the standards of TNR alumni again, eh?

Gotta ask: Chait, Beinart, Easterbrook, Sullivan, Zengerle -- the list goes on, and it's long. Why should anyone give a fuck about the opinions of such determined shitheads?

Posted by: sglover on September 17, 2006 07:18 PM

My problem with all of this claptrap is that it conveniently sidesteps, and thus, in a sense, legitimizes, the insane, destabilizing and dangerous Bush preemption doctrine.

Posted by: Brautigan on September 17, 2006 07:31 PM

"I'm not super-concerned about personnel as such."

Right. Got it. They will now admit you in the club and buy your book. I figured it was coming.

Posted by: bob mcmanus on September 17, 2006 07:42 PM

Capitán Canuck,

Using the ratio of oil production to total gdp is a good idea, but there is still a problem, which is that the oil to gdp ratio is endogenous. That is, you can pull oil out of the ground even when your domestic institutions are in terrible shape --- viz Mexico at the height of the Revolution, or Angola during the Southern African wars, or Nigeria today. It's much harder to have, say, a vibrant manufacturing sector or sophisticated service providers when your domestic institutions don't work well. So in a country with lousy institutions, then oil will be a big part of the gdp. On the other hand, if you've got good institutions, then all sorts of others things will be going on in your economy, and oil won't (certainly not after a time) drive your gdp.

FWIW, Sachs and Rodriguez, one of whom first brought the broader "resource curse" hypothesis to the forefront of the field, have made a slightly different form of this argument to explain Sachs's finding that countries with high resource exports-to-gdp ratios are richer but grow more slowly than other, similar countries.

The oil curse as Judis presents it is a stronger hypothesis --- the oil curse argues that oil somehow makes your institutions worse. It's hard to find evidence of that. Is Trinidad more badly managed than Jamaica? Does Venezuela have worse state institutions than Colombia? Is Iran less democratic than Egypt? Was Sudan a paragon of good governance before finding oil? I have some doubts.

None of which has any bearing on Matt's argument, of course. Rebuilding Iraq as a liberal democracy was a mug's game, for all the reasons he mentions ... except oil.

Posted by: Noel Maurer on September 17, 2006 08:04 PM

Re: Second, remember that Bush told a friend back in 1999 that were he elected he'd like there to be a war so that he could push his domestic agenda.

If Bush did say that then it's more evidence that the man is a fool. Wars (when serious and sustained) generally drive domestic agendas onto the back burner. And the history of the Bush administration shows exccatly that: most of his domestic successes occured fairly early, but since Iraq has come to dominate American politics there have been very few domestic policy successes.

Posted by: JonF on September 17, 2006 08:11 PM

JonF,
Bush is a fool -- I believe the only Presidential history he really knows is his father's, and I think his father's incredible Gulf War I surge in popularity, followed by the precitpitous decline leading to his defeat had a profound impact on GWB's political outlook. I think it is worth keeping that in mind when thinking about GWB's decision to greenlight the Iraq war.

Posted by: theCoach on September 17, 2006 09:13 PM

I would suggest that what we take for unbelievable incompetence of this administration in Irak is in fact the consequence of the failure of a decent but risky gamble and the lack of a backup plan. Very probably, the original plan was something like what Petey describes; "deposing Saddam and quickly installing a less hostile regime". It would have been less brutal than Saddam, more inclusive of Shias, with even a few rigged "elections" now and then, a Saddam Lite, if you want. That was certainly not impossible with the resources allocated and numerous details of the original planning only make sense under this hypothesis. But unfortunately, that plan assumed two key components that failed to materialize; the changing of side of a large part of the Iraki Army and the Baath Party during the early phase of the war and the existence of a real base of political support and organization for Chalabi inside Irak. With the Iraki Army (and the police and most of the administration, too) basically desintegrating (or remaining loyal to Saddam and going underground) and Chalabi incapable of producing even a minimal number of organized supporters, there was basically nobody to "install" left. And it was then when things started to go really wrong, because nothing had been planned for that circumstance and so we were left to contemplate the improvisation and incompetence that we are almost used to now. We can argue about what would have happened if several Iraki Army divisions and a few provincial governors had changed sides as soon as the troops invaded (and if Chalabi had possesed even the skeleton of a political organization inside Irak) and I will grant that a Chalabi led "soft dictatorship" with the support of a large part of the Baathist elite and Shias would have been possible in that case. But it wouldn't have been democracy in any sense of the word and THAT has to be clear.

Posted by: Carlos on September 17, 2006 09:35 PM

Ummm... Venezuela has an elected president who has stood up in several campaigns, as well as a trumped up recall election. There is no evidence that his regime is "authoritarian", unless you mean "pisses off rich people" as authoritarian.

Posted by: Mysticdog on September 17, 2006 10:04 PM

On the other hand, though, it's not Bush's fault that a hurricane hit New Orleans.

Silly Matt! Everyone knows Katrina was God's judgement on the U.S. for being dumb enough to elect the guy two times.

Posted by: flippantangel on September 17, 2006 10:43 PM

Canada and Mexico aren't oil nations?

Posted by: Geek, Esq. on September 18, 2006 12:57 AM

Well, we all accept that Bush administration is utterly incompetent, and, of course, it is possible that incompetence may have been the reason for the fiasco in Iraq.

That does not prove, however, that the Iraq project was not doomed to begin with. This is precisely the basis of the main liberal critique of the 'liberal hawks', i.e., they enthusiastically supported the Iraq war which was a thoroughly bad idea even before the first bombs were dropped on Baghdad.

Posted by: gregor on September 18, 2006 02:48 AM

That "resource curse" idea is pernicious nonsense, ignoring as it does the context in which these authoritarian or semi-authoritarian regimes arose. It is because first the UK, then the US actively helped these repressive regimes come to power, overthrowing more democratic regimes in e.g. (wottacoincidence!) Iraq and Iran in favour of authoritarian regimes that did as they were told.

To then pretend that, gee there's something magical about oil that makes countries that have it not democratic is just offensive. Oil rich countries tend to have authoritarian governments because that's what the US wants, as long as they do as they're told. It's only once they stop doing so that the US gets terrible concerned about democracy. Viz. Venezuela, so anti-democratic the US just had to sponsor a coup there.

Posted by: Martin Wisse on September 18, 2006 05:31 AM

Most victims of invasion would challenge your assertion that being invaded is "a benign occurrence."

But since you're a sheltered little bourgeois American (and no immigrant from a war-torn land, nor apparently have ever talked with one), which is just longhand for "lacking in empathy", you *still* don't understand how having the hell bombed out of your infrastructure and foreign armies on your soil could be a negative.

