Rudy Giuliani: Hegelian?

In partial defense of Rudy Giuliani's seemingly creepy and authoritarian notion that "freedom is about the willingness of every single human being to cede to lawful authority a great deal of discretion about what you do" I believe this is essentially the view the great philosopher G.W.F. Hegel's view of the matter as well. He's still, I think, a pretty creepy authoritarian but the idea he's expressing has a reasonably distinguished lineage and isn't just some madness he dreamed up on his couch one afternoon.

What's more, if you back a way a little from Giuliani's extreme formulation of the claim I think you'll see that there's some wisdom in it. The cause of political liberty is not, in fact, served by living in an underpoliced city. Generally speaking, while freedom does require that authority not overstep its proper bounds, it also very much requires that properly constituted authorities be reasonably strong and effective. The absence of effective state institutions does not make contemporary Baghdad freer" than Boston in any way that makes "freedom" denote a worthwhile political ideal.

Comments


Man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains.

Posted by: Jean Jacques Rousseau on March 21, 2007 04:22 PM

freedoms...just another word for nothin' left to lose

Posted by: judson on March 21, 2007 04:24 PM

I'll fade you one "license" for two "freedoms."

Posted by: Ellen1910 on March 21, 2007 04:27 PM

Well, freedom requires authority, but in the context of our current conversation about things like the Patriot Act, terrorism and what-have-you, I think this is a strange thing to be bringing up. There is no credible movement to abolish the state in this country, for example.

Down to the particulars: how does Giuliani think we need to increase the role of authority in the world today?

The abstract, philosophical point may be worth making but the particulars are the most relevant thing.

Posted by: mk on March 21, 2007 04:31 PM

Freedom is about the willingness of every single human being to cede to lawful authority a great deal of discretion about what you do: Giuliani 2008!

Necessary, perhaps, but certainly not a sufficient definition of freedom.

Though, I think that'd look nice next to my yellow ribbon bumper sticker.

Posted by: AJ on March 21, 2007 04:38 PM

Wow man, so we should have, like, laws and stuff? You're blowing my mind.

Posted by: uh yeah on March 21, 2007 04:38 PM

Speaking authoritarian figures, John Bolton was on the Daily Show last night. It was really interesting listening to him talk: he was seriously arguing, I think, that to get in the President's way, to prevent him from carrying out any action he wished in the Executive branch that wasn't explicitly illegal, was undemocratic. I had the feeling that almost everything he said about his version of democracy could be applied to a non-democratic, authoritarian government, without much modification. It wasn't subtle. For example, one line I remember is this: "The President has the responsibility to be true to the people who voted for him." Actually, the President is responsible to all of us, not just those who voted for him. The mind boggles.

Posted by: RSA on March 21, 2007 04:46 PM

Isn't this essentially Hobbes's thesis in Leviathan? I read it 25 years ago, and frankly it was tough sledding, but I recall this being the solution to the natural human state of the war of all against all.

Coming from Rudy though it makes you envision a gaggle of brownshirts and "Tomorrow Belongs to Me" playing in the background. Or maybe that's just a Cabaret flashback.

Posted by: Klein's Tiny Left Nut on March 21, 2007 04:46 PM

Of course, that is the argument that has been made by every authoritarian in history who has bothered to justify their dictatorship with democratic rhetoric.

But, no, you're right, more cops means more freedom. Got it.

Posted by: Freddie on March 21, 2007 04:50 PM

Re: "freedom is about the willingness of every single human being to cede to lawful authority a great deal of discretion about what you do".

Or, as one NYC policeman put it so succinctly: "its Giulianni time!".

Posted by: Jim W on March 21, 2007 04:56 PM

Of course this is the liberal attitude. Big government is ALL ABOUT "ceding to lawful authority a great deal of discretion about what you do". Liberals want to be able to say that, e.g., government takeover of the entire health care system of the country is somehow not authoritarian. Um, sorry, no.

Government takeover of the entire healthcare system is far more authoritarian than anything Rudy ever did or proposes to do.

Posted by: Al on March 21, 2007 04:57 PM

I think the liberal version would be:

"freedom is about the willingness of every single human being to agree to cede to a lawful authority a degree of discretion about what you do, though such agreement can be recinded if said authority begins to act in an unlawful manner."

Posted by: cvcobb01 on March 21, 2007 04:58 PM

Must I cede to lawful authority my discretion about what I pay my employees? Minimum wage is authoritarian.

Must I cede to lawful authority my discretion about how much CO2 I emit? Global warming caps are authoritarian.

I can go on forever. You get the point.

Posted by: Al on March 21, 2007 05:01 PM

Grrrargh!

Now give me your guns!

Grrr! I'm Rudy Guiliani! Do it because I said so!

Posted by: anonymous on March 21, 2007 05:02 PM

Rudy Giuiani banned dancing! I'm not seeing the upside to that one.

Posted by: Jackmormon on March 21, 2007 05:04 PM

Wait, Rudy banned dancing? When? I danced in NYC during the Giuliani era. Not well, mind you, but I did.

Posted by: Al on March 21, 2007 05:08 PM

Hegel/Schmegel. It sound like one component of generic contractarianism to me. The social contract both limits and expands freedoms. There are natural liberties which we all possess in the "state of nature" and don't really want to lose, but ceding some of them is the cost for membership in a civilized society. In exchange, we derive certain benefits, including certain new freedoms, like the freedom to walk about without getting clubbed on the head by someone trying to take our apples, or the freedom to listen to recorded music, a product of human industry which doesn't exist in the state of nature on either the Hobbesian or Lockean conception.

Posted by: Dan Kervick on March 21, 2007 05:09 PM

It is truly odd how the Republican party manages to be BOTH the "law & order" party and the "Libertarian" party. It sure looks like what it's actually being is the party that furthers the interests of the wealthy and upper-middle class white male population. I mean, that seems to explain most of their policy positions fairly well. But, I'm sure it has some sort of larger ideological justification . . . .

Posted by: MDtoMN on March 21, 2007 05:13 PM

Matt, coupling Hegel with that quote of Giuliani's is more of an indictment of Hegel than something that lends Giuliani an intellectual air. Just because Aristotle was a misogynist doesn't put saying that a woman's place is in the home on solid intellectual ground.

Posted by: Clark on March 21, 2007 05:15 PM

Al, you missed the cabaret laws? Here's an account of one protest against them, back when protests were funny.

Posted by: Jackmormon on March 21, 2007 05:21 PM

And here's a more straight-up news story, complete with picture of one of those "No Dancing" signs.

Posted by: Jackmormon on March 21, 2007 05:25 PM

Matthew, freedom for Hegel is best understood as self-determination, a state in which one's determinations or properties are not determined by an other but by oneself. For self-determination we need to think of ourselves as a person subject to juridical right (subject to a rights based system of guarantees), an as an autonomous moral subject. The way in which Hegel differs from Kant, who also thinks of freedom as self-determination, is that for Hegel self-determination is not just germane to the structure of an individual's reason, but also to our selves as embodied social beings. In other words, Hegel wants to think how self-determination can be achieved when we recognize that agents are intrinsically social. His full answer is that freedom is 'being-with-oneself-in-another'. What he means by this phrase is that the 'objective social order' (what he calls 'ethical life') must be structured in such a way that agents can live out their life projects in accordance with their various self-understandings and conceptions of the good. Here, we find that we can be 'with-ourselves' (determine ourselves in accordance with our conception of the good) in 'the other' (that conception can be objectively realized). This is what true freedom requires. But to make the social life world amenable for our projects is not something that agents can achieve by themselves. Rather it takes collective action, i.e., politics. Contrary to the common view of Hegel as a collectivist, i.e., one who sacrifices the claims of the individual for the sake of the collective, the true picture should be of a philosopher who in the most penetrating manner thought through the conditions for individual freedom. Where Hegel differs from typical forms of liberalism is that he thinks that there are social conditions for individual freedom, including our taking part in political action. Freedom is not given, as it is for many liberals, but achieved.



Posted by: S Levine on March 21, 2007 05:25 PM

If a Guiliani administration tries any crap like that, Jackmormon and I will overthrow the government in a Dance Dance Revolution.

Posted by: Neil the Ethical Werewolf on March 21, 2007 05:26 PM

Required the establishment to have a license. Not banned. I was not a fan of the rule, but let's not overstate it.

Posted by: Al on March 21, 2007 05:27 PM

I would like very much to overstate it. Those licenses are expensive; only the gigantic clubs can afford them.

Posted by: Jackmormon on March 21, 2007 05:34 PM

Perhaps a better way to critique Guiliani's statement, which might address the knee-twitch reactions from the pro-dysfunctional-health-care peanut gallery, is to bring our good friends Mill and Rawls into the discussion of Hegelian notions of freedom.

Certainly the modern liberal view is that one must cede a good portion of one's freedom of action within the public sphere to a lawful authority that regulates economic activity. The alternative is the consolidation of wealth and power to the detriment of everyone else, and the de facto destruction of freedoms that occurs to those born into a lower class. When one person is born to inherit large amounts of land, and another is born with no choice but to rent from the former or live on the streets, then the latter is not born free in any meaningful sense.

However, within the PRIVATE sphere of choices that occur outside of public spaces and outside the economy, there is no legitimate purpose to be served by ceding freedom of action to state authority. This leads to the petty tyranny of a government that doesn't merely try to protect you from others, but tries to protect you from yourself. THAT is where liberals should, and generally do, get off the "big government" bus.

Interestingly, the conservative movement can be described as a rough alliance between those who believe in minimal government in the public sphere, and those who believe in maximal government in the private sphere, united against the modern liberal conception of freedom.

Posted by: LaFollette Progressive on March 21, 2007 05:35 PM

e.g., government takeover of the entire health care system of the country is somehow not authoritarian. Um, sorry, no.

Yes, every time I went to my (private) doctor in Canada, it was just like living under Saddam's Iraq because I had health insurance supplied by the government rather than a heavily regulated market that doesn't work (and requires much more government spending!) And it's much, much worse than trying to abolish the rule of law and appoint yourself mayor-for-as-long-as-you-feel-like-it! Your argument couldn't be more logical! (Anyway, Jonah Goldberg will be happy to know there's one rube who would by his new book if it were ever going to be released.)

What's even scarier, though, is that the government in its authoritarianism has taken over...our precious water supply! Talk about yer liberal fascism!

Posted by: Scott Lemieux on March 21, 2007 05:50 PM

The cause of political liberty is not served

Of course, if your job is political commentator like MY or New York politician like Giuliani you might be under the impression that freedom consists mainly of "political liberty". There are plenty of other types of liberty. Someone who makes their living through trade might think that economic liberty is important. Some people might think liberty to marry whoever you want is important.

There is a lot more to it than merely freedom of political speech.

Posted by: eeyn524 on March 21, 2007 05:51 PM

This must be why Andrew Sullivan has the Yglesias' award. I just hope I understand what you're getting at Matthew. Not that Giuliani philosophical position has much salience in today's political environment, but that somehow that philosophy does not start from a reasonable premise.

