Hire and Fire

This is a touchy issue so I'll tread lightly. On occasion I substitute for a California school district in a city with a population of about 140k (53%white, 14.5% black, 33% Hispanic). The public school student population does not match the overall demographic. I'm guessing public schools are about (50% Hispanic & 47% Black).

All the public schools facilities are fairly clean and modern. Most teachers and administrators seem competent and dedicated.

The problem with the schools are not the teachers or the facilities or the "computers" or lack thereof. The problems stems with the students and, by extension, their parents.

It's as simple as that and I'll leave it to others to fill in the blanks.

There's also another dynamic at work here. Teachers are underpaid in many cases with regard to ther skill setg, but the difference is made up for in extremely good benefits with regard to most other professions out there. Thus, health insurance, retirement benefits, and job security are better in education than most other jobs. You can try to eliminate these things, but you'll rapidly find a decrease in the number of qualified applicants unless you raise salaries to compensate. This requires raising taxes and all sorts of other free things that people often dislike. Jobs and Kaus are looking for a free lunch, which any school administrator can tell you isn't free in the way one would think.

Matt,

There is some research supporting the idea that there is a pool of talented young teachers, but existing contracts present big barriers to entry:

http://www.tntp.org/ourresearch/unintendedconsequences.html:
Unintended Consequences: The Case for Reforming the Staffing Rules of Urban Teachers Union Contracts focuses on the impact of “voluntary transfer” and “excessed teacher” staffing rules found in the collective bargaining agreements of urban school districts.

“Voluntary transfers” are incumbent teachers with seniority rights who want to move between schools, while “excessed teachers” are those whose positions are cut from their school, often due to enrollment or budget changes.

Through a study of five major urban districts, the report demonstrates how “voluntary transfer” and “excessed” teacher rules result in systems that hire too late to secure the most talented teacher applicants, bump valuable teachers, and require schools to hire poorly matched or—worse—poorly performing teachers.

An Addendum in case anyone gets the wrong idea.

This is not a racial issue - far from it. I suppose the better term would be "cultural". And it's not even the majority of students that contribute to the problems but just enough to degrade the system as a whole.

Just another in a long line of capitalists who bash unions. Is Apple unionized?

In NY the wealthiest school districts spend about $16,000 per student, the poorest about $8,000. If you look at spending in places in the south you will find numbers under $3000. If people want better schools spend the money. This means not only adequate salaries, but supplies and even support services for families that are on the brink of disaster. How is a school supposed to teach when a kid lives in a stressed home environment? Schools see the kids for 6 hours a day for half the year. Who molds them the other 7/8 of the time?

Let's not expect schools to solve the problems of society.

Actually, the REAL action is in finding funding to pay people enough so that highly qualified people would rather teach in the primary/secondary market instead of going into the corporate world or into post-secondary academic institutions, where the pay is marginally better (for those without PhDs), but the working conditions are much, much better (i.e. fewer angry parents to deal with, more time to teach and less time spent "babysitting" the students, almost nonexistent discipline problems to handle, etc.)

If you want to pay teachers as minimally as they get paid now, you're going to have to deal with the teachers you can get for that pay. High quality people have a strong incentive to move to Community College positions at the very least, rather than hang around teaching in most High Schools and Middle Schools.

If you just increase the standards for certification you're going to end up with FEWER people overall in the system looking for jobs. That might push salaries upward IF schools followed traditional economic models. But they don't - they're funded by the goodwill of the taxpayers, not by the individual students who attend. So instead, the schools will make do with the money they have and increase the per student ratio for the teachers still in the building. Giving those teachers an EVEN STRONGER incentive to escape into a different job market - like Community Colleges or corporate training if they want to stick with teaching, or any other job at all if the experience has burned them out to the point where they don't even want to be in a classroom anymore.

This is not an argument against pressing for stronger certification, but know what that leads to - higher taxes and better paid teachers OR a school system that is even more broken that the one that we have now. I'm in favor of both of these things myself, but those who are usually in the camp pushing for "more responsibility" often neglect the responsibility of the taxpayers to fund the system so that it works.

I suppose I would expect that holding everything else constant, at the margin not being able to fire poor teachers would have a significant impact. And the sort of statements that only if something else changes then should we consider making it easier to fire poor teachers is the sort of bien-pensant liberal-leaning, ignoring-the-influence-at-the-margin, waffle which one doesn't expect from this site. I expect your posts to be more insufferable!

Uncle Benny: instead of leaving it to others to fill in the blanks and saying that we shouldn't get the wrong idea, can you just spell out more precisely what is wrong with the school children.

Just another in a long line of capitalists who bash unions. Is Apple unionized?

You might try looking up Steve Jobs' campaign contributions over the years. He's donated hundreds of thousands of dollars to the Democrats. He's not exactly a shill for big business.

Software engineers have a saying:
under every patch, there is a bullethole.

The unions are important to some teachers because some small percentage of administrators, superintendents, and school boards are high-handed, unfair, venal, are zealots, or have other reasons to abuse the teaching staff. And try to do so. And the union stands up for them.
That's how the schools got unionized in the first place.

It's my impression that in good schools, the union is often an obstruction, but never an insurmountable one. Everyone sighs and deals with it.

American public education is a failure but Iraq is a success?

What color glasses do you have to wear to see that?

Must be bifocals.

The federal government spends twice as much per year on Iraq as it does on K-12 education...maybe our schools deserve a surge.

"Uncle Benny: instead of leaving it to others to fill in the blanks and saying that we shouldn't get the wrong idea, can you just spell out more precisely what is wrong with the school children."

Complete lack of discipline. No appreciation of education. No respect for the teachers. They're at school not to learn but to pass time until the last bell of the day rings.

And this is not just kids being kids - It's far worse and it's actually very sad to experience first hand.

I said its a cultural issue but perhaps "class" would be even more accurate. Kids who show no signs of being serious about their education should immediately be separated from the rest of the population. Teachers spend WAY to much time disciplining instead of teaching.

The last season of The Wire actually touched on some of these issues. Believe me, there was no exaggeration in those classroom scenes.

otto:Being someone who reads..and is hit over the head with this stuff on a routine basis, it's usually a couple of things depending on the person.

#1. It's the TV/Video Games/Movies/Internet, whatever

#2. It's the poverty

#3. It's a lack of concern from the parents

OR a mix of all of the above.

If you ask me, as someone who is in the said generation (although at the older fringes), it's that our society has turned education from a worthwhile pursuit in and of itself, to the means to an end, the end being of course the amassing of material goods.

Why anyone, looking over the state of American education would imagine that educational administrators would either be able to distinguish "good" teachers (or "good" teaching) from "bad", or would care to make the distinction, escapes me.

Did no one watch The Wire?

You might as well assert that nothing will improve in education until the teachers are able to fire incompetent principals.

Clearly the question is: would President Lib Hitler Hillary be the kind of bitch that lets schools fire bad teachers (even if she isn't a bitch for hiking gas taxes because everyone knows we need to hike gas taxes rather than pay off the debt and sell energy independence bonds and obviously because it's like totally sexist to call her a bitch [except when it's not]).

Since SES does a massively better job predicting student performance than anything you can say about schools, and since the quality of the schools is usually a direct function of the SES of the neighborhood is serves, the idea that we could make failing American schools better by simply being able to fire teachers and break the union is beyond absurd.

If you don't deal with the underlying poverty and all its concomittants (crime, despair, poor housing, bad healthcare, bad neo-natal treatment, weak daycare and kindegarten, teenagers working 40 hours a week while attending school), then "school choice" and other educational reforms are simply masturbatory fantasies.

Since everybody went to school everybody's got an opinion, including me: In the long run schools are pretty much as good as the parents want them to be. If the parents, whether PhDs or immigrants that hardly speak English, push the kids, the district will attract good teachers, parents will raise hell about bad teachers, and the test scores will go up. Positive feedback loop. And it works in the other direction too. Money helps, but it's not the main thing (look at all the Nobel prize winning scientists from ordinary NYC schools and City College back in the 1930s and 1940s).

And since half the time education issues are really about race, I give you this:

http://www.eastbayexpress.com/2003-05-21/news/rich-black-flunking/1

I never got all this huge anger at teachers' unions compared to all of the other reasons our schools are failing. It seems like the CW repeated in places like The Economist is that everything is the teachers' unions fault. You never see the critics like Mickey Kaus want to go into teaching. Why? It probably pays more - at least relative to effort and stress levels - to be a blogger with no actual ideas taking up room on the Slate site. Who would really want to go to school, get a master's, get certified, have to babysit kids all day who can't find Ohio on a map and then get paid like shit?

I think I have some idea of what Uncle Bunny is getting at. I spent most of childhood in what was actually considered a decent school system with large majority of white students. However, excluding a small minority of the students (many of them the children of immigrants), most of the kids did not really seem to care or were motivated. A lot of the best K-8 teachers simply gave up and didn't know how to control the kids anymore. I then went to a respected New England prep school with a higher minority population, percentage-wise, and the experience was a lot better. The kids were actually motivated, curious and did work. The teachers could spend their time teaching instead of worrying about the types of trenchcoat mafia kids that had been under psychriatic evaluation in the public system. The school also had tons of resources; meanwhile in my hometown all of the old, retired voters would vote down any attempt to increase funding for the schools. I believe a budget cut just passed that cut away a bunch of AP classes (thus making it harder for students to get into college), along with funding for firefighters, police and roads. Anytime a tax increase is propsed for something good, even conservative, Republican-leaning parents are for it because it raises the property values of their house by improving the local schools, but the old people don't care.

The difference was that in one setting it was ok to be smart, but in another it wasn't. Across our country too many parents care more about the high school football team than about how up-to-date the math and history books are. If anti-intellectualism is taught at home as a positive trait, what are parents supposed to do?

My guess is that it has something to do with the idea of being trapped. Most of the people in my public school system had the same teachers their parents had. Most were townies and knew they would always be townies. They felt trapped. If you're from a poor black or Latino family in East LA, not only do you feel trapped in your own community, but you feel unwanted outside of your community due to the racism that is still with us today. Try being a black guy walking around Orange County. The LAPD is insane while the gangs are cruel. Kids in gang-inflicted areas in the likes of Compton suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder at levels associated with survivors of civil wars. How are kids supposed to learn under such conditions? What teacher would want to work there making crap pay?

> That's how the schools got unionized
> in the first place.

Most of the US big city school districts became unionized around 1932, when the the teachers worked for 12-18 months without pay, then were paid with School District scrip that the School Districts failed to redeem. That experience is still remembered by quite a few out there.

Cranky

> finding funding to pay people enough so that
> highly qualified people would rather teach
> in the primary/secondary market instead of
> going into the corporate world or into
> post-secondary academic institutions

For "people" read "women". All the way into the early 1980s it was common to find women with, e.g., Masters' and PhDs in math or chemistry or history teaching elementary school because after graduation they couldn't be hired for any corporate job other than secretary. This pool is now exhausted; many of those candidates never wanted to teach anyway and those that might consider it would require renumeration _and respect_ equal to what they can get in the corporate market.

Just another take on the "free lunch" theory.

Cranky

Too much "accountability" without enough support is useless. It's good Obama ties it to better pay. Frankly it seems like the rights obsession with "teacher accountability" is just a desire to see people punished for the problem.

Anyway, you can, obviously, have bad principles too.

In our capitalist economy where CEOs get immense separation packages for doing a lousy job, I'm amazed that some think that public education can be improved by eliminating teachers' unions, tenure, benefits and job security. These people don't mention anything that might compensate for making the job of public school teacher even less attractive than it is. They seem to think that some "fairy dust" will make everything better. Perhaps, as I have seen with nurses, they think that teachers should be "above" mere money and should be willing
to work for zip.