Wow. Just wow. (And people wonder why I'm not impressed with Ivy League schools - or their products.)

Posted by: bellatrys on September 18, 2006 07:15 AM

Most victims of invasion would challenge your assertion that being invaded is "a benign occurrence."

The only person who used that term is Matthew.

He said, "Bush took a bad thing and made it worse, he didn't take a benign occurence and make it bad."

As best as I can tell, you're criticizing Matthew for asserting something that he emphatically rejects.

Posted by: DivGuy on September 18, 2006 08:01 AM

Re: It is because first the UK, then the US actively helped these repressive regimes come to power, overthrowing more democratic regimes in e.g. (wottacoincidence!) Iraq and Iran in favour of authoritarian regimes that did as they were told.

What former democratic Iraqi regieme? Are you posting from some alternate reality? Iraq has always been governed by autocrats-- first by Hashemite monarchs, then by Baathist dictators. And the US (although not the UK) is largely blameless in the accession of any of those thugs.

Posted by: JonF on September 18, 2006 09:54 PM

Just to be clear, the fourteen leading oil-producing nations in 2004 were:

Saudi Arabia
Russia
United States
Iran
Mexico
China
Norway
Canada
Venezuela
United Arab Emirates
Kuwait
Nigeria
United Kingdom
Iraq

It's really hard to claim with a straight face that the US, Canada, Norway, the UK, and Mexico are totalitarianisms, and not easy to make that claim about Venezuela. Russia moves back and forth across the border, and I'm honestly not sure where Nigeria falls these days. Most of these top fifteen are marked by heavy kleptocracy, though--the US now much more than five years ago, with all of the attendant ill effects.

(The US is an extraction economy--it is heavily dependent upon depletion of natural resources for its survival. The two biggest in the US are oil and underground water.)

Posted by: Kevin J. Maroney on September 19, 2006 01:03 PM

Well, I would say that Matthew should be taken to task for supporting aggressive, pre-emptive wars in the first place. His liberal cred is blown away completely by that.

Any complaining or analysis you do after the fact, Matthew Yglesias, is a waste of time and effort.

This war is YOUR fault. ALL the death and destruction that is a result of YOUR support is on YOUR SOUL. Who cares if we didn't know how badly the cheney administration would bungle the result? Everyone knew it was a bad idea from the start. A bad, illegal, unnecessary and completely un-needed idea.

Your support for it makes YOU a bushite. I blame people like you for the place we are in now.

I hang the iraq war like a burning tire around YOUR neck. Good luck getting it off, you pompous, fake liberal.

Posted by: Shorter Rightwing Arseholes on September 19, 2006 01:55 PM

thanks
best regards.

Posted by: mirc on September 22, 2007 08:03 PM

dhbasd

Posted by: perde on October 1, 2007 06:26 AM

dsadasda

Posted by: perde on October 1, 2007 06:27 AM

duıahdıoa

Posted by: mefruşat on October 1, 2007 06:28 AM

very
good..

Posted by: evden eve nakliyat on October 8, 2007 02:26 AM

thanks

Posted by: sex shop on November 16, 2007 04:35 AM

thanks

Posted by: alisveris on November 16, 2007 04:36 AM

haber sitesi

Posted by: haber sitesi on November 16, 2007 07:52 AM

Interesting article!
Thanks

Posted by: youtube on November 16, 2007 01:04 PM

slm

Posted by: pede on February 17, 2008 11:01 AM

thanks ;)

Posted by: firefox indir on March 31, 2008 04:49 AM

thanks ;)

Posted by: firefox indir on April 1, 2008 06:42 AM

thank you

Posted by: html kodları on April 6, 2008 04:23 AM

thank you

Posted by: firefox indir on April 6, 2008 09:04 AM

thank you

Posted by: maswey on April 9, 2008 11:08 AM

thank you

Posted by: firefox nedir on April 13, 2008 03:50 AM

thank you

Posted by: firefox nedir on April 13, 2008 03:51 AM

good!!thanks!!

Posted by: Amway on June 2, 2008 10:08 PM

thanks!!

Posted by: Moving services on June 2, 2008 10:09 PM

sex shop
thanks good .

Posted by: seks shop on September 14, 2008 10:59 PM

harbiarkadas.com
harbiarkadas.net
harbiarkadas.org
itirafet.org
ebedava.net
elektronikmarket.net
ameribress.com
clitoriacream.net
superspenisbuyutucu.com
megabress.com
rednightperformans.com
performansartirici.com
penisplus.tv
penispluspenisbuyutucu.com
penispluspenisbuyutucu.net
cinselmerkez.com
aseks.net
erotikcamasirlar.com
vajinatr.com
bakirevajina.com
cinselkozmetik.com
kozmetikmedikel.com
eturknet.com
tecavuz.net
yutuvideo.com
ponotubesex.com
laraperuk.com
sackanagimerkezi.com
peruksa.com
perukmarket.com
aseks.com
aloveshop.com
erotikgiyim.com
geciktiricispreyler.com
geciktiricihap.com
geciktiriciler.com
azdirici.com
bayanuyarici.com
fntazialemi.com
fantaziservisi.om
cinselmazemeler.com
cinselfantaziurunleri.com
erotikdakikalar.com
erotikmarketiniz.com
seksmarketiniz.com
sekshatlari.com
erotikdergiler.com
erotikderginiz.com
penisbuyutucuviprx.com
penisbuyutucuvigrx.com
penisbuyutuculer.com
vigrxpenisbuyutucu.com
sismebebekler.com
sismebebekshop.com
yemekeviniz.com
sanalmarketiniz.com
elektronikmarket.net
ebedava.net
kontortr.com
elaydin23.com
turkcellkontorcu.com
aveakontoral.com
vodafonekontoral.com
toptankontorcu.com
cinselkozmetik.com
bayanpartnerler.com
erkekpartnerler.com
kizarkadaslar.com
yonjaarkadas.com
siberalem-siberalem.com
sexpartnerler.com
sekspartnerler.com
erotikpartnerler.com
gencyuz.com
erkekarkadaslar.com
bayanarkadaslar.com
yemekeviniz.com
sanalmarketiniz.com
baskahaber.com
medikalkozmetik.net
kozmetikmedikal.com
zayiflamavediyet.net
zayiflamahapii.com
zayiflamabandii.com
kilovertr.com
zayiflamatr.net
diyettr.com
toksinbandi.net
botoxtr.com
botokstr.com
selulittedavii.com
selulitgiderici.net
selulitkremii.com
catlaktedavisii.com
catlakgiderici.net
catlakkremii.com

