Rich Lowry says Rudy Giuliani has what it takes to be the antidote to George W. Bush's incompetence:
Giuliani’s axioms of governance, described in his book “Leadership,” now read as a kind of rebuttal to Bush’s hands-off management style. One of his rules is “Always Sweat the Small Stuff.” Another is “Prepare Relentlessly.” He delivered annual 90-minute State of the City addresses without a prepared text: “I presented it from my own head and heart, not from a page.” And “Everyone’s Accountable, All of the Time.” Giuliani kept a two-word sign on his desk: “I’M RESPONSIBLE.”Famously the first CEO president, Bush has had his reputation as an executive trashed by Katrina and Iraq. Bush had seen his role primarily as setting goals, then remaining resolute and confident about them. But the resolution and confidence are self-defeating if the goals aren’t matched with the appropriate means. Bush has been ill-served by his willingness to stand by failed subordinates (thereby eroding any sense of accountability), by his relative lack of interest in details and by his inability to establish coherence within his own government.
Frankly, I think this is crap.
Cashing in on post-9/11 popularity with a business/self-help book on "leadership" offering the same pearls of wisdom you could get from a popular retired NFL coach or, for that matter, a high school basketball coach is not the same as management expertise. Specifically, when it came to municipal management, the signal quality of the Giuliani administration was tunnel vision. He came into office deciding that what he cared about was reducing the crime rate and security credit for reducing the crime rate. He pursued both goals zealously, and achieved them both. On the education front, what he wanted to do was avoid being held responsible for NYC school performance -- he pursued that goal zealously. When he didn't care about something -- like, say, improving school performance -- he didn't do anything about it.
This produced okay results as mayor. The crime problem when Giuliani took office was really bad. Things got much better under his tenure. The fall in crime improved other aspects of city life. Giuliani got tons of credit for it and cruised to re-election. At the same time, it was a self-limiting process and by the end of his second term all he was doing was picking pointless fights and aggravating people, not moving on to tackle new problems. Low-profile things like, say, disaster response were horribly mismanaged, just like Bush with Katrina. Corrupt toadies like Bernard Kerik did very well. Absolute loyalty was the key qualification for top aides.
Again, it all comes back to the same thing: the case for Giuliani rests entirely on some good post-9/11 speeches and on the theory that he deserves the lion's share of the credit for the unusually large crime drop NYC experienced in the 1990s. The first is plainly irrelevant. The second might be relevant if Giuliani were running for mayor of a large city with a major crime problem (Washington, DC, say) but has nothing to do with being president. His term as mayor, meanwhile, strongly suggests to me that he's not really up to the job. He's primarily a glory-chaser and a spotlight hog, which are absurd qualities for a president to have since, unless a US Attorney or a mayor, the president is constantly in the spotlight no matter what he does. I think he'd be clueless in an office where attention-grabbing publicity stunts are pointless.
Comments
Attached is a link to a column in todays Washington Post about Mr. Giulianis' mean disposition and explosive temper. He might well self destruct in the heat of a hotly contested presidential race.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/03/05/AR2007030501187.html
"The crime problem when Giuliani took office was really bad. Things got much better under his tenure."
Sigh. Crime had already started a dramatic decline under the Dinkens administration.
And crime in NYC across the Dinkens and Giuliani administrations fell almost in perfect lockstep with other US cities, which serves as strong circumstantial evidence that the drop in crime should be laid at factors far beyond Gracie Mansion.
I hope you get a gig in the MSM, and continue to be as incisive and direct a bulsshit detector as you are in your blog.
One thing's for sure- our next president must be able to accomplish those goals which he or she promised to achieve. That would include the Millennium Development Goals!
The second might be relevant if Giuliani were running for mayor of a large city with a major crime problem (Washington, DC, say) but has nothing to do with being president.
Of course, if one believes this, then nothing that a Governor or Senator does is relevant to being president either. So Matthew's assertion is really damning every single candidate out there.
Low-profile things like, say, disaster response were horribly mismanaged, just like Bush with Katrina.
What???
New York City had the biggest disaster in the history of the Untied States during Giuliani's tenure, and Giuliani performed perfectly. Is Matthew completely out of his mind???
"New York City had the biggest disaster in the history of the Untied States during Giuliani's tenure, and Giuliani performed perfectly."
Providing good sound bites on the day of the disaster is not the sole responsibility of a chief executive. Heeding his advisors and not locating the city's emergency command center inside the most obvious target of a terrorist attack would be better evidence of performing perfectly.
Bingo.
And let's not forget the crime rate started to drop under Dinkins, and continued to drop (and stay low when other cities were climbing) after Guiliani left office. Rudy's first term wasn't met with anything near universal approval--he was re-elected with just 55% of the vote, compared to Koch's 78% re-elect in the mid 1980's.
And also, Giuliani's a miserable failure on leadership. On 9/11, firefighters and cops couldn't communicate with each other--and this had been a problem for YEARS. He spent millions moving the city's emergency response center to the 23rd floor of WTC 7, over the protests of many including his chief of police, and as predicted, it was useless in a terrorist attack (and was actually destroyed when WTC7 collapsed). He did nothing to warn people about the toxic air after 9/11, and thousands of people are sick as a result. He threatened to illegally run for office, creating a constitutional crisis, unless his term in office was extended.
Heeding his advisors and not locating the city's emergency command center inside the most obvious target of a terrorist attack would be better evidence of performing perfectly.
He put it in WTC 7, not WTC 1 or 2. I mean, come on.