This is nuts.

I usually say to these folks - OK, let's just abolish public education entirely, RIGHT NOW. They usually think that I am an extremist looney - as if they aren't extreme.

Last summer I had just such an exchange. I was told that public school teachers aren't "productive" and that they have "too much time off" and "too much job security" and excessive benefits. When I offered my counter-challenge, my (slightly choleric) interlocutor accused me of being "extreme".
During all of this, his wife was sitting nearby and saying nothing.

The next day I found out that she had just retired from a local school district with a large pension. Too bad. If I had only known, I would have asked her husband

"Just how much of her ill-gotten gains should she have to give back?"

His answer might have been enightening.

> Anyway, you can, obviously, have bad
> principles too.

And IMHO the Radical Right does have bad priciples. But for purposes of this discussion we might want to consider that "The princpal is your pal."

Cranky

Actually, the REAL action is in finding funding to pay people enough so that highly qualified people would rather teach in the primary/secondary market instead of going into the corporate world or into post-secondary academic institutions, where the pay is marginally better (for those without PhDs), but the working conditions are much, much better (i.e. fewer angry parents to deal with, more time to teach and less time spent "babysitting" the students, almost nonexistent discipline problems to handle, etc.)

Amen.

I have to laugh at people who complain about teacher's unions.

Let me tell you something from personal experience. My wife is a teacher right now. She teaches ESL at one of the poorest school districts in the metro Seattle area. She gets up at 5 in the morning to go to school everyday. She comes home anywhere from 3 PM to 8 PM at night. Many teachers actually stay past 5 PM everyday. None of the time after 2 PM is officially compensated, even though many days there are endless after school meetings and the like. Really, your summer vacation is only one and a half months because of similar reasons.

Right now, her school is going through a "reform" (breaking the school into small schools) which is actually working relatively well, as the students performance has generally improved in the last several years and so has discipline. (although this reform has not worked many other places it has been tried, my wife's school has a lot of very good teachers and principals).

This said, there is a chronic shortage of math and science teacchers because no one with college level knowledge in these subjects would want to subject themselves to the kind of conditions I describe above, for pay that is mediocre in many places. You can get English, foreign language, and history degreed students into teaching because the amount of degrees in these areas vs. the amount of jobs available means teaching actually remains a good option - even here, many of the teachers now will have master's degrees. But this said, the best people who get these degrees for the most part will not want to go into teaching or will only stay in it for a short time - like my wife, who will teach only a year or two more, until she gets her PhD - because the job is mentally and physically demanding, pays not very well, and is not respected (often because of sexism, as teaching is, traditionally and still to a large extent, considered "women's work").

Teachers unions can be hackish and short sighted, this I can tell you as well. But they do provide teachers benefits and on the whole are a plus, although its a mixed bag.

But teaching unions have nothing to do with the problems in hirign and retaining good teachers. Nothing. So in this sense, all the (male) critics of teaching who have more comfortable, better paid, and more prestigious jobs should try teaching at a bad school for a year or two before they continue to make ignorant statements such as the ones MY cites here.

In Republican-land, people only need incentives once they're making $500,000+ and then they don't even have to respond to the incentives.

If I could wave a magic wand, Steve Jobs would be taking my place Tuesday morning when I serve my weekly stint as a volunteer reading tutor in our neighborhood elementary school. It might be an eye-opening experience for him.

Our school is a very well-funded suburban one that consistently gets 'excellent' ratings from our state board of education. The teacher pay is one of the best in our area and getting a job in our school system is very competitive. They very rarely hire anyone who hasn't first taught somewhere else successfully for at least two years.

The "reading buddy" tutoring program is one of many efforts the school makes to help struggling students.

One of my "buddies" is a bright, delightful first-grader who literally can't sit still long enough to finish a page, so it's been hard for him to get as much practice as he needs to become a good reader. I bring in easy books on his favorite subject, science, and spend a fair amount of energy redirecting his attention to to the book at hand.

Another is a sweet, enthusiastic girl who can read aloud pretty fluently. She knows lots of sight words and she's able to sound out the words she doesn't recognize. But she can't read "between the lines" and as a result, her comprehension is weak. For example, once she picked out a book titled "Three Scary Stories." After she read the first line of the first story, "As the sun set, Sally and Sue put on their costumes," I interrupted to ask, "When do you think this story is happening?" She answered, "Wednesday." It took me a while to convince her it was Halloween night.

Comparing schools to business is silly. If I'm making widgets, I have control over what raw materials I use. If I'm running a school, I have to take all comers (as I well should). The challenges my reading buddies face have nothing to do with whether or not there's a computer in their classroom and whether the students know how to use it (there is and they do).

Anyway, I'd like to see how much success Mr. Jobs has as a reading buddy. Teaching is a lot harder than it looks.

Ben P said:
"But teaching unions have nothing to do with the problems in hirign and retaining good teachers. Nothing."

For the sake of discussion, I'd like to repost this abstract from The New Teachers Project. Can we discuss whether existing teacher contracts might be a problem at all? without discounting many of the other problems posters have addressed.

http://www.tntp.org/ourresearch/unintendedconsequences.html:
Unintended Consequences: The Case for Reforming the Staffing Rules of Urban Teachers Union Contracts focuses on the impact of “voluntary transfer” and “excessed teacher” staffing rules found in the collective bargaining agreements of urban school districts.

“Voluntary transfers” are incumbent teachers with seniority rights who want to move between schools, while “excessed teachers” are those whose positions are cut from their school, often due to enrollment or budget changes.

Through a study of five major urban districts, the report demonstrates how “voluntary transfer” and “excessed” teacher rules result in systems that hire too late to secure the most talented teacher applicants, bump valuable teachers, and require schools to hire poorly matched or—worse—poorly performing teachers.

> Through a study of five major urban districts,
> the report demonstrates how “voluntary transfer”
> and “excessed” teacher rules result in systems
> that hire too late to secure the most talented
> teacher applicants, bump valuable teachers,
> and require schools to hire poorly matched
> or—worse—poorly performing teachers.

In other words, the same sort of tricks that private businesses in competitive markets (e.g. Silicon Valley) and professionals in high demand specicalties pull every day. And which both competitive private schools and high demand private teachers would use when the Radical nirvana of vouchers and private schools arrives.

Cranky

Suburban Mom has reminded me of an old joke that is a favorite of a friend of mine:

A high school math department at what is considered to be a reasonably good suburban school is interested in "assessing" their activities. A speaker is recommended to them with experience in the business world - his business being ice cream.

The speaker comes and gives a talk to the department that is well-received by the members. In the following Q&A, one of the
faculty asks:

Q: "I see that you purchase ingredients from a number of vendors and that you assess the quality of what you buy.
What do you do when a vendor consistently sends you inferior ingredients, like poor strawberries?"

A: "Well, in order to control the quality of our strawberries, we change vendors."

Q: "How do we control the quality of our strawberries?"

It's a real knee slapper, isn't it?

I think a much more important policy change would be to switch from seniority-based pay to merit-based pay. This of course involved accountability and standards as well, but it also would probably be something many teachers' unions would oppose.

> I think a much more important policy
> change would be to switch from
> seniority-based pay to merit-based pay.

Taking into account the above 29 posts, exactly how do you propose to define "merit"?

Cranky

I drifted between public and private schools before ultimately realizing that they let you skip school more at the latter, and sticking around there.

But when I was at public school I had this really cool teacher who would bring me in on the weekends to play with the robots. He was teacher of the year for the state and all that jazz. He brought in tons of free computers and good publicity for the school.

And eventually he went to work for Apple.

(If you're reading this Mr. Ro I'm no longer an adorable blond child but if you read these threads you'll note that I'm still mindlessly resisting peer pressure and generally have nothing useful to say.)

The folks blaming the teachers unions for the failures in the public schools sound much like the folks who blame the UAW for the failures of GM, Ford, and Chrysler.

Uncle Bunny writes: They're at school not to learn but to pass time until the last bell of the day rings.

Sounds like excellent preparation for the working world. Keep up the good work.

the term "teacher's unions" really doesn't do justice to significant differences in positions towards issues of accountability, etc., between the NEA and the AFT, the two main unions.

for the curious, the AFT has been much more supportive of NCLB-type accountability systems and have looked to "get it right," rather than the NEA, which has reflexively resisted NCLB's provisions.

Based on my own extensive experience with public school policy issues, I don't see the teachers' unions as a particularly negative factor. Some of the things they do/support are good, some are bad, and most are marginal in that regard.

On the other hand, I think a very positive reform step would be the abolition of all the Schools of Education, which have propagated a huge number of very disastrous educational policies and have almost no positive or redeeming features whatsovever.

Most conservatives obviously share this view. Interestingly enough, most of the senior teachers' unions leaders I've met have the exact same perspective.

Taking into account the above 29 posts, exactly how do you propose to define "merit"?

I'm not sure, since I'm not an educator.

But it should be something a lot better than "I've been here longer."

I have no problem with a merit based scale, but the baseline has to be pretty good.

The job is harder than many other professions that are also: 1) better paid, and 2) enjoy higher esteem.

This is the fundamental problem. Particularly when it comes to math and science, you just aren't going to get enough good people unless you pay people a lot of money.

I think some kind of "chicken hawk" argument should apply here. Since most of the peoople criticizing teachers - which is how teachers union criticism comes off to teachers - aren't teachers, why aren't they asking themselves why they aren't if they think the status quo is unacceptable? Shouldn't they be going in to the schools in an effort to "save" the kids since the teachers are corrupt and incomptent?

I have no problem with a merit based scale, but the baseline has to be pretty good.

The job is harder than many other professions that are also: 1) better paid, and 2) enjoy higher esteem.

This is the fundamental problem. Particularly when it comes to math and science, you just aren't going to get enough good people unless you pay people a lot of money.

I think some kind of "chicken hawk" argument should apply here. Since most of the peoople criticizing teachers - which is how teachers union criticism comes off to teachers - aren't teachers, why aren't they asking themselves why they aren't if they think the status quo is unacceptable? Shouldn't they be going in to the schools in an effort to "save" the kids since the teachers are corrupt and incomptent?

I'm a 47 year old teacher to be in Wisconsin. I am now student teaching 3rd graders full time after a year of training. What I can tell you is that my post baccalaureate program provided pretty good training. I can also tell you that teaching is hard than hell. I worked as a graphic artist at places like Boeing and Starbucks and it was way easier. I would honestly compare successful teaching with being a general practitioner or a lawyer. You have to be very, very organized, prepare at least twenty lessons a week, contribute to all kinds of meetings, work more than 40 hours a week, and teach 15 to 25 kids of vastly different backgrounds, abilities, needs and get them all to learn the same stuff at the same time. You really have to know what you are teaching and how to teach. It is a real art form. My current kids are remarkably well behaved and motivated but I have worked with the kids uncle bunny was talking about, and he is right. There are a lot of kids out there, black, white, red, green--it's seems like mostly an economic thing--who are good kids, but have been trained not to do well in school. I think that this is the real problem with US schools. Suburban and good urban schools are doing fine, but we are not successfully educating poor kids. If we address that problem, then most of the problems with US schools would disappear. We would be on a par with anyone in the world, if that is really the goal.