sex shop

Posted by: sexshop on November 10, 2008 07:15 AM

vpills shop

Posted by: vpills shop on November 21, 2008 12:14 PM

thenks http://www.sexshopum.com: sex shop, sexshop, erotik shop, erotikshop, erotic shop, eroticshop, erotik market, erotikmarket, seks shop, seksshop, erotic market, eroticmarket, sex market, sexmarket, seks market, seksmarket, sexs shop, sexsshop, erotik, erotic, seks, sex, erotik magaza, penis büyütücü, penis büyütücüler, geciktirici sprey, geciktirici spreyler,göğüs büyütücü, göğüs büyütücüler, bayan azdırıcı damla, geciktirici hap, geciktirici, geciktiriciler, penis büyütücü haplar, penis büyütücü hap, prezervatifler, şişme bebek, şişme bebekler, şişme manken, vibratör, vajina, cinsel istek arttırıcı, cinsellik, geciktirici krem, cinsel ürünler, erotik ürünler

Posted by: erotik shop on November 27, 2008 06:48 AM


thenks http://www.penisbuyutuculeri.com Penis Büyütücü, Penis Büyütücü Ürünler,Büyük Penis, Cinsel Organ, Cinsel Performans, Erken Boşalma, Penis Geliştirici, Cinsel İsteksizlik,Kalın Penis, İri Penis,Super S, SuperSize, Super S Penis Büyütücü, SuperSize Penis Büyütme

Posted by: penis buyutuculer on November 27, 2008 06:54 AM

Now a days web application are increasing


simdi biz bu siteyi kasarken cinsel chat birde sohbet odaları
olarak kasmaya calıstık iki sohbet de ilerleme var ona birde mirc yaptık gun gectikce
kelebek script olarak hit alamaya basladık oda olmadı birde kelebek
radyo muz olsun dedik iyi kotu muhabbet oluyordu ama baktık sohbet
çet cet odaları de is yok donduk indir e ondada tat tuz kalmamıs rüya
tabirlerine zipladık izmir de oturuyorum iste .. sonra da yavas yavas ilerlemeye basladık
turk sohbet odalarına kadar geldik .. bir sonraki hedefimiz
yada mIRC olacak insallah ..

cinsel sohbet | operserv | chanserv | memoserv
nickserv | ask | kadınca oyun itiraf link degisimi siir guzel sozler

izmir sohbet cinsel sohbet kelebek mirc operserv chanserv siir botserv zurna mynet ataturk universitesi sohbet chat odalari au sohbet au chat kelebek script kelebek script kelebek mirc kelebek skript mric gazi universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,gazi sohbet,gazi chat,kelebek duzce universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,duzce sohbet,duzce chat ... ege universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,ege sohbet,ege chat,kelebek dumlu pınar universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,dumlupınar sohbet ... memoserv, memo serv,memoserv komutlari mesaj komutlari irc mesaj ... mirc indir kamerali mirc yabanci mirc mirc 6.21
sesli tv seslisesli sesliask sesli fıkra sesliefsane sesliyiz sesli türkiyem seslialem sesli dini sohbet ... erzincan universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,erzincan sohbet ... Yüzük Script mirc yüzük cet yüzük script 4 yuzuk sohbet yüzük chat ankara sohbet ankara chat ankara muhabbet ankara arkadas ankara.net erciyes universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,erciyes sohbet,erciyes ... dicle universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,dicle sohbet,dicle chat ... mirc indir,mirc script,mirc yukle,mirc,script mırç,mrc,kelebek ... kelebek cinsel sohbet cinsel chat kelebek mirc myrc script mirc programi turkçe mirc indir mric mrc ... izmir sohbet izmir chat izmir muhabbet izmir arkadas izmir cet çet kelebek sohbet odalari chat sohpet cet kelebek muhabbet çet ... arkadasbul askim - arkadas bul, arkadas arama, arkadas ara ... kelebek host iletisim bilgileri sitene sohbet ekle sitene chat ekle sitene sohbet odasi koy kelebek sohbet , chat kelebek sohbet , cet kelebek sohbet , canli ... sohbet Kizlarla Sohbet Kızlarla Sohbet, Bedava Sohbet Odası ... kelebek sohbet chat muhabbet amasya uiversitesi sohbet chat odalari au sohbet au chat canakkale onsekiz mart universitesi sohbet chat odalari comu ... istanbul sohbet istanbul chat istanbul muhabbet istanbul arkadas

Posted by: çet on December 8, 2008 01:52 PM

Thank you

Posted by: beslenme on December 14, 2008 05:02 AM

THANKS

Posted by: Frmlive on December 14, 2008 05:04 AM

;Thanks

Posted by: Lonyer on December 14, 2008 05:04 AM

thanks you

Posted by: porno on December 14, 2008 06:00 AM

Hii
very very nice blog
thank you

Posted by: indir on December 14, 2008 06:24 AM

very nice

Posted by: Video on December 14, 2008 06:40 AM

very very nice

Posted by: mustafa on December 14, 2008 06:41 AM

very very nice...

Posted by: Video on December 14, 2008 06:42 AM

very very thanx

Posted by: İzle on December 14, 2008 06:42 AM

www.cinselliksorunlari.com
www.dizimix.org
www.programpaylas.net
www.sanalbanka.net

Posted by: mahlas on December 14, 2008 06:50 AM

amına koyyım link çöplüğüne döndürmüşsünüz.

Posted by: program indir on December 14, 2008 06:54 AM

Very nice

Posted by: Burçlar on December 14, 2008 07:11 AM

Good post

Posted by: okey on December 14, 2008 07:13 AM

thanks for this post

Posted by: http://www.exdizayn.com on December 14, 2008 07:18 AM

thanks my friend

Posted by: http://www.bybugu.com on December 14, 2008 07:19 AM

thanks.

Posted by: Dantel on December 14, 2008 07:22 AM

merci..

Posted by: msn indir on December 14, 2008 07:22 AM

good job thanks for the post

Posted by: porno on December 14, 2008 07:25 AM

hey admin good post.

Posted by: porno izle on December 14, 2008 07:26 AM

thanks

Posted by: pornolar on December 14, 2008 07:28 AM

thanks very...

Posted by: Eglence on December 14, 2008 07:31 AM

thank on the post

Posted by: pornosu on December 14, 2008 07:32 AM

I’m writing from turkey. It’s very nice that you mention this subject. Your explanations are enough.

