A Choice, Not an Echo

Since it's apparently acceptable to argue that Democrats rode to victory on a wave of conservative nominees in the South based entirely on the fact that Health Schuler won, I suppose I can vastly overgeneralize from the case of Carol Shea-Porter, the sort of woman who never in a million years would have secured a nomination in a seat the party thought was in play but who nonethelss won her race in New Hampshire. Here's her website. Note that in the "on the issues" section of the site, "civil liberties" is the first issue listed and if you click the link you'll see a full-throated denunciation of the Bush surveillance policies. Her economic agenda consists more-or-less entirely of tax hikes:

I will push to eliminate the tax cuts for the top 1% of income earners (individuals earning $400,000, couples making $800,000), raise the minimum wage, and invest in our children, families and seniors. In Congress, I will work to guarantee Social Security's long-term health by voting to put a Social Security tax on someone's full income, not just the first $90,000.

On education, she's against vouchers, against NCLB, and basically just wants to throw money at public schools and teachers. She wants us to fight global warming, and on national security leads with the observation that "Terrorists will only be defeated if there is goodwill and cooperation among various governments, so that all nations will aid in hunting them down. There are certainly a few rogue nations, but by invading Iraq, we have lost credibility with many other nations who could be helpful." She takes a shockingly unnuanced stance on abortion: "Women have a right to make their own reproductive decisions, and families have a right to make end of life decisions."

Just saying -- lotsa liberals in the new crew.

Comments

Thanks for the afternoon chuckle.

Posted by: jbou on November 10, 2006 01:36 PM

Women have a right to make their own reproductive decisions

Gotta love the continued refusal to address the question of the human embryo and whether it is worthy of any legal protection.

families have a right to make end of life decisions

For whom? In what situation? Or is it just carte blanche?

Posted by: Mark Adams on November 10, 2006 01:40 PM

Great point, but I think we have nothing to lose by nodding politely with those who say that this was a win for "conservative Democrats".

In fact, I think we should echo that analysis all over the place: "this was a win for CONSERVATIVE DEMOCRATS."

Let's help the wingnuts link "conservative" with "Democrat" every chance we get. If we're successful, that cedes only the fascist end of the political spectrum to the Republican party.

Meanwhile, all of those CONSERVATIVE DEMOCRATS can raise the minimum wage, negotiate for better medicare drug prices, and end illegal surveillance, among other conservative acts.

Posted by: Tom Ames on November 10, 2006 01:42 PM

All I know is, John Sununu is politically a dead man walking.

Posted by: JP on November 10, 2006 01:54 PM

She also advocates expanding medicare to cover every citizen.

Posted by: FTJ on November 10, 2006 01:58 PM

"I will work to guarantee Social Security's long-term health by voting to put a Social Security tax on someone's full income, not just the first $90,000."

I like that 'someone'.

Posted by: otto on November 10, 2006 02:02 PM

"Women have a right to make their own reproductive decisions."

Gotta love the continued refusal to address the question of the human embryo and whether it is worthy of any legal protection.

Alright. The embryo is not a human being, and in a situation in which we have to decide whether to protect the rights of a human being versus protect the rights of something that is not a human being, well, I, and most Americans for that matter, choose the former.

Another episode of easy answers to easy questions.


Posted by: oneangryslav on November 10, 2006 02:10 PM

I agree with Tom Ames.

We should continue to reinforce the theme of CONSERVATIVE DEMOCRATS. The more we talk about it, the more power the Democrats will have to do what they (and most Americans) want.

If left-wing Democrats are thinking strategically, they'll get behind the CONSERVATIVE DEMOCRATS theme and say it with a straight face.

Posted by: Vicki Meagher on November 10, 2006 02:18 PM

I hate to nitpick, but this is something we're all going have to learn.

There is no 'C' in Heath Shuler. Presumably this is because his ancestors came from Germany/Austria/Alsace-Lorraine at a different time than Chuck Schumer's.

Posted by: Nicholas Beaudrot on November 10, 2006 02:19 PM

oneangryslav,

If you are saying that “in a situation in which we have to decide whether to protect the rights of a human being versus protect the rights of something that is not a human being” most American choose the to protect the rights of the former you are correct. If you are saying that most Americans believe that a human embryo is not a human being than you are wrong.

Posted by: Mark Adams on November 10, 2006 02:22 PM

I love the notion that the proper home for common-sense conservatives is in the Democratic Party. Shout it from the rooftops.

It's clear that pushing this meme is a strategic disaster for Republicans. The reason we hear it from them is not based on logic, but on the fact that so many Republicans are motivated from day one by nothing more than hatred of liberals.

All Rush Limbaugh's audience cares about is that this election not be considered in any way, shape or form as a victory for liberals. Fine. Let them have what they want.

Posted by: Steve on November 10, 2006 02:35 PM

There is no 'C' in Heath Shuler.

But there is a 'L'. (Brought to you from the 'M' and 'E' in team.)

Posted by: LowLife on November 10, 2006 02:36 PM

Somebody should just make a list of all the new congressfolk and then count heads.