Let me see what else have I observed:
-All the teachers I've worked with have been intelligent, dedicated, and talented. Really. That's in a good urban school district, though. I have heard bad stories about Milwaukee.
-The education schools in the area I am familiar with teach what research has proven to work.
-The things that teachers are mandated to do with special ed kids are impossible given the funding they get.
-Many people, especially politicians, have opinions about education but no knowledge about it at all. It's one of those subjects that everyone feel qualified to spout out about.
-Schools are driven by politics. They are political footballs for people who care nothing about education.
-The overriding issue in all schools is funding: how much is it going to be cut, where does it come from, how is it apportioned.
-A new teacher in Madison gets about $27,000 a year. It's way, way less in other places. The south, in rural and poor urban districts. $27 works out to about $13 an hour. Of course you do get good benefits.

Well, Ben, consider this.

Under the current system of seniority-based pay, there is no opportunity for rapid salary advancement. Thus, a young, bright person who is considering becoming a teacher must commit to being a teacher for life if he/she intends to ever make a good salary teaching. That's a big barrier to getting good, talented teachers.

For example: suppose I'm a physics major at a good school, but I'd rather not be a prof. I could go into engineering or finance, where, if I do well, I could make $100k or more in a couple years. But suppose I'd rather work with kids, so I wouldn't mind a $60,000 teacher salary. But if I become a teacher, I won't make $60,000 until I've been teaching for 10 years or more. No matter how good a teacher I am, I'll get a low salary throughout my 20s. And by the time I'm making that $60k, I'll have pretty much killed my other career options, so if I find I don't like teaching, I'll be stuck. That's a big risk to take. I might as well suck it up and be an engineer or work on Wall Street.

See what I mean?

"But if I become a teacher, I won't make $60,000 until I've been teaching for 10 years or more"

More like 25 years in most districts.

I know a sociologist doing research on education in Kentucky and he also finds that student test scores track closely with the SES of a county. What that means for our rural school system is that there is inconsistency at all levels of the system. For my youngest daughter, the teachers in 4th grade range from very good to superb, but my 7th grade daughter has only two good teachers and the high school has a reputation as a disaster. The same patchiness can be seen with the principals and the last two school superintendants. The school board is dominated by useless good old boys.

Teacher training is another thicket in this area. There are some good things going on at the education college at my University, but they are also determined not to raise standards for teacher training. My own Department has been trying to raise standards for social studies teachers for years but we just had to terminate a social studies coordinator who completely rejected our values. It's always one step forward, two steps back. If there are a lot of highly qualified teachers ready to work in impoverished areas like Eastern Kentucky, they're not coming out of our education program.

Teacher's unions are the least of the problems of education in a poor area like Eastern Kentucky.

The reason politicans rarely push for the ability to fire bad teachers is that they are afraid of the teacher's unions. What other explanation is there for making it difficult to fire teachers caught in gross misconduct such as criminal activity? Perhaps education pundits would argue that such cases are actually rare and adequately dealt with by assigning such teachers to rubber rooms where there are paid to do nothing but since when have politicians have cared about such considerations? If they are not willing to go against the teachers unions on what would appear to be the politically popular cause of firing felons it is because they are terrified of the teacher's unions not because they think firing felons won't make much difference.

They're public schools.

If the public wanted them to be better than they are, they would be, and if they don't want them at all -- and when the students in them are too poor, too dark, too different -- they'll provide the minimum consistent with the clause in most state constitutions that mandate them.

The most important statistics in public education: 70% of voters don't have kids in the local schools, and 50% plus 1 is a majority.

The mediocrity of public education is a feature, not a bug.

MY's claim that firing bad teachers doesn't have enough payoff to be worth fighting for also brings to mind the aphorism about perfect being the enemy of good. Liberals like MY unrealistically want schools to eliminate the gap in academic performance between smart rich kids and dumb poor kids. So they dismiss worthwhile incremental improvements like making it easier to fire bad teachers as not being enough.

Note the fact that the pool of people willing to work in bad schools is inferior to the pool of people willing to work in good schools means it is more important for bad schools to be able to fire bad hires because they are more likely to make bad hires in the first place since they have no choice but to hire more risky candidates to fill their slots.

I spent 30 years in private industry as a computer programmer and systems analyst. Every company had a different method of evaluating employees and every company changed that method after two or three years. My evaluations were all over the place depending on the particular manager or client I had at the time - usually excellent sometimes middle of the pack, sometimes in-between, and one time - problematic). The reviews were really very subjective, often politically based, and ultimately useless. Considerations for bonuses were even worse. I have no confidence that any system for reviewing teachers could be implemented in a way that 90% of the reviews would be truly objective. It is possible to weed out the worst employees, but separating good, better, and best gets real subjective. School systems need to be able to weed out the worst teachers, but they also need to offer better salaries and working conditions to attract a better pool of applicants to begin with.

My parents were lifelong public school teachers (and moderate Democrats), and let me tell you, their terrible local was a common topic of dinner conversation. Basically the union spent most of its time and money -- their dues -- defending terrible teachers from getting fired. This included a guy who at least three times beat kids in class, once enough to send the kid to the hospital, and another guy who slept with students. More than anything the union was for the status quo. In a good district that might not be too disruptive.

Yup. It's society's fault!

http://thefrustratedteacher.blogspot.com/index.html

James B. Shearer claims that the inferior pool of people willing to work in bad schools means it is more important for bad schools to be able to fire people. This brings to mind a certain aphorism about libertarian economists. When their model fails to match reality, they change their descriptions of reality to match the model.

Failing school districts don't merely have trouble hiring quality people to teach, James. They also, not coincidentally, have trouble attracting and retaining quality administrators. Therefore, making it easier to fire teachers will not magically result in better teachers, because bad administrators tend to reward people who suck up and fire people who try to shake things up. It will result in more abuses of power by bad administrators, and more opportunities for decent teachers to be scapegoated for low test scores achieved by students who come into their classrooms unprepared and receive no educational support at home.

Conservatives find it politically convenient to blame everything on the unions and the (mostly female) teachers, rather than confronting the realities of systemic poverty, or the embarrassingly low pay and dismal conditions that drive good people out of the education profession. So, naturally, the political discourse of education reform is all about punishing teachers. But here's a little economics lesson for conservatives... If you want to attract and retain a talented motivated labor pool, you have to pay well and treat people well, and not burden them with the inordinate amount of paperwork and unpaid labor that results from most "accountability" measures.

And replace them with who, exactly?

RKU had it right. Define "merit" in merit pay. OR "poor" in "poor teachers." Turns out to be harder than you think. If you use student test scores as a measure of teacher ability, I can select a group of students that would make you look like a genius. Or a different group could make you look like a failure. There are some systems of teacher evaluation out there that are showing some promise, but they aren't simple and no one knows how reliable they are. Describing a "good" teacher is a your basic can of worms.

Stipulating that neither I nor my wife are teachers, nor were any of our parents, neither do we belong to unions...

This is as commonsensical as "unions were needed once, but not anymore."

I love Steve Jobs, but the test of a CEO is hardly his ability to treat his employees as widgets.

Unions are a force for good. Workers have as much of a right to bargain collectively as capitalists do to pool their funds and form corporations. Indeed, unions can be seen as corporations whose product is the labor of their membership.

Nobody holds a gun to the employers head to sign union contracts, unless you consider bargaining an unfair tool, which sort of knocks capitalism out of the game, doesn't it? And once signed, those contracts should be as enforcable as any other, if not more so.

I wonder if his suppliers know how Steve feels about contracts?

Just another in a long line of capitalists who bash unions. Is Apple unionized?

You might try looking up Steve Jobs' campaign contributions over the years. He's donated hundreds of thousands of dollars to the Democrats. He's not exactly a shill for big business.

The answer is: No, Apple is not unionized.

Following up; Steve Jobs has a long record of bashing unions. He is, nonetheless, a Democrat.

On the other hand, I think a very positive reform step would be the abolition of all the Schools of Education, which have propagated a huge number of very disastrous educational policies and have almost no positive or redeeming features whatsovever.

This is just about the only "reform" worthy of the name in the education sector. Sadly, it's practically never mentioned.

Otherwise.... The dirty little secret of public schooling in America, the land where people supposedly "love" education, is that the great majority of people view it as a necessary path to a better job, and that's it. There's nothing wrong with that, but we should quit pretending that most Americans want their kids to be inquisitive and eager to learn. In light of that, I'd like to hear Jobs explain what exactly a teacher is supposed to do, when at the end of the day his students are likely to return to a home without a single book on the shelf?

And by the way, where are all these great advances that computers have introduced into classrooms? The Web is a terrific thing, but it's free. Most of the "educational software" that I've seen was crap pimped by hucksters (many of them from education colleges -- see opening paragraph).

LaFollette Progressive, actually I mostly blame the kids not the teachers or their union. In many cases they are being scapegoated. On the other hand education advocates set teachers up for scapegoating by arguing that more pay would help by attracting better teachers which implies the current teachers are lousy.

Steve easily could say technology in the classroom will help and try to sell a few more computers. He is speaking against his companies interest becuase he feels what he is saying is the truth.

I commend him for that.

I think instead of making the focus on giving principals more power over teachers, we should focus on getting better principals. Good administration is key to running a good school. I find it hard to imagine that there are really that many otherwise excellent principals who would have a great school if only they could fire their bad teachers. Making teachers scapegoats is an easy fix.

Pretty funny, really. Most of the software giants got there by ruthlessly exploiting fine print and striving for monopolistic positions where they could tax us with the costs of endless 'upgrades'.

We wouldn't be too happy with teachers who suddenly told us "You know all that stuff we taught you last year? We have a better idea now and you'll have to learn a bunch of new stuff instead. Go ahead and just use those old textbooks for firewood."

Certainly, if we could afford to do it, education might be improved by building all-new schools every three years and spending as much time on every student as the average blog reader spends reading blogs, say, two or three hours of one-to-one personalized instruction every day.

Care to guess how much that would cost? And for that amount of money we might get something that only works as well as Adobe Acrobat, which apparently needs a 20-gigabit processor to run properly.

Well, thanks, but no thanks. Local control through local schoolboards, a peculiarly American form of education, is still preferable to the dictatorship of Steve jobs.

Notice that James B. Shearer ignored the question; how do you define or measure "merit" in a system where teachers cannot control their inputs?

I agree with Bunny; there are many children in poor districts (like than district I was raised in) who have absolutely no interest in learning. They are not curious or inquisitive, and they enjoy "scoring points" with their similarly disinterested peers by disrupting class. I can't prescribe any solutions, other than banning irresponsible people from having children. However, I can state that teachers had nothing to do with the problems of the public school system.

Merit Pay = Ass kissing pay.

(been there, seen it done)

Its a relief to read all these posts and see people are not buying the Steve Jobs B.S. I especially agree with William's 07:06 post. When it comes right down to it the school's community is responsible for their lot. A community thats lazy and votes for unqualified school boards sets in motion a downward spiral.

Obviously you would couple teacher accountability and merit pay with various other reforms. The total package is what counts, right?

People with uninformed, sophomoric opinions like Steve Jobs no longer make me furious; they just make me sad. After being a teacher for twenty years, I know that it's almost entirely the reverse of what Jobs is saying. Even somewhat inept teachers can be effective if they have students who are even a little bit willing to learn and administrators who are not idiots. I currently have an administrator who ships students with bad grades off to our continuation high school at the drop of a hat. Guess what? I look like I'm teaching much better than I did ten years ago. For good measure he fired some good non-tenured teachers so it could like like he's taking care of "bad" teachers as well. We're in big trouble in this country and a bunch of ex-football coaches and insufferable academics who never taught a day in their lives aren't going to fix it by firing teachers. You think that pool of qualified teachers is small now. It's going to get smaller. It was already an incredibly difficult, but rewarding job before. I've told my daughter I wouldn't pay for her college if she decided to be a teacher, and I wasn't kidding.