Posted by: dali paşa on December 14, 2008 07:53 AM

Your site is so nice. Esperially it is nice as visual.

Posted by: dali paşa on December 14, 2008 07:55 AM

Thanks!

Posted by: Müzik on December 14, 2008 12:41 PM

thanks

Posted by: turksiding on December 14, 2008 01:04 PM

köpek sitesi

Posted by: köpek sitesi on December 14, 2008 06:40 PM

hamile kalmak isteyenlere öneriler. gebelik konusunda ön bilgiler hepsi ve daha fazlası http://www.hamilekamak.com Adet düzensizliği hamile kalmak için uygun günler ve cinsel sağlık bilgileri

Posted by: hamile kalmak on December 15, 2008 10:13 AM

It’s very nice that you mention this subject. Your site is so nice. Esperially it is nice as visual.

Posted by: dalidas on December 15, 2008 11:37 AM

Dizi izle , türk dizileri , dizisi , kore dizileri , dizi izle , adanalı , asi , yaprak dökümü

Posted by: dizi izle on December 16, 2008 12:05 AM

Dizi izle , diziizle , türk dizileri , dizisi , kore dizileri , dizi izle , adanalı , asi , yaprak dökümü

Posted by: dizi izle on December 16, 2008 12:06 AM

His use of "hawks" and "doves" is somewhat slippery, as well. Much of the anti-Iraq War crowd--including, I think, you--critiques the decision to go to war in the same way that Scowcroft does. Yet no one would call Scowcroft a "dove." To the extent that those Dems who supported the Iraq War are really neoconservative-lights--a fair charge--then "hawk" and "dove" doesn't get to the heart of the disagreement. More, it muddles the disagreement: the implication is that "doves" are dead-set against war in almost all cases, and that nothing is lost by grouping them with pacifists.

Posted by: canlı tv on December 16, 2008 12:22 AM

just a little clarification. a LEVEE breaching hurricane did not hit new orleans. katrina caused cat 1 or 2 conditions in new orleans, and the federally designed and constructed levees failed under those conditions. there were supposed to protect against cat 3 conditions. the army corp of engineers has investigated and admitted this, but no one seems to notice.

Posted by: film listesi on December 16, 2008 12:23 AM

thank you baby eyvallah :D

Posted by: forum on December 16, 2008 05:31 AM

thanks.

Posted by: turksiding on December 16, 2008 05:47 AM

thanks.

Posted by: fibercement on December 16, 2008 05:49 AM

Thanks

Posted by: Oto Tuning on December 16, 2008 03:32 PM

tuning

Posted by: Tuning on December 16, 2008 03:33 PM

Thanks for this nice article.
Regards...

Posted by: oyunlar on December 16, 2008 04:06 PM

thx for text

Posted by: msn ifadeleri on December 16, 2008 06:54 PM

thanks

Posted by: smf on December 16, 2008 07:10 PM

thanks jnx ;)

Posted by: teknoloji on December 16, 2008 07:12 PM

thanks for admin

Posted by: porno izle on December 17, 2008 03:43 AM

thanks for admin

Posted by: pornolar on December 17, 2008 03:44 AM

thanks for you. very nice sharing online film izle

Posted by: film izle on December 17, 2008 07:08 AM

thanks

for news web site

http://www.politikhaber.org

Posted by: Haber on December 17, 2008 08:58 AM

thanks janım

Posted by: msn nickleri on December 19, 2008 10:40 AM

I’m writing from Turkey. I like your writings.