Posted by: mpowell on March 21, 2007 05:51 PM

"Extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice. And let me remind you also that moderation in the pursuit of justice is no virtue"

Conservatism has gone a long way in the 40 years.

Posted by: Nick Kaufman on March 21, 2007 05:58 PM

Interestingly, the conservative movement can be described as a rough alliance between those who believe in minimal government in the public sphere, and those who believe in maximal government in the private sphere, united against the modern liberal conception of freedom. - LaFollette Progressive

I've actually blogged about this (blogwhore: but a lazy one -- too lazy to actually link!). The alliance is not as tenuous as one might think: it is possible to accept both aspects of the modern conservative movement and be intellectually coherent.

Posted by: DAS on March 21, 2007 06:07 PM

I dunno, I'd say that in practice LA is a freer city than New York, and that this does have quite a bit to do with the weakness of local political institutions, including the relatively understaffed police force.

Posted by: Senescent on March 21, 2007 06:09 PM

because I had health insurance supplied by the government rather than a heavily regulated market

Heavily regulated markets are authoritarian, just slightly less than the ultra-authoritarian government-only health system in Canada. It most certainly is authoritarian to provide that it is illegal to purchase health care privately.

that doesn't work (and requires much more government spending!)

More government spending = more authoritarianism, of course. Taxation is authoritarian.

Posted by: Al on March 21, 2007 06:19 PM

To be fair, no one actually understands Hegel.

Posted by: Jack on March 21, 2007 06:25 PM

What's interesting in Giuliani's formulation is the trendy and gramatically non-standard use of the phrase "is about." What does it mean to say "freedom is about"? Does he mean "a necessary condition of freedom is..." That would be a true and uncontroversial statement. Or does he mean "the concept of 'freedom' is equivalent to the concept of 'ceding discretion to lawful authority'"? If that's what he means, we're in Orwell country.

Posted by: Bloix on March 21, 2007 06:40 PM

Al is right, though it all depends, of course, on how you want to spin the situation.

Posted by: Korha on March 21, 2007 06:44 PM

Generally speaking, while freedom does require that authority not overstep its proper bounds, it also very much requires that properly constituted authorities be reasonably strong and effective. The absence of effective state institutions does not make contemporary Baghdad freer" than Boston in any way that makes "freedom" denote a worthwhile political ideal.

Baghdad has the handicap of being the focal point of bloody sectarian strife.

I would argue that the vast majority of individuals are guided by a basic moral view, which they may sometimes fall short of, but which they all share, if laws are calibrated properly, rather then being distorted by powerful or vocal groups then individuals may live their entire lives guided by their own moral view without ever feeling the bootheel of government. These people would be very free.

Posted by: Chad Okere on March 21, 2007 06:52 PM

No one but no one should ever follow Dracula's authority. 99.9% of all authority in this country is illegitimate, venal, small, vile, racist, discriminatory, cheap, ugly, and diseased. Especially the justice system. Jeffrey Dahmer had a deeper sense of fairness and more integrity than 97.2% of all the prosecuters, judges, and cops do.

Posted by: Trevor on March 21, 2007 07:49 PM

You see: some might say this Giuliani character is a kewl mayor type but in reality he's a big jerk type.

I'm John Fucking McCain and I approve this message.

Posted by: John McCain on March 21, 2007 07:54 PM

As Bloix suggests, the only creepy thing about the comment is the word "about." It is obviously true that true freedom cannot exist without contraints on the war of all against all that prevails in the state of nature. That's banal contractarianism. But it's demented to think that "freedom" is "about" the constraints that must be imposed to facilitate its existence. Freedom is "about" the discretion to do the things you want to do, whenever and wherever you want, consistent with a social contract that allows you to do them *at all.* The terms of the contract -- our "laws" -- must be debated and revised constantly, and, the liberal contractarian hopes, always with an eye toward maximizing overall "freedom," but freedom is not "about" thos elaws, any more than, say, basketball is "about" the referee and the shot clock.

Posted by: JDH on March 21, 2007 08:06 PM

Wow that is a stupid quote. I don't care if Hegel said it first - Hegel is no sacred cow.

Giuliani is basically defining social order, but pretending that it is the definition of freedom. It's idiotic. It's like defining infinity to be a finite number.

Posted by: RickD on March 21, 2007 08:56 PM

Health Insurance is Fascism! Guantanamo is Freedom!

Got it, Al.

Posted by: John Emerson on March 21, 2007 08:56 PM

You know, Al actually believes his shit. That's really something.

Seat belt laws: fascism!

Posted by: John Emerson on March 21, 2007 08:59 PM

I'm with Johnny Fucking McCain.

This guy is a real jerk type.

Posted by: Linus on March 21, 2007 09:19 PM

Hip hip hooray for Hegel...but do Americans need to exercise more "discretion" in our deference to authority than we currently are? Have we been behaving badly under Bush?

And are any of Giuliani's opponents suggesting turning America into Baghdad?

It seems a little odd for a presidential candidate to be coming down so hard on the "order" side of the old "order vs. liberty" debate at a time when the presidency is so busy overstepping its authority in every way...

Posted by: Mr. Noah on March 21, 2007 09:23 PM

Hegel's not the governing reference here. It's been a long time since I read any Hegel but the key Hegel reference from Wikipedia is "rational government" which I take to be a government that adheres to laws and procedures enacted by previous administrations formed under a constitution as a supreme law. If anything, this is exactly what contemporary authoritarians like Giuliani reject. The authoritarians claim that being elected gives them a mandate to govern in opposition to constitutional mandates and established laws and procedures. Needless to say, this is exactly the opposite of Hegel, the authors of key American documents, and John Locke.

In a way, Thoreau and Emerson are better references than Hegel. Like these authors, Giuliani dismisses democratic traditions and defines his own freedom, manhood, and self-worth in terms of acting on his own "truth." Of course, Giuliani's truth of authoritative discretion is different from the truths foreseen by Thoreau and Emerson, but it's just as individual. Where Giuliani goes further is that he demands that everybody in society give up their freedom (as protected by laws, rules, procedures, and constitutional provisions) so that Giuliani can govern by his "truth." In other words, we sacrifice our freedom so Giuliani as an elected official can have the freedom ("a great deal of discretion") to do what he believes to be the right thing. The same is the case with Bush and Cheney. They're all "scary and creepy," but their authoritarian ideas are an application of a romantic American individualism to the "individuality" of those in authority.


Posted by: Ric Caric on March 21, 2007 10:03 PM

Rudy will never win because:

a:) he's from New York
b:) he's pro-abortion
c:) he's been married 3 times
d:) he's a Jew,... I mean, uh, Catholic

Posted by: TheOkie on March 21, 2007 10:28 PM

I don't think comparisons to Hegel should legitimize anything at all. Hegel was a through and through racist (see, for instance, his assertion that by definition there can be no African history), and its easy to see his Historical March to Perfection underpinning (not to say causing) Nazi political philosophy.

Hegel's grand, baroque system of thesis/antithesis/synthesis had no time for individual freedom. That was why we needed Kierkegaard and the existentialists in the first place

Posted by: Thor on March 21, 2007 10:35 PM

More government spending = more authoritarianism, of course. Taxation is authoritarian.

Ah, good, so Al has conceded that Bush's health care policies are vastly more "authoritarian" than France's. So we can implement the French system, make America more democratic (as vastly improving health care), and we both go home happy.

Posted by: Scott Lemieux on March 21, 2007 10:36 PM

Strong authority is not necessary to freedom. To say that it is, is to suggest that freedom never existed until there was government, which is demonstrably false.

Authority is only necessary to counter the effects of an unequal distribution of power among individuals and groups. In a state of perfect equality any attempt by one individual to interfere with another can be equally countered by the aggrieved individual. The attacker may come out ahead on occassion, but he cannot hope to all the time and once he becomes known as a threat to the liberty of individuals of a community they are likely to become wary of him and perhaps might even band together to stop him. But when you have powerful groups and bodies emerge like corporatons and the mob and aristocratic families and technologies like gun or other such concentrations of power that create a situation where an individual cannot protect their own liberty, only then do you need authority to protect freedom.

Too many people today talk about freedom in terms of rights that are granted by government. That gets it completely backwards. The question is not by what right is an individual free. Human freedom is inherent to human existence. This is the point that our forefathers considered a self-evident truth.

The real question is, by what right does government interfere with anything an individual does? There is no inherent right for any person or persons or group of persons, however selected, to exercise control over another person's life. Therefore, if a body of people -- which is what government is -- wants to exercise such control, the burden is on them to justify it. And that is what you, Matt, and Giuliani and so much of America have completely misunderstood.

Posted by: DS on March 21, 2007 10:42 PM

How odd it is, that whenever you hear a sentence beginning with "Freedom is" or "Liberty is" it almost always ends up being something less than, or in some cases antithetical to what Freedom & Liberty actually are.

Posted by: DRR on March 21, 2007 10:52 PM

Engraved above the columns of Worcester County Courthouse: "Obedience to Law is Liberty"

gross, huh?

Posted by: Walter Crockett on March 21, 2007 11:06 PM

MDtoMN:

"It is truly odd how the Republican party manages to be BOTH the "law & order" party and the "Libertarian" party."

Is that odder than how the Democratic party manages to be the party of choice for poor, uneducated, religious, homophobic blacks as well as educated, affluent, secular gay whites?

It's simply the result of having two major parties: unless an interest group wants to start a viable third party (not a bad idea), it has to find a home in one of the two majors.

Posted by: Fred on March 22, 2007 02:58 AM

Yes, Fred, it is much, much odder. The mish-mash you cite as the Democratic contradiction consists of dichotomies that are either not contradictory or not both Democratic positions:

poor/affluent: not contradictory. The Democratic party is about a fair shake for poor and affluent alike

educated/uneducated: "uneducation" is not a Democratic value

religious/secular: not contradictory. The Democratic party is not against the practice of religion, only against the establishment of *one* religion (1st Am.)

gay rights/homophobia: homophobia is *so* not a Democratic value. Homophobes are well aware they have no chance of their homophobia being respected by Democrats. It is, however, a Republican value, and therefore a common Republican wedge tactic to win the votes of otherwise Democratic voters.

black/white: not contradictory. see poor/affluent, religious/secular

Now look again at that Republican dichotomy again.

libertarianism/authoritarianism: deeply contradictory, yet supposedly both Republican values. Giuliani, by preaching submission to duly constituted authority, is either no Republican, or libertarianism has no place in the Republican party. Which is it?

Posted by: derek on March 22, 2007 05:06 AM

Order is all that's necessary for freedom, and the requires only a very minimal level of authority in a free society. Only those that hate freedom, as Matt has made it clear he does, fear that freedom will create anarchy. That is the argument of totalitarians and monsters everywhere. Good men don't make that argument, and by making that argument you show the measure of your soul. Anyone can examine this position and find it's flaws if they care to. That this argument is not an argument for some control, but rather for total control of a nation's citizen's actions. That it instills in a human entity; either government, church, or community, the essence and providence of freedom. When freedom is provided by men, men may take it away. That it demands complete obedience to a government of flawed men, rather than an acceptance that leaders are human and that they make mistakes that must be corrected.

