Freedom and Egoism

Lots of paens around to the late Milton Friedman, including here from Alex Tabarok who attributes to following to Friedman in Capitalism and Freedom:

President Kennedy said, "Ask not what your country can do for you - ask what you can do for your country."... Neither half of that statement expresses a relation between the citizen and his government that is worthy of the ideals of free men in a free society.

Tabarrok remarks "Damn right."

This seems like a straightforward misreading of Kennedy's statement. He didn't say "ask what you can do for your government" he said "ask what you can do for your country." Surely it doesn't follow from libertarianism -- a doctrine about the appropriate scope of state power -- that it's inappropriate for free men in free societies to act exclusively out of selfish intentions. One assumes, for example, that Friedman regarded his efforts to, say, destroy American public education or make heroin more widely available as things he was doing for his country rather than an extremely roundabout method of personally getting his hands on more heroin.

Closer to the context at hand, it seems exceedingly odd for one of the leading proponents of the volunteer military to object so stridently to patriotic appeals from government leaders -- America's recruits, obviously, get tangible compensation for their military service, but it seems pretty clear that the whole thing would be non-viable without the presence of what you might call a fairly large "patriotism externality" being in play.

Comments

Surely it doesn't follow from libertarianism -- a doctrine about the appropriate scope of state power -- that it's inappropriate for free men in free societies to act exclusively out of selfish intentions.

Call me naive, but among some of the libertarians I know, it's axiomatic that people do act exclusively out of selfish intentions. As to Friedman's hypothetical heroin habit, I think that it can be seen, in selfish terms, as a way of pushing back against intrusive laws in general, with the specific cases being immaterial. The fewer such laws, the lower the chance any will affect me.

Posted by: RSA on November 16, 2006 04:21 PM

Oh sure Matt - take a swing at Friedman when he can't fight back!

Cranky

Posted by: Cranky Observer on November 16, 2006 04:26 PM

If people act exclusively out of selfish reasons, there's no point in writing about it since there's no debate about ethics or morality. (Ah, reductionism!) There's only selfisness of one form or another. Why have a government which minimizes intrusiveness? So that some weak sonofabitch can get more than me? Not me. I want Strong Man Government with me on top! Any "argument" about reductionist principles seems comically extraneous. Hey, if it has to be that way, what difference does it make? Just go out and get what you want and the devil take the hindmost. Or the first guy. Or the three in the middle. What difference does it make?

Posted by: Jeffrey Davis on November 16, 2006 04:27 PM

Ayn Rand's followers actually do believe that there is a moral obligation to be selfish. (They think Kant was the most evil person who ever lived. Seriously.)

Maybe Tabarrok is an Objectivist?

Posted by: lemuel pitkin on November 16, 2006 04:28 PM

Is it that obvious he's misreading Kennedy? It's not like presidents are always scrupulous about the distinction between a nation and its government (cf. "Why do you hate America?"), and an entity that can "do" things "for you" sounds like a more coherent sort of agent than America in the abstract.

Posted by: Julian Sanchez on November 16, 2006 04:41 PM

Hate to break it to you guys, but Country and Government are pretty frequently seen as synonymous. Everybody who's ever protested a war has gotten the evil eye from plenty of god fearing folk who wonder aloud what the hell those god damn hippies have against America. Obviously people who are actually capable of nuance can distinguish the two, but its not always clear when they're being distinguished.

And I don't think I've ever heard a libertarian who was actually worth listening to argue that someone had a moral obligation to be selfish (note that I am deliberately excluding objectivists from the worth listening to camp). I personally just object to being told what my moral obligations are. Theres nothing wrong with being altruistic, I just think that it should be my choice as to when and where I express my altruism.
I have a pretty good feeling that if Kennedy had replaced country with "fellow human" or "fellow american", neither Milton or Alex would have had any problem with it.

Posted by: Travis on November 16, 2006 04:43 PM

Yeah, when the president of the US and A, and the leader of the government says we should ask what we can do for our country, is it unreasonable to assume he's talking about the government? Basically, he's saying, "ask not what I can do for you; as what you can do for me." Jerk.

Posted by: too many steves on November 16, 2006 04:58 PM

Well, I mean, it's not like this is a quotation from some painfully obscure speech or something -- you can read it yourselves here and see what you think. Obviously, Kennedy wasn't a libertarian and did, in fact, want to do things "for his country," in part through new federal programs (Medicare) and regulatory initiatives (the Civil Rights Act) but that portion of the speech is a rather vague exhortation for people to do things to combat poverty and disease and advance the cause of human freedom.