Posted by: dalidas on December 19, 2008 06:43 PM

thanks

Posted by: porno izle on January 4, 2009 09:20 AM

thanks

Posted by: bilgi on January 4, 2009 09:21 AM

thanks

Posted by: video izle on January 4, 2009 09:22 AM

thanks you

Posted by: kelebek mirc indir on January 8, 2009 11:59 AM

thanks admincim

Posted by: seks hikaye on January 12, 2009 05:31 PM

thanks admin

Posted by: seks hikaye on January 13, 2009 11:23 AM

thank you

Posted by: porno izle on January 18, 2009 10:48 AM

mirc mırc mirç

Posted by: mirc on January 23, 2009 06:21 PM

Filmizle | Film izle | Vizyon Filim | VizyonFilmi | Seyret | Filmini | Full izle | Dizi izle | Online izle | Filmini izle | Film izlemek | Online Full Seyret izle | Bedava Film izle | internetten Film izle | Online Sinema izle | Videoizlesene | Online Dizi izle | Erotik Filmler | indirmeden Full izle | 18 Filmler | Son Bölümler | SinemaFanClub | Dini Filmler | Video Klibler | Serdar Ortaç | Online 2009 Filmleri | sinemafan | Online Sinema | Hadise | girbi | Kavak Yelleri | 2009 Filmleri | Film Seyret | Süper Sinema | videocenter | 18 film izle | 2008 Filmleri | Sinema Filmi izle | Sinemalar izle | Videoları izle | Dizifilm izle | indirmeden Film izle | Netten izle | Film izlet | Lost | Maç izle | Canlı izle | Full Film izle | Sinema izle | Yeni Filmler | Vizyondakiler | Vizyon Filmleri | izlesene | Direk izle | Kurtlar Vadisi Pusu | Canlı Yayın Maç | Tekmekan Sinema izle | Netten Bedava izle | Sinema Seyret | Aksiyon Filmler | Yabancı Sinema | Beleş izle | DVDRip Film izle | Canlı Yayın Film izle | XviD Film izle | DivX Film izle | Cinetr | Full dizi | Korku Filmi | Kesintisiz izle | Direkizle | Korkufilmi | Online Film izle | Çizgifilm | Animasyon izle | izle | Canlı Yayın Maç izle | Canlı Yayın Film izle | Kurtlar Vadisi Pusu izle | Vizyondakiler izle | Eski Türk Filmleri | Yerli Dram izle | Yerli Aksiyon izle | Yerli Komedi izle | Yerli Korku izle | Yerli Romantik izle | Yerli Savaş izle | Yerli Dizi izle | Yabancı Dram izle | Yabancı Romantik izle | Yabancı Aksiyon izle | Yabancı Macera izle | Yabancı Gerilim izle | Yabancı Korku izle | Yabancı Savaş izle | Yabancı Polisiye izle | Yabancı Dizi izle | Belgesel izle | Fantastik Film izle | Tiyatro izle | İslami Film izle | Çizgi Film | Videoizle | indir izle | Link Değişimi | e-film | e-sinema | islami Filmler | Tiyatro izle | Belgesel izle | Romantik Film izle | Komik Film izle | Seks Filmi izle | Vizyondakiler | Türk Filmi izle | Kemal Sunal Filmleri | Show | imeem | Justin.tv | Tv izle | Tv Seyret | Netlog | Facebook | Youtube | Site Ekle | Siteekle | Link Ekle | Link Değişimi | Toplist | Hit Siteler | Oriflame | Oriflame Kozmetik | Oriflamekozmetik | Oriflametr | Kozmetik | Parfüm | Koku | Cilt Bakımı | Saç | Makyaj | Ruj | Katalog | Üyelik | Satış | Sipariş | Hediye | Kampanya | Kariyer | Kazanç | Fırsat | Oje | Krem | Losyon | Jel | Kazanç | | iş imkanı | Danışman | Temsilci | Sponsor | Bilgi | Bilgibu | Bilgi Bu | Popüler Bil | Bedava Bilgi | Online Bilgi | Ücretsiz Bilgi | iyi Bilgi | Aşk Şiirleri | Yemek Tarifleri | Rüya Tabirleri | Şifalı Bitkiler | Dini Bilgiler | Güzel Sölzer | Atatürk | Sağlık | illerimiz | Eğitim | Anne ve Bebek | Aşk ve Evlilik | internet | Astroloji | Bilgisayar | Fıkralar | Çiçek ve Bitkiler | Sevgi | Türk Tarihi | Oyunlar | Pratik Bilgiler | Güzellik ve Moda | Hava Durumu | ilansayfası | Forum | Efendi Forum | Forumx | Forumtr | Frm | Bilgi Forum | Sağlık Forumu | iş forumu | Wordpress | Joomla | Php Nuke | Forum Turkey | Sohbet | Chat | Muhabbet | Mirc | Efendi | Efendi Sohbet | Canlı Canlı | Heyecanlı | Kızlar | Msn | Sohbet Odaları | Bedava Sohbet | Görüntülü Sohbet | Kameralı Chat | Memur | Memuru | Memurlar | Memurum | Memurumuz | Sağlık Memuru | Polis Memuru | Öğretmen | Atama | Yer Değiştirme | Tayin | Becayiş | Yönetmelik | 657 | Devlet Memuru | Sivil Memur | Bağkur | Emekli Sandığı | Bağ-kur | Kanun | Torpil | KPSS | Sınav | ÖSYM | OSS | Kamu Personeli | Doktor | Doktorlar | Hemşire | Ebe | Hemşireler | Ebeler | Hademe | Milli Eğitim | Hastane | Okul | Lisans | Doktora | LDS | TUS | Sözleme | Sözleşmeli Memur | Sözleşmeli Personel | Personel | Diyanet | İmam | Asker | Askeri Personel | Subay | Astsubay | Polis | Hakim | Savcı | Avukat | Hukuk | Mühendis | Karayolları | Belediye | Zabıta | Güvenlik | TCK | Devlet Su işleri | Özel idare | Köy Hizmetleri | Alt Yapı | Daire Başkanlığı | Tıbbi Sekreter | Sekreter | Dışişleri | içişleri | Bakanlık | Bakanlıklar | Memur Sorunları | Psikolojik Danışmanlık | Taltif | Terfi | Ödül | Hediye | Kıdem | Derece | Kademe | Emeklilik | Emekli olmak | Emeklilik Tarihi | Başarılı Personel | Ceza | Kıdem Cezası | Disiplin Cezası | Disiplin Tüzüğü | Personel Alımı | Bayan Personel | Erkek Personel | Disiplin Cezası | Disiplin Cezaları | Sicil | Sicil Affı | Ruhsat | Disiplin Affı | Silah | Pasaport | Yeşil Pasaport | Eş ve Çocuklar | Bakmakla Yükümlü | Yardım | Sağlık Yardımı | Para Yardımı | Borç | Sandık | Sendika | Sendikası | Sendikalar | Üye Olma | Ayrılma | Meslekten Atma | Meslektan Çıkarma | Yemek | Binbir Tarif | Pasta Tarifi | Kek Tarifi | Tatlı Tarifi | Yemek Tarifleri | Türk Yemekleri | Yöresel Yemekler | Tarifler | Oriflame | Oriflame Kozmetik | binbirtarif | Oriflametr | Kozmetik | Parfüm | Koku | Cilt Bakımı | Saç | Makyaj | Ruj | Katalog | Üyelik | Satış | Sipariş | Hediye | Kampanya | Kariyer | Kazanç | Fırsat | Oje | Krem | Losyon | Jel | Kazanç | | iş imkanı | Danışman | Temsilci | Sponsor | Video | Videolar | Video izle | Video seyret | Video ekle | Komik Video | Kamera Şakaları | Korkunç Videolar | İlginç Videolar | Site Ekle | SiteEkle | Toplist | Hit Sayacı | Dizin | Link Değişimi Backlink | Ücretsiz Site Ekle | Bedava Site Ekle | Karşılıksız Site Ekle | Hit Siteler | Ktunnel | Vtunnel | Youtube |

Posted by: Online Mp3 Dinle on January 23, 2009 07:51 PM

tank you

Posted by: anal sex on January 28, 2009 08:22 AM

good

Posted by: sex on January 28, 2009 08:23 AM

thank

Posted by: sex on January 28, 2009 08:24 AM

More often than not, anything that screams “call me immediately, limited time offer” is perceived by scam by a lot of people. However, if someone is really serious about buying what you are selling, they will definitely call - they got nothing to lose by making preliminary inquiries.

Posted by: sohbet on February 23, 2009 03:51 PM

i have seen the fashion magazine before but one made by bruce gilden. loved it. i did not know alec soth also made one. thinking about ordering a copy now…

Posted by: Dekorasyon on March 18, 2009 10:18 AM

porno cd

Posted by: porno cd on March 19, 2009 09:53 AM

thanks

Posted by: sikiş on March 19, 2009 11:44 AM

erotic shop

Posted by: erotic shop on March 21, 2009 07:55 AM

porno dvd

Posted by: porno dvd on March 21, 2009 07:58 AM

hello

Posted by: perde on March 24, 2009 09:06 AM

hi nice web

Posted by: mirc on March 27, 2009 08:25 AM

thanks, By Brooklyn

Posted by: cet on March 27, 2009 10:58 AM

thanks for all

Posted by: azdırıcı on March 28, 2009 06:28 AM

thanks...

Posted by: kayan-yazı on March 29, 2009 05:19 AM

nice site

Posted by: nude pictures on March 29, 2009 05:20 AM

a good things

Posted by: cinsel sorunlar on March 29, 2009 05:21 AM

thank you...

