Torture as Investigation

Vladimir Bukovsky:

Investigation is a subtle process, requiring patience and fine analytical ability, as well as a skill in cultivating one's sources. When torture is condoned, these rare talented people leave the service, having been outstripped by less gifted colleagues with their quick-fix methods, and the service itself degenerates into a playground for sadists. Thus, in its heyday, Joseph Stalin's notorious NKVD (the Soviet secret police) became nothing more than an army of butchers terrorizing the whole country but incapable of solving the simplest of crimes. And once the NKVD went into high gear, not even Stalin could stop it at will. He finally succeeded only by turning the fury of the NKVD against itself; he ordered his chief NKVD henchman, Nikolai Yezhov (Beria's predecessor), to be arrested together with his closest aides.

It goes on, including tales of Bukovsky's own experiences as a victim of Soviet torture and deserves to be read in its entirety. But this here is essentially the key point at hand. While you can obviously imagine or gerrymander or stipulate a situation in which torture might yield useful information, in practice the systematic authorization of torture creates an army of butchers, not a crack investigative team. Bush, Cheney, and those around them remind me of Nietzsche's line about staring too long into the abyss. They've become transfixed, hypnotized almost, by the evils they believe themselves to be fighting. Obsessed to the point where they've clearly developed an admiration for the brutal methods, ruthless dishonesty, and utter secrecy with which the enemies of liberalism conduct themselves.

But these things they're so eager -- determined, really -- to cast aside aren't frivolous luxury to be abandonned in times of peril. They're the very essence of what makes our system of government work. They're what makes it worth preserving, as a matter of ethics, but also as a matter of practice vital to the preservation of our way of life. Liberal democracy isn't a fluke occurrence that just so happens to have survived despite its drawbacks. It's actually a superior method of organizing a state. The idea that the country is being run by people who don't understand that is sad and frightening. The idea that the very same people claim to be embarked upon a grand mission to spread our system of government around the world is like a horrible tawdry joke, but doubly frightening in its own way.

Comments

If liberalism is a technology rather than a consciousness, then it is the rare technology that is willfully abandoned. The implication for a technology that can be deliberately abandoned is that the technology is not adequate to its purpose, or not cost effective.

Posted by: bob mcmanus on September 23, 2006 03:49 PM

Unleashing the Beast

Digby on the same source and subject.

To be clear, I am not above defending the Bush administration, but calculating and contemplating the appropriate response.

Posted by: bob mcmanus on September 23, 2006 04:00 PM

After much reflection, I think the Dems must come out clearly and aggressively against the torture compromise. If we lose the election, so be it. It's that important, as Matt's post makes clear. Give me liberty or give me a congressional minority.

Posted by: mert7878 on September 23, 2006 05:43 PM

I can imagine a case where I might have to steal a car, but that doesn't mean stealing cars should be legal.

Posted by: Misplaced Patriot on September 23, 2006 06:01 PM

A few commentators have mentioned that torture deforms a society as a whole, but few have mentioned that torture creates actual monsters. I'm glad you pointed this out.

Posted by: RWB on September 23, 2006 06:22 PM

You give Cheney and Bush far too much credit when you go into that "They became what they beheld" song and dance. Cheney in particular has always aspired to the tools of totalitarianism. It's the practice of democracy he despises

Posted by: Paul Gottlieb on September 23, 2006 07:01 PM

I have a friend who is a fundamentalist Christian, who believes that a benevolent dictatorship is the optimal form of government. Apparently this belief is based on an analogy to the relationship between God and his subjects. I couldn't disagree more. I think, as Matt suggests, that a well functioning democracy provides for the kinds of feedback that actually cause it to work better than dictatorships, even benevolent ones.

I've read a lot of World War II history, and have always been struck by how much better the leadership in America and Britain was compared to the Axis powers and Soviet Union. There just seems to have been more vetting of and open discussion about decisions. I suppose this could be a certan amount of historical bias in the books I've read, though.

Posted by: Jim W on September 23, 2006 08:19 PM

"I've read a lot of World War II history, and have always been struck by how much better the leadership in America and Britain"

A "fighting liberalism" that lasted until the early 70s, I think. An important data point. Later liberalism was willing to fight wars abroad, and defend the country to the extent politically necessary, but did not scare its internal enemies. And still obviously doesn't scare Bush or Cheney.

OK, it is about time the lesson was learned. If the left tries to disarm, pulls back from overseas engagements, tries a multilateral institutionalism, America will get an authoritarian militaristic dictatorship. I don't even know if the question is interesting anymore, because I don't know that we are getting out of this one.

Posted by: bob mcmanus on September 23, 2006 09:29 PM

Bob,
"Pulling back from overseas engagements" and "trying a multilateral institutionalism" are not the same thing. And multilateral institutionalism was pretty much what that "fighting liberalism" was fighting for.

Posted by: SqueakyRat on September 23, 2006 10:09 PM

"And multilateral institutionalism was pretty much what that "fighting liberalism" was fighting for."

But they did it with a million-man army. I don't want the multilateralism to substitute for that, even if it would work better. But your point is good.

Posted by: bob mcmanus on September 24, 2006 12:29 AM

I met Bukovsky on a few occasions about twenty-five years when I worked for a lecture agency that represented him.

Let me mention this without any equivocation: Bukovsky is about as thoroughly right-wing as they come. He supported the Contra War in the 1980's, for example. I mention only in the event that anyone tries to paint him as left-wing. He most assuredly is not.

But he is a victim of torture and he is a consistent voice aagaints it and having experience it first hand speaks against it most eloquently.