Posted by: Matthew Yglesias on November 16, 2006 05:16 PM

If you look at the full context of the speech, it is definitely a Cold War speech with a call towards some sort of voluntarism. This is, after all, the same guy that prided himself on being a Cold Warrior to the right of Eisenhower and the creator of the Peace Corps. Kennedy is not appealing to people to glorify the state, but to pursue abstract ends like the struggle against "tyranny, poverty, disease, and war itself." If you look at the very next statement after the famous line, it gives a sense of what he was driving at:

"My fellow citizens of the world: ask not what America will do for you, but what together we can do for the freedom of man."

It has nothing to do with the kinds of speeches that someone like Mussolini would give. Friedman is making a point with an ill chosen example.

Posted by: catfish on November 16, 2006 05:16 PM

Matt, since when do you have so many creeps and idiots for readers? You used to attract a reasonably interesting level of comment. But these pimply-faced basement-dwellers are well below your usual standards.

Posted by: JR on November 16, 2006 05:17 PM

Well I agree with Friedman's and Tabarrok's comments, but not their reasons. It would be better worded as "Ask not what the world can do for you, but what you can do for the world".

Posted by: Ginger Yellow on November 16, 2006 06:01 PM

This strikes me as strange quibbling.

"Ask not..." was clearly an exhortation to volunteerism at a particular time, and speaking of particular persuits. Attempting to distinguish between government and country in that particular context seems much like worrying over the gender of the person who just ran you over.

Friedman seems, in contrast, to be using the phrase to make a larger point about economic policy. Much in the same way I think it is fair to quote "heck of a job, Brownie" as a telling example of the Baby Bush administration policy choices in contexts outside of Katrina, I think it is fair to oppose a set of Kennedy policies by using a pull quote to start the discussion. Whether that is correct or not is not the question being asked.

Posted by: fishbane on November 16, 2006 06:36 PM

Hate to break it to you guys, but Country and Government are pretty frequently seen as synonymous. - Travis

Indeed. And that so-called libertarians would so easily misread Kennedy's statement in the indicated manner says a lot about the mindset of these people, nu? Scratch one of these so-called libertarians, and you'll find an authoritarian just under the surface.

Recently, the Rutgers alum magazine had an article on Friedman in which they indicated that some talk or something he gave in Chile was controversial. Of course, in an alum magazine profile one does not expect nor would it be appropriate to have a "warts and all" biography, but still -- they could have at least mentioned that it wasn't that Milton "Miracle of Chile" [and cf. Palast for what really saved Chile's economy] Friedman gave some academic talk in the place while Pinochet was in power ... it was that the students of him and his like minded colleagues, with the backing of Pinochet's dictatorial power, were forcibly implimenting Friedman's so-called "libertarian" economic ideals.

If people act in rational self-interest and they don't want a "free market economy" to the point where it takes a brutal dictatorship to install one by force, doesn't that mean it is not in people's self interest to have such an economy? Or that people do not actually act in terms of their rational self-interest in which case the very foundations of Friedman's theories, etc., are rotten?

The misreading of country for government is a confusion made by many so-called libertarians (would a real libertarian make this confusion?) that betrays authoritarianism.

And maybe now is not the time to speak against Milton Friedman, but why should we treat the hero of Pinochet's henchmen any differently than we would treat the hero of the henchmen of any other brutal dictator?

Posted by: DAS on November 16, 2006 07:03 PM

One assumes, for example, that Friedman regarded his efforts to, say, destroy American public education or make heroin more widely available as things he was doing for his country rather than an extremely roundabout method of personally getting his hands on more heroin.

On the other hand, a heroin habit would go a long way toward explaining his crazy-ass ideas.

Posted by: Tom Hilton on November 16, 2006 07:27 PM

And that so-called libertarians would so easily misread Kennedy's statement in the indicated manner says a lot about the mindset of these people, nu? Scratch one of these so-called libertarians, and you'll find an authoritarian just under the surface.