For the eight new Senators (besides Klobchar who I know nothing about), for each set of issues I count four Senators on the left half of the caucus, and four on the right half. So our new Dems are just like our current Dems.

Not sure about the House.

Posted by: JP on November 10, 2006 02:40 PM

Here's some food for thought: with the entry of Vilsack into the presidential race, the Iowa caucuses have been demoted in importance - since Vilsack will be a favorite son lock there - and the New Hanpshire primary has consequently been elevated in importance. And New Hampshire now appears to be a decisively more liberal state than it once was.

Our Democratic governor won 74% of the vote. Democrats picked up 88 seats in the House of Representatives and now control both houses for the first time in living memory. Both US congressional districts switched from Republicans to unabashedly progressive Democrats. I'm so loving this.

Posted by: Dan Kervick on November 10, 2006 02:40 PM

Mark Adams,

Of course an embryo is a human being. "Human being" is a species description. Whether an embryo is a PERSON or not is what is under debate.

Defining "personhood" as magically adhering to an embryo at the moment of conception is a religious and metaphysical conceit that most Americans may or may not agree with.

There is no empirical evidence supporting the claim, however. Furthermore, I wonder just how many Americans actually believe it to be true? If most Americans hold that embryos are people, as you claim, why is there a general level of comfort with the process of in vitro fertilization, which results in the destruction of MANY embryos?

I suspect that people don't really think too much about the distinctions. They're happy to be outraged when the religious right projects images of cooing babies onto the reality of a blastocyst. But if someone want to get pregnant at the cost of a couple of dozen of them, they really don't seem to give a damn.

This kind of sloppy moral reasoning ought not to provide the foundation for depriving women of the right to control their own reproductive destinies.

Posted by: Tom Ames on November 10, 2006 02:42 PM

88 seats?? How big is the state house? Does each legislator represent, like, twenty people?

Posted by: JP on November 10, 2006 02:43 PM

I guess this isn't working out too well for the folks involved...

Posted by: JP on November 10, 2006 02:45 PM

since Vilsack will be a favorite son lock there

My understanding is that Vilsack is polling something like 4th. I agree the importance will be reduced, but I wouldn't write it off just yet.

Posted by: Steve on November 10, 2006 02:46 PM

88 seats?? How big is the state house? Does each legislator represent, like, twenty people?

I believe it has 400 seats, and describes itself as the third largest legilative body in the English-speaking world. Gven the current population of about 1,310,000, that comes out to one rep for every 3275 people,

Posted by: Dan Kervick on November 10, 2006 02:52 PM

For whom? In what situation? Or is it just carte blanche?

I'm sure she means that everyone should be allowed to kill everyone else as long as they belong to some sort of family. Thanks for pointing out the hidden implications.

Posted by: Cryptic Ned on November 10, 2006 02:52 PM

That's pretty amazing, Dan. I know some high schools with more than 3275 people.

Posted by: JP on November 10, 2006 02:56 PM

That's pretty amazing, Dan. I know some high schools with more than 3275 people.

It's a very, very strange situation. Pretty much any New Hampshire-ite who's interested in politics winds up running for the state legislature at some point.

Posted by: Matthew Yglesias on November 10, 2006 03:11 PM

I'm sure she means that everyone should be allowed to kill everyone else as long as they belong to some sort of family. Thanks for pointing out the hidden implications

I'm sure that is not what she meant. I only meant to illustrate how devoid of any meaningful content such a statement is. It's nice to say families should make end-of-life decisions but how that gets worked in the nitty-gritty reality of any given situation is much more complex and much more susceptible to ethically dubious conduct than people realize.

Posted by: Mark Adams on November 10, 2006 03:16 PM

Tom Ames,

Of course an embryo is a human being. "Human being" is a species description. Whether an embryo is a PERSON or not is what is under debate.

Yes, I realize this and I wish more people would acknowledge it. My problem is that the typical language of pro-choicers makes it sound as if anti-abortion people simply don't want women to do as they wish with their body while ignoring the whole argument of the anti-abortion side that once pregnancy occurs there is more than the women's body involved, there is now a second life that has to be taken into account.

Defining "personhood" as magically adhering to an embryo at the moment of conception is a religious and metaphysical conceit that most Americans may or may not agree with.

Conferring personhood at any point in human development is metaphysical conceit.

There is no empirical evidence supporting the claim, however. Furthermore, I wonder just how many Americans actually believe it to be true? If most Americans hold that embryos are people, as you claim, why is there a general level of comfort with the process of in vitro fertilization, which results in the destruction of MANY embryos?

I think you are correct. That is why I didn't say that "most Americans hold that embryos are people". I think most Americans don't have a well thought out position (in part for reasons you explained) and depending on how you phrase the question in polls entirely determines on which side of the question the majority falls. For that reason I wouldn't say there is a consensus on either side of the question. As for in vitro you make a good point but I would says that I think there is widespread ignorance among the public about what happens with in vitro. I was shocked at the number of conversations I had with people in connection to the Missouri Amendment 2 who didn't know that multiple human embryos were often frozen as result of each in vitro treatment.