Posted by: Randy Paul on September 24, 2006 02:02 PM

In my experience, the view that a benevolent dictatorship is the best form of government is fairly widespread. For a certain definition, I suppose it's true, but it's based on the fallacy of affirmation of the consequent. "A good dictatorship is good, because we already specified that it was good when we called it a 'good dictatorship.'" Basically, it's circular reasoning that could equally well be applied to a benevolent democracy, benevolent anarchy, etc.

Before asserting that "Liberal democracy ... [is] actually a superior method of organizing a state," though, one must ask, "for whom?" Liberal democracy would not have been a superior way of organizing the state of Zaire for Mobutu Sese Seko in achieving his objectives, nor a superior way of organizing the state of the Philippines for Ferdinand and Imelda. Liberal democracy may create stronger nations as a whole, but is that the objective of those so eager to reject it?

Posted by: Julian Elson on September 24, 2006 06:18 PM

Why oh why do people who should know better get seduced into debating the utility of things like torture?

Matt, your argument is besides the point. It's interesting, I suppose, to learn that permitting torture rapidly degrades the effectiveness of a police force. But so what? The fact that torture doesn't work and leads to incompetence isn't the point. Suppose it did work. Suppose it made police better at solving crimes. Would that make it acceptable?

The reason torture is banned by all civilized countries is that it is immoral according to any value system of any worth, religious or "secular." That it doesn't work, that it leads to an increase in unsolved crimes - these are poor arguments, as many arguments from utility are. At best they are trivial arguments compared to the fact that torture assaults the very meaning of what it means to be a human being.

Posted by: tristero on September 24, 2006 10:56 PM

Find examples closer to home

Americans find denial too easy when you push on them comparisons of this Republican political machine to dramatically evil political machines like that of the Soviet Union or Germany under the National Socialists. Most Americans won't accept such comparisons until it's too late to avert the evil, until the potential for evil has been actualized in numbers imprisoned and numbers killed approaching the Holocaust and the Gulag. Even if there were not the question of the direct effects of moralistic narcissism ("Americans couldn't possibly do such things!"), an important part of the moralistic grandstanding the national mytholoigy indulges in when it remembers the Third Reich and the Evil Empire, is the idea that we were so moral that we rejected evil means, such as torture and the other means of totalitarian control, despite the practical advantage that they supposedly conferred on those, like the Nazis and Soviets, who lack our fine scruples. It wouldn't have been such a hard struggle to defeat the Axis, or worldwide Communism, had the dastards not cheated. Yes, that is Bukovsky's main argument, that these totalitarian means are actually the opposite of effective, and it is a much sounder way of arguing than appeals to disinterested moralism. But it's an uphill slog directly contradicting the national mythology of "The Good War" and "The Greatest Generation", and our struggle against the "Evil Empire".

Start with more humble examples nearer to home. We've had political machines in this country, in many cities and sometimes even whole states, and in the not too distant past. The common memory of them is that the shortcuts they indulged in, like police forces that tended to just beat confessions out of "the usual suspects" rather than actually expend the effort to solve crimes, were the opposite of efficient at anything but maintaining themselves in power. No, we haven't had a political machine at the national level, until now. But imagine if Huey Long had had the US Army, the CIA, NSA and FBI to play around with, instead of just the Louisiana State Police? Most Americans could make that leap of imagination, even if they won't accept a direct comparison of Bush to Stalin or Hitler.

Posted by: Glen Tomkins on September 24, 2006 10:59 PM


I always thought that there's a great study to be made of the college courses on authoritarian and totalitarian societies that these clowns took when they were young. It's as if they were paying so little attention that the lessons on the Politburo and the Gestapo merged with the lessons on the Supreme Court and the Pinkertons.

Posted by: Ottoe on September 25, 2006 12:12 AM

Beside Nietzsche there's also the old saying, "Choose your enemies wisely -- they are what you become."

Posted by: AndrewBW on September 25, 2006 08:40 AM

Let's not overreact now. It's not immoral to apply pressure to a limited set of terrorist suspects. "Torture" will only be applied to a narrow set of terrorist cases. It won't be used on common criminal cases, nor on enemy soldiers who uphold the Geneva Conventions. And all the permitted techniques are those we already use on our own soldiers, in special forces training, etc.; death, mutilation, and rape are forbidden. And the available techniques don't necessarily have to be used, but are a backup (or used to put pressure on a terrorist being questioned) when someone trained to resist interrogation doesn't respond, and the cost of not getting the information is high.

Posted by: LiberalatWar on September 25, 2006 12:23 PM

LiberalAtWar,

Torture is torture. It doesn't stop being torture because you put quotes around it. As for backup, puhleeze. When you have a hammer, everything looks like a nail.

Posted by: tristero on September 25, 2006 03:14 PM

And all the permitted techniques are those we already use on our own soldiers, in special forces training, etc.; death, mutilation, and rape are forbidden.

Irrelevant. The letter of the law is not what's important here. What's important is the spirit of it - in other words, the fact that the Bush Administration is legitimizing any kind of torture is more important than the fact that rape is not permitted.

And the available techniques don't necessarily have to be used, but are a backup (or used to put pressure on a terrorist being questioned) when someone trained to resist interrogation doesn't respond, and the cost of not getting the information is high

You mean like the "ticking time bomb" scenario that only happens on 24? The scenario that's been discredited by pretty much every antiterrorism professional out there?

Posted by: ned fucking flanders on September 25, 2006 05:27 PM

The definition of torture is important. You like to use that word to discredit the Bush Administration. Yet the interrogators do have to know how much pressure to apply on their captives.

The equation of "torture" such as playing loud rock music or showing gay porn videos to captive jihadists, to the true inhumanity meted out on the victims of the Argentine military regime, of Stalin in the 1930s, or Germany in the 1940s, is overwrought.