Yes, because no one could possibly have foreseen that WTC7 would have been affected by an attack on the two enormous buildings right across the street. Idiot.
"He put it in WTC 7, not WTC 1 or 2. I mean, come on."
But many were opposed to even that, for reasons that proved quite prescient.
And, as noted by another commenter, he failed to heed repeated warnings about the fire/police command structure that ended up being fatal on 9/11.
I honestly can't figure out what you're referencing when you say he "performed perfectly" other than his ability to give good TV on the day of the attacks. And while that's not an unimportant thing, it's really not a good measure of the fullness of a chief executive's responsibilities.
Is this fake Al?
The point isn't Guliani, per se, but Bush. Guliani is the flotsam Lowry is hoping to cling to, as he can no longer pretend that the CEO goal-setting, delegating, "decider" president is competent in any sense of the word.
The appeal of Guliani, and Romney for that matter, is that neither of them screwed the pooch when the heat was on. We can argue endlessly about how they performed overall, but it took the ex-CEO team of Bush/Cheney to repeatedly ignore warnings of impending doom, and then claim what was predicted was unforseeable and unavoidable, as with 9/11, Iraq and Katrina.
Shorter, more musical Al:
How did I get so rude and reckless?
Why am I so crude and feckless?
I must be drinking booze for breakfast
Rudy can't fail
Yes, because no one could possibly have foreseen that WTC7 would have been affected by an attack on the two enormous buildings right across the street.
All of America was "affected". You're saying Giuliani should have put the OEM center in Canada?
WTC 7 was just simply not a high profile target. Pretending that WTC 7 is no different than WTC 1 or 2 is transparent obfuscation.
I honestly can't figure out what you're referencing when you say he "performed perfectly" other than his ability to give good TV on the day of the attacks. And while that's not an unimportant thing, it's really not a good measure of the fullness of a chief executive's responsibilities.
So, the only thing that was done is to go on TV? Maybe I remember 9/11 differently than you. I remember a hell of a lot happening - such as getting the city back on its feet and going again. I remember dealing with hundreds of scares and yet still keeping the city going. I remember a rescue and recovery effort on a completely unprecedented scale. I guess that was all just on TV.
One larger point that Lowry is brushing upon is that all the GOP candidates are front runners because they have performed ably in the jobs--governor, mayor, and senator--and are in the race by virtue of their political and governing skills. This is a good thing, and it means that whoever wins the GOP nomination will likely be a competant politican who will perform better than the current president.
In contrast to the "choice" the Republicans had to make in 2000, they now have a field devoid of any candidates who feel entitled to the presidency by virtue of their last name. Which, unfortunately, is more than the Democrats can say,
Me? I remember Giuliani wanting the laws to be ignored so that he could continue in office.
That's just insane.
And insanity's pretty damning.
New York City had the biggest disaster in the history of the Untied States during Giuliani's tenure, and Giuliani performed perfectly."
Hyperbole much?? About 3 times as many people were killed in the Galveston Hurricane of 1900 than died in the terrorist attacks on 9/11.
"I remember a hell of a lot happening - such as getting the city back on its feet and going again."
My point here is that several of Giuliani's decisions as chief executive prior to 9/11 negatively impacted the situation in several ways, including debatably leading to the deaths of many, many firefighters. (And these poor decisions were not only poor in retrospect.)
And thus it's not quite right to describe Giuliani's 9/11 performance as chief executive as having "performed perfectly" unless you're oddly restricting yourself to describing his public cheerleading efforts - which he did indeed perform far better than his counterpart in the White House.
All of America was "affected". You're saying Giuliani should have put the OEM center in Canada?
Canada? No. But a building that wasn't across the fucking street would have been nice. I didn't realize that every building in all of America collapsed on 9/11. That must have been one hell of an impact.
Hyperbole much??
Maybe a little. But Galveston is not Lower Manhattan, no matter how many people died there. Number of deaths is not the sole way to rank the effect of a disaster.
OMG, I don't even know where to begin. My wife worked for City Hall during the Giuliani administration and the notion that he's a responsible, competent manager is perhaps the single greatest myth perpetrated by the MSM. So-called journalists like Rich Lowry need to spend time in New York, canvassing all five boroughs and reporting on whether eight million New Yorkers consider Giuliani an effective leader and manager, compared to, say, Michael Bloomberg. The answer -- from millions of us who depised Rudy's narcissitic style of governance -- would be a resounding "no."
As distasteful as it to observe Washington media types pontificate, it drives me bonkers when they pontificate about something they know NOTHING about: the true state of affairs in New York thtoughout Giuliani's mayoralty. Hence we get the same stupid cliches, time after time. Talk about galling.
You mean 'unlike a US Attorney' instead of 'unless a US Attorney' right? Sorry it just threw me for a sec.
All of America was "affected". You're saying Giuliani should have put the OEM center in Canada?
WTC 7 was just simply not a high profile target. Pretending that WTC 7 is no different than WTC 1 or 2 is transparent obfuscation.
I would have found that comment funny had I not had to walk past the still-smoldering wreckage of those buildings every day for months - beset by the overpoweringly pungent odor of burning chemicals and rotting flesh.
From my vantage point, there seemed to be quite a bit of room between WTC 7 and Canada - yet not so much between WTC 7 and WTC 1 and 2. But, then, I was never much good with maps. Giuliani must be though, because Al's right: it was either WTC 7 or Ottawa.
To claim otherwise would be transparent obfuscation, and Al knows a thing or two about that now don't he.
Matt,
I think you're being insufficiently generous.