[... many lines of concern over Rutgers not criticizing Friedman for giving a speech in Pinochet's Chile]

Please name names. I'm one of those "so-called libertarians" who can legitimately quibble with Kennedy. I realize that the Glenn Reynolds of the world are giving us a bad brand name, but that we're all closet authoritarians is simply silly. Get to know a Radley Balko or a Nick Szabo before you come to such a glib conclusion. Or, heck, me. I know we won't agree on everything, but I'm not so arrogantly silly as you arrogantly suggest. I even, like, have an education and stuff, and don't want to enslave everyone into a Walmart company town. I hate that, and I've got the NYC expenses to prove it.

Posted by: fishbane on November 16, 2006 07:43 PM

yeah, Friedman tendentiously distorted Kennedy.

And if this had been the stupidest, most dishonest and malicious thing that had ever come out of Friedman's mouth, the world would be a lot better place right now.

Don't waste your time on this one, MY--there are many more substantive atrocities to document.

Posted by: kid bitzer on November 16, 2006 08:32 PM

A Few points:
Ted Sorensen wrote JFKs inaugural.
Friedman considered himself to be a classical liberal (i.e. Lockian) as opposed to a libertarian (not even the the same as Rand's objectivism)
Libertarians "free ride" on the natural human instinct for altruism.
Nice to see someone beat slate for the contrarian reaction to his death. If that is praiseworthy.

Posted by: Smile of Reason on November 16, 2006 09:36 PM

I think Friedman is reading Kennedy's phrase and his own principles correctly. "Your country" is not the same thing as "your government", but neither is it the same thing as justice, the right, or the whole universe of ends other than self-interest. Friedman would probably be quite skeptical of the idea of doing something for your country. Doing something for another person or doing something to promote human freedom in general, yes; but doing something for 'the nation' or 'country', no. Libertarianism, and indeed many other strands of liberalism involve not just a rejection of government promotion of collective goods, but indeed a skepticism about the reality of such collective goods or collective subjects. The Volk, the public thing, and the common good are phantoms. My guess is that Friedman would readily admit that there is such a territorial unit such as the country of the USA, but not such an entity that one can or should try to 'do things' for.

Kennedy's statement is a fundamentally republican notion which unalloyed libertarianism cannot accept.

Posted by: Jeremiah J. on November 16, 2006 10:19 PM

You know how not too long ago Al said that "conservatives think liberals are wrong, and liberals think conservatives are evil," and everybody jumped all over him? Well, here you have somebody, a liberal I would assume, calling Milton Friedman "malicious." Friedman would never say that about, say, Galbraith, JFK or any of his other political opponents. He'd say they were wrong.

Posted by: too many steves on November 16, 2006 11:17 PM

No, He would say they were not even right.

Posted by: fishbane on November 16, 2006 11:46 PM

Kennedy's people got rich not doing enough for the government.

Posted by: Linus on November 17, 2006 12:26 AM

Yglesias,

One suspects, in reading your comment, that you're looking for something, some piece you can hang your conservative social democratic criticism on to in the face of (to you) hagiography. So after all your perusing, you find Tabarrok's statement as a point of entry. Unfortunately, you not only uncharitably interpret Friedman, but you also misinterpret Kennedy as well. Kennedy was not simply saying, "Do good to your fellow country man." That much is explicit in the momentum, rhetoric and logic of his speech. Consider, for example, that this famous question is preceeded by appeals to nation states, republics, (implicitly) the Soviet Union and the United Nations to alleviate poverty, keep the peace, and cooperate. The entity these appeals are made in relation to are clearly the United States. It is a fundamental axiom of libertarianism that the government and the people are two different entities. It is not clear that Kennedy was referring to the latter and not the former.

Please find better arguments to hand your conservatism on. It's too precious to offer petty criticisms just to have something to say.

Posted by: Rue Des Quatre Vents on November 17, 2006 01:44 AM

OT -anyone else seen this (http://www.house.gov/apps/list/hearing/ca18_cardoza/bluedogsexposeunknownreport.html) from the Blue Dog coalition website? It's a treasury report that basically admits the real deficit is over $700 billion.

Posted by: Stewart Kelly on November 17, 2006 02:34 AM

'Ask not...' has taken on a meaning separate from whatever Kennedy was talking about. It's an icon, like 'I have a dream...', 'The only thing we have to fear...', 'Four scores and seven year ago...' and 'all men are create equal'.

Most of the time people don't even think what these things mean. The words just feel patriotic and that they deserve great reverence. They're chants of the American religion.

