Lead Abatement

Campus Progress put on an event yesterday where they screened Season 4, Episode 3 of The Wire and then had a Q&A with David Simon and Ed Burns. Since it was a political crowd, the questions were all about "the issues" and it confirmed my sense that the creators of this extraordinarily subtle show have a rather crude take on what it all means. Nothing they said about politics really bothered me, however, except for what Burns said when somebody mentioned that one problem inner-city kids face is that many of them start life off hobbled by lead poisoning.

Burns was completely dismissive of this notion, holding that the real toxins out there are you, me, capitalism, and America's indifferent consumer culture. Kids who grow up in the ghetto and become violent criminals are just engaged in a rational response to the environment they've been plopped into. Lead is just an excuse to avoid coping with the real issues. Well, it'd be a shame to use the existence of lead poisoning as an excuse to avoid coping with other, deeper problems. On the other hand, to the best of my knowledge lead poisoning is a very real problem. What's more, it's a problem with a clear-cut solution. We know how to implement lead-abatement procedures and, in fact, lots of them have been carried out. It just costs money, so poor people suffer. But it doesn't cost an especially large amount of money -- funds could be appropriated, the problem ameliorated, and America would be a better place for it. In a sense, nothing would be thereby "solved" but conditions would improve.

9/21/06 9:41AM del.icio.us this incoming links

Comments

Amelioration is good. More happiness is good. Finding an issue that lots of people can agree on is good.

But I understand the show's creator's thinking. What's better than to do what's best? Unfortunately, that kind of thing, like all manner of reductionism, gets crippling fast. Sort of like lead poisoning. There's a horrifying "saint" who spent his whole, brief life doing what's best. Aloysius Gonzaga, I think. (Or it could be another one.) Ferocious praying. Eye-squinting avoidance of impure thoughts. A real pain in the bazoo. His superiors -- he was in some kind of religious order -- counseled him and disciplined him to no avail. Thank heavens he was taken young to his otherworldly reward. After he was dead there wasn't anything left but sainthood.

Me, I'm an ameliorist.

Posted by: Jeffrey Davis on September 21, 2006 10:21 AM

Let's see now....when challenged about lead poisoning, the producers offer several other plausible factors that need to be considered. And this, to Matt, is "a rather crude take on what it all means".

Well, Matt, I'd say you are a very tough audience to play to.

Posted by: serial catowner on September 21, 2006 10:22 AM

from the wire to lead-poisoning...

But, you're right-on here. A colleague of mine did the cost-benefit analysis for undertaking publicly-funded lead abatement programs, and, the net benefit is shockingly high.

joshb

Posted by: joshb on September 21, 2006 10:22 AM

Matt, you've criticized some of David Simon and Ed Burns' political views before, perhaps as too simplistic. As an enormous fan of the show (on a side note, has anybody who has seen at least one full season NOT liked the show? I've personally added at least 50 people in my social circle to the viewership through my own proseltyzing, all of whom agree that it's the greatest show on TV), I'm curious to see a blog post on where exactly their views are astray. I have a high regard for your thoughts, but not quite as high as my reverence for The Wire.

"The Wire doesn't deserve an Emmy. It deserves a Nobel Prize."

Posted by: gautsid on September 21, 2006 11:21 AM

I'm inclined to think highlighting lead poisoning as a topic for special comment with respect to inner-city dysfunction is a bit like pointing out that a cancer patient also has athlete's foot. It may well be true, but it's not going to be anywhere near the decisive factor in determining his fate.

Still, given that all of these crumbling East Coast shitholes like Newark and Baltimore have unbroken, multi-generational liberal Democratic political establishments, maybe someone can explain to me just why lead poisoning is still a problem two generations after it was identified as a significant inner city health risk. Surely the party of "compassion" and "the people" can't be short-changing the noble poor? Can it possibly be that the calcified, congenitally corrupt political machines in these charming places are so busy pursuing their negative-sum games of personal aggrandizement that they can't spare a few bucks to buy our cancer patient a tube of freakin' Tinactin?

Posted by: Dick Eagleson on September 21, 2006 11:59 AM

Hi Dick

I live in the "crumbling East Coast shithole" called Baltimore, and I'm good friends with the man who heads ths city's lead abatement program and I can assure you that the corrupt democrats running my fair city are investing a fair number of resources in helping lead compromised kids. Johns Hopkins Hospital has an entire section of their children's center devoted to lead poisoning.

The main problem among others is that the low-income rental market in Baltimore is saturated with houses that were built in the late 19th century and are covered in lead paint. Since these houses are not well-maintained at all the lead dust is a constant problem. And it's the inhaled lead dust that's the source of the problem, not children licking walls.