This kind of sloppy moral reasoning ought not to provide the foundation for depriving women of the right to control their own reproductive destinies.

What other issues are people not well informed enough on that they ought to be taken out of the democratic process?

Posted by: Mark Adams on November 10, 2006 03:36 PM

It's nice to say families should make end-of-life decisions but how that gets worked in the nitty-gritty reality of any given situation is much more complex and much more susceptible to ethically dubious conduct than people realize.

As opposed to the ethical clarity that obtains when people like Tom Delay, Bill Frist and Jeb Bush make those end-of-life decisions.

Posted by: Tom Ames on November 10, 2006 03:37 PM

Tom Ames, Where did I say that?

Posted by: Mark Adams on November 10, 2006 03:38 PM

Tome Ames,

And if we are talking about the Terri Schiavo case then I believe her family, you know the people that share her DNA, raised her, and that kind of stuff, wanted to keep her alive. Her long-estranged husband didn't. And a court decided. So can I assume that Carol Shea-Porter thinks that situation came out the wrong way?

Posted by: Mark Adams on November 10, 2006 03:47 PM

What other issues are people not well informed enough on that they ought to be taken out of the democratic process?

I can think of plenty of moral questions that are too complex to be resolved by a majority vote among a public that, as you say, is poorly educated. This is why we have a Constitution.

As to the question of personhood: I have yet to find a pro-lifer who can explain to me how personhood-at-conception can be reconciled with either the twinning of one embryo or the fusion of two. In the first instance, one "person" becomes two, while in the second, two "people" become one. Clearly, in these (not rare) cases, the defining event for personhood takes place well past fertilization. If that's true here, why isn't it always true?

Can you explain where the extra person comes from or goes to in each of these examples?

Posted by: Tom Ames on November 10, 2006 03:52 PM

I was almost following you, Mark, until you said this:

And if we are talking about the Terri Schiavo case then I believe her family, you know the people that share her DNA, raised her, and that kind of stuff, wanted to keep her alive. Her long-estranged husband didn't.

Um, yeah, Mr. Schiavo hadn't spoke to his wife for years because she was in a vegetative state. That tends to happen, you know. There was no estrangement prior to the accident. By your logic, you could just as easily say that her parents were estranged from her too.

That's the kind of sloppy reasoning that will lose you a lot of credibility in a short time.

Posted by: JP on November 10, 2006 04:10 PM

Tom Ames,

I will try to provide a more complete answer later, but for now I will say that for me, personhood or ensoulment at the moment of conception is not necessary to say that a human embryo shouldn't be killed. It is still, as you concede, a human being.

I'm not sure what problem twinning presents: another embryo is produced through an asexual method. The first embryo remains a the distinct entity it was before. If someone believes in personhood at the moment an embryo comes into existence, then once the second embryo comes about you have a second person.

Fusion I had never heard of but from what I can tell Googling, you have two embryos. One is absorbed into the other such that it dies. Once again, what is the problem? You had two embryos. One remains and one dies.

Posted by: Mark Adams on November 10, 2006 04:17 PM

JP,

Perhaps I used the word incorrectly. I simply meant to refer to the fact that he had lived with another woman for some time and had fathered two children with her.

Do I get any credibility back?

Posted by: Mark Adams on November 10, 2006 04:21 PM

I had a college classmate who was a poli-sci major run for, and serve in, New Hampshire's lower house. She applied for credit, for real-world experience.

The relevant dean gave her only six credit-hours.

Posted by: Davis X. Machina on November 10, 2006 05:12 PM

Seeing as how, in Schiavo's view, his wife was dead (and, by the way, her parents fully approved of his relationships with other women prior to their falling out with him, which came years later), "estranged" is an inherently misleading and unfair word for you to use. You might not agree with his judgment that his wife was dead, but if that's your basis for denying him the right to take her off the feeding tube, then all you're doing is putting the rabbit in the hat.

Posted by: JP on November 10, 2006 05:21 PM

Mark,

My point regarding twinning is that personhood clearly cannot be linked to conception. In twinning there IS NO "first embryo". An embryo splits into two. Does the "personhood" also split? Or does the original person stick to one of the two twins while a new person appears and adheres to the other?

With embryo fusion (which has only recently been described in the scientific literature) two distinct embryos become one. It's not that one dies and is absorbed by the other. Rather, where there were two genetically distinct embryos, after the event there is only one mosaic that remains to become an actual person. Where did the other person go when the embryos fused? Is the personhood of the fused embryo somehow greater than the personhood of a normal embryo?

These are not meant to be flippant questions. Anyone holding the serious belief that an embryo has a unique personal identity has to confront the fact that that personal identity may be less of a discrete quality than it first appears. These examples demonstrate that the unique and indivisible nature of an early zygote is largely an illusion.

Posted by: Tom Ames on November 10, 2006 05:25 PM

Carol Shea-Porter for President!