Caroline Schoneweis, given your propensity to blame the victim ("if they have students who are even a little bit willing to learn") perhaps you should have cut to the chase sooner and refused to pay your daughter's tuition if she decided to become a student?

Students, in general, don't arrive at school unwilling to learn. But the system takes care of that pretty fast.

Students, in general, don't arrive at school unwilling to learn

Elementary, yes. Middle and high school, very much no.

If you stake out a school or two, you'll notice, at the former they run off the bus to get into the building at 9:05, at the latter they run out of the building to get onto the bus at 2:05.

Davis:Lettuce's point, which is a good one, is that in elementary, you see what you mentioned. The kids are excited to go to school, all that. Something happens between then and middle/high school that quite frankly, turns most kids off the whole mess.

Karmakin, something does happen, but the teacher is probably low on the why list. For starters kids are tested repeatedly and when not testing, they are beaten down again with preparing to take the next test.

If you think it's difficult to fire teachers, you ought to consider SecDefs.

This thread seems to be filled with exchanges like this:

A: The problem with schools is that the teachers unions make it too hard to fire bad teachers.
B: No, that's stupid. The problem with schools is that we don't pay teachers enough.
C: That's ridiculous. The problem with schools is that parents don't care enough.
D: Actually, the real problem with schools is that administrators are awful.

Can't it be a dessert topping AND a floor wax?

I think that the reason why this has been such an intractable problem in America is that there are myriad structural failures in schools, and the complex of problems means that a single "cure" gets sidelined by the problems it doesn't address.

So you give more money to a school, and an incompetent administrator fritters it away, or the unions sideline it to senior teachers who just don't care anymore, or it gets to the teachers, and they still don't want to teach the horrifying children whose parents don't give a rats ass about their education.

You do a big parent involvement initiative, and the benefits are minimal because the underpaid teachers aren't really qualified to handle the students, or the administration forces some idiotic education iniative which boils down to "teach the test."

You get a great new principal, and he's blocked and hemmed in by budgetary problems and teachers unions hostile to changes to the status quo.

Etcetera. If this was basically as simple as most of you guys are making it sound, we'd have seen the answer a long time ago. If you could just pour money into schools and make them better, or just fire some teachers and make them better, or just do any one single, simple policy prescription, we'd have figured it out by now.

Father Figure asked:

"Notice that James B. Shearer ignored the question; how do you define or measure "merit" in a system where teachers cannot control their inputs?"

I don't know why this is being asked of me since I didn't advocate merit pay. I am advocating making it easier to fire teachers who get arrested for dealing drugs and the like.

However defining merit is easy enough you just adjust for the quality of inputs. Measuring it is harder since the easiest way to improve test scores is to cheat. I have repeatedly read admiring stores about how a bad school or group of schools has been "turned around" and then read exposes a few years later about how the "turn around" was an illusion based on gaming the measurements somehow.

Note if you really don't think you can measure merit then you gain little by paying teachers more.

A teacher dealing "drugs and the like," would be gone the next day.

"Note if you really don't think you can measure merit then you gain little by paying teachers more."

Why pay them at all? We could just hook up computers to every classroom and hire ex-carnies to do the paper work.

I know of no union contracts anywhere that prohibit firing individuals for serious felony infractions. It is possible that the alleged cases in this area are the result of certain administrators being unable to properly handle the necessary documentation. In any case, I would like to see actual evidence. So far, one right-winger posted an unverified anecdote, and the entire thread was sidetracked as a result.

For decades, the teaching profession was subsidized by traditional gender roles - to put it bluntly, sexism. Skilled and talented women who today would enter law, medicine, or any number of other well-paid professions were then restricted to teaching and nursing. As a result, Americans tend to grossly underestimate the human capital requirements in these fields. Those days aren't coming back, nor should they. We need to face this fact and realize that we can't maintain any reasonable level of quality in these fields while trying to pay people as if it were still the 1950s.

Merit pay sounds nice on the surface, but it is extremely difficult to quantify. Most of the time, it's simply an excuse; instead of increasing pay across the board, conservatives want to pit teachers against each other for the same small, pitiful pool of funds. How do you compare a teacher in an upper-middle class district to one in the inner city? You obviously can't just compare test scores without taking other factors into account. And you can't just let the principals decide because then you're not rewarding good teaching, but sycophancy.

In some areas, there is indeed fat to be trimmed. Administrative hierarchies are often overly bloated, so far too little of the money spent on schools actually reaches the classroom. Contracts for food and bus service are sometimes crooked, especially in large cities. And we send a lot of kids to "special ed" who really shouldn't be there. But this isn't going to change the fact that we will need to spend more on schools if we want better quality. There is no inexpensive quick fix.

It's also amazing how many of the Econ 101 worshippers seem to forget all the tenets of their religion when it comes to education. Normally, if you have a shortage of applicants for a needed job, you would increase pay or benefits. Here, we have a shortage and the conservatives instead advocate slashing pay and benefits and making working conditions worse. This is just another brick in the edifice of dishonesty built by the right wing.

Everything I have seen says that main predictor of school performance is the parents income level. By the time my kid was 3 or 4, he had his own computer full of edutainment software. Edutainment software taught him how to read. By the time he got to kindergarten, he could read and do addition and multiplication. He was way, way ahead of any kid that didn't have such "wealthy" parents.

The answer to "level the field" is more time in school. More school days in the calendar, longer school days, universal pre-school. That would take lots more teachers and lots more money. Politicians want to find something that "fixes" public education but doesn't cause a lot of dough. That was really the whole point behind NCLB - for Bush to say that he was doing something about improve education without actually spending much money on improving education.

Teaching suffers a whole genre, fiction and non, of literature along the lines of "Coach Carter." There's just that one fantastic teacher / coach / prinicpal who really cares, and will do anything for the children (sniff!)including breaking a few rules if necessary. It's like an action movie with no action, which bears a similar relationship with reality.

Once you buy into this nonsense, it's not a stretch to think the teacher's union is somehow quashing this vast army of Coach Carters. But if you expect teachers to work 60 hours a week instead of 50 for the same pay, just because they care, you could book the number of applicants on Oprah. Hell, Oprah might even book a real teacher and Denzel Washington on the same show, perpetuating the myth even further.

Actually, James B. Shearer, I don't think that the quality of teachers is too low. Teachers should be paid more because they are the front line that feels the externalities caused by massive resource inequalities. There really aren't any educational policies that can rectify the damage done by poverty; some lucky kids can overcome it, but most can't. If we eliminate inequality (or at least drastically reduce it), test scores would compress. People who blame that inequality on teachers are either very naive about wealth effects, or they are being dishonest.

Its strange that police officers don't catch the same flak for allowing socio-economic factors to result in different crime rates in different areas.

Russ, not in New York. Here is an example of how hard it is to fire teachers in New York. I believe they finally succeeded in this case but it took 6 years.

Father Figure, so you think teachers should be paid more for symbolic reasons, to show we care, even though paying them more won't actually help their students in any way.

It is funny, whenever people like say Jobs or Mickey Kaus launch into these tirades about reforming education policy in this country, they act like being a teacher is a profession in which streams of talented, motivated people are just dying to teach, and it's only the teacher bureaucracy that's holding them back. If teaching is such a wonderful, terrific profession, why don't people like Mickey Kaus or Steven Jobs become teachers (I'm sure Mr Wozniak would be happy to give them advice). If they would understand why they don't head off and become teachers themselves, they might have a better understanding of why education is where it is today.

Also, I don't know if firing people will necessarily improve the situation. I have a friend whose ex-boyfriend is a band and music teacher at a charter school. His band has won all sorts of honors, performed around the country, and each year has well over 100 people auditioning to perform in it--in other words, he's the sort of teacher Hollywood makes movies about every year. But the principal of his school is trying to push him out so he can put a friend of his in this man's place.

I don't think firing people is the simple answer for any problem. After all, in a just world, all of the pundits who supported the Iraq War would have lost their jobs, wouldn't they?

James B. Shearer, regarding your New York anecdote, it sounds like the investigator is the true culprit of the malfeasance. Had the investigation occurred properly, things would be fine. In addition to that, you and the radical neoliberals who advocate pure, whim-based at will employment constantly refuse to address the reality that for every one situation like that New York case, at-will employment generates thousands of non meritocratic, cleptocratic employment decisions. Even worse, at-will employment creates subtle pressure to conform to the attitudes of "the boss," to the detriment of fundamental liberty.

As for your other comment, teachers should be paid more because they do a difficult job that has a far more profound influence on our society than the NFL football, or most of the other occupations that receive far more resources than they deserve. Plus, teachers have been forced to constantly put up with attacks on their livelihood and dignity from hacks who have never successfully taught.

James B. Shearer writes, "If teaching is such a wonderful, terrific profession, why don't people like Mickey Kaus or Steven Jobs become teachers."

This perpetuates the myth that people who can succeed in other professions have no desire to become teachers, especially in inner city schools. The success of the Philadelphia Teaching Fellows debunks this myth. This is an organization that recruits professionals from other areas to become teachers in the Philadelphia public school system. Check out their web site at www.philadelphiateachingfellows.org. Please note this quote at the top of their Overview page: "Due to the large number of applications that we expect to receive for English, social studies, and special education, we anticipate that the selection process for positions in these subject areas will be particularly competitive." That's right, there is heavy competition for entry level teaching positions in an 86% minority inner city school system. This is probably representative of similar programs in other urban school districts. In short, it appears that people like Mickey Kaus and Steven Jobs DO become teachers.

But teachers can be fired, Mr. Jobs! The only catch is that after the probationary period (usually three years) administrators have to publicly provide clear evidence that the teacher (once judged competent, cooperative and morally sound) has become either incompetent, uncooperative or has a lost moral compass.

You better believe that in the latter case (what used to be called moral turpitude), the firings occur. Administrators are much more cautious about the first two criteria. And they should be.

By the way, in the first couple of years, administrators don't have to give reasons. But it also takes a couple of years to properly prepare a new teacher, so again good managers would want to keep a new employee on their upward curve.

If we want teachers to be professionals (think doctors. lawyers) that seems more than fair.

A recent study found teaching is among the highest-paid careers, even before their generally generous benefits are tossed in.

The amount of money we spend on education has vastly increased, the quality has not been commensurate. That's what happens when there is little or no meritocracy to speak of. Teachers need to be paid and hired/fired based on how well they educate, not certifications and seniority. The only way that will happen is when vouchers enable education to function like a private sector enterprise, with parents are able to CHOOSE what schools to send their kids based on how well those schools are doing.

Just like every other business, if a school is performing poorly it won't have the revenues to hire more teachers or pay them more. Very poor schools will have to lay teachers off as parents pull their kids out. Very good schools will add students and teachers.

I would really like to see the 'recent study' that found teaching is among the highest-paid careers. Let's see. My wife has done a master's, and her starting salary is going to be about $35K. Unlike the usual 2000 hour work year, a teaching year is more like 1600 hours. So that translates to a little over $20 an hour. My part-time baby sitter makes $12 an hour.

Now let's compare that to the corporate world. An average programmer at a big corporation, run by the capitalist gods such as Jobs and Ellison, probably make $80k a year. Translates to about $40 an hour. Speaking from experiece, this fellow can be very very average. He can be a schmuck, harassing a potential female interview candidate by calling her at home. He is not in a union. But he does not get fired. Why? Firing is hard, even in a non-unionized big company. It is often easier to put up with mediocrity.