Posted by: Disney Hotels on March 29, 2009 05:22 AM

very good

Posted by: animal photos on March 29, 2009 05:23 AM

a good web

Posted by: nba photos on March 29, 2009 05:24 AM

hi thanks

Posted by: seo on March 29, 2009 05:26 AM

oo nice...

Posted by: sikiş izle on March 29, 2009 05:26 AM

erotikshop

Posted by: erotikshop on April 1, 2009 10:11 AM

penis büyütücüler

Posted by: penis büyütücüler on April 1, 2009 10:11 AM

sex shop

Posted by: sexshop on April 1, 2009 10:17 AM

penis büyütücü hap

Posted by: penis büyütücü hap on April 1, 2009 11:41 AM

thanks nice web
sohbet

Posted by: Sohbet on April 3, 2009 04:10 AM

thanks..

Posted by: güvenlik on April 8, 2009 02:50 AM

thanks admin

Posted by: mirc on April 8, 2009 08:20 PM

Thanks you ßy_SuSquN

Posted by: Sohbet on April 9, 2009 05:53 PM

Thanks you

Posted by: sohpet on April 13, 2009 11:39 AM

Thanks

Posted by: coders on May 5, 2009 02:08 PM

Thank you well

Posted by: Okey on June 3, 2009 08:58 AM

thanks you

Posted by: bilgi99.com on June 3, 2009 11:06 AM

thanks you

Posted by: bilgi99.com on June 3, 2009 11:06 AM

Thank You well

Posted by: resim indir on June 5, 2009 05:35 PM

thanks

Posted by: idealsohbet on June 5, 2009 07:30 PM

Thanks

Posted by: Okey Oyunu on June 6, 2009 01:01 PM

thank you

Posted by: Bedava Okey on June 6, 2009 01:02 PM

Thank you admin

Posted by: Okey Oyna on June 6, 2009 01:04 PM

warezscript.net leeporn.com

Posted by: lçls on June 8, 2009 07:12 AM

kızı domalltı Zevkten Deliren Lezbiy disney porn cezaevinde TEEN PORN FİLM zenci olgun kadın siki antalyalı kıza gizli ç 68 sikişe kilotları arap kız seks öğrtemeniyle sevişen milf sexi video izle nylon çorapla sexs 88 sex free antalya sikiş gizli sevişmeler amatör sex fotoları tube sex kızlık bozma olgun kadınların sikiş dul oruspular amcuksikiş vidioları orosbu sikiş vidioları ögrenci ögretmenini si cıplak asian çıpla kadın videoları erotizm by horse teen vidioları anne oğul sex komşusunu siken videol banyoda gizlice sessiz ateşli sikiş sahnaleri doktor sevişme video YAŞLI KADIN SİKİŞM 4 dakika ablasını siki orusbuların vidosu delisex,net erotik3d porno bekaret bozma vıdeosu erotik rahibe film izl gey sikiş video kilitori resimleri www.videolarcenneti.co kuduruk kızlar 89 olgun sexs erotik seks porno beda Atla sikişen karı resi erkek çocuk olgun kadı azgın kadın saldırıyor kırmızı çamaşırlı erot olgun travesti tırtıklı sikiş videola www ablam sikiş.com amerikada izlemem en ç arap kadınlar sks vido kardeşiyle sikiş video sevişme videolarını be 60 yaşlı sex videosu nylon çoraplı kadınlar milf sexvideo olgun karıların pornol 89 seks net evde sikis olgunkadınlar ve genç zevkim sex lisdseli rahibe erotikfilm eskişehirde seks lezbyenler yatakta you tube kızlık bozma hayvan penisi pornosu hikayeturk sex dans ederek sikişenler güzel kadın kendini ço küçük çocuk yaşlı kadı travesti erotik porno erotikvideo.net yaslı yaslı kadın sexk pregnand dolgun kadınlar pornos askerotik porno haire arkadaşının kardeşini yaşlı kadınlara oral s annesinin yanında sex ebn sikiş videoları erotik rahibeler filmi seksene liseli sikiş gey skıs travesti porno kadının amını yaladıkt sikişken olgun kapalıların erotık fı seksene seks video izl sıcak erot k orsbu karilar ilginç göt deliği vide teyze yenge pornoları amı güzel kadınlar ve bedava azgın yaşlı bay büyük penis seks izle online porno dvd çocugun sikini TEEN SKS 18 genc olgun kadın se seksene kızların sıkiş su altında porno video ankara sikişi teen kızlık bozma soyunuk kadınlar senci porno seks izle kalın yarak vodeo habile seks dvd lesbiyen lıttle seks teyzesini siken çocuğu fahişe seksi izleyelim yeşilçam sevişme seks filmler izle erotica otubuste taciz pornosi dizi izle yeşilçam sex erotik türk lezbiyen f genç çocuk olgun kadın kapalı kadınla kendini mini am sex şalvarlı erotik kadınl seks bedava sevişme iz KARA AMSEXS türbanlıların kamerada delik göt zevk video.com erotic sex tube penisimi nasıl büyüttü arkadaşlarının önünde sik porno am sikiş.net at ve eşşekle seks fil dayama videoları jigolo arayan kızlar Bu kadar beyaz bir amc komşusuna seks yapan k üyeliksiz vidyo tüysüz porno küçük erotik videoları ağzına verme 17 teen porno video iz 31sıcak porno dvd izl vidvid porno pornositar kız ve çocuk sexs vide masaj erotic video fre pkkda sex erkekcocuk erotik film amateur oral video TÜRKÇE LEZBİYEN VİDEO girls erotizm genc erkek olgun kadın yatakta sek trvesti sıkıs vıdeo parıs hılt jopon kanlı şikiş vide antalya gizli çekim se 69sıcak sikiş videolar arabi kadın parmaklamak travestikız sikişi arabia yaslı kadınlar erotic türbanlılar böyle bir amcık daha g esmer kadınlar videola tube seks ızle içine boşalmak olgun kadınların msn g türkarkadan zeci kadın sikişi zenci göt porno erotik image uzun etekli önce sikti sonra ağzın sikiş için erkek müşte biseksüel video büyük göt pornoları merve boluğur sex sessizbakire sexvideosu.net erotik yengem film minyon tipli kadın karımın çıplak fotoğra otuzbir çeken erkek vi deli gibi erotik böyle bir daha görülm böyle beyaz görülmadi sıcak vidiyolar sexpartiler içine sokuyor yaşlı kadın porn hindistanlı gızlı sıkısen ogrencıl ikiztepeler sex fılmle türkçe am sikenler erotik lezbiyen turk erotik seks sikiş porn kadınlardan sex hikale ablamı yaladm jigolo anal sex iki kadınla sikişen er büyül penis kardeşini siken pornos real sex video amatör olgun kadın erotik sex erotık photo zevke gelmek videyo