I agree that Giuliani's primarly known for reducing New York City's crime problem. Let's leave aside whether he deserves that credit. Your point seems to be that the MOST we should credit him with is BEING A GOOD CRIME REDUCER, which, you rightly note, isn't particularly relevant to being a good president, seeing that American crime isn't so bad and that the president can't do much about crime anyway. But there's no need to view his record so narrowly. The people who support Giuliani don't look at his record and conclude that he's a good crime reducer. They look at his record and conclude that this is a man who can get things done when he wants them done. If Giuliani's passions had been reversed, if he hadn't cared a whit about crime rates but cared desperately about school reform, then what New York would have had under his tenure was much better schools and no progress on crime. Or at least that's what his proponents are taking away from his years in office.
As for Giuliani's quest for the spotlight, I think you're overselling how much attention America pays to the president. Major presidential policy initiatives are often followed by a presidential tour of the nation, with the president travelling from state to state attempting to sell his policy to the public and the major political players at the state level. Bush did one once during his push to revise social security and again when he was promoting the escalation in Iraq. Those tours are necessary precisely because holding a press conference in Washington won't cut it. People aren't listening, even to the President. A president with a passion to be heard and a knack for getting listened to has the potential to use the pulpit the presidency provides very effectively.
Don't get me wrong, I think Rudy would be a pretty terrible president. But I don't think the reasons you give are the reasons to be skeptical.
Bernie Kerik
"Cashing in on post-9/11 popularity with a business/self-help book on "leadership" offering the same pearls of wisdom you could get from a popular retired NFL coach or, for that matter, a high school basketball coach is not the same as management expertise."
Frankly, I had rather read the insights of Belichick (not retired) or Morgan Wooten (legend of HS basketball). Guiliani probably is on par with the insights of the recently re-retired Big Tuna, however.
If Giuliani's passions had been reversed, if he hadn't cared a whit about crime rates but cared desperately about school reform, then what New York would have had under his tenure was much better schools and no progress on crime.
Sorry, but that's bullshit. Know why? Because you can't improve education by the use of physical force, intimidation, and running roughshod over people's civil liberties. Those things can be useful in reducing crime. But you can't force knowledge into kid's heads, you actually have to do the hard work of improving the schools. It was patently beyond Giuliani's competence, which is why I suspect he didn't make it a priority.
And what, by the way, does it say about Rudy that he didn't give a shit about improving the schools?
Maybe a little. But Galveston is not Lower Manhattan, no matter how many people died there. Number of deaths is not the sole way to rank the effect of a disaster.
At the time Galveston was the largest city in Texas. But since it wasn't lower Manhattan I guess it doesn't count.
You want to talk number of people directly affected or area affected or money involved - 9/11 would be drawfed by the Great Mississippi Flood of 1927. Wiggle and squirm and move goalposts all you want, Al - you assertions of "fact" are sorely lacking. Just because something happens in Lower Manhattan automatically makes it "the biggest disaster in the history of the United States". Yeah, right.
Crime had already started a dramatic decline under the Dinkens administration.
correct, the murder rate peaked the first year dinkins was mayor. but dinkins is black so the entire downward spiral is laid at his feet, and not those of former democrat ed koch, whose tenure saw crime increases EVERY YEAR.
BTW - those who blame Giuliani for not fixing education while he was mayor are showing their ignorance of NYC's governance structure.
Giuliani didn't have the authority to fix education while he was mayor. The Board of Ed controls education in NYC, and when Giuliani was mayor, he did not control the Board of Ed. Only after Bloomberg became mayor did the State legislature give the office of mayor control over the Board of Ed.
"New York City had the biggest disaster in the history of the Untied States during Giuliani's tenure, and Giuliani performed perfectly. Is Matthew completely out of his mind???"
Posted by: Al
Try a hurricane. Imagine if a category 3-5 storm was 48 hours from a direct hit on Manhattan. See how the evacuation worked; see how many police and firefighters might have decided that saving their own families was most important.
There were several important things about 9/11 which made Giuliani look better:
1) No warning - which means that bad preparations were largely excused, panic beforehand wasn't a problem; nor was absenteeism. A mass evacuation combined with large-scale absenteeism among city/county workers would have been a disaster.
2) Extremely localized damage - the damage zone in Manhattan was measured in a few blocks. In New Orleans, by contrast, it was measured in square miles. The fact that Giuliani's emergency command post was destroyed was a testimony to his stupidity, not to any massive area devastated.
3) Limited levels of wounded people. Several accounts from the hospitals afterwards commented that the expected influx of casualties didn't happen - for the most part, people were either killed or suffered minor injuries. If several thousand people had been seriously injured, there'd have been thousands of deaths due to lack of medical care (which would pretty much be the case for all cities, but it would take the shine off of Guiliani's rep).
4) Hostile act - people blamed Al Qaida, as they should. But the wave of patriotism, and the taboo on criticism adopted by the GOP and MSM helped. In New Orleans, by contrast, the GOP and its right-wing Wurlitzer quickly adopted a 'blame the victims' propaganda theme.
Another is “Prepare Relentlessly.” He delivered annual 90-minute State of the City addresses without a prepared text...
well that seems contradictory
Only after Bloomberg became mayor did the State legislature give the office of mayor control over the Board of Ed.
Right. Because Bloomberg asked for that control -- actually spent some political capital trying to get it.
But more to the point, Giuliani had de facto control of the NYC Board of Education anyway, through his appointees. He certainly seemed to be able to engineer firings and hirings of the Chancellor (Rudy Crew, Harold Levy) at his pleasure.