Posted by: miguel on November 17, 2006 03:12 AM

Kennedy walked the walk on doing for his country. He was badly wouned in WWII and was acutely aware to the point anticipating that he might be assasinated. It's impossible that he ever thought to try and cleave the notions of country/nation and government. That philosophical field had been shunted far aside during his era. An era which will probably be seen as the apogee of the nation/state.

The American response to the existential threats of the Axis and then Soviet Russia made libertarianism a quaint refuge for intellectuals. Their time came just after Kennedy's death as the existentail threat began to fade away.

Posted by: rapier on November 17, 2006 05:27 AM

I'm one of those "so-called libertarians" who can legitimately quibble with Kennedy. I realize that the Glenn Reynolds of the world are giving us a bad brand name, but that we're all closet authoritarians is simply silly.

I think it makes quite a bit of sense that those attracted to libertarianism is those who have the most respect (or fear) for the coercive power of government. At least, if you're not somebody who thinks government has much coercive power, you're certainly not going to be attracted to the libertarian philosophy.

This is the same basic dynamic which explains why those attracted to socialism are often personally stingy (they fear that selfishness works against the collective needs of a society) and why those attracted to militant nationalism are often personally cowardly (they fear those who want to destroy them and their country).

Posted by: neil on November 17, 2006 08:47 AM

The libertairains and Randists prefer to talk in terms of "government" rather than "country" as a matter of framing: "goverment" can be spun as "other", but "country" is us.

Posted by: rea on November 17, 2006 08:54 AM

Who cares whether he was eliding the distinction between "government" and "country"? Or whether Kennedy intended one? The point is, he was being an idiot. If, in the era of Friedman's intellectual formative years, we lacked glaring examples of what nations look like whose citizens lack any impulse to "do for your country", we are now swimmin' in 'em. They look like Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iraq, Somalia...

Posted by: brooksfoe on November 17, 2006 09:11 AM

neil, I like your analysis except for socialists. I don't think they fear selfishness, I have socialist tendencies and I'm anything but stingy, to the point of my own detriment. I think they fear the coercive power of wealth.

Posted by: miguel on November 17, 2006 09:29 AM

I strongly suspect that, however famous the line may be, that it was included in the speech because it's rhetorically pretty. Like Lincoln's memorable but vague triad "of the people, for the people, and by the people".

Kennedy's program of selfless volunteers, The Peace Corps, was aimed at other countries. Beyond that, Kennedy didn't have any Big Ideas about selflessness, and I doubt he'd have been crushed if The Peace Corps idea had been stillborn in Congress. It was just a campaign notion and rhetorical trope.

Posted by: Jeffrey Davis on November 17, 2006 10:06 AM

Well, I didn't say everybody, just 'often.' And I do think that this is the case, along with its converse (those who believe that the welfare state is unnecessary have personal faith in the power of private charity, or if you prefer, fear that people will cheat the government where they wouldn't cheat charity).

For evidence I would point out that the Republican party always seems to have more than enough volunteer labor while the Democratic party doesn't even seem to get enough volunteers to be able to use the ones it does get. I believe this tendency also holds in other countries' political systems. Maybe this is just because liberals are more likely to be people who go to work though.

Posted by: neil on November 17, 2006 10:18 AM

I'm one of those "so-called libertarians" who can legitimately quibble with Kennedy. - fishbane

Heck ... I can find plenty about which to quibble with Kennedy, and I'm in no way a libertarian. Perhaps I needed to make myself more clear, but at some point I did clarify that I wasn't referring to real libertarians -- and I suspect you are a real libertarian -- but was indeed referring to the Glenn Reynolds types. And heck -- contrary to the praise being sung of Friedman, we he really that much of a defender of "liberty"? He didn't seem to shed any tears for the victims of Pinochet and he wanted the whites in then Rhodesia to have the "liberty" to keep their large plantations but thought nothing of the rights of the majority in that country to have a meaningful chance at even pursuing happiness. Unless Friedman is being praised for defending a form of "liberty" -- the liberty of the seguineurial class to do what they want with their property, including humans -- which should have disappeared from this country when the North frickin' won the civil war -- I fail to see how he really defended liberty.

He was brilliant, true. And I suspect some of his stuff on the money supply per-se was very important to our economic well-being ... but to cast him as this super-hero defender of liberty is to overstate the case for Friedman, who had warts like all of us.