adultrealsex.com teyzesiyle sikişiyor gamze özçelik sikişi erotık kadınları fılım seks yapan zenci kadıl göt film sex videoları canlı ÜCRETSİZ YAŞLI KADIN P yapay yrak znci yarrak full dvdsex izle cüce sikiş vidiosu sex çocukla rahibeler erotik filml lezbiyen seks izle dvd ayak yalat aisan 69 .videolarcenneti fresh sex porn perihan savaş erotik v komşusunu siken genc v amlı kanlı eretik vidy SEXFREECOM şikişi küçük kız izled amına vuruyor olgun kadını cocuk vid seksene sek vidio izle porno olgun müthiş sikiş genç çocukla olgun kad asia sikişi YAŞLI anne ogul sex videoları diskoda büyük yarakla sikişen yaşlı mutfak \"kapalı güzel\" olgun kapalı arap seks erotik video travestil 3d animasyon porno fli kadınım siken at vıdeo erotizm ve sevişme yaşlı teyzelerin sikiş türk şişman kadın siki İZMİRLİ TRAVESTİLER Şİ sicak porno azgin seks sicak se otuzbir çeken kadınlar yarak düşkünü pornolar evli sexsohbet dunyada en büyük zenci büyük anne sikiş amını siktiren deliler gta sananderas kaıdn s kendini okşayan kzlar ilk kez kız siken genç annesini sikenlerin h çığlıklı sevişme Ara üvey kardeşini sik erotik götler izle mutfakta porno film genç çocuklarla sex arap kızı sex fılm bed buyuk göt deliklerı po okşatarak sex ufak penisli olgun kadınla seks dans paris hilton saksafon bar küçük erkek olgun kadı annesiyle sevişen cocu karımı uyurken siktird iginç sikişler jopon amı tube sex kızlık viddeos.sexin.com eşeği sikiyor fresh sex teen porn genç erkek genç kız 3d animasyon porno fil erotık japon kızı üvey anne ile seks izl sevişen çocuklu kadın seksi öğrenci öğretmen sikilecekgötler kardeşini siken zencı erkekle buyk pen kadını kucaklarına alm bedia nın şikişi yaslı teyzeler sikiş bilardomasasında seks am sokan izle üvey anne ile erotik s otobüste liseliyi siki FULL 18+KIZLIK BOZMA S köylü kadınlarını erot bedava seks yaşlı kadı en tecrübeli sex fideo yasli sex bedava izle çıplak karımın resimle kızlık bozma erotik ümiversite yaşlı kadın lezbıyenle izlesene classıc porno liseliyi zenci sikiyor geceleri sevişen lezbi rahibe kilisede siktir sekskızları azgınlar dvd izle erotik turk izle temizlikçiyle kızlar ağzına sıçıyor zenci pornosu izle areb.seks.kızları genç erkek olgun kadın Family tesettürlü karım sikiş Little girl delı erotık seks vıdeo sibel tekin sikişmekten dal yaarrak porno izlemek net mini buyuk yarrakli erkekle SEKSİ ACEMİ KIZLAR etek dar erotık annemin amına koydu penıs goruntulerı you yunger babes video köy rerotik sex iniltisi sex arkadaşı sex izle ayak yalayan kadınlar online turkce dublajli seksi japon kızlar sexyapan eşler güzel skiş teensarea tecavüz Öğrenci öğretmen çıpla kim kardıshian soyunmuş kızlar erkekl koltukta porno izle o sex erotik izle sik hadi sik .com önce elliyor soyunan kadın seks izl sex ve sikis goruntule bedavasevişenler sarışın 18 zenci sikiş kız adamı delice sikiy vice cityde sikişme üstünü soyunan ev hanı yağlı sex azgın hizmetçiler sikiş 45 dul kandın evde soyunu sikiş dersi veren hoca hadi sik,com, sünnet olmamış yarakla çıplak kadın ve erkek ÜNLÜLER EROT temizlikçi ile sex izl WWW ORG PORNO clubsandy kızlar yaşlı kadın genç çocuk gök am sikme sex fahişeleri adultkurtsex lez videoları zevk seks videosu küçük cocuksex seksler memeler yüz stü yatan kadını s am yalayan adam videos çok,çapkın,porno yaraklı lezbiyen amcıgına sokarım çiftler seks videosu erkeğe masaj video sexvidyolar 3 çılgın roman kızı porn doğum günü hediyesi le sikilen göt porno göşmen.sikişi sünnetsiz yarrak resmi japonseks çiş yapan türk amcığı orosbu sexsi bedava çılgın seksi ha amlarını okşuyan lezbi yaşlı hatun sikiş vide sevişen travesti video atın sikini amına soku kızlar ero sikişen manıtalar liselilolitapornoları büssürü porno filmi sünnet olmamış erkek y ireç porno azgın yaşlı kadını boşalttılar sik müjde ar ormanda seviş yaraklı.amcık amına patlıcan sokmak youtub kızlık bozma i got bacak resimleri lezbiyen ögrenci vidos ğötü büyük şişman info@erotik meme emme porno işkence görüntüs parayla sikişen seksi hatun videoları komşusuna tecavüz eden kızlar siktiriyor amı havuz kenarında sikiş kızını yalayan lezbiye +18 SEX VİDEOLARI IZLE küçük vajinalı teen s hoş sikiş video üvey annesini sikin co adutlt34 türk video arkadaşının annesiyle teen tny oral yabancı asyalı porna disneyporn izle garantisex porno siyah adam sex mature türk momerotic video amçığ zenci japon sexi arab kız sex kadın kadına ağza çiş güzel göt film banyu da soyunan kadın hareketlı sıkış resıml derste seks izlese.com kısa anal s lezbiyen kolunu yarakla kadın sikme oy seks yapan kadinlari \"adamın götünü yalıyo video sex forced to fuck tezgah üstünde sevişiy büyük resimli sex Cep video seks teyzesiyle sevişen kız japon kızları sikiş v banyoda sevişme sahnel yaşlı sex videoları seks zorlama videolari sikiş.izleyen esmerin amına koymak türbanlı erodik sex arkadan sevişip sikişe ohhh sex little girl ero foto sexi güzel gögüsler film izlemek net kateg sex sikiş yalatma sahn türkkçe orosbu videola yol ortasında sikiş i kadın kendisini siktir SIKIS SOKUS KUDURDUM sevişen karı koca vide aci vererek sikenler 45 lik kadın sikişi çıplaklar kampı videol cüce kadın seks eşimi zorla sikiyordu türbanlı soyunan kadın wwwsikis21.com çift yarraklı porno ohhh sex SEKSİ ÇIPLAK ERKELER sevişenler bu gece vid club sandy por orosbu fahişeler olgun seks evli seyret porno.teen mini etekli lez sex siyah külotlu çorap po türk ünlülerinerotik f masaj yaparak sexs izmirli fahişe sex