Matt is a flawed person who allows his class bias to weigh too heavily in his arguments. He doesn't believe in egalitarianism. He apparently doesn't understand the essence of what freedom is. He instead fears the masses. That we have, or may receive, too much power and too much freedom. He fears that we will create a society that no longer goes out of it's way to benefit people of his status. For that reason, he is open to these kinds of arguments made by other men of status and wealth to justify their status and their wealth.

Posted by: soullite on March 22, 2007 07:18 AM

Government: Safety First.

Posted by: Jeffrey Davis on March 22, 2007 08:10 AM

Is this Hegel or Hobbes?

Posted by: thegeist on March 22, 2007 08:51 AM

Concerning the very first comment, by Rousseau:
Rousseau deserted his wife and kids. I'm sure he preferred his life without chains better, but I doubt his family had much respect for his version of "freedom."

Posted by: anon on March 22, 2007 08:58 AM

And so the aptly named "anon" mounts the classic ad hominem leveled at Rousseau.

Posted by: Jeffrey Davis on March 22, 2007 09:18 AM

If we're going to talk about Hegel, let's at least come close to getting him right. Any good reader of Hegel of the last half century knows he is by no means "a pretty creepy authoritarian"--his whole political philosophy is founded upon the individual free will. S. Levine's comments are right on track. Silly name dropping might make you look smart, but not when you don't understand the author whose name you exploit.

Posted by: j on March 22, 2007 09:28 AM

Mr. Jefferson Davis,
I'm not mounting an ad hominmen attack, I'm just pointing out that for Rousseau, his concept of freedom was very convenient for him, as it is for a lot of people. I'm curious, do you know the name of his wife?

Posted by: anonYMOUS on March 22, 2007 09:42 AM

Matt is illustrating the dangers of taking a philosophy degree. Sure, it seems innocent enough when you're young and can stay up all night, but before you know it.....

The fact is, most Americans spend most of their lives in a state of anarchy and we do just fine. In an hour I will join hundreds of other scofflaws who speed up the freeway, but we never run into one another. I will eat food that has not been inspected but I will not get sick. I will surf a relatively lawless internet and not become a terrorist.

What threatens Matt is the rule of law, that, through the mechanism of the War on (some) Drugs, has created a blackmarket in his city. What threatens Baghdad is the belief of contending groups that they must impose their rule of law.

To paraphrase Abe Lincoln, the great evil of Prohibition is that it leads people to believe they don't need to have any inner standards of right and wrong, they can just let the government make those decisions for them.

Or, to paraphrase Lord Acton, power corrupts- and absolute power corrupts absolutely.

Posted by: serial catowner on March 22, 2007 10:00 AM

Ooops, I misspelled "ad hominem." My apologies.
Having said that, I don't think my pointing out Rousseau's neglect of his family (especially his children) is ad hominem. His concept of freedom directly relates to his avoidance of personal responsibility in his own life. If I were merely attacking his person in a way detached from his argument about freedom, then that would be ad hominem. (I'm not an expert on logical fallacies, so correct me if I'm wrong, Mr. Davis.)
His children were born free: free of a father.

Posted by: anonYMOUS on March 22, 2007 10:03 AM

Ah, good, so Al has conceded that Bush's health care policies are vastly more "authoritarian" than France's.

???

Government spending on health care is relatively less in the US than in France.

Posted by: Al on March 22, 2007 10:12 AM

Rudy is simply showing his Catholic upbring.

The Christian definition of freedom always turns upon "responsible" freedom under proper order - freedom to obey the will of God. The classical Christian view of freedom is that we are slaves to sin and we become free as we overcome this slavery. When we submit to the will of God we are not entering into bondage but are liberating ourselves from all that is evil in the world.
But freedom in the modern world has become defined as the right to do whatever one pleases, with self-expression regarded as the highest good. That being the case, the very existence of institutions of any kind that claim some kind of higher authority can only be seen as a threat to freedom.

Posted by: veblen on March 22, 2007 10:58 AM

The problem with "freedom is about the willingness of every single human being to cede to lawful authority a great deal of discretion about what you do" is simple: so is slavery. It makes more sense to say "freedom still concedes to lawful authority..." or "freedom unfortunately cannot be achieved without a willingness to cede to lawful authority..." or something, rather than "freedom is about...", which makes it sound like Rudy thinks that the DEFINING characteristic of freedom is unfreedom.

If I read S Levine right above, and if I remember that college course on "Autonomy" right, Hegel also lays the emphasis not on "ceding to lawful authority", but more on embracing the law, as a member oneself of the polity that creates the law and is governed by it. Not so much just "yes sir, officer" ("Why? Because I say so."). Though then again, maybe Hegel did in some ways think the law just fell out of the sky; he was a monarchist after all.

Posted by: mattsteinglass on March 22, 2007 11:48 AM

Government spending on health care is relatively less in the US than in France.

Uh, no: the French government spends less per capita. Why do Republicans hate democracy?

Posted by: Scott Lemieux on March 22, 2007 12:01 PM

I think freedom is best defined by those who are willing to kill and die for it -- vice superficial intellects who would not sacrifice one pay raise to stand up to power. Witness the numerous craven surrenders of America's intelligentsia over the past 5 years.

But if we are going to debate political philosophy, we should at least do so in a way that would interest --say, a high school senior.

The problem is with Giulani is that there is ample evidence that the man is an outright fascist. Does no one remember a NYC police force whose officers shoved a toilet plunger up
a detainee's rectum?? Which has --on several occasions -- pumped roughly 50 bullets into innocent men simply because they did not freeze into immobility. Which claims the right to stop and frisk random individuals on the sidewalk for WWB?
("Walking While Black").

Freedom, like life, is based upon a BALANCE between extremes.
Extreme heat -- and extreme cold -- kill. Extreme dryness --dying of thirst in a desert -- kills as quickly as extreme wetness -- drowning in deep water.

Over 2000 years ago, Aristotle and then Polybius noted the need for balance between the rule of the One, the Few, and the Many.

But who is likely to challenge George Bush's and Giulani's seizure of power? How can you discuss the need for checks and balances when probably 90% of US voters today think Aristotle is a Hollywood hairdresser?

Britney Spears can get $20 for her DVDs. Meanwhile, my local library has books sales to raise money due to funding cuts from our Republican state legislature. And at those books sales, I have been able to buy hardbound copies of Aristotle and Plato's dialogues for 50 cents each.

It's amazing how we can spend over $1 Trillion/year on education and produce some of the most stupid people on the planet.

Posted by: Don Williams on March 22, 2007 12:01 PM

Uh, no: the French government spends less per capita.

But, Scott, that's only because they have less money to spend, because their tax revenues are lower, because they're not as rich as we are because they're lazy socialists! If you multiply French government per capita health expenditures by the ratio of US to French per capita GNP then it becomes larger than US per capita government health expenditures! Ironically, it is their very socialism and resulting poverty which impedes them in their mad thirst to spend government money on their health care. Probably. I'm see no need to actually do the research, or the math, but it stands to reason, because, in the immortal words of Agent Orange:

French people suck
that's what I say
made the jet fighter pilots
go out of their way

Also, are you aware that France was defeated by Germany in World War II?

Posted by: mattsteinglass on March 22, 2007 12:16 PM

Scott, you know how I hate to disagree with Matthew, but you've got to look at it in terms of %age of GDP, not raw dollars. As a percentage of GDP, the French public spending on healthcare is greater than US public spending on healthcare, at least if I did the math right based on the latest OECD numbers. (Of course, public spending isn't all federal (i.e., Bush administration) anyway, but leave that aside, since I don't know that we could get comparable numbers for the US federal government and French federal government.)

Posted by: Al on March 22, 2007 12:21 PM

Heh. Matt Steinglass says it more humorously than me.

Posted by: Al on March 22, 2007 12:23 PM

Oh, for christ's sake. I didn't actually think you were going to MAKE the argument. How dismally predictable.

Posted by: mattsteinglass on March 22, 2007 12:35 PM

Why would you compare to GDP? Is there any evidence that France gets a lower standard of care for its money? At any rate, in the kindest construction Republicans support a system that's about 90% as "authoritarian" as the French one. Fascist!

Posted by: Scott Lemieux on March 22, 2007 01:29 PM

"Freedom is slavery!" Giuliani '08

Posted by: Scylla on March 22, 2007 02:02 PM

yeah, what rudy, the professor and you are all discussing is nuance to getting away with having society. but society and culture have never had anything to do with freedom, and never will, hell being other people and all. STILL I GET YER POINT

Posted by: rotten apples on March 22, 2007 02:03 PM

Cheap shot. The quote is lifted out of context and presented as proof that Guiliani must be some kind of fascist. Trace back to the actual speech in 1994 and the context in which the line was given. He was advocating more individual responsibility rather than greater government repression.
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9A01E2D9173CF933A15750C0A962958260

Posted by: Lemming51 on June 23, 2007 01:27 PM

thanks

Posted by: firma ekle on July 29, 2007 12:58 PM

Perhaps, Gary, but that's hardly why Medicaid is important. It may benefit middle class dudes like you, but we didn't implement Medicaid in order to benefit the middle class, and we wouldn't repeal it if turned out not to benefit the middle class as much as it seems to.

Posted by: sohbet on August 12, 2007 06:04 PM

very nice

Posted by: oyunlar on August 28, 2007 10:24 AM

sohbet, chat, arkadaş

Posted by: sohbet on August 29, 2007 07:13 AM

thanks...

Posted by: hikaye on August 31, 2007 12:52 AM

muhabbet

Posted by: muhabbet on August 31, 2007 12:53 AM

thank you

Posted by: health on September 5, 2007 04:45 AM

thank you

Posted by: bilim on September 5, 2007 04:46 AM

thank you

Posted by: youtube on September 5, 2007 04:48 AM

than kyou

Posted by: kurtlar vadisi on September 5, 2007 04:51 AM

thank you

Posted by: paris hilton on September 5, 2007 05:24 AM

thank you very good.