Posted by: DAS on November 17, 2006 10:50 AM

I think that the problem with libertarianism is, to paraphrase mike meyers, what emPHASis on which syllABle. I suspect that there are those who emphasize either the LIBERT[Y] aspects or the ARIANISM part :-) Freedom vs. doctrinal adherence (adhere to the top dog till you get your chance).

Another way of putting it is what do you think freedom is and how is it expressed? Is freedom an inherent part of the human condition (freedom for all) or does freedom really just mean freedom to exercise power.

Posted by: blank_stare on November 17, 2006 01:30 PM

I think Howard Roark said, "I will never live for another man nor ask another to live for me."

I expect that's pretty much what Milton and Alex meant.

Posted by: th on November 19, 2006 10:32 PM

I think what Friedman was getting at was that countries - which includes but are not limited to their governments - should not be regarded as ends themselves, but only as means of improving the well-being of individuals. As Matt Y. points out, this is indeed an argument against patriotism. However, Matt Y. proceeds to set up a false choice between egoism and patriotism. Friedman would probably say that he advocates the things he does neither for his own narrow benefit or for the sake of his country, but rather for the sake of individuals harmed by the policies he opposes, and what he hopes to reap is the indirect (but nonetheless often tangible) benefits of living among freer people.

I think Friedman may have pulled the quote from its specific context in the speech because it was a pithy way of pointing out the assumptions about the relationship between the individual, government, and country and getting people to ask questions about their validity more so that because of a specific objection to Kennedy's speech.

DAS,

The provision of economic advice for oppressive governments raises the same set of questions as sanctioning them does, and they're not simple ones. In oppressive regimes, the ruling elite makes sure to take care of its own economic well-being, so the poor and politically disenfranchised are going to suffer the most from bad economic policy. Outside of cases where you're looking to degrade the military capabilities of an agressor, the operative question is how much do you expect the regime to reform in response to the pressure and if offsets the damage done by the economic restrictions.

Land redistribution in post-colonial situations actually has frequently been disasterous for agricultural output. So the question comes down to how much future economic growth is revising a distribution that resulted from unjust conditions in the past worth? You can guess that Friedman, like many libertarians, would lean towards future growth, but there are arguments both ways that are based on a sincere interest in improving the well-being of those countries' citizens.

Posted by: MattXIV on November 20, 2006 04:36 PM

harbiarkadas.com
harbiarkadas.net
harbiarkadas.org
itirafet.org
ebedava.net
elektronikmarket.net
ameribress.com
clitoriacream.net
superspenisbuyutucu.com
megabress.com
rednightperformans.com
performansartirici.com
penisplus.tv
penispluspenisbuyutucu.com
penispluspenisbuyutucu.net
cinselmerkez.com
aseks.net
erotikcamasirlar.com
vajinatr.com
bakirevajina.com
cinselkozmetik.com
kozmetikmedikel.com
eturknet.com
tecavuz.net
yutuvideo.com
ponotubesex.com
laraperuk.com
sackanagimerkezi.com
peruksa.com
perukmarket.com
aseks.com
aloveshop.com
erotikgiyim.com
geciktiricispreyler.com
geciktiricihap.com
geciktiriciler.com
azdirici.com
bayanuyarici.com
fntazialemi.com
fantaziservisi.om
cinselmazemeler.com
cinselfantaziurunleri.com
erotikdakikalar.com
erotikmarketiniz.com
seksmarketiniz.com
sekshatlari.com
erotikdergiler.com
erotikderginiz.com
penisbuyutucuviprx.com
penisbuyutucuvigrx.com
penisbuyutuculer.com
vigrxpenisbuyutucu.com
sismebebekler.com
sismebebekshop.com
yemekeviniz.com
sanalmarketiniz.com
elektronikmarket.net
ebedava.net
kontortr.com
elaydin23.com
turkcellkontorcu.com
aveakontoral.com
vodafonekontoral.com
toptankontorcu.com
cinselkozmetik.com
bayanpartnerler.com
erkekpartnerler.com
kizarkadaslar.com
yonjaarkadas.com
siberalem-siberalem.com
sexpartnerler.com
sekspartnerler.com
erotikpartnerler.com
gencyuz.com
erkekarkadaslar.com
bayanarkadaslar.com
yemekeviniz.com
sanalmarketiniz.com
baskahaber.com
medikalkozmetik.net
kozmetikmedikal.com
zayiflamavediyet.net
zayiflamahapii.com
zayiflamabandii.com
kilovertr.com
zayiflamatr.net
diyettr.com
toksinbandi.net
botoxtr.com
botokstr.com
selulittedavii.com
selulitgiderici.net
selulitkremii.com
catlaktedavisii.com
catlakgiderici.net
catlakkremii.com