At the time Galveston was the largest city in Texas. But since it wasn't lower Manhattan I guess it doesn't count.
911 was undoubtedly a more serious cataclysm than the Galveston storm. In addition to the horrific loss of life (which, if not quite as large as Galveston's was still in the same range), global economic losses are likely to have exceed $1 trillion. This really is a different scale than the legendary Texas storm, as horrible as it was.
There's also, of course, the fact that 911 triggered a war (or series of wars) whose disastrous effects we're still living with on a daily basis.
Al: I think you hit a nerve, by the way. If this thread is representative of lefty feelings about Rudy, he's one candidate they're definitely afraid of.
Buh-buh-buh Bush has an MBA!
Why did WTC7 collapse?
Rudy is temperamentally incapable of accomplishing anything if he can't arrest, indict, fire, or de-fund people who stand in his way. He deserves genuine credit for his first-term crime-fighting, even though crime was dropping in NYC for two years before he became mayor, dropped in lots of places where he wasn't mayor, and kept dropping in NYC after he was no longer mayor (under one of David Dinkins's police chiefs, by the way). Not only didn't he do much about reforming education, his very presence impeded reform. It is no accident that mayoral control -- which he and just about everyone else advocated -- didn't become a reality until a very different mayor, who could be trusted to handle it somewhat responsibly, was elected. Rudy's second term, through 9/10/01, was a sad, sour, egomaniacal soap opera of a performance that cost NYC millions in legal fees and, until 9/11, had made his political future a joke.
Just about anybody could have done what Rudy did on 9/11. If the attacks had come on 2/11/02 or 3/11/02, does anyone doubt that Mayor Mark Green or Mayor Freddy Ferrer or Mayor Bloomberg could have had someone write inspiring speeches and stood jut-jawed on the rubble?
Rambuncle, Counterpunch.org, of all places had a good report on this. IIRC, the debris from the falling towers next to it damaged the superstructure of WTC7, the heat from the fires in WTC1 &2 spread to cause secondary fires in WTC7, which in turn spread to the fuel tanks of the backup power generators located in WTC7. The combustion of these was sufficiently violent to bring the whole thing down, given the damage it had already suffered earlier
Also, if i remember rightly, Giuliani showed a deal of physical courage on Sept 11, encouraging emergency workers while standing right next to the danger zone. Physical courage like that makes a big impression (McCain's stay in the Hanoi Hilton does much the same for him). Personally, I think physical courage is a dangerous attribute to select a president on - I admire it, but it's not well correlated (either way) with intelligence and sound morals. For example both Saddam Hussein and Mohammed Atta went to their deaths showing physical courage, but this does not alter the fact that they were both appalling human beings. (and no, I do not think that Giuliani resembles the latter two in any other way than determination in the face of deadly hazard)
Right. Because Bloomberg asked for that control -- actually spent some political capital trying to get it.
Of course Giuliani lobbied for control of NYC education throughout his 8 years too. In fact, as I recall, Giuliani said that his biggest regret in his 8 years as mayor was not being able to get control of education in NY. I guess you can fault Giuliani on not being as good an Albany lobbyist as Bloomberg (note that Giuliani was just as unsuccessful as Dinkins and Kock in this regard). But that's different than faulting him on not improving education.
Al: I think you hit a nerve, by the way. If this thread is representative of lefty feelings about Rudy, he's one candidate they're definitely afraid of.
You can tell that the 9/11 thing really has the left concerned in that the focus of the attacks on Giuliani are 9/11-based: he didn't do anything except go on TV, or 9/11 wasn't that big a disaster. There's plenty of ammunition against Giuliani - Louima and so on - but there's a degree of desperation about 9/11.
"You can tell that the 9/11 thing really has the left concerned in that the focus of the attacks on Giuliani are 9/11-based: he didn't do anything except go on TV, or 9/11 wasn't that big a disaster. There's plenty of ammunition against Giuliani - Louima and so on - but there's a degree of desperation about 9/11."
I can only speak for myself, but my only point about Giuliani and 9/11 was that he hadn't "performed perfectly" in light of various widely reported failings in his management of the city's emergency capabilities.
But I don't deny that 9/11 is obviously his electoral hole card. The fact that he was good on TV that day is all that most non-involved voters will ever care about.
That said, I'd much rather run against Giuliani than McCain. Giuliani (much like Obama) can be sliced up like the 'zards defense. McCain has much stronger shields.
Management, Rudy style.
WTC is bombed in 2/93 by "islamofascists," who claim that the WTC is a symbol, a rotting pillar of Western iniquity.
Mayor Rudy announces that NYC is building a new Crisis Response Center to contend with such emergencies. And the location of that new nerve center?
The WTC.
Not exactly the sort of thing a top-flight manager wants on his resume.
I dunno, Petey. If Giuliani can get through the primary, don't you think that will show his defense isn't all that bad? After all, the people he mostly has to play defense against are conservatives, not independents or liberals. I don't know whether he can get through the primary, but if he can, I think it is pretty clear he'd be the most formidable candidate. ('Course, I'm biased, as a Giuliani supporter.)
"I remember a hell of a lot happening - such as getting the city back on its feet and going again. I remember dealing with hundreds of scares and yet still keeping the city going. I remember a rescue and recovery effort on a completely unprecedented scale."
What exactly what did he do to get the city back on its feet? How did he "deal" with hundreds of scares and to "[keep] the city going"? And what did he have to do with the rescue and recovery process?
"If Giuliani can get through the primary, don't you think that will show his defense isn't all that bad?"