Once in a while in the news, you see a report saying that an al Qaeda leader has been captured due to "intelligence". You don't have to be a "24" viewer to know that sometimes this intelligence isn't obtained by asking friendly questions of your prisoners.

Posted by: LiberalatWar on September 25, 2006 09:52 PM

Shorter LiberalAtWar:

Let's not overreact now. The water's only getting a bit warm.

Let's not overreact now. The water's only halfway to boiling.

Let's not overreact now. The water's only starting to steam....

    "First, they breached the Bill of Rights to get terrorists, and I
    did not object because I was not a terrorist. Then they did it
    to get Muslims, and I did not object because I was not a Muslim.
    Then they did it to get me, and [CENSORED BY HOMELAND SECURITY]

 

Posted by: Raven on September 26, 2006 02:07 AM

I'm sure that once our torturers are told that rape and mutilation are off limits, they'll think of something else appropriately demonic.

There are ways to make a man foreswear his God, sacrifice his own children, or sincerely swear to anything at all without actually mutilating him. Particularly if your lawyers (and your thugs) are ingenious enough about the exact definition of "mutilation."

The real question is simpler: Do you accept the cowardice and brutal sadism preached by our leaders, or do you choose to reject the temptations of evil?

If America does not survive as a moral nation, we may not survive at all. The temptations of evil are often lies, and those who choose evil often destroy themselves. But even if torture "worked," what honorable man would buy his life at such a cost?

Posted by: Eric on September 26, 2006 10:31 AM

Raven, resorting to the slippery slope fallacy is merely sophistry.

Eric, are you saying it doesn't matter at all whether we forbid death, mutilation, and rape, because interrogators will find another way to do these things, so fixing rules is hopeless?

Rough interrogation is sometimes effective, particularly with regard to hardened jihadists. It's not because pain and suffering makes him talk, but 1) it acts to disorient the captive, and 2) it makes the good cop/bad cop routine more credible.

Doubtless, resorting to these techniques is not the preferred way if the world were perfect. But we're in a war that a brutal enemy started, an enemy that has a religiously driven mass-murdering ideology, and who have violated all the laws of war. Gathering intelligence is the most important and effective tactic of the war; it's not tanks, planes, and ships. Maximizing the effectiveness of intelligence gathering, while restricting the use of mild torture to a handful of cases, is needed in this case.

And what is the alternative? Use the pre-9/11 standard -- terrorists have all the rights of common criminals and are to be brought to trial with all the usual rules of evidence -- when that has been shown to be ineffective?

Posted by: LiberalatWar on September 26, 2006 10:02 PM

LiberalAtWar, may I remind you that torture, even so-called mild torture, is evil? And if that does not deter you, then you should know that torture of any kind is a crime under military, national, and international law. Under US law, the maximum penalty is death.

Posted by: Doctor G on September 26, 2006 11:48 PM

If you're equating showing gay porn or playing loud rock music, to killing and mutilation, and that they're both equally evil, then I'm sorry, we're on completely different wavelengths. Sometimes, in the real world, we must choose between lesser and greater evils. The question is how. That takes wisdom and judgment. Perhaps we should turn the other cheek to jihadists, like that nun in Somalia -- why are we even imprisoning them? But if one of the goals is to minimize the chances of another mega-attack, and at the same time keep our effort from embracing an uncontrolled morass of torture, doesn't the compromise discussed in Washington deserve a fair hearing, even among liberals such as us?

About the legality of torture, isn't changing the law what's being debated in Washington? Our government sets the rules, and we're debating the rules. Dismissing those like me with a wave of the hand, saying it's illegal, is like discussing Mexican immigration with someone very opposed to it, and all they say, is that it's illegal, end of story.

I see that blogs such as intel-dump.com have continued the torture debate for hundreds of postings. I'll continue to read the arguments, particularly from those who share the same liberal political views, even though we disagree on the torture issue.

How's this for a standard: If I were to read a revelation about a torture program during WWII, approved by President Roosevelt, meant only for captured concentration camp officials, with the purpose of getting information about the camps, and the standards of torture involved bright lights, loud music, and bad movies, would I then think the entire war effort was pointless, and that Roosevelt was a war criminal?

Good luck to you all. Perhaps the torture bill will be shot down, all torture will be forbidden, it will never be needed, and we'll never experience another terror attack. I certainly hope so.

Posted by: LiberalatWar on September 27, 2006 09:48 PM

veey nice

Posted by: oyunlar on August 28, 2007 10:25 AM

very good

Posted by: izmirchat on August 28, 2007 10:25 AM

thanks
best wishes

Posted by: mirc on September 23, 2007 06:39 PM

thanks. best regards.