Posted by: dizi izle on June 12, 2009 04:24 PM

was a very nice article thank you I'd put my archive

Posted by: Okey Oyunu on June 15, 2009 05:26 PM

Thank you very good

Posted by: Okey Oyna on June 15, 2009 05:41 PM

perfect post

Posted by: Okey on June 15, 2009 05:42 PM

Tatil Cenneti.Org | Tatil, Otel - Tatil rehberi
Akgün İstanbul
info@akgunhotel.com Konaklama: Akgün İstanbul Oda Kahvaltı, Yarım Pansiyon, Tam Pansiyon Yatak Sayısı: Akgün İstanbul 275 Oda, 550 Yatak, 260 Standart Oda, 5 Engelli Odası, 16 Bağlantılı Oda, 2 Kral Dairesi, 8 Suit Oda Özellikleri: Telefon, Direkt Telefon, Duş ve Tuvalet, Banyo, Banyoda Telefon, Saç Kurutma makinası, Yangın Alarmı,...

Doğa Club Tatil Köyü
Doğa Club Oda Özellikleri: 181 toplam oda, 658 toplam yatak, 3 suit oda, 3 junior suit, 27 standart oda, 148 apart oda. Bahçe, dağ manzarası var. Detaylar: Telefon, minibar, internet bağlantısı, televizyon, uydu tv, split klima, duş, wc, saç kurutma makinası. Apart Detayları: Telefon, split klima, minibar, salon, iki yatak odası, internet... Tatil Cenneti.Org | Tatil, Otel - Tatil rehberi

Cinar Otel İstanbul
Oda & Detaylar: 224 toplam odalı 458 toplam yataklı 4 suit odalı 1 özürlü odası, 25 sigara içilmeyen odalı 2 presidential suit. Deniz, kara manzarası bulunuyor. Oda Özellikleri: Direk telefon, müzik yayını, balkon, minibar, kasa, internet bağlantısı, televizyon, uydu tv, merkezi klima, küvet-banyo, wc, saç kurutma makinası, banyoda... Tatil Cenneti.Org | Tatil, Otel - Tatil rehberi
İstanbul’un Tarihi
Efsaneye göre, İstanbul Şehir Byzas tarafından M.Ö. 667 yılında Megarian kuruldu. Olarak iyi bir yer olacaktır Ama bu yerleşim kurma öncesine Byzas, tavsiye isteyen Oracle of Delphi ziyaret etti. Oracle olduğunu yerleşmek öngörüsünde onun kasaba ‘karşısında kör adam. Byzas bu alanda bulmak ve kapalı gitmiş halen nerede Topkapı... Tatil Cenneti.Org | Tatil, Otel - Tatil rehberi

Posted by: Tatil on June 15, 2009 07:21 PM

thanks

Posted by: sikiş on June 16, 2009 06:29 AM

Thank You Matthew

Site Ekle | Siteekle | Link Ekle | Link Değişimi | Toplist | Hit Siteler | Forum | Efendi Forum | Forumx | Forumtr | Frm | Bilgi Forum | Sağlık Forumu | iş forumu | Wordpress | Joomla | Php Nuke | Forum Turkey | Sohbet | Chat | Muhabbet | Mirc | Efendi | Efendi Sohbet | Canlı Canlı | Heyecanlı | Kızlar | Msn | Sohbet Odaları | Bedava Sohbet | Görüntülü Sohbet | Kameralı Chat | Forum | Aşk | Sevgi | IRC | Programlama Dilleri | Paneller | Türkçe Forum | İşletim Sistemleri | Donanım | Yazılım | şarkı sözü | şarkı sözleri | hit şarkı sözleri | türkçe şarkı sözleri | yabancı şarkı sözleri | şarkı ekle | şarkı ara | şarkı sözü bul | şarkı sözü ekle | en güzel şarkı sözleri | Yemek | Binbir Tarif | Pasta Tarifi | Kek Tarifi | Tatlı Tarifi | Yemek Tarifleri | Türk Yemekleri | Yöresel Yemekler | Tarifler | Oriflame | Oriflame Kozmetik | binbirtarif | Oriflametr | Kozmetik | Parfüm | Koku | Cilt Bakımı | Saç | Makyaj | Ruj | Katalog | Üyelik | Satış | Sipariş | Hediye | Kampanya | Kariyer | Kazanç | Fırsat | Oje | Krem | Losyon | Jel | Kazanç | | iş imkanı | Danışman | Temsilci | Sponsor | Video ekle | Videolar | Video izle | Video seyret | Video yükle | Komik Video | Kamera Şakaları | Korkunç Videolar | İlginç Videolar | Bedava Video Ekle | Bedava video yükle | Yükle izle | youtube videolar | Video Paylaş | Site Ekle | SiteEkle | Toplist | Hit Sayacı | Dizin | Link Değişimi Backlink | Ücretsiz Site Ekle | Forum | Cpanel | Plesk | IRC | Lxadmin | Türkçe Paneller | Host | İşletim Sistemleri | Donanım | Yazılım | Bedava Site Ekle | karşılıksız Site Ekle | Site | Babil | Babil Host | Hosting | Dantel | Türk Dantel | Örgü Dantel | Oya | Dantel Örnekleri | şarkı sözü | şarkı sözleri | hit şarkı sözleri | türkçe şarkı sözleri | yabancı şarkı sözleri | şarkı ekle | şarkı ara | şarkı sözü bul | şarkı sözü ekle | en güzel şarkı sözleri | Forum | Cpanel | Plesk | IRC | Lxadmin | Türkçe Paneller | Host | İşletim Sistemleri | Filmizle | Film izle | Sohbet | Chat | Şarkı | Şarkı Sözleri | Youtube Gir izle | Youtube |


Posted by: Bedava Film izle on June 16, 2009 09:44 AM

thanks you

Posted by: kelebek sohbet on June 21, 2009 09:17 AM

Post A Comment

advertise_liberally.gif