It would show his defense isn't utterly abominable, but some pretty flawed candidates can make it through the primaries.
And I'm not saying I think Giuliani would be a weak candidate. I think he'd be pretty formidable. But I do think he'd be susceptible to bleeding, which is a large part of the reason I'd rather run against him than McCain.
A close friend whose political judgments I've always trusted (acquainted me with Chomsky, for example) was a great fan of Giuliani when he lived in New York. He said he was great for public order generally, not just "tough on crime", and that he displayed a lot of managerial competence, for example, in daily morning press conferences addressed to particulars like getting snowplows to airports in blizzards and the like. Anybody here acquainted with this aspect of Giuliani's resume?
That question posed, "managerial competence" at the city level is ultimately irrelevant once one becomes head of an unadulteratedly corrupt national party.
Al: I think you hit a nerve, by the way. If this thread is representative of lefty feelings about Rudy, he's one candidate they're definitely afraid of.
Yes, you've got us. Please don't throw us in that briar patch.
The "nerve" that Giuliani hits may have something to do with this:
"So authoritarian followers hate who their authorities tell them to hate; and will usually let off the brakes and act on that hatred only when their authorities give them permission to. Because they rely on external authority to guide their actions, and fear the loss of social order, social and legal sanctions are often effective at curbing their tendencies toward violence. And, left on their own, they will generally remain fairly benign."
http://dneiwert.blogspot.com/2007/02/eliminationist-minority.html
Abner Louima, a Haitian immigrant tortured and sodomized by officers in a Brooklyn station house in 1997, claimed that one of the officers said, "It's Giuliani time!" during the beating. Mr. Louima later retracted his statement about what the officers said, though his injuries were pretty definitive about what the officers _did_.
The "lefty" concern is that a Giuliani Prsidency would continue the current "permissive" atmosphere, permissive of torture, beatings, border shootings, "extraordinary rendition" and general intolerance backed up by violence and threats thereof.
Of course, "lefty" in this case would include the likes of Barry Goldwater and Ronald Reagan, but we're so past those quaint old birds.
Funny, I'd make the case that Rudy and Bush are the same. Once they have a legal opinion/view that they think gives them Right, they both become ... "the decider". A close coterie provides the unity necessary to form a ramshead.
bitter recounts from the indy press:
http://colorado.indymedia.org/newswire/display/2129/index.php
You can tell that the 9/11 thing really has the left concerned in that the focus of the attacks on Giuliani are 9/11-based
Because his performance on 9/11 is the only thing, so far, that he appears to be running on. Certainly the only thing that most Americans know him for. When Rudy cares to make a case for himself on other grounds (no pun intended), we liberals will be happy to eviscerate that case as well.
Personally, I'm not worried in the least. I have full confidence that, once America gets to know Rudy as well as those of us in NYC, his poll numbers will come back to earth.
"I think he'd be pretty formidable."
Why is that?
All of America was "affected". You're saying Giuliani should have put the OEM center in Canada?
Wow, it's only March, and I still think this is the odds-on favorite for "The Stupidest Argument On The Intertubes Not Made By Glenn Reynolds" this year.
Thanks, Scott. Maybe one day I'll even get to be Atrios's Wanker of the Day. A higher honour I cannot contemplate.
I have full confidence that, once America gets to know Rudy as well as those of us in NYC, his poll numbers will come back to earth.
What in the world makes you think America will get to know Rudy as well as the citizens of NYC?
Will the network news teach America about the real Rudy?
The narrative has been etched in stone, given from on high:
"Rudy Giuliani is America's Mayor."
I think that a good case can be made that Guliani is insane. I would play this radio tape frequently: "there is something sick in your excessive concern for the little weasels". This could be a sarcastic repartee, but no, Rudi ranted on an on against a caller to the radio show he visited, and agaist ferrets --- which were outlawed by his administration.
Cruel attitude toward little furry animals --- that will not go well with the public.
thanks
hgfgfsddfd
jhgfhgsfdsfssd
31321
asdfgdfgdfg
saffgg
Sağır Oda Fan Club
Türk
www.r10.net küresel ısınmaya hayır seo yarışması
www.r10.net küresel ısınmaya hayır seo yarışması
www.r10.net küresel ısınmaya hayır seo yarışması
youtube video
forum
downloads
Haberler
küresel ısınma
dizi izle
Thanks
Best regards
mirc
mirç
mırc
mırç
mircturk
turkmirc
mirc indir
mirc yukle
mirch
mırch
mirc turk
turk mirc
mırcturk
turkmırc
mırc turk
turk mırc
turkiyemirc
türkiyemirc
turkiye mirc
türkiye mirc
mircturkiye
mirctürkiye
mirc turkiye
mircturk
turkmırc
muhabbet
mirc sohbet
mırc sohbet
mirc chat
mırc chat
mırc ındır
mirc ındır
Türkçe mirc
Türkce mirc
Turkçe mirc
Türkce mirc
Türkçe mırc
Türkce mırc
Turkçe mırc
Turkce mırc
mirc
mirc
forum
forum
turkforum
turkiyeforum
mirc
turkmirc
toplist
site ekle
pagerank
turkmirc
turkforum
sohbet
chat
sohbet odaları
bedava sohbet
bedava chat
türk
karar
thansk...