Posted by: Sohbet odası on September 24, 2007 07:20 AM

thankk

Posted by: sohbet on September 24, 2007 03:07 PM

nbr kush basi

Posted by: sohbet on September 24, 2007 03:11 PM

we liked here

Posted by: sohbet odasi on September 24, 2007 03:12 PM

hii how is going

Posted by: sohbet odalari on September 28, 2007 06:12 PM

tsklerr

Posted by: sohbet on October 5, 2007 03:15 PM

tsklerr sagol

Posted by: komik videolar on October 5, 2007 03:15 PM

off off sizwar ya siz adamlarburayı siz gelip link ekleyin diye açmadılar konuyu teşekkürler falan deyip te adamalrı bunlar neye teşekkür ediyor demesin en azından bellei etmeyin:D:D:D

Posted by: oyun on October 5, 2007 05:51 PM

Interesting and very informative article

Posted by: annuaire gratuit on October 5, 2007 07:15 PM

thanks

Posted by: sohbet on October 7, 2007 11:40 PM

Thanks

Posted by: chat on October 8, 2007 12:27 AM

Sohbet, World

Posted by: Sohbet on October 8, 2007 08:28 AM

Birdiyar

Posted by: Birdiyar on October 8, 2007 08:28 AM

Canli Sohbet

Posted by: Canli Sohbet on October 8, 2007 08:28 AM

Canlı Sohbet

Posted by: Canlı Sohbet on October 8, 2007 08:29 AM

Sohbet Siteleri

Posted by: Sohbet Siteleri on October 8, 2007 08:29 AM

Sohbetyap

Posted by: Sohbetyap on October 8, 2007 08:30 AM

SohbetChat

Posted by: Sohbetchat on October 8, 2007 08:30 AM

Sohbetyap

Posted by: Sohbetyap on October 8, 2007 08:31 AM

Haberler

Posted by: Haberler on October 8, 2007 08:31 AM

sohbet siteleri, chat, muhabbet, canlı sohbet chat, güzel sözler, aşk sevgi sözleri, şiir, arkadaş, çocuk şarkıları, oyun

Posted by: Sohbet Siteleri on October 8, 2007 12:16 PM

Canlı Sohbet

Posted by: Canlı Sohbet on October 8, 2007 12:46 PM

Canlı Sobet

Posted by: Canlı Sohbet on October 8, 2007 12:47 PM

thanks

Posted by: çiçek on October 12, 2007 01:37 PM

tnx..

Posted by: Sevgi on October 13, 2007 06:56 PM

thanks for links..

Posted by: sex on October 15, 2007 09:14 AM

mirc

Posted by: mirc on October 15, 2007 11:45 AM

mirc

Posted by: mirc on October 15, 2007 11:47 AM

hikaye

Posted by: hikaye on October 15, 2007 11:50 AM

thanks

Posted by: sohbet on October 16, 2007 09:36 AM

thanks
best regards.ıts cool

Posted by: mirc on October 18, 2007 06:29 PM

thank you very much

Posted by: forum on October 18, 2007 06:29 PM

Chat

Posted by: Chat on October 19, 2007 04:35 PM

sohbet

Posted by: sohbet on October 19, 2007 04:36 PM

chat sitesi

Posted by: chat sitesi on October 19, 2007 04:37 PM

chat siteleri

Posted by: chat siteleri on October 19, 2007 04:38 PM

sohbet odaları

Posted by: sohbet odaları on October 19, 2007 04:38 PM

Sohbet odası

Posted by: Sohbet Odası on October 19, 2007 04:39 PM

canlı sohbet

Posted by: canlı sohbet on October 19, 2007 04:39 PM

sohbet sitesi

Posted by: sohbet sitesi on October 19, 2007 04:40 PM

sohbet kanalları

Posted by: sohbet kanalları on October 19, 2007 04:41 PM

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

chat

Posted by: chat on October 19, 2007 08:07 PM

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

adult

Posted by: adult on October 19, 2007 08:08 PM

thanks for links..

Posted by: abonesin on October 21, 2007 12:22 AM

Oha spama see :P

Posted by: altılı ganyan on October 28, 2007 10:34 PM

thank you

Posted by: bilim on October 30, 2007 07:55 AM

thank you

Posted by: youtube on October 30, 2007 07:56 AM

Must I cede to lawful authority my discretion about what I pay my employees? Minimum wage is authoritarian.

Posted by: Free Download on November 4, 2007 03:07 PM

thanks

Posted by: porno on November 7, 2007 08:23 AM

this site veery good thanksss

Posted by: oyun on November 9, 2007 11:29 AM

Must I cede to lawful authority my discretion about what I pay my employees? Minimum wage is authoritarian.

Posted by: Yemek on November 15, 2007 12:26 PM

thanks..

Posted by: sex shop on November 16, 2007 02:23 AM

thanks..

Posted by: kale kapı on November 16, 2007 04:14 PM

Thanks
ev

Posted by: ev on November 21, 2007 11:30 AM

tsklerrr

ilginize

Posted by: video on November 21, 2007 06:43 PM

thanks

Posted by: sohbet on November 22, 2007 01:54 PM

thanks a lot

Posted by: Elisha Cuthbert on November 27, 2007 10:29 AM

teşekkürler :)

Posted by: grup hepsi on November 27, 2007 10:30 AM

thanks for your efford :)

Posted by: şampiyonlar ligi on November 27, 2007 10:32 AM

thanks a lot

Posted by: gökhan özen on November 27, 2007 10:33 AM

thank you

Posted by: msn hileleri on November 27, 2007 10:34 AM

thanks

Posted by: petegim on November 28, 2007 02:24 AM

thnx

Posted by: seks on November 30, 2007 03:18 PM

Thank you.

Posted by: oktay usta on December 1, 2007 02:38 AM

Very much good text Thanks

Posted by: hikaye on December 6, 2007 03:09 AM

thanks

Posted by: video share on December 6, 2007 05:41 AM

thanks for links allllllllll.

Posted by: adult on December 11, 2007 07:28 PM

video

Posted by: hikaye on December 13, 2007 09:30 AM

hikaye

Posted by: video on December 13, 2007 09:30 AM

sex hikaye

Posted by: sex hikaye on December 13, 2007 09:31 AM

sex hikaye

Posted by: sex on December 13, 2007 09:32 AM

Thanks

Posted by: sohbet on December 13, 2007 06:08 PM

thank for all

Posted by: sex on December 14, 2007 04:09 PM

thnaks

Posted by: webtasarim on December 18, 2007 05:20 AM
Posted by: webtasarim on December 18, 2007 05:23 AM

thank you. thanks


oyun indir

Posted by: oyun indir on December 27, 2007 03:27 PM

thanks admin

Posted by: drcetinerdotorg on December 30, 2007 02:07 PM

mırc soft ware page

Posted by: mırc on December 30, 2007 04:48 PM

hikaye web page good

Posted by: hikaye on December 30, 2007 04:49 PM

adult forum good

Posted by: porno on December 30, 2007 04:50 PM

thank you

Posted by: Cep Oyunları on January 1, 2008 04:19 PM

thank youu

Posted by: Cep Oyunları on January 1, 2008 04:20 PM

Thanks.

Posted by: ümit usta on January 2, 2008 09:20 AM

thanx a lot

Posted by: Onur on January 2, 2008 10:25 AM

thanx a lot

Posted by: Burak on January 2, 2008 10:25 AM

thanksssss

Posted by: video izle on January 4, 2008 11:40 AM

thank youu

Posted by: dizi izle on January 4, 2008 11:41 AM

thanks a lot of

Posted by: forum on January 4, 2008 05:51 PM

thanks, oyun siteleri

Posted by: oyun siteleri on January 6, 2008 10:44 AM

thanks and sex !

Posted by: porno on January 7, 2008 09:02 AM

bedava thanks you..

Posted by: Bedava on January 11, 2008 09:00 PM

thanks you..

Posted by: Canlı Tv on January 11, 2008 09:01 PM

thanks you frend..

Posted by: Youtube on January 11, 2008 09:01 PM

thnaks you frend.. rss license

Posted by: Tc Kimlik No on January 11, 2008 09:01 PM

thanks you frend sözler..

Posted by: Güzel Sözler on January 11, 2008 09:02 PM

thanks you

Posted by: hikaye on January 11, 2008 09:02 PM

thanks you..

Posted by: Komsu.net on January 11, 2008 09:03 PM

thanks you thanks..

Posted by: Özlü Sözler on January 11, 2008 09:03 PM

thanks you frend...

Posted by: Sohbet Odaları on January 11, 2008 09:04 PM

Thank You...

Posted by: Hikaye on January 17, 2008 08:10 PM

thanks for this article.

Radyo Radyo Sohbet Sohbet mirc mirc mirc indir
canavar script tuning

Regards,
Carpe

Posted by: sohbet on January 29, 2008 01:51 PM

Thanks you..

Posted by: Komsu.net on January 30, 2008 05:16 AM

thanks.. youu..

Posted by: Bedava on January 30, 2008 05:16 AM

thanks youu..

Posted by: sıcak videolar on January 30, 2008 05:17 AM

thanks youuuuu

Posted by: Hikaye on January 30, 2008 05:18 AM

canlı tv you thanks..

Posted by: Canlı Tv on January 30, 2008 05:19 AM

thansk youyuuu

Posted by: Youtube on January 30, 2008 05:19 AM

thanks

Posted by: motorsiklet on February 5, 2008 10:55 PM

adana evden eve nakliyat
ıgdır evden eve nakliyat
ardahan evden eve nakliyat
artvin evden eve nakliyat
bartın evden eve nakliyat
şırnak evden eve nakliyat
karaman evden eve nakliyat
bayburt evden eve nakliyat
aksaray evden eve nakliyat
zonguldak evden eve nakliyat
yozgat evden eve nakliyat
van evden eve nakliyat
sanlıurfa evden eve nakliyat
trabzon evden eve nakliyat
sivas evden eve nakliyat
sinop evden eve nakliyat
siirt evden eve nakliyat
samsun evden eve nakliyat
sakarya evden eve nakliyat
rize evden eve nakliyat
nigde evden eve nakliyat
mugla evden eve nakliyat
mardin evden eve nakliyat
maras evden eve nakliyat
manisa evden eve nakliyat
gümüshane evden eve nakliyat
giresun evden eve nakliyat
edirne evden eve nakliyat
çanakkale evden eve nakliyat
diyarbakir evden eve nakliyat
denizli evden eve nakliyat
çankırı evden eve nakliyat
burdur evden eve nakliyat
bolu evden eve nakliyat
adiyaman evden eve nakliyat
afyon evden eve nakliyat
agrı evden eve nakliyat
amasya evden eve nakliyat
antalya evden eve nakliyat
artvin evden eve nakliyat
balıkesir evden eve nakliyat
bilecik evden eve nakliyat
bitlis evden eve nakliyat
bursa evden eve nakliyat
çorum evden eve nakliyat
mersin evden eve nakliyat
iskenderun evden eve nakliyat
hatay evden eve nakliyat
eskişehir evden eve nakliyat
izmit evden eve nakliyat
malatya evden eve nakliyat
kütahya evden eve nakliyat
konya evden eve nakliyat
kocaeli evden eve nakliyat
kırklareli evden eve nakliyat
kayseri evden eve nakliyat
kastamonu evden eve nakliyat
kars evden eve nakliyat
erzurum evden eve nakliyat
elazig evden eve nakliyat
tunceli evden eve nakliyat
gebze evden eve nakliyat
tuzla evden eve nakliyat
pendik evden eve nakliyat
nevsehir evden eve nakliyat
muş evden eve nakliyat
osmaniye evden eve nakliyat
düzce evden eve nakliyat
karabük evden eve nakliyat
yalova evden eve nakliyat
erzincan evden eve nakliyat
istanbul evden eve nakliyat
izmir evden eve nakliyat
nikah şekeri
ankara lazer epilasyon
temizlik
halı yıkama
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
temizlik şirketi ankara
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
lazer epilasyon
lazer epilasyon
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
halı yıkama/
ankara nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
brülör servisi
baca gazı analizi
ankara dekorasyon şirketi
ankara boyacı
lazer epilasyon hakkında
lazer epilasyon bilgi
lazer epilasyon
lazerle epilasyon hakkında
lazer epilasyon
laser epilasyon
ankaralazer epilasyon