Posted by: Charley on November 10, 2006 05:41 PM

The media's definition of 'conservative' is 'electable'. ipso facto, a bunch of conservative democrats got elected. Obviously the 'mericun people would NEVER elect dirty hippy liberals.

Posted by: miguel on November 10, 2006 05:56 PM

On DKos the other day, someone was disappointed at having to choose between two conservatives (Hoyer and Murtha) for Majority Leader, and suggested Carol Shea-Porter instead. You have to forgive us, we're pretty new at this governance thing.

Posted by: Steve on November 10, 2006 06:01 PM

Gotta love the continued refusal to address the question of the human embryo and whether it is worthy of any legal protection.

Easy question.

'Human embryos have no legally enforceable rights that superceed those of born, adult human persons.'

Next in line, please?

Posted by: NBarnes on November 10, 2006 07:28 PM

Re: She takes a shockingly unnuanced stance on abortion: "Women have a right to make their own reproductive decisions, and families have a right to make end of life decisions."

What's so odd about that? Outside of GOP/Religious Right circles it's a pretty normal, mainstream opinion. Indeed, on the second part of it, recall that the Terri Schiavo business was the beginning of the end of the GOP dominion, and even some Republicans (including the new governor elect of Florida) agreed with the opinion expressed above.

Posted by: JonF on November 10, 2006 08:55 PM

If conservative is going to mean social democrat from now on, then perhaps liberal will go back to meaning free market, which IME is its general usage here in Yurp.

Does the American left use "liberal" as much it did? I read a few left pundits, and amongst them progressive seems the preferred term.

Posted by: WK on November 11, 2006 04:30 AM

What program of Shea-Porter shows that hill-folk of NH have no appreciation of nuance, unlike suave denizens of, say, New York (I will not say "inside the Beltway", because people come to that "inside" from somewhere, like Michigan -> Arkansas -> New York -> Beltway).

Right wing policies do not work, try left wing policies. Why not trying small incremental changes until we get it right?

Posted by: piotr on November 11, 2006 09:39 AM

Mark Adams thinks that Shea-Porter should have put out a two-page densely-reasoned essay on end-of-life care, instead of just a soundbite line. I agree. That's the Democratic thing to do, and it worked so well for Dukakis and Kerry.

Posted by: John Emerson on November 11, 2006 01:18 PM

piotr: Hilary is originally from Illinois, not Michigan.
JonF: Actually, most polls show that the percentage of Americans who supported completely unrestricted abortion on demand is somewhere in the twenties.
Something that applies to Ms. Shea-Porter, Mr. Shuler, and everyone in between is that it is hard to know how much voters voted because of their issue positions and how much voters voted as a protest against the Republicans. We should see which of these Democrats get re-elected next time before we make any definitve conclusions about the drift of the Democratic party on the country.

Posted by: James Kabala on November 11, 2006 08:19 PM

James: thanks for a correction.

About "20% only supporting abortion on demand".

Since majority supports the right to abortion, it stands to reason that 30+% agrees on abortion only in the cases when the woman does not demand it. Or in a case when a board of politicians that nobody trust agrees with her.

Absurd? Well, it is rather futile to nuance the pro-choice stand, and there is a certain charm in clarity. My true point is that this ca. 30% voters who are in the zone "abortion rights with restriction" have more of feelings on the matter rather than a position, so they can be impressed with "irrelevant factors" like sincerity. Ponder how wingnuts used to collect points for "sincerity".

On a cynical note, a succesful politician should have a combination of "couragous position" with outright pandering, so the question is: what combinations can work and are good for us.

Posted by: piotr on November 11, 2006 11:03 PM

I realize this thread is dead now but I am only now getting the opportunity to respond to some of these final comments.

Seeing as how, in Schiavo's view, his wife was dead (and, by the way, her parents fully approved of his relationships with other women prior to their falling out with him, which came years later)

JP, I couldn't care less whether her parents approved are not.

"estranged" is an inherently misleading and unfair word for you to use.

I already acknowledged once that it may have been a poor choice of words.

You might not agree with his judgment that his wife was dead, but if that's your basis for denying him the right to take her off the feeding tube, then all you're doing is putting the rabbit in the hat."

Actually I haven't made any argument at all about what should have happen to Terri Schiavo. In fact I wasn't the one who brought up the topic. But her situation is actually a pretty perfect illustration of my original point: saying end of life decisions should be made by the family is not a very helpful statement of principle. Terri's mom, father and siblings all wanted to keep her alive. The man she married, who went on to live with another woman, have two children with that woman, and become engaged to that woman, did not want to keep her alive. And who decided what happened to Terri? A judge. So I ask again, If Ms. Shea-Porter wants families to make end of life decisions, does this mean she opposes the outcome of the Terri Schiavo situation? Without making any judgement on the rightness or wrongness of Michael's actions w/r/t/ the other woman, I can't imagine any objective person looking at that situation and saying that Michael was somehow more Terri's family than her mother, father and siblings.