This is not an arguement to protect unproductive teachers. But it is really unfair to single out teachers as the only ones who are taking advantage of the inertia that is prevalent in big organizations (and that included non-unionized capitalist companies).

TallDave: how do you measure how well teachers educate? If you respond with any version of the phrase, "testing," you are incorrect, and probably disingenuous.

TallDave wrote: "I would really like to see the 'recent study' that found teaching is among the highest-paid careers."

Here's a link to that recent study:
http://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/cr_50.htm

This study merely summarizes data collected by the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) in its annual National Compensation Survey. A key finding: The average public school teacher was paid 36% more per hour than the average non-sales white-collar worker and 11% more than the average professional specialty and technical worker. This does not include benefits, which would put teachers even farther ahead.

The teachers unions have attempted to debunk these statistics the only way they can, i.e., by claiming most teachers actually work 60 to 65 hours per week, etc., etc., blah, blah.

Thanks Mike Abbott for the link to the Manhattan-Institute study. Fortunately, you can go directly to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, and look at the data for yourself. Most teachers' salaries have not been converted to hourly rates, except pre-school, where it converts to about $12/hr, annual $25K.

Non special-ed middle school (code 25-2022) make an average of $48K/year. To convert this to a $34/hr salary, you have to assume that a teacher is working 1411 hours in a year. You don't need the teacher's union to tell you that the estimate is wrong.

Teacher's Pet, I'm not sure what BLS statistics you found that did not convert most teachers' salaries to hourly rates, but this is the data I found that does include that information: http://www.bls.gov/ncs/ocs/compub.htm. I believe this is the source used in the Manhattan Institute study. Hourly wage rates are presented by state, region and nationally on that page.

Please note the following quote from page 1 of the National Compensation Survey: Occupational Wages in the United States, June 2005 (which can be found on the web site cited above):

"Among white-collar major occupational groups, workers in professional specialty and technical occupations earned $31.25 an hour in State and local government, while their private industry counterparts earned $29.80. This earnings differential may be explained by the prevalence of teachers in State and local government, many of whom tend to have higher hourly earnings than professional specialty and technical workers in the private sector."

Please note that this quote was not made by the right-wing teacher haters at the Manhattan Institute; it was made by the author(s) of a U.S Dept. of Labor report. Similar quotes are included at the beginning of prior years' reports. To me this is significant because it shows that the Bureau of Labor Statisitics is standing by their methodology despite what must be trememendous pressure from the teachers' unions.

I think it's worth examining the background for this line of thought, which is that No Child Left Behind sets firing of staff as the primary accountability mechanism short of closing a school down, and this would require preempting union rules.

I don't have a dog in this fight, but I think it's worth noting that the folks in the Bush administration who drafted the rules are anti-union, and I don't think time is going to prove that sanctions will in general improve schools except as a threat that prods action rather than through the sanctions themselves. And by and large, I think the low-hanging fruit as a prod to action has been reaped.

hi all..

Thanks for sharing your feedback! If your feedback doesn’t appear right away, please be patient as it may take a few minutes to publish - or longer if the blogger is moderating comments.

adasdasd

There is available an Arabic Adobe Reader already. Check the language selections on this site Thank you

There's also another dynamic at work here. Teachers are underpaid in many cases with regard to ther skill setg, but the difference is made up for in extremely good benefits with regard to most other professions out there. Thus, health insurance, retirement benefits, and job security are better in education than most other jobs. You can try to eliminate these things, but you'll rapidly find a decrease in the number of qualified applicants unless you raise salaries to compensate. This requires raising taxes and all sorts of other free things that people often dislike. Jobs and Kaus are looking for a free lunch, which any school administrator can tell you isn't free in the way one would think.

There really is, obviously, two sides to this argument and Steve Jobs has a point : no amount of technology is actually going to suffice or take the place of a good teacher. This is a very needed point. But the problem is that the good teachers deserve the good wages, and generally also deserve (or prefer) the school with the technology and the resources that will help them to teach. A good teacher is even not as good as he can be in a bad school. Accountability is a good point, and Obama has probably stepped on the right toe there. The education system itself needs to have proper teachers coming through. But, secondly, schools need to beef up and also go through 'accountability' programs.

very good sites

thank you

thanks

very nice

very good

sohbet, chat, arkadaş

yine yeniden en iyiye

I am so sick of technology savvy people saying that technology could fix public schools if only...for crying out loud. They're public schools and we need all the teachers we can get in public schools. Sure, they may not all be good teachers, but at least they're willing to be there...and it certainly is NOT for the pay. Teachers are there because they are doing something that no one else wants to do. If we fired all the bad teachers because technology CEOs told us to, then we'd have 10 teachers in the whole state of Utah. This is one of those topics where you try to cross millionaires with middle class citizens and you find out that it doesn't work. Technology doesn't solve every problem in the class room and getting technology in more public elementary schools is not going to help the learning deficit. He's right that we need more and better teachers...maybe he could donate some of his millions to helping us educate our teachers so they can educate the kids?

Chat

oyunkabini

melekler

alaturqa

netbahane

oyun oyna

heyt babalar ya burayida bulmussunuz

loadtrsitesi

komik resimleri

acuit

resminipaylas

thank youu..

thanks..

thanks..

thanks..

thank you

I am so sick of technology savvy people saying that technology could fix public schools if only

Father Figure, so you think teachers should be paid more for symbolic reasons, to show we care, even though paying them more won't actually help their students in any way

thank you

evden eve nakliyat

evden eve ciler

tks aaa

www.r10.net küresel ısınmaya hayır seo yarışmasıwww.r10.net küresel ısınmaya hayır seo yarışması

thanks
best regards

thank you good job

nice collection thanx

thank you very much

thank you good work

thank you very thanxx ;)

thank you good work nice ;)

thank you nice collection

super collection good work

thank you good job ;)

thank you matt

thanks matthenew you are numberone

thank you

thank you

thank you very very much

Thanks

Thanks

Thanks

Sounds like excellent preparation for the working world. Keep up to date.

thanks
best regards.

thanks
best wishes

i like that

mirc sohbet chat

sohbet chat

sohbet chat muhabbet

Hello Matthew, i thank you very much for this Article

thanks

thanks in flowers istanbul

flowers istanbul post

thanks

hire and fire.... thanks :)

www.alonechat.net Alonechat

Thanks your article

[URL="http://www.hobichat.com/ilginc.htm"]chat[/URL]

thankss :)

thanks

thanks

THANKS

selams

selamlar

farz

seksi

thankss forr mathheyyy

thanks for your efford

whar a usefull information :)

thankx :) :)

thank you

thanksss

what a bizarre site :)

thanks
its cool
best regards..

thank you very much

thanks a lot

Love a you blog

chat

adult

islam

sohbet

sohbet

sohbet

2.el-ikinci-el

3d_resimler

29_ekim

30_agustos

6600_uygulamalar

7610_program_download

acem_kizi_mp3_midileri

acik_ogretim_sinav_sonuclari

agaclar_ormanlar

ahmet_ozhan

ahu_tugba

akor_akorlar

alisveris_alis_veris

almanca_germany

almanca_turkce_sozluk

altili_ganyan_tahmin

am_amciklar

am-amcik

Angelina-Jolie

animasyon

ankara_hotel

ankarada_satilik_ev_ilanlari

anket_sayfalari

anna_kournikova

anne_anneler

anneler_gunu_hazir_cep_mesajlari

anneler_gunu_mesajlari

antalyada_konutlar

araba_ilanlari

search_ara

search_search_motorlari

arkadas

arkadas_search

arkadas_bul

artvin_hopa_resim_galerisi

arzu_arzular

ascii_mesajlar

asian_sites_for_free_email_addresses

ask_askim

ask_harita

ask_hazir_mesaj

ask_mesk

ask_ogut_99ogut

ask_sembolleri

ask_siirleri

ask_sizi_ele_verir

ask_sozleri

ask_tazelemek

ask_ve_guzellik_tanricasi_afrodit

asker_hazir_mesajlari

asker_hazir_mesajlari2

aski_sicak_tut

askim_askim

askin_sayilari

ask-sozleri

asp

asp_scriptler

at_yarisi_sonuclari

ata_demirer

ata_sozleri

ates_atesli

ataturk_ataturkculuk

atyarisi_at_yarislari

avea_melodileri

avrupa_amerika_asya_kitasi

avrupa_yakasi

aya_ikinci_cikan_insan

ayak_ayakta_sex

aylin_coskun

ayrilik

ayrilik_mesajlari

ayrilik_nefret_mesajlari

aysel_gurmen

aysu

aysu_basar

azerice_canli_radyo

baba_babalar

babalar_gunu_hazir_cep_mesajlari

babalar_gunu_mesajlari

bagimli_muptela

bahis

baliklar

bahama_maldiv_adalari

baliklar_balikcilik

banka

banka_bankalar

banu_alkan

banyo_aksesuarlari

basak_sahin

basketbol

basketbol_basket

bayan_arkadas_ariyorum

bayan_msn

bayanlarla_sesli_sohbet

bayhan_gurhan

bayram_kandil_hazir_cep_mesajlari

bayram_kandil_hazir_cep_mesajlari2

bayram_kartlari

bayram_mesajlari

bayram_slaytlari

bayramin_kutlu_olsun

bebek_resimleri

bedava

bedava_bedavalar

bedava_cep_melodileri_oyunlari

bedava_email

bedava_mp3_yukle

bedava_oyun

bedava_resimli_mesaj
 
Bedava_melodi_bedava_sms__wap_melodi_cep_melodi_polifonik_melodi_turkcell_melodi_nokia_melodi_logo_cep

bedava_site_bedava_siteler

bedava_sms

bedava_web_sitesi

bedava-melodi

Bedava_melodi_bedava_sms__wap_melodi_cep_melodi_polifonik_melodi_turkcell_melodi_nokia_melodi_logo_cep1