bebek şekeri
nikah şekeri
nikah şekerleri
nikah şekeri
estetik
ankara nakliyat pr 3 uluslararası-nakliyat.org omtasnakliyat.net
ankara nakliyat pr 0 uluslararası-nakliyat.org omtasnakliyat.net
halı yıkama pr 0 link
çiçekçi pr 0 link çıkışı
jenerator pr 0 link çıkışı
halı yıkama pr 0 link çıkışı
kale çelik kapı pr 0
çelik kapı pr 0
mermer granit sorunlu açılmıyor
catering pr
catering
tercüme
lazer epilasyon
lazer epilasyon
jenerator sorunlu açılmıyor
duşakabin
duşakabin
kale çelik kapı omtaş uluslarası
kale çelik kapı
emlak
emlakcı
çiçekçi
tüp bebek
sondaj
sondaj
lojistik
evden eve nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
su deposu
su deposu
saç ekimi merkezleri
saç ekimi
niakh şekeri
nikah şekeri
nikah şekeri
ankara evden eve nakliyat

ankara nakliyat

ankara nakliyat
saç ekimi
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
rent a car
evden eve nakliyat ankara
ankara temizlik şirketi/

temizlik şirketi
ankara nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
tüp bebek
saç ekimi
evden eve nakliyat
ankara nakliyat
temizlik şirketi
ankara nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
temizlik şirketi

evden eve
nakliyat

lazer epilasyon


ankara nakliyat


evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
estetik
oto kiralama
çiçekçi
vidanjör
evden eve nakliyat
lazer epilasyon
lazer epilasyon ankara
evden eve nakliyat ankara
evden eve nakliyat ankara
halı yıkama ankara
evden eve nakliyat ankara
ankara nakliyat/
ankara nakliyat/
evden eve nakliyat
su deposu/
temizlik şirketi/
temizlik şirketleri
temizlik şirketi
temizlik şirketi
temizlik şirketi
halı yıkama/
temizlik firmaları/
ankara temizlik şirketi
promosyon ürünleri
istanbul nakliyat
izmir nakliyat ankara
google optimizasyonu/
nakliyat/
nakliyat/
google optimizasyonu/
halı yıkama/
temizlik şirketleri
tüp bebek
promosyon ürünleri
uluslararası nakliyat

estetik
yag alma
yag aldırma
liposakşın

estetik merkezi
estetik ameliyat
estetik cerrahi
plastik cerrahi
burun estetik
burun estetigi
estetik burun ameliyatı
arama motoru optimizasyonu
oto kiralama


estetik
yag alma
yag aldırma
liposakşın
estetik merkezi
estetik merkezleri
estetik ameliyat
estetik cerrahi
plastik cerrahi
burun estetik
burun estetigi
estetik burun ameliyatı


Posted by: ankara nakliyat on February 9, 2008 05:15 PM

akoymussunuz ortaligin turk oldugunuzu her tarafta belli etmeyin lan :)

Posted by: chat on February 26, 2008 08:09 PM

sohbet edelimmi

Posted by: mirc on February 29, 2008 01:47 PM

goods works

Posted by: Dizi izle on March 11, 2008 02:38 PM

mirc yukleme yeridir...

Posted by: mirc on March 12, 2008 12:53 PM

mirc yukleme yeridir...

Posted by: mirc on March 12, 2008 12:53 PM

halter video

Posted by: halter on March 18, 2008 03:22 PM

film indir

Posted by: film indir on March 18, 2008 03:23 PM

Thank Youu

Posted by: youtube on March 28, 2008 04:27 AM

thanks ;)

Posted by: firefox indir on March 31, 2008 04:05 AM

thank you !

Posted by: firefox indir on March 31, 2008 01:05 PM

thank you

Posted by: diş beyazlatma on April 4, 2008 04:49 PM

thank you

Posted by: html kodları on April 6, 2008 03:56 AM

thank you

Posted by: firefox indir on April 6, 2008 06:00 AM

thank you

Posted by: maswey on April 9, 2008 10:37 AM

thanks..

Posted by: facebook on April 14, 2008 04:02 AM

Negrosoft Medya ve Bilişim Teknolojileri

Web site tasarımı, web site programlaması, web site barındırma, veritabanı yedekleme ve veri depolama hizmetleri, logo, banner, gazete, dergi ilanları, amblem, katalog, broşür, takvim, afiş, poster tasarımı, kurumsal kimlik tasarımları (kartvizit,antentli kağıt vb.), e-ticaret, eğitim ve tanıtım prezentasyonları, internet reklamcılığı, arama motoru optimizasyonları, bilişim danışmanlığı...

Posted by: Negrosoft Medya ve Bilişim Teknolojileri on April 20, 2008 12:08 PM

thank you

Posted by: corum on April 20, 2008 05:35 PM

Thank You!

Posted by: Ata Demirer on April 20, 2008 05:39 PM

hi there

thanks for post

Posted by: baron on April 30, 2008 05:57 PM

Saat


thanks

Posted by: Saat on May 19, 2008 05:45 PM

very nice

Posted by: youtube on May 29, 2008 11:22 AM

zayıflama

Posted by: zayıflama on June 9, 2008 05:44 AM

Thanx a lot.. Good a website archive.

Posted by: sohbet on June 24, 2008 04:48 PM

thank you

Posted by: iç giyim on June 26, 2008 06:01 AM

thank you

Posted by: fantazi iç giyim on June 26, 2008 06:04 AM

thank you

Posted by: jartiyer on June 26, 2008 06:06 AM

thank you

Posted by: tanga on June 26, 2008 06:07 AM

thank you

Posted by: erotik iç giyim on June 26, 2008 06:08 AM

thank you

Posted by: fantazi giyim on June 26, 2008 06:08 AM

thank you

Posted by: seksi gecelikler on June 26, 2008 06:11 AM

thank you

Posted by: külotlu çorap on June 26, 2008 06:12 AM

thank you

Posted by: jartiyer çorabı on June 26, 2008 06:15 AM

nice document

Posted by: Hegelian? on June 30, 2008 06:36 AM

If you went with the SunEdison model you could basically do this without any capital outlays. And save money at the same time.

Posted by: milan hotels on July 5, 2008 11:29 AM

Thanks Sohbet

Posted by: Sohbet on August 10, 2008 07:17 AM

Thank YOUU MF yess

Posted by: penis büyütücü on August 11, 2008 02:13 PM

thanks

Posted by: şiir on August 12, 2008 12:36 PM

thank you

Posted by: kozmetik on August 15, 2008 02:59 PM

thank you

Posted by: mirc on August 16, 2008 04:19 PM

thanks

Posted by: chat on August 17, 2008 04:24 AM

Thanks

Posted by: Chat on August 17, 2008 01:22 PM

Thanks

Posted by: Mirc on August 17, 2008 01:23 PM

nice document

Posted by: Chat on August 23, 2008 09:45 AM

3D
Ada
Aksiyon
Altin
Araba
Araba Surme
Arı
Arkanoid
Asa
Atari Oyunları
Ateş
Ay
Ayartma Cıkma
Ayı
Balık
Balık Tutma
Balina
Balonlar
Basketbol
Beceri Oyunları
Beyzbol
Bilardo
Bilgi
Bin Ladin
Bira
Biriktirme Oyunları
Birinci Bakıştan Vuruş
Bisiklet
Bitki
Boks
Bomba
Bomberman
Boru
Bovling
Boyama
Bul ve Yok Et
Bunny
Burç
Buyücü
Buz
Canak Cömlek
Canavarlar
Çanta
Çarpişan Oto
Çarpma
Çiçek
Çiftlik
Cihaz Techizat Aparat Alma Yukseltme
Çizim
Çocuk
Çop Adam
Cuce
Dağitma
Dalga
Dalma Dalgıç
Dans Etme
Dedektif
Dekorasyon
Denge Oyunları
Dengeleme
Denizaltı
Dinazor
Domino
Dört Tekerlekli Motor Quad
Duşunce
Duvar
Egitim
Eğlenceli
Ejderha
El Kaide
Emlak
Engel
Erkek
Eşleştirme
Ev
Fabrika
Fantazi
Film
Firavun
Fırlatma
Flash
Futbol
Gazino
Gemi Bot Kayık
Gercek Zamanlı
Gevşeme
Gezegen
Giysi Giydirme
Gizlilik
Gok Taşı
Golf
Goril
Güvenlik
Hafıza
Hamburger
Hap
Hapishane
Harf
Havai Fisek
Havuz
Hayalet
Hayvanlar
Hazine
Hedef
Helikopter
Hokey
İcki
İlerle ve Patakla
İlerle ve Vur
Intehar
Isık
Isıtma
İskelet
Java
Jedi
Kabarcık
Kaçış Firar
Kaçma
Kale
Kamyon
Kan
Kaplumbağa
Kar
Karınca
Kart
Kaya
Kayak
Kaykay
Kedi
Kedi Yavrusu
Kelime
Kılıç
Kiz
Komik
Köpek
Köpek Yavrusu
Korkunç
Korling
Koruma
Koşma
Kovboy
Kukla
Kule
Kung Fu
Kurbağa
Kurgu Oyunları
Kurtarma Oyunları
Kuş
Labirent
Langırt Tilt Oyunları
Lemmings
Maç Yapma
Macera
Maden
Makine
Makine Alet Becerisi
Mario
Masa Üstü Oyunlar
Matematik
Maymun
Meyve
Mezarlık
Motorsiklet
Mouse Becerisi
Mücadele
Mücevher
Multiplayer
Mutant
Muz
Müzik
Ninja
Numara
Oda
Ok ve Yay
Okul
Öldurme
Ölumsuz
Ordu
Ortaçağ
Palyaço
Panda
Para
Park Etme
Parodi
Patenle Kayma
Penguen
Peri
Piramit
Platform Oyunları
Play God
Poker
Pompalı Tüfek
Puzzle
Reklam Oyunları
Robot
Roket
Rol Yapma
Rollerblade
Romantik
Rulet
Sakız
Samuray
Sarhoş
Sarkı Türkü
Satranç
Savaş
Savunma
Seriler
Sevgi
Şeytan
Shockwave
Siçrama
Şiddet
Side Scrolling
Sihir Büyü
Silah
Simpsonlar
Simülasyon
Sirk
Smileys
Sniper
Sokak
Sokak Dövüşü
Solucan
Sörf
Şovalye
Spor
Strateji
Su
Sumo
Süper Kahraman
Süslenme - Makyaj Yapma
Tahmin Etme Fark Bulma
Takip
Tank
Tavşan
Tavuk
Tek Kişilik Oyunlar
Tenis
Terorist
Tesisat
Tetris
Top Bilye Oyunları
Top Gülle
Toplama Ekleme
Tren
Tuğla Parçalama
Tuhaf
Turn Based
Tuzak
Uçak
Uçma
Uzay
Uzay Gemisi
Uzay Istilası
Uzaylı
Virus
Voleybol
Warcraft
Yapboz
Yaralama
Yaratık
Yarış
Yemek
Yemek Pişirme
Yemek Servisi
Yılan
Yılbaşı
Yumruklama
Yüzme
Zamanlı Oyunlar
Zar Oyunlar
Zıplama
Zombi

Posted by: Oyunlar on August 23, 2008 07:56 PM

thanks admin

Posted by: mirc on September 3, 2008 06:17 AM

thanks

Posted by: mirc on September 8, 2008 06:50 AM

thank you web admin.