Posted by: forum on September 23, 2007 06:39 PM

very good site
i will say everyone

Posted by: sohbet on September 27, 2007 01:03 PM

i will wait news from you

Posted by: sohbet on September 27, 2007 01:07 PM

adana evden eve nakliyat
ıgdır evden eve nakliyat
ardahan evden eve nakliyat
artvin evden eve nakliyat
bartın evden eve nakliyat
şırnak evden eve nakliyat
karaman evden eve nakliyat
bayburt evden eve nakliyat
aksaray evden eve nakliyat
zonguldak evden eve nakliyat
yozgat evden eve nakliyat
van evden eve nakliyat
sanlıurfa evden eve nakliyat
trabzon evden eve nakliyat
sivas evden eve nakliyat
sinop evden eve nakliyat
siirt evden eve nakliyat
samsun evden eve nakliyat
sakarya evden eve nakliyat
rize evden eve nakliyat
nigde evden eve nakliyat
mugla evden eve nakliyat
mardin evden eve nakliyat
maras evden eve nakliyat
manisa evden eve nakliyat
gümüshane evden eve nakliyat
giresun evden eve nakliyat
edirne evden eve nakliyat
çanakkale evden eve nakliyat
diyarbakir evden eve nakliyat
denizli evden eve nakliyat
çankırı evden eve nakliyat
burdur evden eve nakliyat
bolu evden eve nakliyat
adiyaman evden eve nakliyat
afyon evden eve nakliyat
agrı evden eve nakliyat
amasya evden eve nakliyat
antalya evden eve nakliyat
artvin evden eve nakliyat
balıkesir evden eve nakliyat
bilecik evden eve nakliyat
bitlis evden eve nakliyat
bursa evden eve nakliyat
çorum evden eve nakliyat
mersin evden eve nakliyat
iskenderun evden eve nakliyat
hatay evden eve nakliyat
eskişehir evden eve nakliyat
izmit evden eve nakliyat
malatya evden eve nakliyat
kütahya evden eve nakliyat
konya evden eve nakliyat
kocaeli evden eve nakliyat
kırklareli evden eve nakliyat
kayseri evden eve nakliyat
kastamonu evden eve nakliyat
kars evden eve nakliyat
erzurum evden eve nakliyat
elazig evden eve nakliyat
tunceli evden eve nakliyat
gebze evden eve nakliyat
tuzla evden eve nakliyat
pendik evden eve nakliyat
nevsehir evden eve nakliyat
muş evden eve nakliyat
osmaniye evden eve nakliyat
düzce evden eve nakliyat
karabük evden eve nakliyat
yalova evden eve nakliyat
erzincan evden eve nakliyat
istanbul evden eve nakliyat
izmir evden eve nakliyat
nikah şekeri
ankara lazer epilasyon
temizlik
halı yıkama
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
temizlik şirketi ankara
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
lazer epilasyon
lazer epilasyon
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
halı yıkama/
ankara nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
brülör servisi
baca gazı analizi
ankara dekorasyon şirketi
ankara boyacı
lazer epilasyon hakkında
lazer epilasyon bilgi
lazer epilasyon
lazerle epilasyon hakkında
lazer epilasyon
laser epilasyon
ankaralazer epilasyon


bebek şekeri
nikah şekeri
nikah şekerleri
nikah şekeri
estetik
ankara nakliyat pr 3 uluslararası-nakliyat.org omtasnakliyat.net
ankara nakliyat pr 0 uluslararası-nakliyat.org omtasnakliyat.net
halı yıkama pr 0 link
çiçekçi pr 0 link çıkışı
jenerator pr 0 link çıkışı
halı yıkama pr 0 link çıkışı
kale çelik kapı pr 0
çelik kapı pr 0
mermer granit sorunlu açılmıyor
catering pr
catering
tercüme
lazer epilasyon
lazer epilasyon
jenerator sorunlu açılmıyor
duşakabin
duşakabin
kale çelik kapı omtaş uluslarası
kale çelik kapı
emlak
emlakcı
çiçekçi
tüp bebek
sondaj
sondaj
lojistik
evden eve nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
su deposu
su deposu
saç ekimi
saç ekimi
niakh şekeri
nikah şekeri
nikah şekeri
ankara evden eve nakliyat

ankara nakliyat

ankara nakliyat
saç ekimi
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
rent a car
evden eve nakliyat ankara
ankara temizlik şirketi/

temizlik şirketi
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
tüp bebek
kısırlık
saç ekimi
evden eve nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
temizlik şirketi
ankara nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
temizlik şirketi

evden eve
nakliyat

lazer epilasyon


ankara nakliyat


evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
estetik
oto kiralama
çiçekçi
vidanjör
evden eve nakliyat
lazer epilasyon
lazer epilasyon ankara
evden eve nakliyat ankara
evden eve nakliyat ankara
halı yıkama ankara
evden eve nakliyat ankara
ankara nakliyat/
ankara nakliyat/
evden eve nakliyat
su deposu/
temizlik şirketi/
temizlik şirketleri
temizlik şirketi
temizlik şirketi
temizlik şirketi
halı yıkama/
temizlik firmaları/
ankara temizlik şirketi
promosyon ürünleri
istanbul nakliyat
izmir nakliyat ankara
google optimizasyonu/
nakliyat/
nakliyat/
google optimizasyonu/
halı yıkama/
temizlik şirketleri
tüp bebek
promosyon ürünleri
uluslararası nakliyat

estetik
yag alma
yag aldırma
liposakşın
botox
estetik merkezi
estetik ameliyat
estetik cerrahi
plastik cerrahi
burun estetik
burun estetigi
estetik burun ameliyatı
arama motoru optimizasyonu
oto kiralama


estetik
yag alma
yag aldırma
liposakşın
estetik merkezi
estetik merkezleri
estetik ameliyat
estetik cerrahi
plastik cerrahi
burun estetik
burun estetigi
estetik burun ameliyatı


Posted by: ankara temizlik şirketi on February 9, 2008 05:43 PM

thanks ;)

Posted by: firefox indir on March 31, 2008 06:00 AM

thanks ;)

Posted by: firefox indir on April 1, 2008 10:18 AM

thank you

Posted by: firefox indir on April 6, 2008 09:39 AM

thank you

Posted by: maswey on April 10, 2008 06:44 AM

çiçek

Posted by: çiçek on April 10, 2008 06:58 AM

thank you

Posted by: firefox nedir on April 13, 2008 05:17 AM

thanks

Posted by: epilasyon on April 17, 2008 05:29 AM

Thanks

Posted by: Oriflame on April 17, 2008 01:14 PM

Thanks

Posted by: Oriflame on April 17, 2008 01:18 PM

Thanks

Posted by: Oriflame on April 17, 2008 01:19 PM

teşekkürler

Posted by: şömine on April 18, 2008 07:43 AM

lazer epilasyon merkezi

Posted by: lazer epilasyon on April 19, 2008 03:37 AM

Thanks.. good

Posted by: web tasarım on April 19, 2008 12:15 PM

thanks for article

Posted by: turkey holiday on May 5, 2008 02:48 AM

asdasd

Posted by: aöf on August 7, 2008 12:41 PM

thanks

Posted by: chat on October 14, 2008 06:18 PM

slm

Posted by: perde on October 15, 2008 08:38 AM

thanks.