sohbet
chat
sohbet
sohbet
sohbet
chat
hikaye
diziler
facebook
chat
kadın
forex
arkadaş
muhabbet
gebze
webtasarım
toplist
sinema
film
gebze
asansör
felsefe
reklam
webtasarım
face book
face turk
face turk
youtube
sinema
sohbet
muhabbet
chet
çet
arkadaş
palet
trkadin
hikayen
chat
sohbet
sohbet
marmara
gebze web tasarım
gebze webtasarım
sohbet
chat
moda
magazin
yemek tarifi
yemek tarifleri
kozmetik
diyet
Yakışıklı
Yakışıklılar
Anne Çocuk
Filmler
Filimler
Film
Dizi
sohbet
sohbet
chat
chat
diziler
asansör
hikaye
felsefe
reklam
facebook
face book
face turk
pagerank
masaj
masör
sohbet
sex
porno
kadın
youtube
sinema
sohbet
chat
gebze ticaret
kredi
borsa
sohbet
chat
sohbet
Arkadaş
sexshop
sex shop
erotik shop
penis büyütücü
Şişme Bebek
botanik
peyzaj
alçı dekorasyon
terlik
matbaa
çelik kapı
sexshop
sex shop
masaj
masor
masor
masöz
web hosting
Hosting
mobilya
mutfak dolabı
motor yenileme
polyester
lunapark
oyun parkı
sexshop
sex shop
erotik shop
penis büyütücü
Şişme Bebek
Thank you very much for this information.
sohbet
sesli sohbet
chat
muhabbet
mirc
evden eve nakliyat
mirc
mirc
sohbet
kelebek
chat
Thank you very much for this information.
sohbet
sesli sohbet
chat
muhabbet
mirc
evden eve nakliyat
mirc
mirc
sohbet
kelebek
chat
Thanks Best Regards
mirc
mırc
mırç
mircturk
mirctürk
turkmirc
mirc indir
mırc indir
mirç indir
mirc yükle
mırc yükle
mirc yukle
mırc yukle
mirch
mırch
turk mirc
mircada
muhabbet
mirc sohbet
mırc sohbet
mirc chat
mırc chat
mırc ındır
mirc ındır
türkçe mirc
turkce mirc
turkçe mırc
turkce mırc
oper mirc
irc forum
Mirc forum
irc forum
It's very good article. Great site with very good look and perfect information........
Thanks a lot.
Great site.
thanks.
Yeah.
thanks.
boya
dış cephe
mantolama
dış cephe kaplama
boya
izolasyon
e-ticaret
ısı yalıtım
söve
boya
dış cephe söveleri
söve fiyatları
söve imalatı
söve kaplama
söve nedir
söve sistemleri
söve firmaları
pencere sövesi
dış cephe süsleme
hazır söve
siding fiyatları
siding
amerikan siding
kartonpiyer söve
cephe söveleri
söve harcı
dekoratif söve
boya dekorasyon
plastik boya
dış cephe mantolama
mantolama sistemleri
plastik boya
dış cephe boyaları
antibakteriyel boya
astar boya
dış cephe macunu
saten boya
dış cephe boyaları
ahşap koruyucu
sanatsal malzemeler
boya fiyatları
dış cephe giydirme
cephe sistemleri
mantolama
dış cephe kaplamaları
izolasyon malzemeleri
dış cephe
dış cephe fiyatları
söve mantolama
pencere sövesi
siding
söve fiyatları
söve resimleri
söve nedir
söve firmaları
söve kaplama
söve uygulamaları
strafor söve
prekast söve
söve imalatı
dış cephe söveleri
söve sistemleri
hazır söve
dekoratif söve
hazır söve
mantolama
dış cephe mantolama
dış cephe süsleme
söve tasarımı
söve dekorasyon
siding
söve çeşitleri
poliüretan söve
kartonpiyer söve
cephe söveleri
extraordinarily good
Thanks Best Regards
mirc
mırc
mırç
mircturk
mirctürk
turkmirc
mirc indir
mırc indir
mirç indir
mirc yükle
mırc yükle
mirc yukle
mırc yukle
mirc sohbet
mırc sohbet
mirc chat
mırc ındır
kafkas
kafkasya
adige
irc forum
mirc forum
irc forum
mirc forum
irc forum
mirc forum
mirc
mirç
mirc inndir
türkçe mirc
mirc download
forum
sohbet
chat
catlak
evden eve nakliyat
istanbul evden eve nakliyat
evden eve nakliyat
thanks for all
thanks for all
herkezin içinde sex herkezin içinde sikiş herkezin içinde herkezin içinde sıcak herkezin içinde porno herkezin içinde erotik herkezin içinde sex ya herkezin içinde sikiş herkezin içinde sıcak herkezin içinde sikişi büyük kadın sikişi yaşlı olgun kadın erot porno yapan cenc kızla şişman erkekle şişman ertotik lezbiyen oto yol oto yolda oto yolda sex oto yolda sikiş oto yolda sıcak seks oto yolda porno film ç oto yolda erotik film oto yolda sikişiyorlar oto yolda sex yapıyorl oto yolda sıcak seks y oto yolda sıcak görünt yolda sikiş yolda sıcak seks yolda porno film izliy yolda erotik film izli yolun ortasında sex yolun ortasında sikiş yolun ortasında sıcak yolun ortasında porno yolun ortasında erotik yolun ortasında sevişi yolun ortasında sikişi yolun ortasında sex ya GÖYÜS YALİY porno sex zenci adamın ağzına çişini y kadın adamın ağzına çi ağzına işiyor adamın ağzına işiyor ağzına çişini yapıyor kız çişini yapıyor karı çişini yapıyor hatun çişini yapıyor kız işiyor kadın işiyor ağza çiş yapıyor ağza çiş yapan kadın adamın ağzına çişini y kadının ağzına çişini adamın ağzına işeyen k kadının