Posted by: bayanlarla sohbet on September 17, 2008 08:44 PM

umm great.! thank you :)

Posted by: kocaeli sohbet on September 17, 2008 08:45 PM

thankyou yasamak güzel

Posted by: muhabbet on September 18, 2008 04:40 AM

my favorite web blogs thanks

Posted by: mersin sohbet on October 3, 2008 05:30 AM

There is big faults on computer history. Someone says world economy won’t be higher that 6 PC’s, another was said who needs an e-mail address. Anyway social networking will be live, because humans are social creatures.

Posted by: izmir chat on October 7, 2008 05:50 PM

erotik partner, erotik arkadaş, partner, arkadaş

http://www.aarkadas.com

Posted by: arkadaş on October 14, 2008 04:31 AM

The best is not always the most popular. My favorite scientific blogs

Posted by: Rap Dinle on October 26, 2008 05:02 AM

thanks.

Posted by: hekimboard on October 26, 2008 07:39 AM

thanks a lot .

Posted by: turksiding on October 26, 2008 07:41 AM

Thank You.

Posted by: Hack on November 1, 2008 06:09 PM


Filmizle
Film İzle
Seyret
Filmini
Full İzle
Dizi İzle
Online İzle
Filmini İzle
Film izlemek
Online Full Seyret İzle
Bedava Film İzle
İnternetten Film İzle
Online Sinema İzle
Netten İzle
Online Dizi İzle
Erotik Filmler
İndirmeden Full İzle
+18 Filmler
Son Bölümler
SinemaFanClub
Dini Filmler
Video Klibler
Serdar Ortaç
Online 2008 Filmleri
sinemafan
Online Sinema
Hadise
Kavak Yelleri
2008
Film Seyret
Süper Sinema
videocenter
+18 film izle
2008 Filmleri
Sinema Filmi İzle
Sinema İzle
Video İzle
Dizifilm İzle
İndirmeden Film İzle
Netten İzle
Film İzlet
Lost
Sinemalar
Vizyon Filmleri
Kariyer
Eski Türk Filmşeri
Yerli Dram
Yerli Aksiyon
Yerli Komedi
Yerli Romantik
Yerli Savaş
Yerli Korku
Yerli Dizi
Bilim Kurgu
Tiyatro
Belgesel
islami Filmler
Fantastik
Çizgi Film
Animasyon
Yabancı Aksiyon
Yabancı Dram
Yabancı Korku
Yabancı Gerilim
Yabancı Macera
Yabancı Polisiye
Yabancı Dizi
Yabancı Savaş
Yabancı Komedi
Yabancı Romantik
Yararlı Linkler
Kurtlar Vadisi Pusu
Link Değişimi
Site Ekle
Oriflame
Oriflame Kozmetik
Oriflamekozmetik
Oriflametr
Kozmetik
Parfüm
Koku
Cilt Bakımı
Saç
Makyaj
Ruj
Katalog
Üyelik
Satış
Sipariş
Hediye
Kampanya
Kariyer
Kazanç
Fırsat
Oje
Krem
Losyon
Jel
Kazanç

iş imkanı
Danışman
Temsilci
Sponsor
Bilgi
Bilgibu
Bilgi Bu
Popüler Bil
Bedava Bilgi
Online Bilgi
Ücretsiz Bilgi
iyi Bilgi
Aşk Şiirleri
Yemek Tarifleri
Rüya Tabirleri
Şifalı Bitkiler
Dini Bilgiler
Güzel Sölzer
Atatürk
Sağlık
illerimiz
Eğitim
Anne ve Bebek
Aşk ve Evlilik
internet
Astroloji
Bilgisayar
Fıkralar
Çiçek ve Bitkiler
Sevgi
Türk Tarihi
Oyunlar
Pratik Bilgiler
Güzellik ve Moda
Hava Durumu
ilansayfası
Forum
Efendi Forum
Forumx
Forumtr
Frm
Bilgi Forum
Sağlık Forumu
iş forumu
Wordpress
Joomla
Php Nuke
Forum Turkey
Sohbet
Chat
Muhabbet
Mirc
Efendi
Efendi Sohbet
Canlı Canlı
Heyecanlı
Kızlar
Msn
Sohbet Odaları
Bedava Sohbet
Görüntülü Sohbet
Kameralı Chat
Memur
Memuru
Memurlar
Memurum
Memurumuz
Sağlık Memuru
Polis Memuru
Öğretmen
Atama
Yer Değiştirme
Tayin
Becayiş
Yönetmelik
657
Devlet Memuru
Sivil Memur
Bağkur
Emekli Sandığı
Bağ-kur
Kanun
Torpil
KPSS
Sınav
ÖSYM
OSS
Kamu Personeli
Doktor
Doktorlar
Hemşire
Ebe
Hemşireler
Ebeler
Hademe
Milli Eğitim
Hastane
Okul
Lisans
Doktora
LDS
TUS
Sözleme
Sözleşmeli Memur
Sözleşmeli Personel
Personel
Diyanet
İmam
Asker
Askeri Personel
Subay
Astsubay
Polis
Hakim
Savcı
Avukat
Hukuk
Mühendis
Karayolları
Belediye
Zabıta
Güvenlik
TCK
Devlet Su işleri
Özel idare
Köy Hizmetleri
Alt Yapı
Daire Başkanlığı
Tıbbi Sekreter
Sekreter
Dışişleri
içişleri
Bakanlık
Bakanlıklar
Memur Sorunları
Psikolojik Danışmanlık
Taltif
Terfi
Ödül
Hediye
Kıdem
Derece
Kademe
Emeklilik
Emekli olmak
Emeklilik Tarihi
Başarılı Personel
Ceza
Kıdem Cezası
Disiplin Cezası
Disiplin Tüzüğü
Personel Alımı
Bayan Personel
Erkek Personel
Disiplin Cezası
Disiplin Cezaları
Sicil
Sicil Affı
Ruhsat
Disiplin Affı
Silah
Pasaport
Yeşil Pasaport
Eş ve Çocuklar
Bakmakla Yükümlü
Yardım
Sağlık Yardımı
Para Yardımı
Borç
Sandık
Sendika
Sendikası
Sendikalar
Üye Olma
Ayrılma
Meslekten Atma
Meslektan Çıkarma
Oriflame
Oriflame Kozmetik
Oriflamekozmetik
Oriflametr
Kozmetik
Parfüm
Koku
Cilt Bakımı
Saç
Makyaj
Ruj
Katalog
Üyelik
Satış
Sipariş
Hediye
Kampanya
Kariyer
Kazanç
Fırsat
Oje
Krem
Losyon
Jel
Kazanç

iş imkanı
Danışman
Temsilci
Sponsor
Full Film İzle
Sinema İzle
Yeni Filmler
Vizyondakiler
Vizyon Filmleri
izlesene
Justin
Netlog
Kurtlar Vadisi
Full Dizi
Direk izle
Tamekran Sinema İzle
Netten Bedava İzle
Sinema Seyret
Yabancı Sinema
Beleş izle
DVDRip Film izle
XviD Film izle
DivX Film izle
Cinetr
Full dizi
Korku Filmi
Kesintisiz izle
Direkizle
Korkufilmi
Online Film İzle
Çizgifilm
Animasyon izle
Çizgi Film

Posted by: Oriflame Kozmetik on November 2, 2008 10:58 AM

thanks

Posted by: oyunlar on November 21, 2008 12:18 PM

thanks

Posted by: comedya on November 21, 2008 12:20 PM

thanks

Posted by: roket oyun on November 21, 2008 12:22 PM

thanks

Posted by: sohbet on December 2, 2008 04:10 PM
Posted by: baterry on December 7, 2008 01:18 AM

Cam Balkon Glasing System

Posted by: Cam Balkon on December 14, 2008 04:13 PM

Cam Balkon Sistemlerriii

Posted by: Cam Balkon Sistemleri on December 14, 2008 04:15 PM

Wordpress definitely seems to be the best…everyones using it and seem to show no such complications……I too plan my way to get a blog of my own running on wordpress !

Posted by: türkü dinle on December 20, 2008 12:21 PM

Wordpress is good script but there is some reasons that i dont like it. its very good for blogs but admin panel is not comfortable.

Posted by: sohbet odaları on December 21, 2008 04:56 AM

Wordpress makes things to easy I feel, and it's too commonly used by just about everybody. Meaning there is nothing original about wordpress sites.

Posted by: kayseri on December 22, 2008 05:21 PM

Pourquoi ce site Web n’ont pas l’autre appui de langues ?

Posted by: yozgat on December 24, 2008 05:26 AM

very veyr thanx...