Posted by: turksiding on October 24, 2008 11:22 AM

thanks a lot.

Posted by: hekimboard on October 24, 2008 11:22 AM

thanksss.

Posted by: dış cephe on October 24, 2008 11:23 AM

hello

Posted by: perde on October 27, 2008 07:59 AM

For sharing thank you very much good very beautiful work

Posted by: çiçekçi on November 7, 2008 01:53 PM

harbiarkadas.com
harbiarkadas.net
harbiarkadas.org
itirafet.org
ebedava.net
elektronikmarket.net
ameribress.com
clitoriacream.net
superspenisbuyutucu.com
megabress.com
rednightperformans.com
performansartirici.com
penisplus.tv
penispluspenisbuyutucu.com
penispluspenisbuyutucu.net
cinselmerkez.com
aseks.net
erotikcamasirlar.com
vajinatr.com
bakirevajina.com
cinselkozmetik.com
kozmetikmedikel.com
eturknet.com
tecavuz.net
yutuvideo.com
ponotubesex.com
laraperuk.com
sackanagimerkezi.com
peruksa.com
perukmarket.com
aseks.com
aloveshop.com
erotikgiyim.com
geciktiricispreyler.com
geciktiricihap.com
geciktiriciler.com
azdirici.com
bayanuyarici.com
fntazialemi.com
fantaziservisi.om
cinselmazemeler.com
cinselfantaziurunleri.com
erotikdakikalar.com
erotikmarketiniz.com
seksmarketiniz.com
sekshatlari.com
erotikdergiler.com
erotikderginiz.com
penisbuyutucuviprx.com
penisbuyutucuvigrx.com
penisbuyutuculer.com
vigrxpenisbuyutucu.com
sismebebekler.com
sismebebekshop.com
yemekeviniz.com
sanalmarketiniz.com
elektronikmarket.net
ebedava.net
kontortr.com
elaydin23.com
turkcellkontorcu.com
aveakontoral.com
vodafonekontoral.com
toptankontorcu.com
cinselkozmetik.com
bayanpartnerler.com
erkekpartnerler.com
kizarkadaslar.com
yonjaarkadas.com
siberalem-siberalem.com
sexpartnerler.com
sekspartnerler.com
erotikpartnerler.com
gencyuz.com
erkekarkadaslar.com
bayanarkadaslar.com
yemekeviniz.com
sanalmarketiniz.com
baskahaber.com
medikalkozmetik.net
kozmetikmedikal.com
zayiflamavediyet.net
zayiflamahapii.com
zayiflamabandii.com
kilovertr.com
zayiflamatr.net
diyettr.com
toksinbandi.net
botoxtr.com
botokstr.com
selulittedavii.com
selulitgiderici.net
selulitkremii.com
catlaktedavisii.com
catlakgiderici.net
catlakkremii.com

sex shop

Posted by: sexshop on November 10, 2008 07:39 AM

For those of you thinking that if they implement this it will eliminate some of the waiting and lines…

Posted by: Meme on November 18, 2008 09:55 AM

MHO, what has always scared the suits away from GNU/Linux and open source in general is the loss of control over proprietary intellectual property. In their minds, patented proprietary software is like a real property mortgage that you can could record on your balance sheet as a tangible asset. GPL nixes that and that's what has made the suits wary of adopting OS software since you can loose your original art by mixing it with GPLed stuff. With the advent of SAAS, the fear is just not there anymore. You can get your supporting software for free much cheaper that the electricity or water in your building!

ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
ankara evden eve nakliyat
nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
ankara evden eve nakliyat
I remember reading circa 2002 that IBM employed about 600 full time OS developers; the last article in Business Week last year quoted the same figure five years later. The good thing for corporate is that although they cannot re-license it(a’la M$), the labor cost to maintaining it on a global scale is small. And, from what I've read the labor cost for OpenBSD are even less. Sounds like a deal to me!
saç ekimi
saç ekimi
saç ekimi
ankara evden eve
estetik
I'm not sure how Shirky's remarks could be seen as an attempt to "mythologize [a] collection of gratis labor and encourage an ersatz politics of volunteer participation in these fundamentally corporate, private-interest projects," as he explicitly addresses the efforts and implications of paid corporate labor.

There's no blind utopianism in the post; it's a look at what the evolution of Linux development in the corporate realm means for corporate entities and management, not an attempt to pretend we're still in the volunteer phase of the game.

burun estetiği
lazer epilasyon
estetik cerrahi
ankara lazer epilasyon
tüp bebek
ankara lazer
I worked in an IBM shop when the first GNU programs -- GCC, GDB, and Emacs -- were released. I was in rooms where the executives' take on it and interests were being explored. It was quite simple: at that time, the development tools market was starting to boom. Investment capital was concentrating on it. The first GNU releases killed that and investment in that space contracted and never picked back up to the same levels of interest. A growth market had been destroyed.

Posted by: oto kiralama on November 18, 2008 02:59 PM

thanks you site admin.