Posted by: Mark Adams on November 12, 2006 01:33 AM

These are not meant to be flippant questions. Anyone holding the serious belief that an embryo has a unique personal identity has to confront the fact that that personal identity may be less of a discrete quality than it first appears. These examples demonstrate that the unique and indivisible nature of an early zygote is largely an illusion.

Tom Ames, I do not take them as flippant questions and I appreciate you asking them. Unfortunately I simply do not know enough about biology/embryology to give an adequate answer. While I acknowledge that the issue of twinning presents interesting and difficult metaphysical questions, it doesn't pose any problems to saying that because of the very fact that determining the point at which personhood comes about is inherently speculative, we ought to err on the side of caution and all human life ought to be given some sort of legal protection.

As for a more thorough answer to your question Tom, here is a piece by Patrick Lee and Robert P. George. I plagiarised some of my original answer to you from this article: http://www.thenewatlantis.com/archive/13/leegeorge.htm

Posted by: Mark Adams on November 12, 2006 01:42 AM

Uh this post was not about fuckin' embryos. Plz grind your own tired axes up on your own blogs.

Mark Adams probably posted the same comment at fifteen other popular Democratic blogs today.

Posted by: tps12 on November 12, 2006 03:21 AM

tps12,

Actaully I didn't post my comments on any other Democratic blogs.

Also, several people engaged me on the points I brought up so I am not sure why you get to tell me that I have to go somewhere else.

Posted by: Mark Adams on November 12, 2006 10:21 AM

It's speculative to say that personhood begins at any exact point in time, granted. But it is not speculative to say that an embryo is not a person. If one defines personhood by possession of any distinctly human faculties (as opposed to the arbitrary and assumed presence of a "soul"), and one puts any creedence at all in scientific and medical knowledge about where human faculties come from, then the fact that an embryo lacks a brain is dispositive. The brain is the source of such human characteristics as intelligence, consciousness of self, emotional life, etc. This simple knowledge is the source of most peoples' intuitive understanding that an early-stage embryo is not a person and e.g. one should not be penalized for murder for arranging a first trimester abortion.

There is no biblical support for the position that personhood begins at conception. Traditional societies did not punish abortion as murder. For almost two thousand years the Catholic church held that an early-stage embryo is not a person.

Frankly I think this whole brouhaha is a result of cultural backlash by a particular branch of Christianity against the combination of feminism and the sexual revolution. The anti-abortion people think the whole single people having sex thing has gotten out of control, and they want an excuse for thinking liberals are mass murderers. That's the source of this, not dubious pseudo-religious assertions.

Posted by: MQ on November 12, 2006 11:50 PM

P.S. just to be clear, my pro-choice position has some basis in my scientific beliefs, but one can perfectly well be religious and be pro-choice. THe larger point is that an embryo is not a person, because, well, it's just obviously not. It can't do any person-type things at all. Most societies and Christians through most times in history have had no problem recognizing this. The knowledge that the embryo is not a person because it doesn't have a brain is just an extra scientific twist. But you know, the obvious has never held people back when there's a cultural need to whip up a reactionary movement.

Posted by: MQ on November 12, 2006 11:54 PM

There has been an exodus of people leaving MA and entering NH because of the housing market. I suspect Shea Porter's win is due to the densely populated Southern NH. NH is changing liberal with social and foreign policy opinions, although I suspect economically the big T word is still not popular.

Posted by: Adrock on November 14, 2006 12:16 PM

thanks ;)

Posted by: firefox indir on April 1, 2008 01:08 PM

thanks ;)

Posted by: firefox indir on April 1, 2008 01:09 PM

cinselkozmetik.com

Posted by: cinsel ürünler on September 18, 2008 04:38 AM

harbiarkadas.com
harbiarkadas.net
harbiarkadas.org
itirafet.org
ebedava.net
elektronikmarket.net
ameribress.com
clitoriacream.net
superspenisbuyutucu.com
megabress.com
rednightperformans.com
performansartirici.com
penisplus.tv
penispluspenisbuyutucu.com
penispluspenisbuyutucu.net
cinselmerkez.com
aseks.net
erotikcamasirlar.com
vajinatr.com
bakirevajina.com
cinselkozmetik.com
kozmetikmedikel.com
eturknet.com
tecavuz.net
yutuvideo.com
ponotubesex.com
laraperuk.com
sackanagimerkezi.com
peruksa.com
perukmarket.com
aseks.com
aloveshop.com
erotikgiyim.com
geciktiricispreyler.com
geciktiricihap.com
geciktiriciler.com
azdirici.com
bayanuyarici.com
fntazialemi.com
fantaziservisi.om
cinselmazemeler.com
cinselfantaziurunleri.com
erotikdakikalar.com
erotikmarketiniz.com
seksmarketiniz.com
sekshatlari.com
erotikdergiler.com
erotikderginiz.com
penisbuyutucuviprx.com
penisbuyutucuvigrx.com
penisbuyutuculer.com
vigrxpenisbuyutucu.com
sismebebekler.com
sismebebekshop.com
yemekeviniz.com
sanalmarketiniz.com
elektronikmarket.net
ebedava.net
kontortr.com
elaydin23.com
turkcellkontorcu.com
aveakontoral.com
vodafonekontoral.com
toptankontorcu.com
cinselkozmetik.com
bayanpartnerler.com
erkekpartnerler.com
kizarkadaslar.com
yonjaarkadas.com
siberalem-siberalem.com
sexpartnerler.com
sekspartnerler.com
erotikpartnerler.com
gencyuz.com
erkekarkadaslar.com
bayanarkadaslar.com
yemekeviniz.com
sanalmarketiniz.com
baskahaber.com
medikalkozmetik.net
kozmetikmedikal.com
zayiflamavediyet.net
zayiflamahapii.com
zayiflamabandii.com
kilovertr.com
zayiflamatr.net
diyettr.com
toksinbandi.net
botoxtr.com
botokstr.com
selulittedavii.com
selulitgiderici.net
selulitkremii.com
catlaktedavisii.com
catlakgiderici.net
catlakkremii.com