Posted by: sexshop on November 5, 2008 05:30 AM

asyalı sıcak izle harika amlar yaşlı kadın amcığı zenci hamilel at çıplak kampları izle hayvalnı sex azdırıcı sikiş izle banyoda sikişme videol atla sikişenkad zoo sex duna sex hayvanli sex youtube büyük yaraklı kanlı amcık koca yaraklı kızı iki erkek öpüyo v istanbullugaylar teen seksi kadınlar vi banyoda traş videosu olgunsex soyunan avratlar en güzel amcuk videola üvey oğlunun annesiyle çocuklara yalayan lezb garanti sexs serabın seks resim sikişm1 bekaretinin bozulmasın on sekızlık gaylar adult manita www.turkıshporno.org 89 öğretmen öğrenci se sarışın lezbiyen sikiş sarhoş kadın sikiş vid git gel sikiş flimleri kadın çocuk sex şikişin köleleri karım yarak yemek isti istekli hırçın sikişle türk üvey anne sikiş i sikişen am göt sınıfta ögretmenlerle zorla siktiriyor KAPIYA GELEN SİKİYOR kıllı götlü kız küçük gögüslülerin h yaşlı kadın film izle en azgın erotik sikişl porno kırmızı kilot amcalar.süper sikiş poposex naylon çorap giyerek s iki çocuk sevişiyor sarışin kız sik kız il defa sikişiyor yaşlıkadın çocukla sik sıcak lezbiyen video i sex dergilerin resimle naylon çorap giyerek s olgun kadınların sek banyoda soyun sik sünnetsiz penisin siki seksı kadınlar ve gogu evli bayan videoları kız öğrencisini sikiyo spor salonlarında sex youtube zenci kadın me yarağın üzerine oturm nefis sikiş yapan kızl kadınların kırmızı kil gizli sikişmek şişman kadınlar sıcak comics erotik kadın kendini zorla si erotic4e.com san andreas da karı si seks kadını giydir doyasıya seks video ca azgın olgun kadınların popo sex film ikinci el sikişen kadı evli kısa erotik video grupça 1 kadını sikmek http.www.seksene.net/v iki sikli adam video seks izle 18 lez sıcak hikayeler filmizle yaşlı sex bilardoda sikişenler bayanpartner.com azmış olgun kadınların http.//www.seksene.net koca yarak şikiş ful i erotik sexvideoları www.AMTVsex.com yeşilçam lezbiyen gall eski kız arkadaşına ar zevkmania kapatılmış iki kadini sikisi full erotık büyük göğüslü kadın ya kaplı yerde sex erotık sıkkış yapanlar evli kadınlar video yaşlı erkek ile yaşlı büyük insan yaragı kalçaya vurarak sikme gizli kamera sıcak sıcakerotizm.net kudurum kadınlar SEKSENE NMET asyalı porna film lezbiyenler toplu sex karım hamile son günle amcamla yengemin sex v ADAM SİKİŞİYOR DUVARIN çalkala pornu sarışın güzel fahişele dolgun kadın seksi manken sikiş izle sıcaksex filmler izle lise mini etek sex por kizlar birbirine sokuy tül çoraplı pornolar seks porno lezbiyen iz sarışın çıtır kırmı ki azgın olgun video sınıfta lesbiyen önce uzun süre sevişip sıcak kadınlar sexs kadının amına sokma domalan ve boşalan senci kız ve am arkadaşının annesini evli kadın sex filmi wwworosbu yaşlı adamla genç kız tecavüze uğrayan kadın türbanlıyı s yerde seksporno azgın olgun kadın siki www.erotikkızlar kadın yaşlı olgun kadın hika osman la sikiş seksene net erkek sikm porno star pozları dulsikiş erkek kendini sikitir okulda hoca ile sikiş sıcak video olgun kadı sekizlik sevişen kız kadı inliyor am videoları fakeler seks yaragımı amına sokup b orosbu telefonu evli kadın sexi sexte ahh ohh sişman kadın sexsi fot www turbanlı hatunlar annesini çocuğu sikiyo amına kocaman alet sok komşusuyla çıplak sevi gızlı cekım soyunan adamın ağzına işeyen