Posted by: mirc on November 25, 2008 04:11 PM

online cicekve malzeme satıs dagıtım ve pazarlama

Posted by: cicekmalzemesi on November 26, 2008 09:01 AM

Thanks you really perfect one writing.I m always follow you.

cinsel sohbet
sohbet odalari kelebek script kelebek sohbet chat sohbet cet çet mirc script muhabbet sohbet radyo kelebekfm mirc kelebek turk sohbet çet sohbet sohbet muhabbet seks sohbet universite sohbet universite chat çet sohbet kelebekfm izmir sohbet kelebek sohbet

cinsel sohbet sohbet odalari kelebek script kelebek sohbet chat sohbet
turk sohbet | çet | kelebek sohbet | turk chat | turksohbet | sohbet |
muhabbet | turk sohbet | sohbet | kelebek | mirc |
izmir | cet | sohbet | zurna | sohbet | kelebek
sohbet odaları | turk sohbet | muhabbet | irc forum | kelebek | universite sohbet | sohbet | sohbetbizde


izmir sohbet cinsel sohbet kelebek mirc operserv chanserv siir botserv zurna mynet ataturk universitesi sohbet chat odalari au sohbet au chat kelebek script kelebek script kelebek mirc kelebek skript mric gazi universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,gazi sohbet,gazi chat,kelebek duzce universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,duzce sohbet,duzce chat ... ege universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,ege sohbet,ege chat,kelebek dumlu pınar universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,dumlupınar sohbet ... memoserv, memo serv,memoserv komutlari mesaj komutlari irc mesaj ... mirc indir kamerali mirc yabanci mirc mirc 6.21
sesli tv seslisesli sesliask sesli fıkra sesliefsane sesliyiz sesli türkiyem seslialem sesli dini sohbet ... erzincan universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,erzincan sohbet ... Yüzük Script mirc yüzük cet yüzük script 4 yuzuk sohbet yüzük chat ankara sohbet ankara chat ankara muhabbet ankara arkadas ankara.net erciyes universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,erciyes sohbet,erciyes ... dicle universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,dicle sohbet,dicle chat ... mirc indir,mirc script,mirc yukle,mirc,script mırç,mrc,kelebek ... kelebek cinsel sohbet cinsel chat kelebek mirc myrc script mirc programi turkçe mirc indir mric mrc ... izmir sohbet izmir chat izmir muhabbet izmir arkadas izmir cet çet kelebek sohbet odalari chat sohpet cet kelebek muhabbet çet ... arkadasbul askim - arkadas bul, arkadas arama, arkadas ara ... kelebek host iletisim bilgileri sitene sohbet ekle sitene chat ekle sitene sohbet odasi koy kelebek sohbet , chat kelebek sohbet , cet kelebek sohbet , canli ... sohbet Kizlarla Sohbet Kızlarla Sohbet, Bedava Sohbet Odası ... kelebek sohbet chat muhabbet amasya uiversitesi sohbet chat odalari au sohbet au chat canakkale onsekiz mart universitesi sohbet chat odalari comu ... istanbul sohbet istanbul chat istanbul muhabbet istanbul arkadas

Posted by: kelebek on December 2, 2008 04:36 PM

thanks.

Posted by: dış cephe on December 16, 2008 05:52 AM

hosting

Posted by: hosting on December 25, 2008 08:52 PM

thanks.. you..

Posted by: Sohbet on December 28, 2008 11:57 AM

thanks you Ahmet ;)

Posted by: Sohbet on December 28, 2008 11:58 AM

thanks you.AnarChy

Posted by: cet on January 5, 2009 03:09 PM

thanks you.AnarChy

Posted by: kelebek mirc indir on January 5, 2009 03:10 PM

Thanks

Posted by: kelebek on January 5, 2009 03:35 PM

Thanks for you.

Posted by: oyun on January 5, 2009 04:18 PM

thank you site admin..

Posted by: mirc on January 13, 2009 05:45 AM

thanks site admin.

Posted by: mirc yükle on January 13, 2009 05:46 AM

thank you site admin..

Posted by: mirc indir on January 13, 2009 05:47 AM

thank you very much

Posted by: bilgisayar on January 22, 2009 08:37 PM

thanks all things

Posted by: nikah sekeri on March 21, 2009 11:39 AM

thanks all things

Posted by: nikah sekeri on March 21, 2009 11:41 AM

thanks

Posted by: nikah şekeri on April 7, 2009 02:02 PM

Thanks you

Posted by: sohpet on April 13, 2009 11:41 AM

thankss

Posted by: mirc on May 18, 2009 10:13 AM

thanks

Posted by: Web Tasarım on May 19, 2009 07:30 AM

government. These are families that have been torn apart by hearsay. This is driving me nuts, thinking that no one has challenged the government on this. This will be an even bigger tragedy than Waco in a very short time because no one has died yet, but they sure are being tortured.