Posted by: sexshop on November 5, 2008 04:31 AM

zayıflama

Posted by: zayıflama on November 8, 2008 04:31 AM

seks shop

Posted by: seks shop on November 8, 2008 04:32 AM

penis büyütücüler

Posted by: penis büyütücüler on November 8, 2008 04:38 AM

thank you

Posted by: sohbet on March 5, 2009 10:07 PM

You will find that the more cheap eve isk here is very good for you.

Posted by: rhino geciktirici on March 18, 2009 03:33 AM

You will find that the more cheap eve isk here is very good for you.

Posted by: rhino geciktirici krem on March 18, 2009 03:34 AM

thanks for you

Posted by: azdırıcı on April 1, 2009 07:08 AM

thanks for all

Posted by: doğal ürünler on May 3, 2009 04:42 PM

thank for admin very good

Posted by: mirc on May 20, 2009 03:35 PM

Thanks.

Posted by: mirc on May 21, 2009 06:03 PM

istanbul travestileri

Posted by: istanbul travestileri on June 2, 2009 06:53 AM

travesti

Posted by: travesti on June 2, 2009 06:55 AM

travesti

Posted by: travesti on June 2, 2009 06:55 AM

teyesiyle sikiş teyzem org vıdeosu seks izle üyeliksiz yavri erotik seksene amatör yerli e delice seks .net tül çorap fantazisi vi adult erkek çocuk olgu www. kudurduk .com erotik canlı şikiş buyuk amcuk seks vıdeo erotik movies domaltım sikiyor olgun karı serhoş çocu büyük penisli zenciler banyodaki sevişme kadınlar erotşk film yaşlı adam genç kızı s sex tahtada yaşlı kadın genç çocuğ bedava seks ve porno k zençi kız ve beyaz ada olgun kadınların sex ü am traşı filmi genç kızın yaşlı adaml karımı götten sikiyoru okulda şikşi 3 kız 1 erkek olgun kadınların sikiş türk enses video sex.pkk sıkış gamze özçelik sikiş vi sıcakerotizm 4 net kız çişini yapıyo film dünya sikiş video sikiş seksene teenstube yaşlı şişko kadını sex OLGUN SEVİŞME VİDEO işkenceli sikiş vidiol discoda barda gurp sex SOYUNARAK SICAK SİKİŞ acemi lezbiyen video ten çorap yabancı eski porno fil bosvaktim arkadanalma sexi kadın göğüsleri yenge teyze ile sikişl arab kadınları sikiş v bedava oral sikiş izle video pazar sex acemı kızın seksı gizli kamera seks süper yarak resimleri sıcak ertotik kızın manyak sikişi erkek kadının memesini dağ evi zenci götler video VVİDEO VAJİNA TIRAŞI dvd hayvanlı sikiş fil teyzesini siken ada trvneslihan http://www.seksene.net yaşlı kadının pornosu kadını domaltmak erotik gelin sex avukat halterci erotik kız annemle banyoda sikişt dolgun vücut damat gelin gerdek gec zorla kadın kendını sı sevişen kadınlar erkek şişko kadınların sex h zengi kadınla sex www garanti porno.com üvey annesiyle sex yap odada soyunan kadın i at yaragı okşayan kız cin iskencesi erotik i karı sikme vidoosu sek yapan orosbu ögretmen ders sikiş am yalama videoları ye SEXİ ÇIRILÇIPLAK KADIN çok büyük zenci yarrağ amcıkla sex sikiş sevişme erot seks olgun adult france amcık mıncıklama beyaz külotlu kızlar travestiler süper siki kadın götdeligi nefis yabancı pornolar sayunan seks video download erotik hika yaşlı kadınla sevişiyo çocuk çocuga sex video adam kıza dayıyo hamamda sex film karısını arkdaşına sık pelin sex etekaltına sikiş erotik çekimli filmler video izle 288 içine z 9 aylık hamile kadının teyze seks filmi izle sünnetsiz yarak videol pnis yalayan kızlar ikili sevişme vidyosu CARSAFLI 2 yaraklı götten seks zenç, şikişmeden zevk alan seks delileri güzel vücutlu bayanlar adam kıza kayıyo 89 video İNİLTİLİ SİKİ garantiseks video http://www,seksene,net üyeliksiz türk porno s çocuk sexi siki sokan adam erotik orosbu filmi mastırbaston tombul kadın sex erotik sex sikiş eroti pornoda zevk almak evli kadınlar olgun po götten büyük penis zevkle sikişen yaşlı k ablamla sex sikişi şiman sikişenler türk lezbiyen erotik p dar pantolonlar video sex filmi çekerken oda yağlı masj KOYLUSİKİSİ www.erkek penisi izle ERETİC FİLM İZLE www.