k annesini sikerken hediyi sikmek vkipedi de sikiş izle büyükinsan yarağı erotik sevişme videola sulandıran sex salatalıklı seks cüceyle zenci sikiş yarak seven karı kocaman yarak kızın kı sikiş itme videoları banyoda am traşı izle arkadaşının annesiyle denizde öpüşme videola lezbiyenler amlarına s lucky sick student mil sex ve göğüsler şişman kadınlar siki olgun kadin sevişme fi SARIŞIN LEZBİYEN AMLAR kocasını aldatan kadın adam işe gidiyor kadın orosbu karılarla seks büyüksik adult kurt sikiş erotizm vidio çorap nylon porno ünlü popo firikikler am popo videoları izle zenci pornpsu büyük pe serabı siken erkek por amsikiş videosu zle emma watson seks üvey anne sikiş vide petek firikikleri öğretmen kızı acımadan zenci yarakları neden domalma+18 erotizm video izle sexsi firikikler dvd seks filmi izle kız öğretmeniyle sex y naylon çoraplı seks iz kızın vajinasını elley kırmızı kilot izlesene erotık yarrak www.sicakkadinlar.com çılgınca sevişiyorlar amı kalkan kadınlar kapalı kadın sevişiyor şişman kadın götü nuri alço kız sikme olgun seksi kadınlar v sıcak sekişme orosbular sikme penis vjinayı sikişmes ağza işiyen kadın yasli olgun kadinlarin getada kız sikme şifre yaşlı ve olgun kadınla amyala net amsikiş pornosu kadını kucağında hopla zencı seven sarışınlar gta san andreas de kız zenci polis sikişiyor ru erotik www.filmizle.org porno kudurdum sex vıdo sex kızları giydir kadını götten sikiyorl etek hizmetçi video hamamda japon kızlar m sikişmek isteyen kızla saksafonçeken kadınla şişmanlarla sikiş barda toplu sex videol sarışın bonyoda amcık yarak sikişifilm annesiyle sevişen adam kuvvetin içinde zorla seksi derili lezbiyenl türkce erotic sikiş vi seksı kadın sıkışlerı yaşlı ve olgun kadınla sex filmi izle lezbiyenporno sikişme porn garanti s sarhoşken anal sex ya tecrübeli kadınla sex olgun porno videoları olgun lezbıyen kadın s yoldaki fahişeler ,sik komşusuna zorla sikiş eve gelen özel öğretme yaslı tecrübeli şikişi erotik güreş hikayeler canl ısex fuckhorse sıcak sek video izlesene.net olgun kad anne seks izle olgun kadın küçük erke izlesene.net olgun kad gta san andreas kadın free gaylar evde sexvideoları mini etekli kızı sikti sikiş cezaları video olgun sevişme kadının amına sopa gir lavubada seks youtube zorla sikiş vi yaşlı kadın kendini ge sus sikerim video ovguide porno siteleri adama 31 çeken kadın siki böyuk adam azgın kadınlerın sex f kolejli seks izle kadını götten sikiyorl sarışın kız kocaman ad coklu gurup izle teen seksi kadınlar vi atlı sikiş erotik jopon sex e hazırmısın kız DOLGUN VÜCUTLU KADIN P lezbiyenlerim. com at kızı sikerken gta da kız sikme büyük zenci yarakları yaşlı kadınlarla sex tender teen sek KADIN SICAK EROTİZM İZ amına parmağını sokan olgun ve güzel kadınla erotik kadınlar sikişe amina girdim video KARISIN ARKADAS ILE sarhos seks video seks avratlar mini etekli öğretmen s iyi kadın sex hatun amını poro filım seksizle.gentr çıldırtan soyunan kız kanlı am vidosu hatun sıcak hastanede sikiş izle deri kanepede sikiş iyi amcuk sesli erotık kürtpornosu video yarak porno gta san andreas adam s çiftlikte sevişme vide OLGUN KADIN SİKŞİ adam kıza arkadan dayı 69sex. net am görüntüsü serabın pornosu yarakresimleri genç çocuk olgun kadın altmış dokuz yapanlar kadınların poposu sex