Posted by: penis büyütücü on June 5, 2009 04:34 AM

sex shop

Posted by: sex shop on June 5, 2009 04:36 AM

kadını göötten sikiyor asyalıporno kudurdum sex anal çakış öğrencisini tecavüz ed 17 real sex video levent 123456 olgun kadın ile şikiş tuvalet çekimleri olgun pornu beleş izle frikik YARAK VİDEOLAR adultkurt porn ayakkabı yalama sex zevk filmporno fahişe kadınların vidy kilot sex dansöz sex ormanda kadınlar çişin yaslı bayan vıdosu soyunan ve sevişen kad titen erotik horse vajine sex zenci şişko sikiş büyük beden porno olgun zenci ihtiyar ka banyodan çıkan kız res salata sokuyor zenci travesti kadın s zekten ağlıyan kız por seksene net pornoları bedava en sıcak ğörünt kuduruk sikişken hatun seksporno vidoları amatörsex yapanlar eşşek ile sevişen kadı lezbiyenler amına yalı lezbiyen öğrencilerin sikişvideosu en hızlı azgın kadınlarla sikiş hayat kadınlarının sex sexsy yatak göruntuler kucak sex amını tahriş eden kız öğretmenle kız öğrenci dar giyinmiş sarışınla sex porn zevkmania 2 KADIN SIKİŞİ VİDY wwww.videoseks hot seks videoları zencilerin videoları dersçalışırken sikme evde erotık videolar krüt ce porno japon erotık sıkış yarakemme ormanda çişini yapanla EN GÜZEL SİKİŞME FOTOĞ yaraklara çıldıran kad ZORLASİKİŞ şişmankadın seks yarakyalamak dolgun memeli atesli h genç kızların erotik v sıcak lez vidyoları aldatan kadınlar yerlı amsikme OROSBU VİDİOLARI sevişirken bağıran kız beden hoca sex izle keyiflisikiş mini etek sikiş videol arap orosbu karıları garantiseks rus sex erotık vıdeo ofıste ye?il?am erotik erkeği sert sevişen ka hemşireler sevişiyor y japon kız olgun sikiş erkek yaragı kac santi www garanti sikiş porn japon erotık sıkış diskoda barda sex siki sıcak sex yapan kadınl erkeklerin sikleri kac üvey oğluyla sex yapan gece yarısı sikiş yeter boşal artık vide çılgınca sex yapan yaş dans ederken arkadan s üvey annesiyle sikişen brezilya sikiş yaşlı sekss filimi sex manuel video güzel göğüs sikiş azgın kadınların sikiş üvey oğluyla sex yapam eglenceporno TEYZEM18 + ilk kez götten sikiş v nylon seks domalmış rahibe hizmet \"seks isteyen kadın sıcak vidiolar izle kanada sex online porn tecrübeli bayan erotik konulu dvd porno vidol acemiseks lez videoları sıcak SEXİKALÇA.DANS mini etekli sikiş vide evde sex videoları lezbiyenler arka sex sikciler bebeklere sikis göster domalan köylü kadın vi genc yaşlı sikiş ormanda işeyen kız disko ve barlarda sex milf and yong sex www.zevkmania.cm sürtük japon kız KADIN EROTIKSEX sudan porno flim esmer ve sarışın sex v en b erkek ve kadin sexsi v ate ögrenci ögretmen olgun kadın sikişi tür sikiş türk terörist adam kadına arkadan YAŞLI FULL dağda sexs hemşire domalmış kcuk am sıkerım açık kadınlar orosbu sevginin sikişi domalan.bayanlar.com jalenin firikikleri iz muhteşem sikiş sahnele olgul şikme porno cüceler sevişiyor yaşlı kadın genc erkek 18+zorla sikis video realseks komşusunu siken sikiş tatildeki azgın sikis pozısyonları kar am veyarak sıcak sıcaksex videola 45+kadın sex picture SİCAKSEX 69 japon sex erotik tv ILGINC SEKS VE EROTIK şalvarlı kadın şikişi barda sikilen kadın sex isteyen video sıcak erotik sikiş olgunkadın pornosu erotik çorap video siyah seksi çoraplı ka adam kadını zıplatıyor olgun kadın görüntüler kanka izlesene pornoyu arkadan yiyenlere orosbucom bakirekızınsikişi erotik spor videolar yaşlı ero 31 çeken adam videolar poliz lezbiyenler fahişe seks video sıcak erotizm.net lezb japon kızın seks filmi NAYLON CORAP VIDEOLARI arkadan erotik MİNİ ETEK SEX faişe kadınların sikiş kırmızı kilot pornosu adukt kurt ihanet seks videoları full dvd pornolar erotik yaşlı kadın lez sex filim yaşlı kadın sikiş hika yengesi ile sevişiyor çıtır kızların gögüsün seslı eotık çıplak bayanpartner.co büyük yarakla seks yap www.yengem com. TELEFONLA KONUŞUP SİKİ yaşlı kadın sikişiyor gizli sikişmeler azgın olgun kadınlar ihanet seksfilmleri iz öğrencisex ama şişe sokan kadınla sulu am resimleri türk eve erkek alan ka yaşlı lezbiyenler sevi popo kız gizli sevişmelerin kam kac porno kuduruk türk sikişi Alman rtl sikiş izle konuşulan pornolar YERLİ AM yeşilçamsex.com seks video sikiş am 50 yaşında karı porno 12 13 sikişleri barda sevişen kadınlar damatsevişmesi zencisikişi izle sübyan sikiş resimleri kızlar ormanda çişini kendini siktiren kız okul lavabosunda seviş sıcak lezbıyen vıdyosu komşusunu siken kısa süreli erotik vid sesx kadini sevisiyor üveyannesinisikiyor www.yengem sikiş beyaz amıcıklı seks v bedava garantiseks komşusunu siken türk arap kadın genc kızlar gran ilk kez arkadan yapma olgun karı ağzıyla boş auld kurd güzel ve seksi göğüslü elbiseli çoraplı kadın adultkute.com pornzab.fr 18 şiki vityoları sıcaklezbiyen genç cocugun olgun kad kadın adamla sevişiyo selin demir sikiş yaşlı kadın seks filmi amına meyve sokan lezb hamburg turbanlı sex japon kadınların şikiş zenci kızların sexsi en büyük penisli zenci