We do have laws on the books in Baltimore, forcing landlords to abate their rental properties, but enforcing those laws is expensive. If you're a mom with a couple of kids and your only housing option is Baltimore's low-income housing market, you haven't got a lot of money left over at the end of the month to hire a lswyer.

Dick, come on down to Charm City. I'd like to see you light a fire under the asses of the real estate lobby in MD and get them to sanction their members who don't abate their properties. Or you could have a big, steaming mug of STFU!

Ciao!

Posted by: Sharon on September 21, 2006 12:18 PM

Matt,

I would say that the complexity of the writing they do on The Wire speaks for itself and the fact that Simon and Burns aren't able to articulate the politics beyond simplistic liberalisms when they talk specifically about it simply highlights why they are creative artists and not political scientists. Put simply their skill set is telling stories. A Bill Clinton, John Edwards and so on who can do a great job of playing policy wonk would probably be a pretty lousy screen-writer.

Posted by: Eric on September 21, 2006 02:30 PM

I suppose if you believe lead poisioning is a symptom of the disease of poverty, then cleaning up lead based paint isn't a real solution.
But I personally poverty is bad primarily because of the symptoms, like the fact that the only apartments that some people can afford contain toxins that cause brain damage to children.
This is also one case where allievating a symptom can also allieviate the disease, because a brain damaged child obviously is going to have less future earning potential than a healthy child. Communities with higher incidence of brain damage are then going to be more poor.
This by itself doesn't solve the problem of poverty in inner cities, but I think it is a big marginal improvement with low marginal cost.
This also seems like a place where a non-profit group could do more good than the goverment. Donations could go to cleaning up apartment buildings where the owners weren't willing or able to pay the costs themselves.

Posted by: Travis on September 21, 2006 02:36 PM

I was at the event and what I heard was that Simon responded by acknowledging that lead paint poisoning is a serious problem that should be addressed. But he disagreed with the questioners premise that the behavior problems, violence and learning disorders endemic among the poor were directly attributable to lead paint poisoning as a primary cause. Simon said he was concerned that by blaming environmental toxins for anti-social behavior, it is easier for society to ignore all the other profound influences on these children that would -- even absent any lead-paint issues whatsoever -- result in alienation, violence and an unwillingness to participate in a dysfunctional and disconnected educational process. In short, he argued that be declaring the victims to be sick from lead paint, we mitigate against the fact that they are in fact subject to a loss of meaningful work and purpose, poorly educated by a society that has given up on them, and exposed to violence on a daily basis that is rooted in economic desperation and the gangsterism of a rampant drug economy.
He was not dismissing the health concern of lead paint poisoning, but arguing against the questioner's premise that it was the root cause of the violence. The world in which these kids were consigned -- which is more profoundly screwed up than its lead content -- is the reason for the violence. That seemed to be the crux of the dispute.

Posted by: anonymous on September 21, 2006 03:34 PM

It's always ironic how the NYT denounces the entire concept of IQ as a racist fantasy, _except_ when the topic is lead's deleterious effect on IQ, which is simple scientific fact.

Anyway, the hypocrisy of the great and the good on this question doesn't mean, however, that lead abatement in the inner city wouldn't be a good idea.

Posted by: Steve Sailer on September 21, 2006 04:39 PM

The lead poisoning hysteria is mostly based on junk science.

Let's move on to the next crisis.

Posted by: KDeRosa on September 21, 2006 04:43 PM

To follow-up on Steve Sailer's comment.

Lead poinioning does have a deleterious effect on IQ at high levels; however, lead exposure at those sufficiently high levels are exceedingly rare even in the inner cities.

Posted by: kderosa on September 21, 2006 04:48 PM

anonymous at 3:34PM hits it pretty much on the head. The liberal commentariat is constantly looking for plausible reasons, other than the liberal-backed explosion of welfare statism that began in the 60's, to explain the rapid and parallel degeneration of urban inner cities that took wing starting then and whose effects are still manifest. Lead paint poisoning is just one more in a long string of failed alibis for the hash liberal adiminstrations have made of American cities where they've been in charge for extended periods.

As the oh-so-touchy Sharon helpfully points out, the low-income housing stock of her beloved native shithole dates from the late 19th Century. Most interior, and virtally all exterior paint was oil-based and lead-loaded until well after WW2. Such paint begins to flake within a decade of being applied. In poor areas, fresh coats are less frequent than elsewhere so the flaking between reapplicaions is predictably worse. By my calculation, this means Baltimore has been marinating in lead-rich paint flakes and dust for the entire 20th century. That being the case, the explanation for why B'more, and many of its other urban contemporaries in the Northeast, has been such a horrorshow only in recent decades must be looked for elsewhere than in paint cans.

By all means, get the lead out. Just don't expect improvements to the quality of inner-city social life as a result - you won't get any.