ğötten sikme süper bacaklı kızların zenci seks hikayeleri arkadaşının annesinı s arkadan zorla sikiş iz yaslı adam ve kadın po sikiş şiiri ilk kez sikisi seksene sekx yaşlı kadını genç coçu teyze kızıyla sex genç çocuk çıtır kızla seksi kız genç çocukla sikiş yapan bir yakışı sikişen iki çişt yatak kucağına almış genç kı genç çocuğun çıtır kız çıtır kızın genç çocuk seksimi seksi kızın ge ıssız odada iki çift s çişini kadılar videosu realy porno film lezbiyen sex hikayesi kadın kadına porno yalatan kadınlar coban sıkısı erotık www.sikiş21 döl içen kadınlar sex gta seks video zenginşişko seks OLGUN KARI VE GENÇ ÇOC trkç seks film izle oral sex fotografları direk seksene izle sex ve porno videoları arab erkeklerinin porn elbiselerini çıkaran k üzerini çıkaran kadın buluzunu çıkaran kadın sütyenini çıkaran kand kilodunu çıkaran kadın üzerini çıkaran kız elbiselerini çıkaran k sütyenini çıkaran kız kadın boş bir odada üz hatunlar boş bir odada kadınlar boş bir odada kızlar boş bir evde gi karılar boş bir villad İKİ YAŞLI AMCA KIZI S banyoda kızlar kendi k olgun şiman kadın porn iri göğüslü sikiş amına sokup boşalıyor kadın vajinadan işeme karıamcığı tombul kadın zencı yarraklar arapkızları ile sevişe Bakire özünü acdi teen sex videoları acemikız sex Bakireni acdi seks yapan tombull kad lezbiyen cift vidoları siki kalkmis full sex 69 sarışın arkadan sikiş kendi kendine sikiş ya ütü yapan kadın kendi mutfakta çıplak kadın mutfakta cıbıldak kadı mutfakta çıplak kadın mutfakta cıbıldak kız ütücü kadın mutfak taş mutfakta çırılçıplak k sıkıldım porno film iz sıkıldım sex filmi izl AÇİK KADINLARİ İZLE buyuk am sex vi arap erkeklerinin porn zorla kendisini siktir aylık sikiş garnti seks.com sex forumları sıcak lezbiyen vidiola kanada pornosu www.kızlık bozma filim siman sikisi külotlu çoraplı kadınl dido gelin sikişi p mervenin amı sex zeci porno ücretsiz olgun kadın e kamıyon arkasinda siki rahibe erotikfilm izle yarakyemek canlı sikişi cok guzel kızlar sex i kızkardeşiyle video aşkıma porno seks vide soyunarak sex videolar çırılçıplak seks sikişen yaşlı olgun ka sibel kekili, izle 3d sex kız kilotu yalamak tecavüz sahnrleri yarak istermisin kız kızlık bozma sex filim sesli ve canlı seks ve paris hilton sikiş vid kaslı adam amı kıllı k kaslı adam amı kıllı k düzgün vucutlu erkek a kadın adama kıllı amın kız genç çocuğa kıllı hatun kıllı amını yakı türk kadının sikişi sex porno görüntüleri siktiren lezbiyenler annesiyle sex yapan kı sikini gösterdi amınaalanlar domaltmak sikiş erotiç piçtürs yeşil gözlü küçük kızl erotik porno at sek yapan kadın yaşlı kadınların porno am sokma pornosu vıdeo seks zencıler sünnetsiz porno vidoel seksene türbanlı eroti anadolulu teyzenin sik young sex milf video erotik sikişler videos bakkal çıragı ile seks fres teen porno izle kendi penisini yalayan AMI OLAN HEMYARRAĞI OL sex öğretmen pon video amateur gizli çekim po AMI OLAN HEM YARRAĞI O pussy seks sikişi yaşlı meme esmer büyük göt olgun şişmanlar penbe kultukta sikiş kadın elleme yapancı am motor karı izle www\'kudurdum\'sexcom kılsız vajina vidyosu kadın yarrah resmi acemi kızlar pono soloteens zevkim porno jigolo sikiş videosu porno izle dvd üvey annesını sıken cü amına koyma pornosu te BEKARET VİDİOSU filimden alıntı Anna N Anna Nicole filimden a silahı Anna Nicolenin Anna Nicole domalmış k yabancı filmde Anna Ni Anna Nicoleyi domaltmı masaya yatırmış Anna N domalmış Anna Nicole z Anna Nicole sex Anna Nicole sikiş Anna Nicole sıcak seks Anna Nicole sıcak sex Anna Nicole