ağzına işeyen banyoda çişini yapan k tuvalette çişini yapan tuveletini yapan kadın tuvaletini yapan adam lavaboda çişini yapan lavaboda çişini yapan lavaboda tuveletini ya lavaboda tuveletini ya türkce cocuk seks alman kızlar erotik iz manyak sikişken olgun halterci kadınlar porn amcıgına şişe sokan se parayla sex yapan ya domalan kız firikik ve firikik veren kız firikik veren kadın firikik veren karı firikik veren hatun firikik veren bayan firikik veren hanım firikik veren kızın am firikik veren kızın gö firikik veren kızın ka firikik veren kızın kı firikik veren kadının firikik veren kadının firikik veren kadının firikik veren kadının harika firikikler ateşli firikikler sıcak firikikler muhteşem firikikler firikik veren bayanlar firikik veren ünlüler firikik veren kadınlar firikik veren kızlar firikik veren karılar güzel firikikler sikiş firikikleri sex firikikleri sıcak seks firikikleri yaşlı kadın manyak sev şişman beyaz kadın s.k porno sikiş video genç kız ögretmenle erkek ö karısı başkasıyla siki amcıgına şişe sokan s cüce sikiş cüce sıcak seks cüce porno film cüce erotik filim kadın cüceyle sikişiyo cüceyle sex cüceyle sikiş cüceyle sıcak seks cüce sikişiyor cücenin yarağı cücenin aleti cücenin penisi cücenin siki cücenin sikişi cücenin seksi cücenin sıcak sexi seksi cüce seksi kadın cüceyle si cüceyle sikişen kız cüceyle sex yapan kız cüceyle sıcak seks yap küçük adam sex küçük adam sikiş küçük adam sıcak seks küçük adam porno film küçük adam erotik film küçük adam filmi küçük adam sinema film cüceler sikişiyor cüceler sex yapıyor cüceler sıcak seks yap cüceler porno film cüceler erotik film cücelerin sexi cücelerin sikişi cücelerin sıcak görünt cıplak dans eden kız sex sikilş paraşütle sex paraşütle sikiş paraşütle sıcak seks paraşütle porno film paraşütcü sex paraşütcü sikiş paraşütcü sıcak seks paraşütle paraşüt paraşütcü gök yüzünde sex gök yüzünde sikiş gök yüzünde sıcak seks gök yüzünde porno film gök yüzünde erotik fil gök yüzünde sikişiyorl gök yüzünde sex yapıyo gök yüzünde sıcak seks havada sex havada sikiş havada sıcak sikiş havada porno uçakda uçakda sex uçakta sikiş uçakda sıcak seks uçakta sex uçakta sıcak seks uçakda sikiş uçağın içinde sex uçağın içinde sikiş uçağın içinde sıcak se uçağın içinde porno fi uçağın içinde erotik f uçarken sex uçarken sikiş uçarken sıcak seks uçarken sikişiyorlar uçarak sikişiyorlar uçarken sex yapıyorlar uçarak sex yapıyorlar uçarken sıcak seks yap uçarak sıcak seks yapı uçak uçarken uçarak havuz altında seks vid on sekizlik kızlar amını mıncıklayan kadın amını okşatıyor sex sikiş vidioları göğüsleriyle sex yapan göğüsleriyle sikiş yap göğüsleriyle sıcak sek güzel göğüslü kadın si güzel göğüslü kadın se güzel göğüslü kadın sı güzel göğüslü kadın ze zevkin dorukları zevkin doruklarına cık zevkin doruklarına çık güzel memeli kadın sik güzel memeli kadın sex güzel memeli kadın sıc güzel memeli kadın por güzel memeli kadın ero güzel memeli kız güzel memeli kız sex y güzel memeli kız sikiş güzel memeli kız sıcak güzel memeli kız porno güzel memeli kız eroti güzel göğüslü kız güzel göğüslü kız sex güzel göğüslü kız siki güzel göğüslü kız sıca güzel göğüslü kız porn güzel göğüslü kız erot yaşlı olgun kadın izle yarağını amına vuruyor yarağıyla kadını tokat yarağının üzerinde zıp penisinin üzerinde zıp aletinin üzerinde zıpl sikinin üzerinde zıplı hopluyor adamın üzerinde zıplıy adamın üzerinde hopluy zıplıyor zıplayarak ateşli azdırıcı sex azdırıcı sikiş azdırıcı sıcak seks penis okşama videosu olgun kadınlar küçük ç sikiş dersi sıcak seks dersi seks dersi veren lezbi sex dersi veren kız seks dersi veren kadın sikiş dersi veren kadı sıcak seks dersi veren sikiş dersi veren kız kadın sex dersi veriyo kadın sikiş dersi veri kadın sıcak seks dersi kız sex dersi veriyor kız sıcak seks dersi v kız sikiş dersi veriyo sex hocası seks hocası sikiş hocası sex dersi porno film sex dersi erotik film sikiş dersi porno film sikiş dersi erotik fil seks dersi porno film seks dersi erotik film sıcak seks dersi filmi nefis sikiş videoları parayla sex yapanlar mpney olgun yaşlı kadın seks mini etekli kız sex mini etekli kız sikiş mini etekli kız sıcak mini etekli kız porno mini etekli kadın mini etekli kadın sex mini etekli kadın siki mini etekli kadın sıca mini etekli kadın siki mini etekli kız sikişi mini etekli kadın sex