Bedava-Sms

Bedava-ziyaretci-Defteri

begen_begenme_begenenler_begendim_begendiklerim

belediye_hizmetleri

Ben_sana_olurum_sarisinim

bergama_belediye_spor

berksan_ben_hic_unutmadim_unutamam

Berna_Ozturk

besiktas_bjk_mesajlari

beyaz_esya

beyazesya_beyazesyalar

bilet

bilet_biletler

bilgin-egitim-teknolojileri

bilgisayar

bilgisayar_computer

bilgisayar_pc_pcler

bilgisayarda_ses

bir_demet_tiyatro

bir_istanbul_masali

bir_prens_araniyor

bir-istanbul-masali

biten_iliskiler

bitki_bitkiler

bocekler

bocekler_bocek

bolge_bolgeler

bolgeler

borsa

borsa_borsalar

borsa_imkb

britney_spears_erotik

Britney-Spears

bu_sabahlarin_bir_anlami_olmali_mp3

burc_ask_sevgi

burc_burclar

burc-burclar

burclarin_kotu_yonleri

burcu_gunes_mp3_yukle

bu-sabahlarin-bi anlami-olmali-mp3-yukle

buyu_buyuler

buyuculuk

cagla_sikel_resimleri

cakir_kurtlarvadisi

camdan_papuclar

Cameron_Diaz

cankan_yar_yar_sarki_sozleri

cankiri_meslek_yuksek_okulu

canli_skorlar

canli-istek-hatti

capkinlik_kacamaklar

casino

casino_kasinolar

Catherine_Zeta_Jones

cd_cogaltma

cdkey_serial_no

cdler

cdler_cd

cekici_olmak

cem_yilmaz

cem_yilmaz_yeni_reklam_filmi

cep_melodi

cep_siirleri

cep_telefonlari

cep_telefonlari_cep_telefonu

cep_telefonu_icin_wavlar

cep-melodi

cep-telefon

cep-telefonu

ceza_fan_club

cgi_scriptler

chat_odalari

chat_sesli_chat

chat_sohbet

christina_aguilera

cicek_cicekler

Cindy_crawford

cine5_sifre_kirici_yeni

cine5_sifreleri

cinsellik

cinsellik_ask

cinsel-sapkinliklar-travestizm

ciplak_kizlar

ciplak_unluler_foto

citir_kizlar

claudia_schiffer

cnn-turk

cocuklar_cocuklar_icin

cok-komik

cok-ozel-resimler

corn_pictures

counter_strike

crack_cdkey

cs_1_6_full_download

cv_ornekleri

define-madenler

deniz_denizler

deniz_seki

deprem_kandilli

dergi_dergiler

ders_notlari

dershane_dersler

dijital_yayin

dijital-tv-sifreleri

dijiturk_canli_yayin

dilek_dilekler

dini_ekartlar

disk_diskler



diyarbakir_bilim_tip

dizi_diziler

dizi_muzikleri

dizi-muzikleri

dogum_gunu

dogum_gunu_davetiyeler

dogum_gunu_hazir_cep_mesajlari

dogum_gunu_kutlama_mesajlari

dokuzuncu-hariciye-kogusu

donem_odevi

donem-odevi

dost_dostluk

dostluk_hazir_cep_mesajlari

dosya_dosya_paylasimi

doviz_dovuz_kurlari

dowland-murat-kekilli

download

download-fza

duvar_kagitlari

duvar_yazilari

duvar_yazisi

duvar-kagitlari

duzenle

ebru-gundes-indir-dinle

edebiyatla-ilgili-komik-fikralar

efe-hotel

egitim_egitimler

egitim-ogretim

eglence_eglencelik

ehliyet-sinav-sonuclari

ekran_monitor

ekran_ses_kartlari

el_ile_yuklenen_melodiler

elazig_mhp_belediyesi

Electra_Carmen

elektronik-devre-cizim-programi

eleman_elemanlar

elite-turk

Elle-Macpherson

email_e-mailler

emekli_emeklilik

emlak_emlakcilar

ems_logo

en_atesli_taraftar

en-guzel-ask-siirleri

en-hizli-kosan-kus

en-iyi-siteler

ensest

ensest_resimleri

ericson-melodileri

ericson-samsung-cep-telefonlari

erkek_erkekler

erkek-erkekler

erotik_video_klipler

erotik-ask-ve-cinsel-arzular

erotik-hikayeler

erotik-itiraflar

erotik-resimler

erotik-resimler-bayan

erotizm

erotizm-ve-cinsellik

eski-antika-paralar

espri_espriler

Estella-Warren

etek-alti-resimleri

etkileyici-sozler

Eva-Herzigova

evli-kadinlar

evlilik-hazir-cep-mesajlari

ezan-ezanlar

f1-formala-grand

fal-tarot-fallari

fantezi-resimleri

fare-mause

felsefe-kulubu

felsefe-sozlugu

fenerbahce_hazir_cep_mesajlari

fenerbahce-hazir-cep-mesajlari

fikra-komik-fikralar

filiz-akin

film-gibi

fizyoloji

flash

flash_flashlar

flashget-1.65

flash-komikler

flash-swish-yeni

flort

flower-flowers

formula-1

forum_basvurusu

forum-forumlar

free-mp3-download

free-tv

frikik-frikikler

futbol-yorum

galatasaray-hazir-cep-mesaj

game_dos

gazeteler

gazeteler-gazete

gece-yolculari-yeni-mp3

gecmis_olsun_cep_mesajlari

gecmis-olsun-hazir-cep-mesajlari

gelinim-olurmusun

gelinlik_modelleri

gelinlik-modelleri

gem-wk1

gercek-muzikler

gerekli_siteler

gerekli-siteler

geyik_komedi

geyik-ve-otesi

gezi-geziler

gif-gifler

Gisele-Bundchen

giyilmesi-yasak-kisveler

gizli-kamera-frikik-resimleri

gizli-klasor-download

gokyuzu-neden-mavidir

gora-film-replikleri

green-card-turkiye

gta-kurtlar-vadisi

gta-vice-city-yamalar

gulmek-inin-nedenler

gunesin-sicaklik-derecesi

gunluk-guncel-ve gazete

guzel_sozler1

guzeller_galerisi

guzel-mesajlar

haber-borsa

haber-haberler

hakan-toprak

Halle-Berry

hande-yener

harika-avci

harita-haritalar

Harry-Potter-Prisoner-of-Azkaban

hasan-yasar

hatiralar

hatun-hatunlar

hayat-hikayeleri

hayir-hayir-olamaz

hayvan-hayvanlaralemi

hayvan-resimleri

hazir_mesajlar

hazir_mesajlar2

haziran-gecesi

haziran-gecesi-resimleri

Heidi-Klum

hex-renk-kodlari

host-hosting

hulya-avsar

hulya-avsar-resimleri

hz-ali

ibrahim-tatlises

iddaa_canli_maclar

iddaa-bahis

iddaa-iddaa-sonuclari

ilac-fiyatlari

ilahi-mp3ler

ilce-ilceler

ilginc

ilginc-ilginc_resimler

iliski-iliskiler

ilk-bulusma

ilk-ogretim

ingiliz-ingilizce

ingiltere-hotel-fiyatlari

insaat-sirketleri

insan-insanlar

inter-internet

internetten-para-kazanmak

irakta-iskence-fotograflari

irakta-kafa-kesme-goruntuleri

irmak-unal-resimleri

is-search

isimler

isimleri

islami-ilahiler

islam-islamiyet

ismail-yk

is-makinalari

istanbul_cihangir

italyan-yazarlar

itiraf_itiraflar

iyi_yolculuklar_hazir_cep_mesajlari

iyiki_ask_var

izmirin-doga-resimleri

java-javalar

java-sanal-makinasi

java-scriptler

Jennifer-Lopez

Jenny-McCarthy

Joshua-Malina

joyturk

kader-kaderimsin

kadin_moda_bakim

kadin-dogum-kontrolu

kadin-kadinlar

kadinlar_ve_erkekler

kagit-icat

kalp-kazanmak

kalp-resimleri

kandil_mesajlari

kandil-mesajlari

kapadokya

kapi_kolu

karadeniz

kara-kalem-calismalari

karikatur

kart-kartlar

kayahan-yeni-albüm

kaya-metal

kazaa

kazaa_lite_download

kendini_aska_birak

kilavuz

kirac-bedava-mp3-indir

kita-kitalar

kitapevleri

kizlar

klavye

klip-klipler

Knight_Online

kolejli_kizlar

komedi-komik

komik_fikralar

komik_flash_animasyon

komik_gazete

komik_karikaturler

komik_resimler

komik_sms

komik_sms_sozleri

komik_tv

komikev

komik-hazir-mesajlar

komik-siteler

komik-sozler

komik-videolar

konferans-duyurusu

korpe_kizlar

kpss

kpss-sinav-sonuclari-aciklandi

kredi-karti-basvurusu

kredi-kredikarti

Kultur_Sanat

kultur-kulturel

kulup-kulupler

kurban-bayrami-mesajlari

kurtlar_vadisi

kurtlar_vadisi_melodileri

kurtlar-vadisi

kurtlar-vadisi-melodileri

kurumlar-vergisi

kutlama_hazir_cep_mesajlari

kutlama-mesajlari

Kylie-Minogue

lez_lezbiyen

lise

liseler-kolejler

liseli_kizlar

liseli_kizlarin_sex_resimleri

liseli-dilara

liseli-kizlarla-sinirsiz-sohbet

liseli-lolitalar

lise-liseler

list-hotel-antalya

logomelodi

logo-melodi

love-ask-mesajlari

mac_maclar

mac-maclar

magazin

mailturk

maket-otomobil

mani-mesajlari

manken-frikikleri

mankenler

manzaralar

manzara-resimleri

maria-sharapova

mario-oyunu

markalar

meb-lise-ilkokul

medya

mehmet-ali-nuroglu

memurlar

mesaj-at

messenger-hata

midi-midiler

milli-piyango

mirc-reklam-botu

mirc-scriptler

misrosoft-front-pages-2003

mobilya

modem-adsl

modem-modemler

modifiye

monica-bellucci

motorlu_tasitlar

motor-motorsiklet

motorola_cep_telefonu_modelleri

mp3-mp3ler

msn-arkadas

msn-arkadaslik-siteleri

msn-messenger

muhabbet

muhasebe-elemanlari

murat-gogebakan

muslum-gurses

mustafa_kemal_ataturk

mustafa-sandal

mutfak

muzik

muzik_yeni_albumler

muzik-sistemleri

muzik-siteleri

nokia-wav

nasil-oynanir

natalia-nataly

nazan-oncal-mp3leri

naz-elmas-resimleri

need-for-speed-underground

nefret-mesajlari

nez-frikikleri

noel-dayi

nokia_cep_telefonu_modelleri

nokia_melodileri

nokia-cep-telefonlari

nokia-oyunlari

norton-antivirus

nostaji-mp3

numara

numaralar

oflu-hoca

ogrenci

ogretmen1



okey-oyunu

okullar

online_bahis

online_muzik-dinle

online_oyunlar

online-muzik.dinle

opusmek

ordu-resimleri

Orospu-MaNKeNLeR

oss

osym-sonuclari

otel-hoteller

oto-lastik-resimleri

otomobil-araba

otomobil-resimleri

oyun_hileleri

oyun-hileleri

oyun-oyunlar

oyun-siteleri

ozge-ozberk-resimleri

ozlem-mesajlari

ozlem-ozlemek

ozlu-mesajlar

ozur_mesajlari

ozur-mesajlari

Pamela-Anderson

paparazi_magazin

pc-computer

pekiyi

pembesayfa

Penelope-Cruz

penis-rahatsizliklari

php-scriptler

pinar-kurkut

plan-planlar

platonik-ask

playboy-kizlari

polifonik-melodi

Porno-Sex

posta-kodlari

program_download

program-arsivi

psikiyatri

pusulayi-kim-icat-etti

radyo-dinle

ramazan-bayrami-mesajlari

rejim-diyet

renkli-animasyon

renkli-logo

renkli-resimli-mesajlar

resimler

resimli-mesajlar

rize-artvin

rus-hackerlar

ruya

ruya-tabirleri

ruya-yorumlari

sadece-sex

safranbolu

saglikli-beslenme

Sagopa-Kajmer

sahibinden-kiralik-daireler

sahin-mgp

sair-sairler

saka-sakalar

samsung_cep_telefonu_modelleri

sanal-sex

sanat-sanatlar

sanayi-rehberi

Sandra-Bullock