porno film Anna Nicole filmi Anna Nicole filmden er Anna Nicole pornosu Anna Nicole pornoları sex etekli kadın büyük sikli zenci seks olgun kadın kategorisi www.dantellıkülot.com amını yidim com bekaret bozma video iz FİLM İZLE SICAK LEZ olgun kadın aşk seks s rus video seks net www.izlbir.net masaya yatan ögretmen evli kadın erkek sex p kızlık bozma vidosu ne sexs arkek va kız penbe koltukta sikiş siyah külotlu corap po türkçe seslendirmeli e lezbiyenlerin sıcak gö Kravatıyla Sikisen Öğr şikiş yapan kızlkar porno seyret nefis altdan nasil ellediler zencigöt amcıık isle at üstünde sex yapanla evli çıvtler erotik seksi amını okşATMA VİDEOSU lezbıyenlerın seks gor lezbiyen anne videolar ne sikiş be SICAK BASTI VİDOLARI online kudurtan porno ihtiyar erotik seks sikiş koymak türbanlı soyunan kadın eens vıdeous sexpartisi izlet türk kızları soyunan kadın videosu cep telefonunda porno kadın kalçası sex am yarak sikiş sex sıc iki kızın sevişme vide travestiler izle asian porn girls movie sakso nerden yayıldı türbanlı kızların soyu olgun yaşli genç sikiş türkçe am yalama izle en azgın erotık porno fuk tukçe porno www.zenginporno.net lezbiyen kadın acık si kızı elleme videosu milf pornosu ilginc sikşler asyalı öğrenci sikiş doyasıya seks ve sikiş annesini siken çocukla cep video porno downlo çorablı seksi yaşlı kadın veya olgun rahibe fantezi porno büyükannesini sikiyor sikis adult net video kadın göt deliği olgun ve yaşlı kadınla türbanlı kızı sikme lise ögrencisi komşusu nylon çorap ve sex itlerle sıkısen kadınl teyze kızı erotık vıde kara ten am sex türkünlüporno en genç öğrenciler ve WWW BÜYÜK YARAKLI PORN en iyi yarağ yalayan k sikiş asyalı full dvd yaşlı kadın sex filmle travesti izmir sex ile orgazm olan kız sıcak evli kadınların sikişme videoları takı pornzab porno mini etekli erotik sik seks sıcak lezbiyen vi çocuk sex köleleri izl gay sikişi porno şişman çoraplı seksi amcıık izle soynan kadınlar erotik pornoz ile lezbiyen ye çadırda buyuk buğa sikiş kamerada soyunuyor erotik video izlemek i olgun kapalı sex olgun kadın am videosu büyük yaraklı sikiş vi faişe vıdoları soyunma kabini genç çocukla olgun kad ADULT31 SEKS annesini siken videola free download erotik s şişko erkeğin sevişme kankası kızı sikiyo yerli görüntüler erotik çoraplı video kız kardeşini siken ge arap kadilarla sex vid youtube lezbiyen sikiş acemi sikişme fuul sıkıs vıdeoları porno kocasiyla seks y free seks porno sakso filim duvar deliğinden amını kızsikiş.net seks videosu izle üye sokakata firikik SEKS SIKISME YALAMA VI teyzesiyle sx yapan ço kadın erkek sikiş yapı soyunankadınlar erotik sadece olgun kadınları sevişme ve sikişme vid zenci erkek japon kızl free seks pornofilm Göt deliği büyük olan seksi olgun kadın görü www,seksene,net porno masturbasyonsex sex denizi azdım kudurdum sex işeyen kadınlar pornos türk manita kızların intikamı erke erkek çocuk sex video annemle sekx kilolu olgun sikişi çok yaşlı kadınların p youtubeadult porno izl havyan sex MELİS BİRKAN SEX izlesene porno dvd takil net videolar sev +18 sıcak lezbiyen sik çiftlikte seks erotik lezbiyen evli kadınlar youtube amdan sikiş sex tube vıdolar EROTİK İHANET erkeklerle kadınların porno filim yukle yaşlı got delıgı cep telefonuna porno y azgın kadın videosu sekreterle ilgili erot online öğretmeni öğren www.kudurdum.comn youtube sevişme sex iz porno sikişmeler free sevişme filmleri yaşlı dede pornosu masajlı sexsı fılm bekaret bozma videosu siyah göt videosu sevişme sahneleri porn www.kadınların küçük c en büyük yarağ pornsı hottest blonde video

Posted by: dizi izle on June 12, 2009 04:03 PM

Post A Comment

advertise_liberally.gif