Posted by: Dick Eagleson on September 21, 2006 07:16 PM

Until the early 80's, lead levels of above 10 ug/dL were present in 88% of all children under 6. By 2002, the figure was 1.6%. The reason? The phase-out of leaded gasoline in the 1970's and 1980's. Children used to breathe the stuff in every time they set foot on a sidewalk. If lead were so harmful, you'd expect everyone over thirty to be a retard. oh, wait...

Sorry about that. Seriously, anyone who claims that very low lead levels are a significant public health problem really does have to explain why almost everyone born before 1980 or so isn't retarded or otherwise neurologically impaired.

Posted by: JR on September 21, 2006 08:55 PM

The biggest lead poisoning problem in the inner city poor neighborhoods is caused by chunks of lead leaving muzzles of guns at a high velocity.

Posted by: JD on September 21, 2006 10:09 PM

Good comment.Thanks admin.

Posted by: youtube on November 17, 2007 04:42 AM

mirc
mirç
mırc
mırç
mircturk
turkmirc
turkiyemirc
mircturkiye
mirch
mırch
mirc indir
mirc yükle
mirc yukle
mırc indir
mırc yukle
mirc turkiye
turkiye mirc
turk mirc
mirc turk
türkçe mirc
türkce mirc
türkçe mırc
turkce mirc
turkçe mirc
turkçe mırc
turkce mirc
mirc chat
mirc sohbet
mirc ara
muhabbet
chat
blog
muhabbet
forum
forum
turkiyeforum
türk forum
mirc
mircturk
turkmirc
mirc indir
sohbet
chat
bedava sohbet
turksohbet
turkiye sohbet
sohbet odaları
bedava chat
chat odaları
türk chat
türkiye chat
turkada
turkmirc
mirc inndir
karar

Posted by: chat on January 6, 2008 08:34 AM

evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
Sohbet
sohbet
mirc
penis büyütücü
sohbet
muhabbet
matbaa
seks
sex
hikaye
hikayeler
sex
porno
Sohbet kanalları
Sohbet odaları
Chat
evden eve nakliye
chat
magazin
chat
Sohbet
tuzcuoğlu

Posted by: clubgenclik on February 24, 2008 09:41 AM

komik video
aşk şiirleri
bol sohbet
cinsel sohbet
sohbet
sohbet yerleri
bedava oyun
Bol Sohbet
chat
chat
sohbet
sohbet
seviyeli sohbet
göçmen sohbet
mynet sohbet
islam sohbet
yazılı sohbet
yazgülü sohbet
hollanda sohbet
bg sohbet
dost sohbet
arkadaş sohbet
bayan arkadaş sohbet
kızlarla sohbet
avrupa sohbet
alem sohbet
sohpet sohbet
cinsel sohbet
ingiltere sohbet
liseli kizlar
msn nickler
saç ekimi
sağlık bilgisi
mirc inndir
film inndir

Posted by: msn on February 24, 2008 10:33 AM

thanks ;)

Posted by: firefox indir on March 31, 2008 04:16 AM

thank you !

Posted by: firefox indir on March 31, 2008 01:14 PM

sohbet
sohbet
sohbet
sohbet
chat
sohbet
chat
chat
diziler
gebze
asansör
hikaye
felsefe
reklam
webtasarım
sexshop
sexshop
facebook
face book
face turk
arkadaş
sex shop
sex shop
seks shop
seks shop
sex market
sex market
shop shop
erotik shop
kadın
youtube
sinema
sohbet
sex shop
muhabbet
trkadin
hikayen
sex
porno
chat
sohbet
lokum
sohbet
marmara
gebze web tasarım
gebze webtasarım
sohbet
chat
moda
magazin
yemek tarifi
yemek tarifleri
kozmetik
diyet
Yakışıklı
Yakışıklılar
Anne Çocuk

Posted by: sohbet on April 3, 2008 10:42 PM

thank you

Posted by: cep program, symbian program on May 5, 2008 03:13 AM

sohbet
chat
sohbet
sohbet
sohbet
chat
hikaye
diziler
facebook
chat
kadın
forex
arkadaş
muhabbet
gebze
webtasarım
toplist
sinema
film
gebze
asansör
felsefe
reklam
webtasarım
face book
face turk
face turk
youtube
sinema
sohbet
muhabbet
chet
çet
arkadaş
palet
trkadin
hikayen
chat
sohbet
sohbet
marmara
gebze web tasarım
gebze webtasarım
sohbet
chat
moda
magazin
yemek tarifi
yemek tarifleri
kozmetik
diyet
Yakışıklı
Yakışıklılar
Anne Çocuk
Filmler
Filimler
Film
Dizi
sohbet
sohbet
chat
chat
diziler
asansör
hikaye
felsefe
reklam
facebook
face book
face turk
pagerank
masaj
masör
sohbet
kadın
youtube
sinema
sohbet
chat
gebze ticaret
kredi
borsa
sohbet
chat
sohbet
Arkadaş