sans-oyunlari

sari-yildiz

sans_dilekleri_hazir_cep_mesajlari

sarkicilar

sarki-mesajlari

sarkisozu

satilik-turkcell-hat

sayfa-yukleniyor

sayisal-loto

script_scriptler

seda-sayan-parcalari

sehir-sehirler

seks-hikayeleri

semra-hanim

seray-sever

seslichat

sesli-chat

Seslisohbet

sesli-sozluk

sevda-karababa

sevgi_forum

sevgi_mesajlari

sevgi_sevgiliye

sevgi_siirleri

sevgi_sozleri

sevgili_ne_arar

sevgililer_gunu

sevgiliye-mesajlar

sevgi-mesajlari

sevgi-sevgili

sevgiye-ve-aska-dair

sex_hatiralari

sex_hikayeleri

sex-arkadasiniz-cevriye

sex-filmi

sexhikayeleri

sex-partner

seyahat

sezen-aksu

showtv_ikinci_bahar

showtv-frekans

sibel_can_resimleri

sibel-Can

Sibel-Kekilli

siemens_cep_telefonu_modelleri

sifali_bitkiler

sifre-kirici

siir-siirler

Sima-Karatar

simens

sinav

sinav-sorulari

sinema

sinema-sinemalar

siyaset-siteleri

sms

sms_mesajlari

sohbet_aski

sohbetodalari

sohbetodasi

son-dakika-haber

son-dakika-spor

Sony_Ericsson_cep_telefonu_modelleri

sorular

sozluk

sp2-kurulum-hatasi-lisansli

spor_mesajlari

sporcu

spor-sporlar

sports

ssk_hizmet_dokumu

ssk-emekli

SSK-Hizmet-Dokumu

supermp3

superonline

surucu-kurlari

tahmin

takimlar

Tanyeli

tarih

Tarot-Fallari

tasitlar-vergisi

tatil

tatli-tatlilar

tavla-oyna

tc-kimlik-numarasi

TC-Kira-Kanunlari

teklif-mesajlari

teknoloji-bilim

telefon-elektrik-borcu-sorma

telefon-faturasi-sorgulama

telefon-melodileri

Telekom-ADSL

telsim_melodileri

tema

Temel-Fikralar

tiyatro

toplist-scriptler

travel

travesti

tsunami-goruntuleri

Tugba

Tugba-Ekinci

Tugba-Ozay

turistlik-yerler

turizm

turkce_mp3

turkce_sohbet

turkce_ve_yabanci_mp3

Turkce-chat

turkce-download

Turkcell

turkcell_cep_mesaj

Turkce-Mp3

Turkce-Muzik

Turkce-Sohbet

turk-guzeller

turkiye_alternatif_turlari

turku-mesajlari

turlar

tv-radyo

Tyra-Banks

ucretsiz

ucretsizler

ucretsiz-mesaj-atma

ucretsiz-mp3

ucuzluk

Ucuz-Ucak-Bileti

Ucuz-Web-Hosting

ugur-isilak

ulkeler-ulkesi

underground

universiteler

Universiteli-Genclerin-sorunlari

Universiteli-Kizlar

unlulerin-burclari

Unlulerin-Pozlari

Unluler-Ve-Erotizm

Unut-Beni-Sevgilim

Utangac

Uydudan-Casusluk

Uydu-Frekans

Uydu-sifreleri

Vatandaslik-No-Sorgulama

vatandaslik-numarasi

VCD

Vefasiz-Dostlar

vergi

Vergi-Kimlik-No

vergi-kimlik-numarasi

voleybol

Wallpaper

Wap-GPRS-Ayarlari

webcam

web-cam

Web-Dersleri

Xlarge-logo

Yabanci-Gazeteler

Yabanci-Mankenler

yabanci-mp3

Yabanci-Sarkilar

Yabanci-Sarki-Sozleri

Yamalar

yanlis_ask

yanlizlik-mesajlari

yarislar-yarismalar

Yasak-Resimler

yasaksiz

Yasemin-Ergene

Yas-farki

Yataklar

yayin-evleri

Yayin-Online

yazar-yazarlar

yemek-pasta-tarifleri

yeni_yil_hazir_cep_mesajlari

yeni-albümleri

Yenicag

Yeni-Trafik-Cezalari

yeniyil-mesajlari

yeniyilsms

Yerlimp3

yerli-mp3

yillik-odevler

Yol-Hava-Durumu

Yusuf-Ziya-Onis

Zaga-Okan-Bayulgen

Zamana-Birak

zayiflamak_diyet

Zeliha-Cal

Zerda-melodileri

Zerrin-Egeliler

zil-sesleri

Ziyaretci-Defteri

Ziynet-Sali

3650.program.yukle



6230.wap




6600.bedava.oyunlar




6600.program



6600.symbian.programi



6600.symbian.programi



6600.symbian.videolar



6600.walpaper



7610.themes



acem.kizi.kurtlar.vadisi



adsl.dalnet



adsl.online.kota.takip



ahmet.kaya.mp3



aliye.dizi.muzikleri.download



almanca.sozluk



altdvb



amcik



amr.komik.ses



anadolu.guzel.sanatlar.liseleri



anal.sex




animasyon.mizah.komik




animasyonlar.net



antifener




araba.ses.tesisat.com



arac.vergisi



aramam.ibrahim.tatlises



aramam.remix.free.download



arzum



ascii.nickname.construction



asker.siiri



askerlik.subesi.baskanligi



asp.nuke



avsar.ciplak




ay.ikinci.insan



bagkur.borcu.sorgulama.sayfasi



balca.net



banu.alkan




banyo.aksesuar



basur



batak.online




bebek.isimleri




bedava.melodileri



beta.glukan




bilardo.oyunu




bilinmeyen.numara.sorma.servisi



boxer.dergisi.ceza.elif



burc.yorumlari



candan.ercetin.mp3.yalan.free



canli.muzik.dinle



canli.skorlar



cansu.derenin.ciplak.resimleri



casper.klavye.surum



cdkey.serial.no




cehennem.geceleri



cem.yilmazin.yeni.reklami



cengiz.kurtoglu.full.mp3



cep.dunyasi



cep.symbian.oyun.indir



ceptelefonu



ceza.dosyalari



chat.odalari



cine5.sifresi



cine5.xp



cinsel.capkinliklar



ciplak.kizlar



counter.strike.server.cokertmek



crack



cv.ornekleri



davet.kartlari



deep.freezeindir



dell.axim.cep.bilgisayar.u0131



demet.akalin



dev.insan

 dinle.hz.omer



disco.karadeniz



discovery.biss.key



divx.filmler.download



divx.indirme.programlari



divx.torrent




diyet.listesi



dizi.muzikleri



dj.akman



dj.ekipman



dj.onur.web



dogum.gunu.hediyesi



dostluk



dowland.murat.kekilli



download



download.tr



dursun.ali.erzincanli



dvb.s.offline.download



ebru.destan



ebru.gediz.resimleri



ehliyet.sinav



ehliyet.sinavi



ekart



eleman




emekli.vergi.iade



emrah.keskin



ensest.filmler



erdogan.rize




erkek.resimleri



erken.bosalma




erotik.hikaye




erotik.resim




erotik.resimler.bayan.arkadas



etek.alti




etek.modelleri



etkileyici.sozler



ezan.symbian



fal



fenerbahce.futbolcu.resimleri



feridun.duzagac



fifa.2005.blz.uzantili



film.kemal.sunal.wav



film.yildizlari



filmler



flash.animasyon



flash.mx.crack



football.manager.2005.nasil



fotograf.siteleri



free.x.tv.progdvb



frikik



frikik.tugba.ozay




frikikler.resimler.videolar



full.albumler.bedava.mp3



galatasaray.dergisi



gamegarden.net.gamegarden.net



gamze.ozcelik.popstar.dans.video



gece.yolculari.full.mp3



gece.yolculari.mp3



gelinlikler




geometri.konu.anlatimi




gitar.program



gizli.fotograflar.ve.erotizm




gizli.kamera



gora.bedava.indirmek



gta.kurtlar.vadisi



gulben.ergen



gulsen.video.klip



guzel.kizlar



guzel.resimler



guzel.sozler.dostluk



haber



hack.programi



hacker.programlari



half.life.2.multiplayer.menu




hastane.yemek.masalari



hayalevi




hayvan.resimleri



hayvan.sex




hayvanlarla.seks.resimleri



hazir.mesaj




haziran.gecesi




hediye.secimi.erkek



hikayeler



hile.klavuzu



hileler




hitmp3tr.com



hotmail.hack



hotmail.messenger.7.0



hulya.avsar.foto



ibrahim.tatlises



icq.2004



iddaa



iddaa.mac.kodlari



iddaa.programi



ikinci.el.traktorler



ikinciel.ucuz.sdram



ilahi.islami



ilahiler




ilahiler.kaderimsin




ilmihal.bilgileri



imam.sayko




indirme.2004.sarkilar



ingilizce.turkce.sozluk



internette.beyin.okuma



internetten.para.kazanmak



isim.sozluk

islami.chat



ismail.yk.sappur.suppur



itiraf



itiraflar



japon.amciklar



java.program.nokia



kader.utansin.mp.indir




kanal.d.dijital



kanald.zaga



kanun.tasarilari



karadeniz.manzara.rize



kars.tarihi



kayahan.seninle.hersey.varim.ben.mp3.download



kazaa.lite



kekilli.sibel



kekilli



keremcem



kimlik.numarasi



kitap



kizlar



kizlik.zari.kanamasi



klip




komik.seslermp3




komik.videolar




komikler.com.komik.siteler




korku.siteleri




kral.resimleri



kraltv.net




kurtlar.vadisi.animasyon




kurtlar.vadisi.halil.ibrahim.mp3




kurtlar.vadisi.mp3




kurtlar.vadisi.online



laptop.aksesuarlari



leman.sam.gul.guzeli.mp3



lezbiyen.vcd



lgs.deneme.sinavi



liseli



liseli.dilara.gizli.cekim.video



liseli.kizlar



liseli.kizlarla.sinirsiz.chat



liseli.lolita



liseli.turk.kizlari



liseli.vcd



macromedia.flash.mx.dersleri



mahsun.kirmizigul.nemrudun.kizi.mp3



mankenler



manzara




manzara.resimleri



manzara.wallpaperlari



mario.oyunu



masal




matematik.kitap



melodi.icin.uyeler.zil.sesleri



melodiler



messenger.7.0.beta.indir



messenger.7.0.turkce



messenger.baglanti.hatasi



midi.dosyalari




mobilya.yatak.odasi



modifiye



moonstar



motosiklet



movie.maker.dersleri



mp3.populer.ve.hit.mp3ler



mp3.turkce.pamela.istanbul



msn.messenger.6.2tr



msn.messenger.7.0.turkce



muhasebe.elemanlari.is.ilanlari



mustafa.isyankar.mp3



mustafa.yildizdogan.turkce.mp3.indir



muzik



muzik.dinleme.siteleri



muzik.indir



mynet.chat



naz.elmas



need.for.speed.underground.2.trainer



nemrudun.kizi



neoragex.roms



next.uydu.alici



nfs.underground.2.turkce.download



nokia.6230.bedeva.oyun.indirme



nokia.6600.symbian.programlari



nokia.bounce



nokia.symbian.oyun



norton.antivirus.2005.turkish.download



norton.ghost.2003.crack



norton.ghost.download.full



oflu.hoca



okey.oyun



okey.ucretsiz.oyunu




orospu.mankenler



otomobil.gumruk.vergisi



oyun




oyun.hileleri



pamela.istanbul.mp3




partner.sanal



pembesayfa



penis



penis.rahatsizliklari



photoshop.teknikleri



planlar



pokeimam.download



polofonik.yeniler



porno.siteler



programlar



ps2.tr



r3x.project



resimler