mini etekli siki,ş SİKİŞ VOD banyoda kadın sex ablam banyodayken ikiz tepeler sex izle göte top sokan kadın sıcak kadın sex kız daha sexe acemı dildo makine sex porn gelinlikle gerdek gece sandiwiç sex harika sikiş videoları çılgın kızlar video çe genç kıza sağsafon temizlikci dolgun bacaklı etekli elini sokarak sikiş karımdan firikik komşu kızı dilanın sik kızlık nasıl bozulur ı otopark seks sikiş halay zevk alemı izle porno serab güzelgöt japon kızın ağzına boş interracıal erotik mankeni havuzda sikiyo penisi kadın video hamamda kudurtan seks filmleri seksi çorap giyenler garantisex.com video i lebiyen evli kadın sek kızkardeş erotık filmi yükle izle sıcak çift penisli erkek por 18 video seks türkçe anal ortam kızı hamamda sevişen seksi amına kalın sokan göden sikiş porno izle dolgun şişman şikiş arabic hija porno www.zevk89 götten ilk kez sikişi şahane popo ve sex olgun kadın sevişme sex am göt yarak sikiş sınıfta erotic erotik sevişen gençkız erotic video teen mum 89.japon.sikiş teens ve school soyuna kadın seks porno erot\ videolarporno adamın yaragını yalaya kadın ama sikiyor kudurdum pornoları izl gizli kamera mini etek sünnetsiz erkekin sik türkceerotik erotik teens vids mutfakta seks türk hocası öğrencisin zenci seven porno film sıcak ayak yalama vide penis sürtmek sexs engüzel domalma sikiş mını kız erkek çocukla 14 15 yaş sikiş videol genc ve yasli olgun ka gizli gizli sikişme vi şişmansikiş olgun dul seks videosu erotizm vıdeoları karan lıkta sikişenler sekssi seven lezbien a yasli adam yasli kadin dolgun gögüs vidyoları bilardo masasında sikt bedava şişman kadın ma japon fıstıklar seks rapid sikme karı soyma izle ögrencisini sırada sik kamerada soyunan video azgin arap kadinlari s azgın pornolar fuckgame evli kadın erotik vide kamerada soyunan kadın büyük yarak seven yaşl seks partisi izle youtube zorla sikiş iz hamileler sikişmek ist seks partisi görüntüle 12cm penisle sikiş gizli sikişme videolar haydi sex partisine esmer kadınsik yasak sikiş..com şişman teyze sikiş vid nylon porn izle kuduruk sex izle sex vücutlu hatunlar o kopek lerın cıflesme a köpeyini siken adam grup sex yapan mini et erkek kardeşiyle sex tender teensex.com 89sikiş engüzel domalma sikiş cz porno kudurdun türk com gece yarısı sikiş nevsehirli amciklar seksi nazlı hatun film www teyzem.com. şehvet dolu sevişme er takma amcıkla tatmin o siyah göt büyük porno porno yapanlar genç yarak penis youtubeoral kıllı kadın seks video kocamın önünde zorla v nasıl geç boşalrım erotik çorap giyen kad sex oral vidolar ertik amcığa boşalan yarrak vaginasını traş ediyor şişman sexi izle kadın kendini eşeğe si 2 olgun kız bi cocuk s seksi hamam porno sıcak videolar sikiş net am sikiş vidioları kürt dvd pornosu şikiş corap garanti seks kategori sikiş istiyor kadın EN GÜZEL ÇOBAN SİKİŞME insaat seks izle süpersexs erotik sitriptizler porno sek sex yasli ka lezbiyen askim filmizl ders çalışırken sikiş tatilde sex yapan azgı sekreterlesex bedava büyük göğüslü k rahibeyi zorla siken travestilersex derste seks filimler i arap kız seksı video kanlı şikiş videoları gta san cıplak sexx uzun bacaklı türbanlı yaşlıkadınların sx vid jigolo arayan yası kad gotten ilk kez sikis v dog sex am göt sikişme tenderteensex.com full porno film izle erotik giyinen kadın v acı vererek sikilen ihanet eden kadin seks rahıbe lesbıyenler fetisi tube sex kadin sikme türk.netsex genç çocuk yaşlı kadın seks yapan unluler otobüste sıcak manken..sıcak pornosu sex izle zevke gel matureadult videolar çift cinsiyetli SIKIS FILMY gelin damat türk seks mılf and young lez soyunuk kadın video sex fotğrafları dolgun kadın sex video acemi seks videoları doyumsuz erotik videol 21sikiş ilk defa bağırarak sev japonerotik en güzel popoları gall sicak seksi erotizm japon gangbang sex zevk seks video www sisman kadin sikis baldız sex videoları sikiş 21kom bakire kızın bozmasi sevişen erkekler video teen erotik sikis japon erotik dar amcıklı cocuk porn türbanlı kadın sikiş f kudurdumtürk.com yatakta orgazm olan kı garanti seks zenci ana büyük penisli zenciler kocasının isteğiyle ba olgun şişman kadın por lezbiyen cocuklar sex öğretniyle sikiş erotık lezbıyen vıdeol kürtce porno kürtce Teen Casting ücretsiz başkalarıyla sex japanes boşalıyor kız ıfuck sexs sekspornoerotik adult penis sevişenmature pornsicak seks pornosu Sıcak seks evlilik evde sikiş kadın sikişirken inliy mutfaktasex gta andreas kız sikme yaşlı kadınlar seksi + 18 pornfilm video erkek pensi vidosu olgunkadın video sekreter sevışiyor küçük çocuk yarrağı koca dede yalı dayı sex çpcuk sex kendini travestiye sik düs alıken orgazm olan popo büyük sik dağda sikişme videosu çıtır kızlar 17 si şişman kadınlar seksi kadınların sikiş ve er üvey oğlunun annesiyle postacı sikiyor cemilenin amı sınıfta siken

Posted by: Porno on June 5, 2009 02:00 PM

Post A Comment

advertise_liberally.gif