Posted by: KDvideo on January 4, 2009 04:24 PM

thank you

Posted by: ilkon emlak on January 6, 2009 09:01 AM

simdi biz bu siteyi kasarken cinsel sohbet birde sohbet odaları
olarak kasmaya calıstık guzel sozler de ilerleme var ona birde mirc yaptık gun gectikce
kelebek script olarak hit alamaya basladık oda olmadı birde kelebek
radyo muz olsun dedik iyi kotu muhabbet oluyordu ama baktık kadınca
çet cet üniversite odaları
nda is yok donduk mirc indir e ondada tat tuz kalmamıs rüya tabirlerine zipladık izmir de oturuyorum iste ..
sonra da yavas yavas ilerlemeye basladık operserv chanserv memoserv nickserv komutlarını yazdık .. bir sonraki hedefimiz sohbet yada chat olacak insallah ..sex seks demi kassak acaba :)

ask oyun itiraf link degisimi siir

Thanks for the great work. !


muhabbet - sohbet odaları - mirc indir - mirc indir - çet - kelebek - script - mirc indir - arkadas - chat - sohbet odaları - kelebek - sohbet - radyo - çet - cet odaları - portalsohbet ekle -


kelebek - kelebek - turk sohbet - çet - muhabbet - muhabbet - turkce mirc - sohbet odaları - sohbet - cinsel chat - mynet chat -

izmir sohbet cinsel sohbet kelebek mirc operserv chanserv siir botserv zurna mynet ataturk universitesi sohbet chat odalari au sohbet au chat kelebek script kelebek script kelebek mirc kelebek skript mric gazi universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,gazi sohbet,gazi chat,kelebek duzce universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,duzce sohbet,duzce chat ... ege universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,ege sohbet,ege chat,kelebek dumlu pınar universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,dumlupınar sohbet ... memoserv, memo serv,memoserv komutlari mesaj komutlari irc mesaj ... mirc indir kamerali mirc yabanci mirc mirc 6.21
sesli tv seslisesli sesliask sesli fıkra sesliefsane sesliyiz sesli türkiyem seslialem sesli dini sohbet ... erzincan universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,erzincan sohbet ... Yüzük Script mirc yüzük cet yüzük script 4 yuzuk sohbet yüzük chat ankara sohbet ankara chat ankara muhabbet ankara arkadas ankara.net erciyes universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,erciyes sohbet,erciyes ... dicle universitesi sohbet chat odalari ,dicle sohbet,dicle chat ... mirc indir,mirc script,mirc yukle,mirc,script mırç,mrc,kelebek ... kelebek cinsel sohbet cinsel chat kelebek mirc myrc script mirc programi turkçe mirc indir mric mrc ... izmir sohbet izmir chat izmir muhabbet izmir arkadas izmir cet çet kelebek sohbet odalari chat sohpet cet kelebek muhabbet çet ... arkadasbul askim - arkadas bul, arkadas arama, arkadas ara ... kelebek host iletisim bilgileri sitene sohbet ekle sitene chat ekle sitene sohbet odasi koy kelebek sohbet , chat kelebek sohbet , cet kelebek sohbet , canli ... sohbet Kizlarla Sohbet Kızlarla Sohbet, Bedava Sohbet Odası ... kelebek sohbet chat muhabbet amasya uiversitesi sohbet chat odalari au sohbet au chat canakkale onsekiz mart universitesi sohbet chat odalari comu ... istanbul sohbet istanbul chat istanbul muhabbet istanbul arkadas

Posted by: kelebek on January 13, 2009 09:43 AM

Thanks you

Posted by: Sohbet odaları on January 22, 2009 01:27 PM

The possibility of Wordpress is indeed limited only by your imagination. Happy blooking!..

Posted by: sohbet on January 22, 2009 04:14 PM

tmm tmm kbl

Posted by: chat on January 22, 2009 06:44 PM

The roof, slow arabesk rap, Don't listen the music the adress

Posted by: Sarki Dinle on February 12, 2009 08:25 AM

The roof, slow arabesk rap, Don't listen the music the adress

Posted by: Sarki Dinle on February 12, 2009 08:26 AM

The roof, slow arabesk rap, Don't listen the music the adress

Posted by: Sarki Dinle on February 12, 2009 08:26 AM

The roof, slow arabesk rap, Don't listen the music the adress

Posted by: Sarki Dinle on February 12, 2009 08:26 AM

turkler basmıs burayı yuh amk

Posted by: indir on February 12, 2009 03:53 PM

The possibility of Wordpress is indeed limited only by your imagination. Happy blooking!..

Posted by: indir on February 12, 2009 03:53 PM

I am with you. I am also interested in this kind of article. if you wanna me I will publish all my work which continues about 3 years. thanks for your article and being as a base of my works.

Posted by: msn adresleri on February 28, 2009 12:47 PM

thanks

Posted by: mirc on March 1, 2009 02:55 PM

türkçe mirc indir thanks

Posted by: türkçe mirc on March 7, 2009 07:53 AM

thank you admin super :)

Posted by: mirc indir on April 15, 2009 03:12 PM

thanks you gooddd

Posted by: mirc on April 15, 2009 03:12 PM

thanks

Posted by: chat on April 15, 2009 03:13 PM

thankss

Posted by: porno izle on May 4, 2009 10:52 AM

Thank You Admin.

Posted by: Chat on May 17, 2009 08:44 AM

hallo i wish you verry succes operator

Posted by: sohbet on May 17, 2009 10:33 AM

hallo i wish you verry succes operator

Posted by: sohbet on May 17, 2009 10:34 AM

hallo i wish you verry succes operator

Posted by: sohbet on May 17, 2009 10:35 AM

hallo i wish you verry succes operator

Posted by: Edencity on May 19, 2009 08:47 AM

hallo i wish you verry succes operator

Posted by: Edencity Chat on May 22, 2009 09:47 PM

hallo i wish you verry succes operator

Posted by: Edencity Chat on May 22, 2009 09:49 PM

hallo i wish you verry succes operator

Posted by: Sohbet on May 31, 2009 05:01 PM

seks yapan lezbıyen SEKS VE ORGAM ELLEME V tiny teen 15 sex izle banyoda sex fotoraflar beyaz vucutlu kızlar yeni şiksmeler sikini kız arkadaşına en kötüsex firikikler sex adult ızle free erotik video site: maturepopo erkek penisi gösteren diskoda seks izlesene erotık fabrıka sex DEnizci kızı sikişi am sikiş filmi izle esmeri bağırtıyorlar amına sik sokan kadın erotık turbanlı fotola free sikiş sevişme por webcamda okşayanları h romen orosbuları seks videoları pembele sarhoş firikiler sexparty dans beyaz amc hizmetçisex masturbasyon sıcak fuck you doctor porno \"kanlı am\" wepcam show izle yap k erkek ve kadın sikişle külotlu çorapla giyen wierd hayvanlı porno ateşli popo sikiş kadın gögüsleri erotik kadınsex itiraf kadın soyundur sex izl soyunankızı sikme götten veren kumral ağrılı kızı sikiyor gts san andreas kadın fabrıa kızıyla sex komşusuyla seks acemi kızın webcamda s tül çoraplı kadın por orosbu arrıyorum sex porn erotik video olgun kadın genç çocuk AM GÖT ZENCİ sikişli kız videoları nylons video izle olgun kadın erotikfilm en çığlıklı seks yaşlı erotik film izle amına kola şişesi soka oral se körsikiş seks izle doggy amın dan kan akıyor kı dolgun kadınların siki övgüide izle sitriptiz izle bedava yasak olmayan orosbu k doyasıya seks porno www.zevklifilm.com seks filmi fahişe amını ok erotik üçlü porno fili trevesti şikiş sexs 13 domalma pornolar turkceporno.org buyuk sikşen adamlar free dvd film alman yaşlıkadınlarla sesk p ablanı sike sike bayıl am s,kiş ablanı sike sike bayıl annem vidio erotik sevişme şişman kadınların porn deli sexk yapanlar sex yapan plgun kadınl genç erotik kızlar çıplak erotik görüntül punci resimleri bedava seks pornc film japon porno flim izle daracık kalça sikişi lezbiyen seks videosu azeri kızı porno YAŞLI ŞİŞMAN KADININ İ sikişen ihtiyar lezbiy sikimin gireceği am sex garanti sex adam sikiyo kadın sıçı hoca kiz sikiyor aşkımporno banyoda popoya şaplak cocuk yaşlı sikişi popoporno wwwsıcak videolar izlesene sevişme sahne çılgınca türk sex yaslıların sikişi gelinlikle sikiş helpçi adultr seks şikişen ögretmeni videoseks KOLEJLİ KIZKAR SİKİŞME dolgun vücutlu kadınla çoraplı annesini sikiş yaşlı erotica oğluyla seks yapan kad am görüntüleri izle sımsıkı taş gibi amsik yeşil çam erotikvideo kurt karı pornosu teenspornoizle.com SİKİŞ SHOW erotik milf kadınlar masturbasyon yapan olg erotik lezbiyen show kızı pantolun üzerinde sıcak hatunalr kanlı şikiş videları ŞEFFAF BEYAZ KÜLOTLU K olgun yaşlı kadın porn video erot penis yalayan çıtır en uzun penis vidoolar rusorospular büyük yarrak seven kad en hızlı takılmadan tr olgun sexi dul kadın f okulda hoca sikme zefgınde seks izle sex kız acemi acemi kızlar porno büyük dudaklı vajina p sürtük kızlar karılar kızın ağzına veriyor v sıcak dul olgun video seks sikiş yapan kızla kapalı kız küiotlu çorap döverek zorla sikme başörtülü kız kudurmuş sevişen öğretmenve öğrencisi s sex seksene olgun kadın sikişi tecrübeli amatör sex öğrenci kızı okşuyor jigolo arayan yaşlı ka sikişen 50 yaşın üstün seks porno 30 Annemi zorla sex küçük orosbu 6 yaşında dolgun vücutlu sikiş asyalı kızların bekare eglenceli sikiş videol güzel avrat sikişi mankenlerin seks vidyo young girl büyük popolar sex vide teen erotik izle çoraplı bacaklı seks on sekizlik kızsikişi temiz sikiş denizde kız izle www zevk film izle net büyük sikle seks yapan liseli sex aduld japon babam ablamı sikiyo boşalan kızlar videosu olgun kadın ve genç ço eglenceli azgın sikiş evdesex videosu olgun kadın garajda ve 69sex porno amı kaşınanlar porno f popoya işkence pornosu kız yurdunda şikişenle derste çılgınca sexs anne ile sikiş üniformalı güzeller si dansda sikiyor bilardoda sikişler bedava oral sikiş vide sikiş videoları yaşlı szex fılm öretmen orencı şikiş azgınsikme kendi istegiyle sexyap sıcak kızlar sex ilginç yaraklar sikiş yapan kızla vid evli bayan borno amdan sikişme vidiosu seks yapan gaylar izle kapalı firikik göt delini sikmek rus sarışın seks 18+porno erotik sikiş yaşli olgun kadin dvd olgun izle büyük penisli sex vide COCUK PORNOFILM sadece sisman kadin se sıcak sex türkçe UZUN YARAK SEKS İZLE kız kardeşini sikenler yaramaz adult türkçe önce sohbet so evde erotik porno otobüste fordculuk izl ovguide adoult AMCİK SEX TGP kanlı sikis izle seksı bornolar porno paritisi porno izle seks net vi lezbiyen ögrenci siki www.işeyenkadınlar ımmmmmm porno bedava yaşlı seks köyü erotik izle olgun kadın sikişme dısco sex film kıçlı kızlar video kız balkonda soyunuyor sevişen karı resim zenci adam cüce kız po wwwseks.şow france erotik izle lez şişman seks filmi böyük göslü kadınlar v melis birkan sex kız porno sex erotik s \"çocukla sesk yapan y sex free adult porno i ovguide 18 komikpornosex acık sıcak sex hikaye gerçek samanlık sikiş gelinini sikenler sınıfta sex dersi ilkkez götten sikişenl kanada sexi aletli sikişler site:www.seksene.net k karısını arkadaşına si Yaşlı kadın genç sevi mini etek sikiş video olgun kadın küçük çoçu şikiş şişman orosbu seks saksafon lezbiyen popo porno atyarakları cocuk anal sex 16 17 1 ablamı sikdim izle ablamı sikdim amından almak starporno şişman kadınların sexi daracıkgöt sikme vidos çişyapankadınlar erotik animasyonlar in www ikiztepe porno com erkek çocuk yalıyor genç ve yaşlı sikiş yaşlı kadın sikis porn koca yarakla yüzüne bo porna film izle bir kadın iki erkek si japon spiker sex zencikadınlar tuvalet yapan kadınlar 60 yaşında mature siki evlikadın seks yapıyor dantellikilot olgun kadın küçük çocu rus OROBULAR \"the youngest fuck vi gizli seks izle erotık sevişme videola tuvalet yapan kadınlar 95 cm yarak paris hlton yatakta sikiş videolar amatör orospu kocman göğüsler vajinalılar teen naylon çorap seks büyük emme büyük popo yaşlı kadınlar seks vd annesiyle sevişen kız GÖTTEN SİKTİRME VİDEOS kadın işiyorlar yaşlı sevişme videosu kırmız erotik videolar türk kızının sikişi .c yumuşak travesti mutfakta sikiş izle zencibayan teensarea çocuk.com porno izle seks net vi erotizm turkler en yeni evli karı koca içime girme sex video teyzem türk rotik zadarmo teens porno vi çiftlik olgun porno olgun kadın seks vido japon erotik filim izl çocuklarla sikişen kad olgunlarla sesk kız yurdu pornoları dvd film beautiful seks angelsex japon sikişli vidyolar yaşlıların sekslerini en güzel vajına videyo bursalı orosbu ideal sikiş teknikleri kalın yarak anal rahıbeler şişman teyzenin seks f koca yaraklı adam porn alyssa milano pono porno sıkıs naylon c kadın sexte istiyor dicko sex partileri büyükam üçlü porno sikiş çorap dolgun kadin sikme amı sikmek mpeg kudurdum aduld seksi sevişme sahneler birbirini siken traves asyal japon grup japon erotik videolar kadını arkadan dayıyo teyzesiyle sexs yapan kilitorisi kesik kadın naylon coraplı sıkısı sıcak lezbiyenlerin vi hafif erotik videolar kadın inliyor seks naylon corap girls sex sulu kızlık bozma porn sicak kadin porno lezbiyenporno tv eve erkek alıp sikişen arab kadınların sikiş jaoanes porn bakire tini bozan kizl türk sikişmes alo sex net etiket ero yarağı okşayan kadın a lezbiyen sex show izle olgun kadın seyret vajina sikiş.com EŞEK ŞİKİŞ VİDEO denizde sikişenler fil nylons sex sahilde sevişenler cocuk olgun kadın sevı grup sex pornoları arkadaşının annesini s amı kıllı türkce üvey oğluyla si meme emen lezbiyen naylon coraplı lezbıye zenci erkek masör ist dolgun bacaklı kızlar gta san andreas kızı s olgun kadın seksfilim sıcak cemile sex iki sarışın lezbiyen ö en yeni lezbiyen olgun olgun kadınlar erotık deniz alti sexs ORMANDASİKİŞ japon götten eğilen sikişen lezbiyen karım orospuydu azdımkudurdum yaşlı kadını soyarak şişman kadı sikiş vidi Canlı sex videoları rus ertika www.araba.sex özelporno büyük memeli kadılar temızlıkcı sevısıyo kapalı dul karılar fucked seks france mini seks filimi ağda videoları vajina suda erotık foto zevkden işiyen kadınla öğretmeni ile seks yap sıcak erotısm free sevişmeli sikiş GIZLIK AM ciplakkilar kıllı kız resimleri büyük yark sikiş indir türbanlı kaltak yaşlı kadın genç çocuk buyukpens anime sikiş su içinde porno yarak vi sikişme oyunlari 45 siyah külot porno GOODVIDZ zorla kadın sikme vide zevk icin sikişen yaşl amını yalarken boşaltı zevk için sikişen öğre sarışınlar banyoda yaşlı kadınların büyük yarrağımı beğendi erotik yaşlı kadın sek çişini yapan amlar seks yaoan genç kızlar \"pasif gaylar\" kolejli kız seks zenci sıcak sex sevişme dersi veren öğ olgun kadınlerın sex f amına patlıcan sokan k sekslı bayan çıplak da sıcak asyalı şarışın lezbiyenler am zevkkafe.com sexe gel info video ci aşk sevişme sikişme suluseks sikişen anne porno arabadaseviş tenuyumu sikiş yapay penisle sexk vid sikiş birezilyalı arkadan sevısmek sübyan seks izle japon kızıpornoları gta san andreas da kar büyük sikli yaraklı er kalça am izle kadın hizmetci genç si yaşlı jigolo pornosu iki penisli sikişi olgun am yataktasikiş tül çoraplı güzel kad gelin damat gerdek gec porna lezbiyen show vildan ata ssever teyzem co tr ilk kez seks yapan kız teyzemcom hikayeler sex hane izle tesettürlü araplar giz siyah tül çoraplı göt sex isteyen travestyle sicak lezbiyen video adamın ağzına sıçıyor sikilş11 Vikipedi sikişme video samanlıkta emma watson sikme oyun tecaviz kadınlaara arkadan vid suyun içinde sikiş izl kızların yarakları kürt kızı sex hikaye banyoda dert sikiş seksi seven gaylar yaşlı yarak porno hoyratca sikişen amc şikiş yapan kızlar ve olgun azgın seks nylon çorap sexsi sokuş sitesi olgun kadın sikişleri gta san andreas kadını olgun sikme teyze kızı vidosu lezbiyen sızak sex +18 dolgun kadın video 22 yaşında satılan kız çok yaşlı kadınların k orosbu kadınlar sex vi