romantik.e.kartlar



ruya.tabirleri



ruya.yorumlari



sagopa.kajmer



sahibinden.satilik.araba



samsung.mmf



seks.arkadasi



seks.fotograflari




seksi.travestiler



semra.klip.televole




sen.yoktun.ilahisi




server.kurulumu



sesli.sozluk



sevgi.ask.e.kartlari



sevgililer.gunu




sevgiliye.hitap



sevgiliye.siirler




seviyeli.sohbet



sex.arkadasiniz.cevriye



sex.filmi




sex.hikayeleri




sexi.hatunlar.firikikler.gizli




sezen.aksu.zalim



show.tv



showtv



showtv.frekans



sibel.can



sibel.kekilli.download



sibelcan



sicil.numarasi.vergi.borclarini.ogrenmek.icin



siemens



sifre.cozuculer



siir.ve.guzelsozler



siirler



sikis




silah.krom.kaplama.teknigi

23.nisan.html



5.sevgi.dili.html

a..k.html

a.k.html

aciklama.html

acilis.html

acisi.html

adam.asmaca.html

adresim.sevgi.html

adult.chat.html

ahmet.altan.html

ahmet.arif.html

ahmet.html

ahmet.selcuk.ilkan.html

ahmetarif.html

alman.chat.html

almanca.chat.html

almanca.html

almanya.chat.html

alo.sohbet.html

amiga.oyun.html

amigart.html

amigart.sohbet.html

anet.oyun.html

animasyonlar.html

ankara.chat.html

anlaml.html

anlamli.html

anneler.gunu.html

anneler.html

antik.oyun.html

antikoyun.html

antoloji.htm

antolojisi.html

araba.html

araba.yarisi.html

araba.yarisi.oyun.html

araliklari.html

arayanlar.html

aria.hat.html

ariyorum.html

arkadas.chat.html

arkadas.html

arkadas.sohbet.html

arkadascafe.html

arkadaslik.html

as.html

ashk.html

asik.html

asik.veysel.html

ask.html

ask.sevgi.guzel.sozler.html

ask.sevgi.html

ask.sevgi.mesajlari.html

ask.sevgi.siir.html

ask.sevgi.siirleri.html

ask.sevgi.sms.html

ask.sevgi.sozcukleri.html

ask.sevgi.sozleri.html

ask.siirleri.html

ask.ve.sevgi.html

ask.ve.sevgi.mesajlari.html

ask.ve.sevgi.siirleri.html

ask.ve.sevgi.sozcukleri.html

ask.ve.sevgi.sozleri.html

aska.dair.html

asker.html

aski.html

askim.html

asklar.html

askmesajlari.html

asksiirleri.html

asksozleri.html

asp.chat.html

assk.html

atasozleri.html

ateri.html

australian.html

avrupa.chat.html

avustralya.chat.html

ayarlari.html

aycell.hat.html

ayrilik.html

ayva.html

azerbaycan.chat.html

azeri.chat.html

bahcesi.html

baram.html

barbie.oyun.html

baskadir.html

basketbol.oyun.kurallari.html

batak.html

batak.oyun.html

bayram.html

bedava.chat.html

bedava.oyun.download.html

bedava.oyun.html

bedava.oyun.indir.html

bedava.oyun.indirme.html

bedava.oyun.linkler.html

bedava.oyun.yukleme.html

bedava.sohbet.html

bedavaoyun.html

bedeva.oyun.html

beles.html

beles.oyun.html

benim.html

besiktas.html

beton.html

bilardo.html

bilardo.oyun.html

bilgisayar.html

bilgisayar.oyun.hileleri.html

bilgisayar.oyun.html

bilgisayara.html

bilgisayarda.html

biliyormusun.html

bir.html

biric.html

bitmeyen.oyun.html

bizimalem.html

bric.html

bric.oyun.html

bulmak.html

bulucu.html

burclar.html

bursa.chat.html

calma.html

calmak.html

cam.chat.html

camara.html

camera.chat.html

camerali.chat.html

camerali.html

camgirlslive.html

can.dundar.html

can.yucel.html

canada.chat.html

canim.html

canli.chat.html

canli.html

canli.sohbet.html

cd.oyun.html

cd.siz.oyun.html

cdsiz.oyun.html

cemberi.html

cep.oyun.html

cep.sevgi.mesajlari.html

cesitleri.html

cet.html

cezmi.ersoz.html

chat.adresleri.html

chat.applet.html

chat.arkadas.html

chat.asp.html

chat.cam.html

chat.de.html

chat.download.html

chat.english.html

chat.free.html

chat.gen.tr.html

chat.goruntulu.html

chat.html

chat.kanali.html

chat.kanallari.html

nisan.php



guzel_sozler.php

akparti.php

universiteler.php

universite.php

belediyeler.php

valilik.php

valilikler.php

belediye.php

belediyesi.php

akbank.php

halkbank.php

ziraat_bankasi.php

yurtlar.php

yurt.php

ahmetarif.php

chat.php

camforg.php

camfrong.php

muzik.php

magazin.php

muzikler.php

muzikleri.php

mp3.php

uyeliksiz.php

animasyonlar.php

ankara.php

istanbul.php

izmir.php

antalya.php

anneler.php

islami.php

sohbet.php

antoloji.phpm

antolojisi.php

araba.php

araba_yarisi.php

araba_yarisi._oyunu.php

fizik.php

kimya.php

msn_hack.php

resim.php

siirleri.php

siir.php

arkadas.php

resimleri.php

okul.php

okulu.php

lise.php

liseli.php

as.php

kadin.php

kadini.php

kadinlar.php

odev.php

odevi.php

odevleri.php

donem_odevi.php

motor.php

trafik.php

lisesi.php

deniz_akkaya.php

filmler.php

filmleri.php

album.php

mp3_albumu.php

indir.php

indirme.php

ferdi.php

ferdi_tayfur.php

ibrahim.php

porno.php

porno_video.php

sex.php

youtube.php

izlesene.php

izle.php

filmi.php

son_album.php

son_albumu.php

liseler.php

tekken.php

ssk.php

turkiye.php

pvc.php

alci.php

dekor.php

dekorasyon.php

kuruyemis.php

findik.php

fistik.php

cerez.php

Mebalian.php

turizm.php

tatil.php

tatil_bolgeleriarlari.php

denizler.php

havadurumu.php

oteller.php

pansiyon.php

kara_yollari.php

almanya.php

konsolosluk.php

iddaa.php

sonuc.php

say?sal.php

sonuclari.php

ganyan_sonuclar?.php

say?sal_loto.php

okey.php

batak_oyun.php

bayram.php

bedava.php

sinemalar.php

sinema.php

memurlar.php

forum.php

emlak.php

emlak_vergisi.php

sigorta_sicil.php

oys.php

kpss.php

kpss_sonuclar?.php

galatasaray.php

fenerbahce.php

oyun_sitesi.php

besiktas.php

chat_sitesi.php

sohbet_sitesi.php

ceylan.php

yildiz_tilbe.php

hulya_avsar.php

davut_guloglu.php

ece_erken.php

download.php

kazananlar.php

sinav.php

mesaj.php

cep.php

cep_telefonu.php

cep_telefonlari.php

cep_muzik.php

cep_logo.php

sosyete.php

sendikalar.php

teoman.php

burclar.php

muzik_market.php

marketler.php

kizyurdu.php

cam.php

camara.php

sozluk.php

sozlugu.php

sozlukler.php

sozlukleri.php

turkce_muzik.php

pop_muzik.php

arebesk.php

fantazi.php

sesli_chat.php

canli.php

canli_sex.php

ekart.php

siirli_ekart.php

ask_sozleri.php

toplist.php

toplistler.php

itiraf.php

gazeteler.php

ingilizce_turkce_sozluk.php

fransizca_sozluk.php

ingilizce_sozluk.php

oss.php

lgs.php

oks.php

hosting.php

online_ehliyet_sinavi.php

ehliyet.php

surucu_kursu.php

Knightonline.php

msn.8.0.php

msn.8.1.php

msn

komik_video.php

kral_oyun.php

kraloyun.php

msn_sekilleri.php

wallpapers.php

testler.php

script.php

mirc32.php

mirc.php

duz_mirc.php

duzmirc.php

kurtce_muzik.php

kurtce_sinema.php

kurtce_tv.php

liverograms.php

live_cam.php

girl.php

girls.php

gril.php

chat_script.php

online_radyo.php

radyo.php

sam2.php

radyo_programi

canli_tv.php

bahis.php

edebiyat.php

oto.php

otomobil.php

guzeller.php

gay.php

citir.php

lolita.php

lolitalar.php

konu_anlatimi.php

birim.php

birim_fiyatlar.php

sirketi.php

tib.php

tip.php

tibbi.php

avrupa_yakasi.php

ezo_gelin.php

kurtlar_vadisi.php

kurtlar_vadisi_pusu.php

tavla.php

oyuntr.php

sabah.php

hurriyet.php

milliyet.php

tiyatro.php

chatline.php

dijiturk.php

digiturk.php

dsmart.php

smart.php

turkcell.php

avea.php

wodafone.php

cine5.php

ilahi.php

ilahisi.php

ilahiler.php

cocuk.php

cocuk_oyunu.php

cocuk_oyunlari.php

kandil_mesajlar?.php

vizyon.php

vizyondakiler.php

anal.php

smsuklar.icin.oyun.php

sms_mesajlar?.php

hatun.php

rus_kizlari.php

comtr.php

com.php

net.php

copcatan.php

tercih.php

tercihler.php

komik.php

cozuculer.php

cozumleri.php

cracklari.php

crackleri.php

crack.php

nod32.php

avats.php

antivir.php

antivirus.php

komik_fikralar.php

komik_filmler.php

sakamatik.php

saka.php

fm.php

kelebek.php

anadolu.php

deneme.php

maliye.php

fiyat.php

dantel.php

orgu.php

oya.php

fiskos.php

discilik.php

pagerank.php

rank.php

doktoru.php

doktor.php

haber.php

guncel_haber.php

yeni_haber.php

sondakika.php

burslar.php

ogretim.php

ogrenim.php

kredi_ve_yurtlar.php

devlet_yurtlar?.php

devlet_kurumlar?.php

sanayii.php

ruya_tabiri.php

ruya_tabirleri.php

ruya.php

duvar_yazilari.php

duvaryazilari.php

duygu.php

duygulu.php

duygusal.php

ulkucu.php

mhp.php

saadet_partisi.php

sp.php

bbp.php

fanatik.php

ogretmen_evi.php

egitim.php

cicekci.php

ikinci_el.php

ikinci_el_fiyatlari.php

eczane.php

eczaneler.php

bilgi.php

bilgisi.php

din_bilgisi.php

dil_bilgisi.php

disisleri.php

ikinci_el_fiyati.php

gel.php



ben.php

tigtag.php

sen.php

bedeva.php

ankara.php

adana.php

afyon.php

ardahan.php

adiyaman.php

bolu.php

bingol.php

bitlis.php

batman.php

bilecik.php

bursa.php

balikesir.php

cankiri.php

diyarbakir.php

denizli.php

duzce.php

eskisekir.php

edirne.php

giresun.php

hakkari.php

hatay.php

koceli.php

sakarya.php

canakkale.php

kahraman_maras.php

kutahya.php

kirikkale.php

kirklareli.php

manisa.php

mugla.php

mardin.php

nevsehir.phpm

nigde.php

corum.php

aksaray.php

osmaniye.php

ordu.php

rize.php

sivas.php

siirt.php

sinop.php

sanliurfa.php

tekirdag.php

tunceli.php

trabzon.php

zonguldak.php

sanatcilar.php

ibrahim_tatlises.php

mahsun_kirmizigul.php

serdar_ortac.php

keremcem.php