erkek sokuyor kadın ça adamların ve kadınları en güzel oral seks vid kalkmış amlar sikiyor kadını götten ablamın götünü yedim açık erotik film izle iki çocuk sikişiyor iki lezbiyen bir erkek lezbiyenler sevişiyor 3d yaslı kadın sıkme kız yurdunda sex kız yurdunda sikiş komşu seks videoları erkek kardeş ile kız k amını okşuyo kız www.sendezevkal.com zencı poposu pornosu ı sıcak lez izle sıcak lezbiyen video k orosbu sohbet gölşen pornoları büyük geniş beyaz yara ateşli kadınlar bekliy kilolu sikişvideosu olgun kadın amcıgı türk kadın sek jigolo masaj yaparak seks vid kapalı orosbular balonnla sikiş izle en büyük yarak ve seks seksene lez izle sexsi kıçlar balon sikiş izle kız çişiniyapıyor mini etekli kızlar sev sikişme vikipedi izle büyük vajinalı sikiş erotizmin sex öğretmenini siken çocu beuatiful sex films kadın banyoda kadın deliyi sikiş sex ORUSPULAR VİDEOSU sexi lezbiyen sıcak komşusuna tecavüz sex çocuk olgun ögretmen s rezil sikiş hatun sikmeler 89 sik seven kadın genç aşıklar sert siki 11 yaşındaki kız porno önce temizlik yapıyor sünetsiz yarak penisim videoları sünnetsiz yarrak lar deneyimli kadınlar yarrağı amın üstünde g ayakabı sikiş ponpon kız sikiyorlar izle sıcak.com kızın amına girip çıkm güzel vajin izle www.seks porno.com seslierotik bir erkek 5 kadın ayak www.trv.neslihan yerli am videoları domalan çıtırlar olgun sevişme izle olgun sevişme izle takside seks evde sekx video izle kudurdum sex erotık amcanın kadın sikişi seks yapan ünlüler izl izle 18 seks yapan yenge kız meslek porno vidyo gelinlikle sikişme vid zenciçılgın popo teyzem18 döve döve sikiyor büyük am görüntüsü sexi çıplak kadın iç g erootik poorno seksi kadının sikişi atların penisini yalay bornozlu kadın pornosu 2 kardeş sikişiyor kudurdu bu kız ladyboy long film babek karma grup sikiş üvey annesiyle sikişyo yerli am sikme videosu sıcak lez videoları fu banyoda göğüsler türk subyan seks büyük.yarağım zorla atesli erotık vı kız okşatıyor video öğretmen öğrenci sınıf sarışın lezbiyen porno pornolar izle sikilengötler kız ile çocuk sikişiyo sex fotoğraf ve viğdeo telefon için esmer kad hahise sez türbanlıemo kardeşiyle sex yapanla büyük yaraklı zenci vi www.sicakerotizm3.com sulu sıcak amlar zenci kız ankara youtube hastanede sevi büyük sik videoları hayvancasex mini etek kadinlar sex düğümden sonra sikişen homemade adult sex www seksi erotiski izl kadının amı adaMIN yar yaşlı kadın jigolo por nefis amsikiş sıcak seks erotık ah yenge ah yenge bakireadası kadın erkek seks vide açık seksizle azmış kadın hikayeleri adamla kadın sikişiyor yaşlı kadın seks izle 16 yas kürt kızın amı müthiş sokuyor sekx kölyü porna şirkette sevişme video hizmetçi soymaca boşalan kızlar yarak seven kadın hika kanlı seks ammına sokım çıplaklar kampı EROTİK zevkten ölen adam kız kulesinde sex tül çorap sikiş çok kudurdum amını parmaklıyan kızl SEX SEVİŞME YEŞİLÇAM mini etekte sex türbanlı arap kadın vi garanti sexs video sahnın pornoları travesti sikişleri yaşlı genç sikiş hikay başkasıyla sikişen kad madonnayı sikiyorlar cıplakkamp yeni 69sex amdan sokuş resimleri wwwablamcom.tr olgun kadın seks porno memeleriyle sekse dave popo sikiş gılı frıkıkler yaşılı kadı sex izle

Posted by: Porno on June 5, 2009 02:03 PM

Post A Comment

advertise_liberally.gif