Posted by: Porno izle on June 5, 2009 02:17 PM

very good web, thanx web admin

Posted by: mirc on June 11, 2009 06:16 AM

en güzel oyunlar

Posted by: oyun oyna on June 12, 2009 08:27 PM

Thanks

Posted by: sohbet on June 22, 2009 07:24 PM

video türk net anne cocuk sex yapıyor saksaf ceken kadınlar gay pornoları zencikalçalar sıcak filim izle \" amını parmaklayan k cıldır am izle vajina yalıyanlar erotik hiyaler kız am veriyor bedavasevişme videolar türbanlı kadın seks fi erotik ve seks sevişme atın yarağını yalıyor derste sevişen öğretme tr dublaj sikiş filmmi porno bakire net nylon porno film ammını okşayan yaşlı k maturesait porno beyaz kilot porn YUMUŞAK SİKİŞİ kizlik bozma porno fil sınıfta öğretmeniyle s yarak ami kadının zevkten boşalm onsekizlik rus kocaman göğüslü cocukyaslı kadın kadın köpeğe siktiriyo sex fotoğtafları hemşire sex videosu atın sikini yalıyor amını okşayan kadın re öğretmen ile öğrenci uzun yaraklar vidosu seksene 2 adam 1 kadın ufak öğretmen odasında öğre eğreti gelin sikiş banyoda seks pornoları uydu seks öğrenci öğretmeninin s polis karısı sex ilk sex seksene sex cıft ızle, fahişe parayla sikiş bornozlu porno filmi sex konusmaları disney sex videoları olugun kadınlar ponu ensest ilişkiler sex izle kızlık bozm kurt kızın sikişi senci kalça vidyo tears porn çömez 2 kadın 1 erkek sikiş çiftlikte tecavüz erot gelin ve damadın gerde zenci olgun sikişken k azgın evlıler fukyou porno bul orosbu öğretmen odasında seks otobüslerde erotik kapalı kadınların seks www erotic asia girl.c olgun kadından sikiş d ge nç kızsex tesettürlüsex at kadını sikiyor orgun kadını arkadan s rahip rahibeyi sikiyor hamam vıdeo sex teen kadın yatağa bağlıyarak adult entest hikayeler sicak izlekop seks hastası kadınlar tıny4 fuck kadın sek türkçe dublajlı sikiş travesti gey sikişi iz TUBE,SEX NET,COM ıslanmış am vidyosu anesini siken genç vid olgun tatlı kadınlar s satanist sikiş videola tesetürlü am şişman kadının amını e duştan sonra sikiş sulu am vidyosu yarak seven kadinlar rambonun porno filmi dvd yaşlı kadın porno erotik yabanci seks olgun kadın ve cocuk s porna,gizlilik,arayan amınasalatalık sokuyor FULL YİYEN KARILAR İZ yabancı sevişmek deliler gibi kocamı götünü dünyanın en büyük gögü sicak kadın elleme vid eşek kadınlar koca yarrak kadının gö kadınların.güreşi koca yarrak hala evde sikişiyor 31 çeken adamlar video karım seks hikayeleri çocuklar sikişiyor izl Video seks kızlar 200 erotik sikis filimleri gözü bali sikis evde en beyaz gotler yarak yarışması su şişesini amına soka bayan soymaca www erotic asian girl erotik sikiş polis kar sıcak 18 izle Tangalı Manitaya am opme porno amotö r sikiş porno seks kapalı kadı firiseks yaşlı olgun kadın 89 p dktorla dokroruyla sexs sıçan kızlar kaynımla yengemi videosu erotic hd öğrenci öğretmenine ve gizli kamera doktor sevisme teknikleri vid olugun sikişen kaınlar hayvanla kadın sikişme doktorla sert sikiş kadının yaşlı öğretmenini sike uzun olgun kadın eroti banyoda otuzbir çeken amına ş,şe sokan lezbi bedava orosbu sikişi s yengemle sert yemgemle arap kadınlarının seks yarrak yalayan kız kürt kızları olgun kadın erotik vid doktoruyla sulanan doktor www kapalı sikişenler polis karıs at yarağı ile seks yap esmer ögretmen sex lezbiyen erotik am sikis hikayelşeri fuck you pornos Araç disinda sikis annesiyle sex yapan co türce seks lezbiyenlerin sevişm free full milf pornola şişman erkek zorla sex prgazm fişek sikiş kız boşalması polis sikşi adult film izle zenci sikişi arkadan teyzemi sikiyo göğüsleri yala izle erotik görüntüleri çoc çıplak kadın porno par türbanlı dvd sex film karışık seks izle seks yaparken işeyen k yaşlı ve genc erotik f olgun kadınlar seks tu 13 lük kız gizli ?ekim seks izle küçük yaşta kız sikişi yabancıtravestiler diskoda ertotik dünyanın en büyük meme trasli karilar 3d animasyon pornosu i olgun sex itiraf polis sikiyo yaşlıkadın kilolu kadınların erot erotik ünlülülerin vid yaşlı.kadın.çocuk.siki polis hamile kadı adamın ağzına sıç yaşlı dvd sex izle sisman kadin sikilmesi beraket bozma