mini etekli kız sex ya mini etekli kızı sikiy mini etekli kadını sik mini etekli kızla sikş mini etekli kadınla si öğrenci sikiş yurtta sex yurtta sikiş yurtta sıcak seks lojmanda sex lojmanda sikiş lojmanda sıcak seks lojman yurt lojmanda yurtta kalkmış sik izle soyunan kadın meme uçl soyunan kız meme uçlar muhteşem meme uçları kadının memelerinin uc göğüs uçları kadın göğüs uçlarını g kız göğüs uçlarını gös meme uçlarını ısırıyor göğüs uçlarını ısırıyo adam kadının göğüs uçl kadının meme uçlarını meme uçlarını ısıttıra adam kadının meme uçla adam kadının meme uçla güzel memeli kadının g güzel göğüslü kızın gü dans ederek pantolonun dans eden kız sikişiyo dans eden kız sex yapı kamerada sikişen kız kamerada sex yapan kız kamerada sıcak seks kamerada sex yapan kad kamerada sikişen kadın kamerada sıcak seks ya kadın kamerada soyunuy kız kamerada soyunuyor hatun kamerada soyunuy karı kamerada soyunuyo dolgun KADIN PORNOSU komşu kadın çocukla si çiş yapan kadın yaşlı annesini siken cocuğun inleterek bagirtarak s seks zenci pornoı aşkım pornosu seksene.net/video/turk türkçe şikiş videoları olgun kadın sex olgun kadınların porno jalenin sikis filimi sikişirken ağlayan kad sekse doymayan hamilel terorist porn sex vide erotik lezbiyen gurp i sex yapan genc porno k memeleri okşatanlar ter sıcak kadın videoları animasyonlu sevişme po esmer kadın ateşli adam sikemiyor zenci grup sex orman kadınlar seks yapanlar ISEYEN pelin batu sevişme izl cısını yapan sırayla cıs yapan lezbiyen videoları izl sırılsıklam sikişler sarışın grup cılgınca sevişenler sexi bacaklı kız fotol çift taraflı seks vide büyük göğüslü kadınlar şişko tombul kilolu iri olgun kadin amini tras DANSLI PORN filmlionsex parayla sex vidyosu iz güzel göt videoları golf sahasında sikiş yaşlı kadılar sevişiyo www.e..........net sex deniz altında yapılan PORNO VİDEOLARI büyük genç kızlar birl olgun kadin sik mağazada sexizle olgun sex videoları iz tranny komik gizli kamera gör zenci travesti sexs bisexsual sex kızlar sikişiyorla olgun kadın sexs video ANİME SICAK amını sallayan kadın komşusuna siktiren k mnuel sex sürtük seksler olgun kadınlar sex vid hahise sex giglian porno videosu pon pon kız video askeri sex videoları öğretmenle sexs porn olgun adamların sevişm sikişme videoları on yaşındkikız öğretmenlerle sex sesli erotik dinle ful üçlü grup seks videola dokuz yaşındaki kız kılitorısı izle küçük kızlarin pornosu 13 lük kızlarin seksi doktor adamla sex derste öğretmeniyle se sıcak erotik lez video annesini yalıyan izle çoklu gurup sikiş zenci kadin oral sex manuel pornoları lezbiyen sevişiyo kız erkek erotik sıcak sevişen kadınlar eğlenceli porno sex kadın göğüsleri haykıran sikiş KADIN LEZBİYEN SEX VİD sünnetsiz adam videola vajinali videolar sex yapan kadınlar si erotik film okşama deniz altında sikişme calkala.porno yaşlı k sex yapan gençler vide www.üvey annesini siki fahişe olgun türk SAYFA2 İRİ PENİS SAYFA 2 vajina yalayanlar yeşil çam fahişeleri kadınla sex yapan coc seksi zenci kadın vide şişman kadınlar sekx ş şişmansarışın sikişenl on sekizlik tecavüzler seksi öğrenci öğretmen manyak kızlar seks sevgilisiyle sevişiyor güzel kadınerotik vide göhüs jigoloya kendini sikti ateşli kadınlar.sıcaks coraplı erotik film okşayarak sikiş hayvanca sevişenler şişman sexs ve sikiş zenci fahişe üvey anne erotik video cok.sıcak.seks amını okşuyan kızlar sexo sikiş eglenceli sex filmi iz sünnetsiz penis izle ama giriyor evli kadınlar erotik v en sportif vücutlu bedava arap sisman kad polis yarağı erkeklerle kadınlar ya adam kadın hem sevişiy byük göhüslü kadın por erotik jigolo en uzun kadın kilitori penis yalayan otobüste kalçadan okşu sex yapan kız öğrencil tuvaletteyken sik öğretmeniyle sevişen ö penis yalayan liselikı asyalı erotık kadın nasıl penisi kal okşayan türk kız saksafon çekti sik yalamatube sikiş inceleme kadın adamın penisini penis yalayan liseli k pilise kızların sikişi sikiş erotik zenci seks video koltukta vajina yalata üvey annesiyle sex barda sex film öğretmenlle sex DÖŞEKTE SEKX şişmankadın video sek asyalı sıcak+18 35 yaşında sikiş genç kız erotik videol kolejde.porno yaşlılar sevisiyor 35 yaşındaki sikiş SEX HARİKA KOLTUKTAPOR amına yapay peniş soka saksafon çeken kızlar lezbiyen sıcak fahişe kadınların sex cocuk yalıyor olgun kadınlar sikişiy sex vıdyoları evlilik
thanks
Post A Comment