Posted by: sohbet on May 11, 2008 06:28 PM

youtube
yuotube
yotube
youtobe
video sitesi
video siteleri
izlesene
yutup
www.youtube
youtube izle
video izle
youtub
youtup

Posted by: izlesene on June 2, 2008 08:54 AM

selam söyle GoogLe.CoM.TR'e

Posted by: sohbet on August 29, 2008 10:08 AM

mirc

Posted by: mirc indir on September 4, 2008 04:53 PM

Thanks Best Regards
mirc
mırc
mırç
mircturk
mirctürk
turkmirc
mirc indir
mırc indir
mirç indir
mirc yükle
mırc yükle
mirc yukle
mırc yukle
mirch
mırch
mirc turk
turk mirc
mırc turk
mircada
mircturkiye
muhabbet
mirc sohbet
mırc sohbet
mirc chat
mırc chat
mırc ındır
mirc ındır
türkçe mirc
turkce mirc
turkçe mırc
turkce mırc
oper mirc
sohbet
forum
chat
online sinema
catlak
türk forum
turk forum
kafkas
kafkasya
ders
siyaset
izmir
karşiyaka
karsiyaka
forum
karsıyaka
sohbet

Posted by: mirc on October 18, 2008 05:49 PM

http://www.izokon.com/hakkimizda.html
http://www.izokon.com/hizmetlerimiz.html
http://www.izokon.com/urunler.html
http://www.izokon.com/hekimboard.html
http://www.izokon.com/turksiding.html
http://www.izokon.com/fblam.html
http://www.izokon.com/kalite.html
http://www.izokon.com/sove.html
http://www.izokon.com/referanslar.html
http://www.izokon.com/iletisim.html
http://www.izokon.com/urunler2.html
http://www.izokon.com/sss.html

Posted by: dış cephe on October 26, 2008 09:00 AM

thanks.

Posted by: kamera on October 26, 2008 09:01 AM

thanks.

Posted by: dijital güvenlik on October 26, 2008 09:02 AM

penis büyütücüler

Posted by: penis büyütücüler on November 7, 2008 09:10 AM

harbiarkadas.com
harbiarkadas.net
harbiarkadas.org
itirafet.org
ebedava.net
elektronikmarket.net
ameribress.com
clitoriacream.net
superspenisbuyutucu.com
megabress.com
rednightperformans.com
performansartirici.com
penisplus.tv
penispluspenisbuyutucu.com
penispluspenisbuyutucu.net
cinselmerkez.com
aseks.net
erotikcamasirlar.com
vajinatr.com
bakirevajina.com
cinselkozmetik.com
kozmetikmedikel.com
eturknet.com
tecavuz.net
yutuvideo.com
ponotubesex.com
laraperuk.com
sackanagimerkezi.com
peruksa.com
perukmarket.com
aseks.com
aloveshop.com
erotikgiyim.com
geciktiricispreyler.com
geciktiricihap.com
geciktiriciler.com
azdirici.com
bayanuyarici.com
fntazialemi.com
fantaziservisi.om
cinselmazemeler.com
cinselfantaziurunleri.com
erotikdakikalar.com
erotikmarketiniz.com
seksmarketiniz.com
sekshatlari.com
erotikdergiler.com
erotikderginiz.com
penisbuyutucuviprx.com
penisbuyutucuvigrx.com
penisbuyutuculer.com
vigrxpenisbuyutucu.com
sismebebekler.com
sismebebekshop.com
yemekeviniz.com
sanalmarketiniz.com
elektronikmarket.net
ebedava.net
kontortr.com
elaydin23.com
turkcellkontorcu.com
aveakontoral.com
vodafonekontoral.com
toptankontorcu.com
cinselkozmetik.com
bayanpartnerler.com
erkekpartnerler.com
kizarkadaslar.com
yonjaarkadas.com
siberalem-siberalem.com
sexpartnerler.com
sekspartnerler.com
erotikpartnerler.com
gencyuz.com
erkekarkadaslar.com
bayanarkadaslar.com
yemekeviniz.com
sanalmarketiniz.com
baskahaber.com
medikalkozmetik.net
kozmetikmedikal.com
zayiflamavediyet.net
zayiflamahapii.com
zayiflamabandii.com
kilovertr.com
zayiflamatr.net
diyettr.com
toksinbandi.net
botoxtr.com
botokstr.com
selulittedavii.com
selulitgiderici.net
selulitkremii.com
catlaktedavisii.com
catlakgiderici.net
catlakkremii.com